Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: bonenfant on August 01, 2011, 07:18:13 PM
-
Guys.
I bought an old Hohner. Instead of rubber for the bellows gaskets, there was a cord or small rope. The old accordion maker told me that it was built during WW2. He said they were using a cord because they were saving rubber for the armies. Anyone of you heard or read something like this?
A great day to you all.
-
That is a fairy story. Soft yarn was the norm for bellows gaskets for years before WW2, I've never seen rubber gaskets on accordions of that age. Leather was also used frequently, especially on better quality boxes.
-
Well.... you know your stuff for sure. Thanks for the answer.
But then, is the a way we could date an old accordion?
-
Paperwork like a sales receipt is the most reliable method. Otherwise, dating is more difficult and takes some skill. Original packaging, parts that are unique to a specific date range for the model, or parts that changed numerous times on the same model can help pinpoint a date. Early photographs of a known date containing the instrument are also helpful. Sometimes dates are penciled inside the instrument, like dates of repair, quality control inspection, or manufacture.
Finding a positive match for the model in several catalogs will give you a range of dates to work from: the earliest date in the range will be when the instrument first appeared in a catalog for sale. The latest date in the range is the date of the next edition of the catalog where the instrument was not included, and was presumably discontinued. This process involves examining multiple catalogs from different dealers because inventory was sometimes mutually exclusive - just because an instrument disappeared from one vendor's inventory doesn't mean it was discontinued from the maker's product line. But if it disappears from say five catalogs in the US, Germany and England in the same year, it's safe to assume that the instrument was discontinued by the maker. For this same reason, the manufacturer's catalogs are preferred over dealer catalogs.
If you have a Hohner, check the registry in the back of 100 Years of Hohner Accordions in Pictures which will give you Hohner's opinion on when the models were produced. If you have a very nice Hohner with a serial number stamped on it, you can send this to Hohner via email for a small fee and they will try to find it in their archives.
Most often, it's a lot of educated guesswork and you end up with a "most likely" date that is accurate within 10-20 years, depending on the manufacturer and model. If you have a string/candlewick.hair gasket then it dates anywhere from the stone age of accordions to the 1920s or 1930s.
To an experienced eye, a photo of the instrument helps.
-
If you have a Hohner, check the registry in the back of 100 Years of Hohner Accordions in Pictures which will give you Hohner's opinion on when the models were produced.
For Hohners this is the best single source, though still very incomplete. It is based on catalogues in Hohners own (incomplete) collection.