Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Selam on July 26, 2011, 07:20:19 AM
-
Hi,
Really hoping you can help me! I recently bought a new box (you all knew it was only a matter of time!) but I think the bellows may be leaking. The only problem is, I only have my old box to compare it to and I'm not sure... I've had a hunt through the threads for discussions on leaking bellows but can't tell if I have a problem or not. Should any air escape when none of the buttons are pressed? My other box requires a lot of effort to get air through it so the difference is huge but I can't tell if this is a fault with the new box or just something I'm not used to...
Thanks in advance
Selam
:|||:
-
A quick test would be to hold the melodeon in the air by the keyboard, with the bellows hanging down - and with the bellows straps released, see if the bellows head down to earth. If they do - you have a leak...
Alan
-
Thank you!
Now, please bear in mind I'm very new to all of this but... Should *any* air escape or should it be airtight (or as airtight as something with that many holes/reeds in can be!)? From Alan's test it would seem that air is escaping and as the box is brand new I will contact the seller but don't want to appear completely stupid!... :|bl
Thanks
Selam
-
Most/all boxes leak a bit but if you compare your new box to your old one using Almo's test I would expect the new one to take a lot longer to open under its own weight. Plus as its new take it back and ask I am sure the sellers wont mind most every melodeon seller I have met has been an enthusiast and are keen to help.
-
I was also wondering what constitutes a leak. I have just acquired an old (one careful owner!!) 2 row pokerwork on ebay, which to my inexperienced ear sounds good, but following the above test, does seem to let SOME air through, as the bellows do (quite) gradually begin to expand.
In my case, this is the curse of being a beginner - not knowing as yet what constitutes "acceptable", and what doesn't. I guess the fun's in finding out (and knowing's half the battle!)...
-
I was also wondering what constitutes a leak. I have just acquired an old (one careful owner!!) 2 row pokerwork on ebay, which to my inexperienced ear sounds good, but following the above test, does seem to let SOME air through, as the bellows do (quite) gradually begin to expand.
In my case, this is the curse of being a beginner - not knowing as yet what constitutes "acceptable", and what doesn't. I guess the fun's in finding out (and knowing's half the battle!)...
I repeat my bit from above - all melodeons leak air to a greater or less extent. I was recently playing solo for my Morris team when a bellows pin popped out, this is a *bad* leak, but I was able to get to the end of the dance by just pumping away harder ;D
-
I repeat my bit from above - all melodeons leak air to a greater or less extent. I was recently playing solo for my Morris team when a bellows pin popped out, this is a *bad* leak, but I was able to get to the end of the dance by just pumping away harder ;D
That mental image made me chuckle a bit. :D
I agree with Lester, it would be pretty rare, I think to find an accordion that didn't leak a bit. It's only a problem if it affects bellows usage noticeably or reed response. Small leaks don't affect playing noticeably, but can be on the way to a bigger leak. Also, don't assume that a leak is in the bellows. There's an awful lot of opportunities for pressured air to find an errant exit.
-
Thank you! I've contacted the seller so will wait and see. It is difficult when you don't know what these things should be like!
-
Finding leaks can be a nightmare. Do you have an experienced player you can ask to try the box and see whether he/she thinks there's a problem? Different makes and models of box do have different characteristics, so you may be worrying about nothing, but someone with a few years playing under their belt should be able to try it and judge if it feels "right" or not.
-
I was recently playing solo for my Morris team when a bellows pin popped out, this is a *bad* leak, but I was able to get to the end of the dance by just pumping away harder ;D
It's amazing how much air you can lose when that happens - I lost a bellows pin in a tune session (proceedings were held up for several minutes while we scoured the floor for the little devil, but we never found it!) and it really does make the instrument a bit of a challenge to play with any finesse or expression!
-
bit of a challenge to play with any finesse or expression!
Not a problem for me then ;D
-
Think I've just found an answer. A cheap Chinese concertina in my possession HAS developed a leak. To say there is a difference is a crowning understatement!
I repeat my bit from above - all melodeons leak air to a greater or less extent. I was recently playing solo for my Morris team when a bellows pin popped out, this is a *bad* leak, but I was able to get to the end of the dance by just pumping away harder ;D
The tune wasn't "Coming in on a wing and a prayer", was it?
-
I have to say that if you're playing hard enough to lose a pin then surely finesse and expression wouldn't have come into it in the first place ???
-
I have to say that if you're playing hard enough to lose a pin then surely finesse and expression wouldn't have come into it in the first place ???
Or possibly the pins are just loose. What I need to do is drill out the bellows frame, dowel the old holes, re-drill the holes the correct size. Or just tap them back in with a beer glass once in a while :P
-
Finding leaks can be a nightmare. Do you have an experienced player you can ask to try the box and see whether he/she thinks there's a problem? Different makes and models of box do have different characteristics, so you may be worrying about nothing, but someone with a few years playing under their belt should be able to try it and judge if it feels "right" or not.
Don't put it in a bowl of water like finding a puncture in an inner tube.... ::)
Actually - you could use the old plumbers trick for testing gas leaks.....
If it is the pin area - you could mix a little washing up liquid with a small ammount of water and whip up the bubbles, place some near the pins and squeeze the bellows.
If there is a leak the bubbles will expand....
-
I have to say that if you're playing hard enough to lose a pin then surely finesse and expression wouldn't have come into it in the first place ???
I'm not sure that pins dropping out have anything to do with playing hard; in my case, the box (my trusty old Saltarelle) is a good 25 years old and has played more "note-miles" than I care to contemplate. It's just wear and increasing age; over the years, with regular removal and replacement for routine tuning and maintenance, the holes inevitably enlarge and sooner or later a pin is going to work its way out. Having lost that pin I replaced the whole lot with pins of a very slightly bigger diameter and everything's as good as new. You'd have to playing with the muscle strength of an enraged gorilla to build up enough pressure to push a well-fitting pin out of an unworn hole......and I suspect the bellows would collapse before the pin popped.
-
Fair 'nuff :P
-
One way I check for leaks is to remove one side of the accordion at a time, and get in a very dark place, and shine a light up it's innards. This will show even pinholes. Reed blocks will prevent this from working for the pallets unless they're removable.
My wife is still very suspicious of me coming out of a dark closet with an accodion.
-
Air leaks are often not from the bellows, pallets are frequent source of leaks.
-
Every now and then the air button on my Dino Baffetti BPII doesn't shut properly - the bellows just collapse in a few notes. I'm told that the earlier models had a problem with the air button design, but once I flick the button a few times, the pallet reseats itself and eveything's fine again
One of my old Hohner clubs, which I considered OK for its age, had the pallets refelted when it went for tuning. Its the most airtight box I have even compared with those I bought new! I sometimes wonder whether a box that has been sitting around in a warehouse or shop will suffer from the felt hardening so won't be as tight as it should?
Rob.