Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: seinegydd on August 10, 2011, 05:25:42 PM
-
I've just noticed that the tune called "Scan Tester's Polka No. 1" in Dave Mallinson's English Pub Session Tunes is called "Scan Tester's Polka No. 2" in Nick Barber's English Choice, and vice versa. Which of them is right?
-
I don't have Mally's English Pub Sessions Book but I do have two other books (Lewes Favourites & Paul Hardy's Sessions Tune Book) that have them numbered the other way round from Nick Barber's English Choice. That's not to say that three books can't be wrong!
Pete.
-
Based on past experience of related matters, Nick is probably wrong and I'd expect Will Duke (who owns one of Scan's concertinas and plays lots of his music) to make sure the Lewes folk got it right!
Not that Scan would have called them that anyway, of course. Numbers like that are only assigned by collectors when they don't have any other names for tunes.
-
On the record that Peter Kennedy called "The Man in the Moon", which included music and interviewing, Scan Tester himself said that he numbered the tunes.
I've just had a listen to it again to confirm my memory.
He said that what often "got him beat" was the names of the tunes. When he "went up to London" (to play at Cecil Sharp house I believe) and people asked him for the names he had the bright idea of numbering them ... though this then meant that he had to try to remember which number he had given to which tune for the next time ;D
As an aside (gentley drifting), it's worth having a look at Rod Stradling's musings on the legacy of Peter Kennedy.
Edit: and a link to that Rod Stradling musing might be a good idea ... http://www.mustrad.org.uk/enth53.htm
-
Scan Tester himself said that he numbered the tunes.
Oh well.
That just goes to show you shouldn't believe everything you read on that thar interwebs thingummy.
Especially if I wrote it.
-
Well Andrew, that article you linked by Mr Stradling was an eye opener. Just goes to show that you need to be careful where money and copyright and perfomances are involved. I work in the world of photography and know how many regard copyright with disdain when it suits them, the BBC have a fine set of Double Standards for example.
-
Based on past experience of related matters, Nick is probably wrong and I'd expect Will Duke (who owns one of Scan's concertinas and plays lots of his music) to make sure the Lewes folk got it right!
Not that Scan would have called them that anyway, of course. Numbers like that are only assigned by collectors when they don't have any other names for tunes.
Man of my acquaintance refers to the buggered-if-I-know polkas and waltzes. Has mentioned the buggered-if-I know number so-and-so....
-
Scan Tester himself said that he numbered the tunes.
Oh well.
That just goes to show you shouldn't believe everything you read on that thar interwebs thingummy.
Especially if I wrote it.
Your's would have been my assumption if I hadn't have had the record.
and I'm sure I'll end up arguing with myself on some forum one day.