Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Lester on August 01, 2011, 08:52:31 AM
-
Any thoughts, hints, tips gratefully received
-
After seeing the photo of your latest ebay accidental purchase I was expecting this!
There could be at least two three four options:
1 open out the damaged area to a convenient shape and graft in a new piece of wood, then re-cut the button holes. I've done this and though a bit fiddly it does work.
2 Cut off the entire top of the fingerboard and make a new top
3 make a new top from thin sheet metal and screw it on the top covering the damage
4 throw the damaged one away and fit a new one.
-
After seeing the photo of your latest ebay accidental purchase I was expecting this!
There could be at least two three four options:
1 open out the damaged area to a convenient shape and graft in a new piece of wood, then re-cut the button holes. I've done this and though a bit fiddly it does work.
2 Cut off the entire top of the fingerboard and make a new top
3 make a new top from thin sheet metal and screw it on the top covering the damage
4 throw the damaged one away and fit a new one.
Then option 5;
Although this keyboard looks a little past it for what I'm about to suggest; another way of fixing the keyboards up and filling where there are a few gaps is with leather. I have at hand very hard cow hide (shoe sole leather that is about 2-3 mm thick,) this can then be cut with a sharp knife and as it will slightly compress it is far easier to fit than trying to make another bit of timber fit to shape. It can then be stained black and nobody will never know the difference.
Peter
-
After seeing the photo of your latest ebay accidental purchase I was expecting this!
There could be at least two three four options:
1 open out the damaged area to a convenient shape and graft in a new piece of wood, then re-cut the button holes. I've done this and though a bit fiddly it does work.
2 Cut off the entire top of the fingerboard and make a new top
3 make a new top from thin sheet metal and screw it on the top covering the damage
These might be a good reason to buy a table saw ;)
4 throw the damaged one away and fit a new one.
This is the easy option but I think I will try Option 1 and if that fails progress to 2 then 3 and possibly 4 after learning a lot of useful stuff on the way (:)
Thanks Theo
-
No2 would be better done with a bandsaw, but you probably need the table saw too. (:)
-
No2 would be better done with a bandsaw, but you probably need the table saw too. (:)
The bandsaw will be much safer and easier to deal with for taking the top off. I hate ripping a piece on the table saw. So prone to kick back and other accidents.
Do you have a plunge router? Given the damage and the fact that the keyboard is painted, I'd go with making a new piece. Not that difficult if you have the router. It's a very handy tool.
-
Table saws might be a bit ruff but they cut straight which cannot be said for the average affordable home bandsaw.
-
No2 would be better done with a bandsaw, but you probably need the table saw too. (:)
The bandsaw will be much safer and easier to deal with for taking the top off. I hate ripping a piece on the table saw. So prone to kick back and other accidents.
Do you have a plunge router? Given the damage and the fact that the keyboard is painted, I'd go with making a new piece. Not that difficult if you have the router. It's a very handy tool.
The router is one of the most dangerous (when hand held) tools in the workshop (but also one of the most useful when mounted for our work) although I have a heavy duty one and a smaller one that I never use either free hand, the big one is upside down in a router table, the small one is up the right way in a Boch drill press, and under that I have a pin guide, I have then jigs made up that this is where I cut holes in pallet boards and reed block shoes and keyboards like you are talking about.
Probably the easiest and safest way of doing this job is with a hand held fret saw, draw a template on graph paper, (then take a few copies of it) and then stick it down on to the timber you are going to use and then cut it out using a jewelers V support, very easy and fingers are still intact.
-
The router is one of the most dangerous (when hand held) tools in the workshop (but also one of the most useful for our work) [snip]
Very true. I've never worked with one free hand. I've always made use of jigs for holding the work piece and setting exact placement of the router. Sorry if I seemed to make light of using this tool.
-
The router is one of the most dangerous (when hand held) tools in the workshop (but also one of the most useful for our work) [snip]
Very true. I've never worked with one free hand. I've always made use of jigs for holding the work piece and setting exact placement of the router. Sorry if I seemed to make light of using this tool.
No problems; but I thought I should warn people, i could imagine in my minds eye fingers flying everywhere.
Peter
-
If you're doing just one job or several and not a large batch of them, a fretsaw or gauged razor saw will do the job. Stewart MacDonald offers useful razor saws in different gauges, they have a rigid spine and look like a long shallow gent's saw. They're good for all sorts of small jobs - fret slots, nut slots, top removals, etc. They're good for similar small scale work with accordions, or model making.
A deeper saw like a fretsaw might work better because of the thick solid edges of the keyboard cover could be deeper than is comfortable with the razor saw, but I like the rigidity for control. First score a line to cut and then hold the keyboard cover in a bench vise or third hand. Also drill small guide holes in the thicker edges of the cover and transfer the mark to the new top to ensure a flush match. Razor saws work well cutting off mandolin backs, can't see how it wouldn't work with a melodeon keyboard cover.
The link to the StewMac product is here:
http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Tools/Saws/Gauged_Saws.html?tab=Pictures#details
:||: :||: :||:
-
Probably the easiest and safest way of doing this job is with a hand held fret saw, draw a template on graph paper, (then take a few copies of it) and then stick it down on to the timber you are going to use and then cut it out using a jewelers V support, very easy and fingers are still intact.
[/quote]
Most people have been put off fret saws due to bad experience with them, this in the norm is not due to the saw; it is the saw blades and the lack of a V support. Do not buy blades from the hardware shop, they are expensive and break to fast, go to a jeweler supplier and and buy the Swiss made blades as they are the most reliable for this job #3 are the best, you will have to buy them by the gross if you send away for them, but they are cheaper that way. I used to use an Eclipse FS70 fret saw until I wore it out then a Hegna until that wore out as well. I got my latest one around the tool markets and it is locally made about 100 years ago, and is very nice to use.
If I had to go back to using all hand tools that would be high on the list as so much can be made from one.
Peter
-
This all seems to be getting a bit complicated!
The patching repair can be done with nothing more complicated than a chisel, a sharp knife, and some abrasive paper, and might take a couple of hours at the most the first time you do it.
It occurs to me that another way to remove the damaged top would be to sand it off. The wood is quite soft and it could even be done by hand on coarse abrasive paper glued onto a flat surface, though a belt sander would be quicker.
-
This all seems to be getting a bit complicated!
The patching repair can be done with nothing more complicated than a chisel, a sharp knife, and some abrasive paper, and might take a couple of hours at the most the first time you do it.
It occurs to me that another way to remove the damaged top would be to sand it off. The wood is quite soft and it could even be done by hand on coarse abrasive paper glued onto a flat surface, though a belt sander would be quicker.
Oh silly me; looks like I need to fill in the gaps, I thought we were talking here about making a new complete front or fascia, not a patching repair.
Try and ease off the fascia without breaking it any further if possible, for this job I have a very fine single edged knife that will slide under very easily, you will find that the glue is very brittle on most accounts, and it will come off very easy. Then draw around all the remaining fascia on to graph paper, you should find that there are a few holes that are still in place, you can then slide the fascia along until those good holes match up with missing holes, draw in new holes. Stick template down (after you have made copies of it, you might stuff the first one up and you do not want to have to draw up another template) to your choice of timber and within half an hour (or 32 minutes if you are not as good on the saw as me, or 28 minutes if you are better) with a fret saw you will have it cut out, and ready to glue on. I would not have thought this was to complicated for people who are "keen as mustard" to "give it a go".
Peter
-
Peter, the fingerboard we are talking about here is machined out of solid wood, there is no separate fascia to remove.
-
Peter, the fingerboard we are talking about here is machined out of solid wood, there is no separate fascia to remove.
If it is that type then use the razor saw to cut it off, I would use the band saw as I have them, but most people do not, keeping as much of the original as a pattern for the template will make the making of a new one a lot easier.
Peter
-
Regarding cutting the top off, all the ideas about using a bandsaw or some sort of fine cutting saw would minimise the amount of waste from the cut. But is that relevant in this case, given that the idea is to replace the top altogether rather than fit it back on? You could cut it off pretty roughly, then plane down to a true surface afterwards.
-
Regarding cutting the top off, all the ideas about using a bandsaw or some sort of fine cutting saw would minimise the amount of waste from the cut. But is that relevant in this case, given that the idea is to replace the top altogether rather than fit it back on? You could cut it off pretty roughly, then plane down to a true surface afterwards.
I'm sure a good sharp hand saw would do the same job (but how many good saw doctors are around to sharpen them?. If its anything like here in Adelaide the last good one passed away 5 years ago) but it is more about getting it off and then using it as a pattern. there is nothing lost in trying to retrieve as much of the original material, as you will never know how handy it will be until you need it.
Then what remains of the finger board can then be sanded down as Theo suggests.
Peter