Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ron1 on August 01, 2011, 08:35:02 PM
-
I want to play English music and wondered what box is considered the best and in what key. To be honest,
I'm not even sure how you define so called "English Music. Can anyone help with either question?
-
I'm not going to attempt a definition of English music. But I can list some of its sources and features -
Take tunes from the dance manuscripts of 1650 to 1750, add country dance tunes from all English regions, plus the manuscripts typified by those in the Village Music Project mostly around 1800, not forgetting Morris tunes :M of all genres. Then accompaniment of English song ancient and modern and music hall songs. And all played in styles which vary across the country and encompass the gentlest of airs to the most lively folk-rock. Along the way, borrow some material and features from adjacent countries and re-import some which went to the colonies and then came back. But don't over-ornament it nor make it prescriptive.
Does this help at all?
Most people use a D/G melodeon except when they don't or if they live in East Anglia (:).
-
Most people use a D/G melodeon except when they don't or if they live in East Anglia (:).
Even though a great deal of our repertoire is English I agree with Howard that to define it is impossible. All things to all men. What I would add though is the use of D/G is to conform for sessions and come in line with fiddles on two major keys. We play in many keys choosing what hopefully best suits each piece. Your choice of box is once again down to what you like although too much musette will sound French or Scottish, even Italian dependent on the music being played.
If you play with others, the overall sound will depend entirely on the instrument make up of your group.
-
Thank you Howard.
Your advice is enlightening and very useful. I am a wiser man today. (:)
(No Strings Attached) I must admit to playing a one row, C/G. I will at least try an English song or two, but I am tempted to change to your recommended box and run with the crowd. :||:
-
I want to play English music and wondered what box is considered the best and in what key. To be honest, I'm not even sure how you define so called "English Music. Can anyone help with either question?
My kit is in essence a D/G and a G/C - both with lots of extra notes. So while they are playable outside their bass keys and can always do chords - it isn't that easy melodeonism that makes our instrument what it is. 'Travelling light' (highly recommended) I only take the D/G to British festival sessions. 'Off to France' later this month I'll only have the G/C (the Oakwood in reserve in the boot as last w/e is in Gent and I'm not quite sure what they play)
So I 'd say the English question's answer is "D/G". Do read up our recent thread on '4th note start' etc if you're planning to buy new. http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7358.0.html
-
D/G is definitely the way to go if you want to be able to play along in most English sessions. Any other kind of box will leave you on your own for much of the time, either playing solo or sitting out because you haven't got the right notes to join in.
The best way to get a feel for English music is to get to sessions and festivals where it is played. Session playing tends to divide into Irish music on one hand and English/French/Scottish/Swedish etc on the other (although Scottish music sometimes sneaks its way into Irish sessions on the dubious grounds that it's "celtic"). But in the latter variety of session, most of the tunes will generally be English, or played as if they are.
I couldn't begin to define English music, although Howard has made a manful attempt to do so. Some of its characteristics are that it tends to be played in a chord-driven and rhythmic way, with a bounce and a lift that keeps the feel of the dance, rather than at breakneck speed. The melodies tend to be strong and clear, sometimes song-like, and the chord sequences often quite simple. Many of the tunes have their own distinctive rhythms, which isn't always the case in other dance traditions.
If you want a book to guide you, there are plenty of good ones around. I'm very fond of "Hardcore English" which comes with a CD of some of the tunes, and costs £20 from EFDSS.
-
I couldn't begin to define English music, although Howard has made a manful attempt to do so. Some of its characteristics are that it tends to be played in a chord-driven and rhythmic way, with a bounce and a lift that keeps the feel of the dance, rather than at breakneck speed. The melodies tend to be strong and clear, sometimes song-like, and the chord sequences often quite simple. Many of the tunes have their own distinctive rhythms, which isn't always the case in other dance traditions.
If you want a book to guide you, there are plenty of good ones around. I'm very fond of "Hardcore English" which comes with a CD of some of the tunes, and costs £20 from EFDSS.
Totally agree with what Marje has written, and also thoroughly endorse her recommendation of Hardcore English as a very fine collection indeed of English tunes, many of which are currently played in English sessions.
Here's a link to the relevant EFDSS page:
Hardcore English (http://folkshop.efdss.org/Books+and+Publications/Hardcore+English+Book.html)
-
, ,
"or played as if they are. "
.
I this is a key factor in 'English' session playing - Many tunes that are played may or may not be of pure English origin or may have originated elsewhere or be 'shared' with other muiical cultures. The important thing ,to me anyway, is that in an English session they are played very much in the English style outlined by Marje and others.
george :||:
-
, ,
"or played as if they are. "
.
I this is a key factor in 'English' session playing - Many tunes that are played may or may not be of pure English origin or may have originated elsewhere or be 'shared' with other muiical cultures. The important thing ,to me anyway, is that in an English session they are played very much in the English style outlined by Marje and others.
george :||:
I suppose the same applies to Irish-style playing. Some of the popular "Irish" session tunes are not in fact Irish in origin, but are played in a style that makes them more Irish than anything else. I find Irish sessions vaguely unsatisfying, not because I can't play the tunes, or even because I can't play them fast enough (although this may well be the case) but because even when I can play them, I want to play in an English style, and don't really enjoy trying to blend in with an Irish sound.
-
I find Irish sessions vaguely unsatisfying, not because I can't play the tunes, or even because I can't play them fast enough (although this may well be the case) but because even when I can play them, I want to play in an English style, and don't really enjoy trying to blend in with an Irish sound.
That's exactly my problem.
-
Surprised we got this far without a mention of Bob Cann, although it may be argued that he plays Devonian not English. Others to consider are Tony Hall, Steve of this parish (above) and many of the fine melodeon players from morris backgrounds now leading excellent bands.
As for the high jacking of tunes, the wonderful 'Old French' is a fantastic Québécois tune often played as an Irish piece, to my mind destroying the splendid rhythm and pace of the whole thing.
-
Dances danced at English ceilidhs are also not necessarily of English origin but are done to the English style of playing eg The Gay Gorddons may well be done to the same tunes as a Scottish band would play but with a more 'lumpy' rhythm. Also well known 'ordinary' i.e. not traditional of folky tunes can be used ,again with the right rhythm for the purpose, eg I often use Lilly the Pink as a Gay Gaordons tune & it always brings a smile to faces (where else!)
As far as I am concerned the 'dance may be of English, Scottish , Iirish, French or whatever origin and the same goes for the tunes. It is the , sometimes, subtle, changes that are made to suite English dancing & playing that make it essentially English, not the origins.
george
-
Collectively, thank you for your help.
I am now keen to buy a D/G box. Listen to as much English music as possible and more importantly, Learn to play something other than a one row.
Never been to a session, so that's an experience i look forward too. Your descriptions of English music has given me food for thought.
Thanks
ron1
-
Believe there's a good 'English' session in NW London though never managed to get there personally .
If you're in south London - Gavin and his merry men actually offer a teach-in
If you can offer your rough coodindates, I promise someone here will invite you to theirs.
-
Thanks Chris,
A kind offer.
Lewisham SE13 is near enough.
-
If you can get to any of the major festivals in August/september there should be a number of English(ish) sessions to go at .Certainly Whitby and Sidmouth have plenty to go at along with a lot of other stuff.
george
-
I notice every-one is shying of Question 2 which is 'which box?' >:E
So I'll start the ball rolling by saying that when I started I was advised by a very helpful gentleman manning the Music Room stall at priddy festival who recommended that if I wanted to play English (inc. Morris) the Hohner Pokerwork was 'what most people start with' . Workshops are awash with them which tends to bear out the veracity of this statement. I certainly found mine to be great to learn on. Personally I would eschew the advice I have heard given which is to buy 'the best box you can afford', but that may be just a personal view stemming from having a Castagnari and been a bit embarrassed I can't play it as well as I feel it deserves :|bl
It may be something to do with heredity and resonance with earth energies or something but I find it's only English tunes that really hit the spot for me
:||: (born and bred in Yorkshire and now resident in Dorset)
-
I want to play English music and wondered what box is considered the best and in what key.
There is no single answer to this question. If there was, everyone at an English session or playing for morris would play the same make and model of box. There is a general consensus that for English music it is best to have a box that can be played easily in D and G because the vast majority of tunes are in those keys, but there the consensus ends.
The best way to play any kind of music is to play it on a box that you feel comfortable playing because that will enable you to play with more expression and with greater confidence. We all have our own idiosyncrasies about how we hold the box, how we play it and the sound we prefer, so it should come as no surprise that some prefer Hohners, others Dino Baffettis, others Castagnaris etc. The best advice I can offer is to try as many different boxes as possible until you find one that sounds and feels right for you.
-
:||: (born and bred in Yorkshire and now resident in Dorset)
Ah - welcome to civilisation!
-
I'm prepared to give a little advice on 'what box', which is that there's a lot to be said for a Hohner Pokerwork, but they are extraordinarily expensive new (as are all boxes to be honest) these days. And although Pokerworks have a fantastic sound, they are quite hard to play. You can get a real sense of what sorts of things are available by going to, eg, the Music Room stall at a festival, or even by hanging around with box players. But eventually you are going to have to pick a budget and either go to a dealer and play a range of things, or try to find a second-hand box sold privately to suit you.
D/G boxes come up quite often for sale on these very forums; a wide range of shapes and styles, and people here can give you advice. eBay is a bit scary if you're not sure what you're doing. I bought my first box secondhand from Rees Wesson and was very happy with it (need to sell it actually but it still needs that hour of maintenance doing that S said he'd do over a year ago and never has).
-
And although Pokerworks have a fantastic sound, they are quite hard to play.
That is true to a certain extent - I have played some Pokerworks that were a nightmare, and others that were a delight. It seems to me the quality and playability of Pokerworks is very variable, depending on such factors as age, place of manufacture and degree of "tweaking". The nicest one I've played was about 30 years old, German built, and apparently much as it left the factory. OK, it didn't play quite as smoothly as my Saltarelle, but it spoke very quickly and easily, took me maybe 90 seconds to adjust to, and sounded GORGEOUS. On the other hand, one I borrowed was frankly fit only for dismantling for spares....I was glad to return it to its unfortunate owner. I have to admit I've never actually owned a Pokerwork, though I've played many, and I do have a couple of pre-Pokerwork (or "Goldbrand") 2915s, both of which I find a pleasure to play - both wooden fingerboards, of course. Maybe older is better..........
Graham
-
It seems that D/G tuning puts an immediate price premium on a box, but if you buy a popular melodeon such as a Pokerwork or Erica, they do hold their prices (as do their more expensive bretheren, of course).
I have found that, if you do make it to sessions, other players are often more than willing to let you have a go - don't be afraid to ask, even if it's just to get the feel of a box. I find it a little daunting to try boxes at trade stalls or shops, at my present level, although I've never felt any pressure. On the other hand, if you do try one from a dealer it is likely to be in good condition.
Your biggest problem might be stopping at one...
-
I am overwhelmed by the response to my English Question and the diversity of knowledge. To be honest, I never expected more than (1) or (0) answers. Thank you so much for all your advice.
I tend to steer clear of Ebay now, as a box I purchased was to be honest, a piece of junk and certainly not as advertised by the seller. Dare I say, not a Hohner Pokerwork. Still to be purchased.
Yes, its nice to find a box that suits you and you enjoy playing but it takes time to feel comfortable and at one with the instrument, no matter what make or model. The joy for me is buy and try. Even if I end up with a closet full.
-
Lots of people mention the Pokerwork but I would advise anyone thinking of a Hohner to try an oldish Erica. The insides are the same but the case is much more comfortable to play. They do need the button travel limiting, just like pokerworks. However chaps like Theo can sort that out for a very reasonable fee. I have had an Erica for over 25 years and it has never let me down and it still gets used despite my now having a posh Italian box.
-
If you take your time and ask nicely, most people will let you try their box - so long as you aren't wearing braces, big belt buckle or zipped jacket! (normal morris gear) I find most beginners/intermediates have reached the stage of wondering whether their perceived limitations are from their own ability or the boxes.
I've never leant my best box to anyone without having to prize their fingers off it to get it back. It may not be that a new box is needed, but it's nice to know that you're not doing bad whilst fighting with a cheap(ish) box. I also have a Chinese Pokerwork and it's c++p, but I still use it in the Border band, but whilst I can put up with the action, the reeds are just too variable in performance. Recently got very tempted by a good German Erica and just missed a Swiss one (damn).
Rob.
-
Erica's have been recommended. I to have a cosatlottie and an Erica which I wouldn't dream of parting with. Theo often has such boxes as does Mike (http://www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/index.html) in the southwest. Old ones are best.
-
I've had a couple of Ericas - in fact my first ever melodeon was an Erica - and they were both very nice boxes. Yes, the treble action needs limiting but they do sound good. I must admit I don't like the look of them as much as a Pokerwork, and the 30/40-year old one I referred to above played better than either of my Ericas of roughly the same vintage.
-
I've had a couple of Ericas - in fact my first ever melodeon was an Erica - and they were both very nice boxes. Yes, the treble action needs limiting but they do sound good. I must admit I don't like the look of them as much as a Pokerwork, and the 30/40-year old one I referred to above played better than either of my Ericas of roughly the same vintage.
Eh? The pokerwork has to be the most unpleasantly hideous commonly available box.
-
Eh? The pokerwork has to be the most unpleasantly hideous commonly available box.
You are not a fan then ::)
-
Eh? The pokerwork has to be the most unpleasantly hideous commonly available box.
No, that would be a Castagnari.......... or maybe a Serenellini.........>:E
-
Joking aside, and to clarify my last post a little, I'm not a great fan of boxes that look as though they've been made by cabinet-makers or (even worse!) woodwork teachers; accordions are not pieces of furniture, they're instruments made to be played. My original comment actually only concerned the aesthetics of the Pokerwork vs the Erica. The Pokerwork looks the way it sounds, if you see what I mean; the Erica is plasicky, juke-boxy and generally rather tacky, while the Pokerwork is a no-nonsense, no-frills workhorse of a box. Maybe that's why I own one Saltarelle and 8 Hohners.......... (:)
-
that S said he'd do over a year ago and never has).
Rees has been to Suffolk and has slowed down.
Cheers Chas :|glug
-
Eh? The pokerwork has to be the most unpleasantly hideous commonly available box.
You are not a fan then ::)
Erm, no. Although I have to say that I am more of a fan of celluloid than I was, as long as it's applied with taste and no rhinestones. However, a well made wooden box is a beautiful thing (:)
-
Eh? The pokerwork has to be the most unpleasantly hideous commonly available box.
You are not a fan then ::)
Erm, no. Although I have to say that I am more of a fan of celluloid than I was, as long as it's applied with taste and no rhinestones. However, a well made wooden box is a beautiful thing (:)
My opinion hohners are, I like the sound but not the clackity buttons. And bar one every pokerwork I've ever tried has been a pig to play and I've ended up aching afterwards.
-
My opinion hohners are, I like the sound but not the clackity buttons.
The clackity buttons are optional, I am about to reveal my Super Pokerwork which has no such buttons.
-
Hohners - the Marmite of melodeons. You either love 'em or hate 'em. Now personally I can't STAND Marmite - even the thought of it makes me feel queasy; but give me a nice old Hohner, clacketty buttons and all...............
-
(although Scottish music sometimes sneaks its way into Irish sessions on the dubious grounds that it's "celtic").
Can it be true that Scottish music is not celtic? Shock, horror!!! Me thinks this may be a tad mistaken!
-
(although Scottish music sometimes sneaks its way into Irish sessions on the dubious grounds that it's "celtic").
Can it be true that Scottish music is not celtic? Shock, horror!!! Me thinks this may be a tad mistaken!
I don't think Scottish music 'sneaks' into irish sessions - it is taken on board willingly because of its intrinsic merit.
george >:E
-
(although Scottish music sometimes sneaks its way into Irish sessions on the dubious grounds that it's "celtic").
Can it be true that Scottish music is not celtic? Shock, horror!!! Me thinks this may be a tad mistaken!
I don't think Scottish music 'sneaks' into irish sessions - it is taken on board willingly because of its intrinsic merit.
george >:E
Not wishing to get any more off topic but I agree George. It is inextricably linked and as celtic as you get!
-
It seems that by straying into provenance, the old rivalries of ownership have raised their ugly heads again.
If we leave out Irish and Scotts we are still left with Welsh, Northumbrian, East Anglian, Devonian and other regions of England (Opps, sorry Wales) who all play in different styles. The tunes are of course in many cases arguable as to where they originated as we see in many threads on this site. People who learnt in isolation before the internet etc often remembered snatches of a tune which they then pieced together. A recent offering on melnet had The Cliff as an A part and Harvest home for the B part with a claim of the whole having been recently written. I don't believe there is any malice in such claims just they have no recall of how the tune got in their head.
So, it must all be about how the tune is played which raises the further question of if an trad celtic tune is played in an English style how is it classified?
This maybe a good one for Clive, tune of the month, one culture played as another. Maybe this already exists on Youtube (everything else does !!)
-
This maybe a good one for Clive, tune of the month, one culture played as another. Maybe this already exists on Youtube (everything else does !!)
We've already had that, it was called "Morris Tunes" ;)
-
. A recent offering on melnet had The Cliff as an A part and Harvest home for the B part with a claim of the whole having been recently written. I don't believe there is any malice in such claims just they have no recall of how the tune got in their head.
So, it must all be about how else does !!)
I have written a few tunes like that myself only to be disapointed when somedy says ' thats such and such a tune - bugger - back to the drawing bnoard!
george :(
-
We've already had that, it was called "Morris Tunes" ;)
LOL ;D
-
It seems that by straying into provenance, the old rivalries of ownership have raised their ugly heads again.
If we leave out Irish and Scotts we are still left with Welsh, Northumbrian, East Anglian, Devonian and other regions of England (Opps, sorry Wales) who all play in different styles. The tunes are of course in many cases arguable as to where they originated as we see in many threads on this site. People who learnt in isolation before the internet etc often remembered snatches of a tune which they then pieced together. A recent offering on melnet had The Cliff as an A part and Harvest home for the B part with a claim of the whole having been recently written. I don't believe there is any malice in such claims just they have no recall of how the tune got in their head.
So, it must all be about how the tune is played which raises the further question of if an trad celtic tune is played in an English style how is it classified?
This maybe a good one for Clive, tune of the month, one culture played as another. Maybe this already exists on Youtube (everything else does !!)
Don't forget propriety ;D Whoever the Scotts are please include the Scots! ; >:E
-
Don't forget propriety ;D Whoever the Scotts are please include the Scots! ; >:E
Another Opps it's not just Wales I've offended :|bl and me a Jardine from Ayrshire
-
And a lot of the Scotts are English and proud of it! My mum's family have been in York for several centuries now, so I will be offended as well if that's all right with you Graeme. ;D
-
Offended people - please form an orderly queue here ;D
-
As a Scouser can I say I am PERMANENTLY outraged and offended- even when not wearing my shell-suit. I am lining up in hopeful anticipation of being insulted.
-
I didn't know there were any melodeons in Liverpool ???
-
Speaking of good looking boxes and although i have never played them, I do like the look of the Castagnaris and similar boxes. If only I could afford. To get my hands on one of these would be great.
Again I have not played, but pictures I have seen of the Hohner Pokerworks, they do look rather "boxy"
Then again, maybe I haven't lived yet and need experience, lol
-
I should imagine there are several melodeons in Liverpool - it's a very musical city and always has been. However, I am exiled in Norfolk! (From the sublime to the ridiculous 8))
-
I should imagine there are several melodeons in Liverpool - it's a very musical city and always has been. However, I am exiled in Norfolk! (From the sublime to the ridiculous 8))
I'm trying VERY hard to resist the temptation.....one of my best friends is a Scouser and she'd laugh, but I'd better not risk offending anyone!
Graham