Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: DoninOhio on August 01, 2011, 09:27:40 PM

Title: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: DoninOhio on August 01, 2011, 09:27:40 PM
A simple question. If you had to choose between the Weltmeister "Cajun" model or Hohner HA114 model, which would you recommend and why?
Thank you all.

Don
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 02, 2011, 01:47:07 AM
A simple question. If you had to choose between the Weltmeister "Cajun" model or Hohner HA114 model, which would you recommend and why?

In order of preference for beginners:
1. OLD (wooden keyboard) HA-114.  Great, easy-playing boxes.  Get one from Messervier or Gagne, or another shop in Quebec where they replace the spoon basses with buttons. Great mojo!
2. Weltmeister -- decent boxes, well-built, decent components.
3. New HA-114 -- plastic keyboard is not as nice as an older wooden one, bellows can be very stiff at first but OK once loosened up.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Theo on August 02, 2011, 09:38:02 AM
It depends on the sound you want.

Hohner - loud raucus, brash in yer face.  Stops have a habit of dropping to off position unless modified.
Weltmeister - still loud, but more refined (for a four stop) possibly less air hungry, factory tuning has less tremolo.  Stops are down for on, and less prone to dropping, so no risk of cutting out mid play.

As with all boxes there are diferences between examples of the same model so if at all possible try before you buy.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: ocajun on August 02, 2011, 01:49:18 PM
Probably the Weltmeister - better sound for Cajun - but my Hohner is in G and is doing a fine job on all the things we need a G box for, plus it weighs less and I'm usually carrying two boxes, guitar, cittern and mandolin (and 30" bodhran too at Lomond Folk Festival last weekend!).

What I need is a G Weltmeister and one of each in D (we have a fiddle player who is reluctant to tune down but is looking for a reasonable quality, left-handed second fiddle). I could then decide what works best with what material. I'm debating the C#/D option which would keep all the Cajun on the row in D or A and potentially give me some of the Scot/Irish/other American stuff in G if Joe can't manage singing it in A. It would also mean I might not need to get a wheelbarrow.

Basically, I like both and would choose mainly on sound (rather than size and weight).
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: forrest on August 02, 2011, 03:14:47 PM
A simple question. If you had to choose between the Weltmeister "Cajun" model or Hohner HA114 model, which would you recommend and why?
Thank you all.

Don

Hi DoninOhio.....you neglected to mention what style of music you intend to play.... as you mentioned the Weltmeister 'Cajun', you may or may not know that the Weltmeister 4 stops are available in several keys, some that are not Cajun tuned. I happen to own a Weltmeister in C that was Cajun tuned, with no tremolo, and I opted to alter the flatted thirds and sevenths, and added tremolo to the MM reeds, to get a more conventional tuning that could accomodate different styles of music.
  The Weltmeister is a solid box, very neatly and strongly built, no frills, corners and frames are mitred, will probably hold up as well as any Hohner in the long run. As Theo has mentioned, it is a bit milder sounding than the Hohner, the highs are less bright, but is very responsive and airtite. My main complaints about it (only from my point of view) is that it's a bit heavy, being built of beech...and the button springs are stiffer than other one rows I have played. The upshot of that is that (for me) I cannot play as quickly or perform ornaments as smoothly as with a good Hohner. Other folks, with less wear and tear on their hands, may have no difficulties there. Nevertheless, I am quite satisfied with it, and I think it's a good value for the price range. Also, as Theo suggests, try one out, if possible.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: DoninOhio on August 02, 2011, 07:14:11 PM
A simple question. If you had to choose between the Weltmeister "Cajun" model or Hohner HA114 model, which would you recommend and why?
Thank you all.

Don

Hi DoninOhio.....you neglected to mention what style of music you intend to play.... as you mentioned the Weltmeister 'Cajun', you may or may not know that the Weltmeister 4 stops are available in several keys, some that are not Cajun tuned. I happen to own a Weltmeister in C that was Cajun tuned, with no tremolo, and I opted to alter the flatted thirds and sevenths, and added tremolo to the MM reeds, to get a more conventional tuning that could accomodate different styles of music.
  The Weltmeister is a solid box, very neatly and strongly built, no frills, corners and frames are mitred, will probably hold up as well as any Hohner in the long run. As Theo has mentioned, it is a bit milder sounding than the Hohner, the highs are less bright, but is very responsive and airtite. My main complaints about it (only from my point of view) is that it's a bit heavy, being built of beech...and the button springs are stiffer than other one rows I have played. The upshot of that is that (for me) I cannot play as quickly or perform ornaments as smoothly as with a good Hohner. Other folks, with less wear and tear on their hands, may have no difficulties there. Nevertheless, I am quite satisfied with it, and I think it's a good value for the price range. Also, as Theo suggests, try one out, if possible.

Irish and Quebecois style on a D box
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Christopher K. on August 02, 2011, 07:42:29 PM
A riced up, de-branded Ariette would be perfect for those purposes  ;D
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 02, 2011, 09:26:32 PM
A riced up, de-branded Ariette would be perfect for those purposes  ;D

I have to say, I don't understand why one would go that route when a refurbed wooden-keyboard HA-114 can be had for $300-425 from any number of Canadian dealers.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Christopher K. on August 03, 2011, 12:34:05 AM
A riced up, de-branded Ariette would be perfect for those purposes  ;D

I have to say, I don't understand why one would go that route when a refurbed wooden-keyboard HA-114 can be had for $300-425 from any number of Canadian dealers.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Christopher K. on August 03, 2011, 12:40:36 AM
I meant to allude to member Quebecois' thread about his improved Ariette, I wasn't seriously suggesting an Ariiette as an alternative to a restored HA-114.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Harmonicatunes on August 03, 2011, 01:07:51 AM
Andy in Vermont said

"a refurbed wooden-keyboard HA-114 can be had for $300-425 from any number of Canadian dealers."

Who are these dealers? I might be interested in a HA114 in D somewhere down the track
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 03, 2011, 02:37:30 AM
Andy in Vermont said

"a refurbed wooden-keyboard HA-114 can be had for $300-425 from any number of Canadian dealers."

Who are these dealers? I might be interested in a HA114 in D somewhere down the track

Many players in Quebec start on one of these used and refurbed HA-114s, then sell or trade it when they upgrade to a Quebec-made box. They are usually in D (as opposed to used HA-114s elsewhere, where D is not necessarily the common key).  Box builders like Melodie and Messervier are one place to start, another place is the music store Gagne et Freres.  Finally, there are several Quebecois classifieds sites with people selling used stuff, and there are frequently used accordions.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Harmonicatunes on August 03, 2011, 06:55:04 AM
Hmm. Gagne et Frere didn't have anything (I read French). Nothing on ebay.ca Any other Canadian sites worth looking at for a refurbished HA114 in D? I'm in no rush, but I'd eventually like to have a good one. I have an HA114 in C which I like a lot, however many of the tunes I'd like to play are in D.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 03, 2011, 01:42:14 PM
Hmm. Gagne et Frere didn't have anything (I read French). Nothing on ebay.ca Any other Canadian sites worth looking at for a refurbished HA114 in D? I'm in no rush, but I'd eventually like to have a good one. I have an HA114 in C which I like a lot, however many of the tunes I'd like to play are in D.

Just call them. These guys are only minimally interested in internet business. When I saw the HA-114s at Gagne, they also were not on the website.
But anyhow, I think you'll have better luck calling Messervier.
Title: Re: Opinions on (One Row)Melodeon
Post by: pikey on August 30, 2011, 09:01:50 PM
@Theo - use the old fix for dropping stops - two wooden clothes pegs !  One does for 2 stops !
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal