Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on July 28, 2011, 11:57:12 AM
-
Hi,
The title says it all really. I've got a couple of Ericas and I've been told that I can tape over the thirds but I don't want to do that because I do like to use the full triads most of the time.
Any suggestions? - I want a D/G box which has got a stop for removing the thirds from the chords but without going into huge expense. Does a box like this exist?
I could live with a C/F that does the same btw.
Thanks for any help
Les
-
Saltarelle bouebe has a stop for the thirds in the bass. Used ones turn up fairly often.
-
Sandpiper and Morgane iirc both have bass stops. Those are probably the cheapest good boxes around (imo only). Second hand will get you to around the £500 I expect. Alternatively talk to one of our erstwhile repairers and see what they can do for you. You can add stops to some old boxes, depending on the reed configuration, they might be able to provide you with a nice old Hohner or something.
-
Sandpiper definitely has a stop to remove the thirds.
Rob
-
"Most" Italian boxes could have a stop added, but small hohners cant
-
Really? I thought that there were some that could. Stand corrected.
-
Exactly, most, not all.
-
I read the topic as ADG ::)
-
I read the topic as ADG ::)
Sorry - it should have read "a D/G"
-
I'm fairly sure the Scarlatti Nero has/had a stop.
-
The Music Room have a new Primo Scholar box at £450 which has Italian reeds and a thirds stop on the bass. A brief play on one at Witney suggested to me that there's nothing to touch it at the price. It's shown as B/C but they will have a D/G one as well.
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4221
-
The Music Room have a new Primo Scholar box at £450 which has Italian reeds and a thirds stop on the bass. A brief play on one at Witney suggested to me that there's nothing to touch it at the price. It's shown as B/C but they will have a D/G one as well.
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_249_485/products_id/4221
If that plays as good as it looks, then it's fantastic value.
-
the BC version is 23 button but for some strange reason (or non-reason) the DG has only 23!!
george
-
George, we seem to be starting a game of typo-tennis!
I think George meant the DG has only 21 buttons.
-
It all depends on what you mean by budget but I was in exactly the same position earlier this year with the same requirements as you. My shortlist ended up being a Le Bouebe, an Irish Bouebe or a Sandpiper. I liked the look of the Morgane but, as has already been mentioned, it doesn't have the stop that you're after. I tried a Sandpiper and really liked it but ended up buying a Le Bouebe for a good price. When I was looking there were a couple of Le Bouebes for sale but you need to be prepared to traveel!
Dave
-
I've got a couple of Ericas and I've been told that I can tape over the thirds but I don't want to do that because I do like to use the full triads most of the time.
Any suggestions?
Just tape one of your Ericas and leave the third in the rest of them. ;)
-
I've got a couple of Ericas and I've been told that I can tape over the thirds but I don't want to do that because I do like to use the full triads most of the time.
Any suggestions?
Just tape one of your Ericas and leave the third in the rest of them. ;)
[/quoteSorry - should have explained - one is a D/G and the other G/C