Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: bb23 on August 11, 2011, 08:19:52 AM
-
Please forgive me if this has already been covered - didn't find it.
I just received Bal Folk, which is the Mel Bay incarnation of a great collection of 214 French Trad tunes. Most of the tunes give the melody, but no hint as to the bass line. My question is whether there is generally accepted standard or norm as to how the bass line progresses in a given tune type, say a waltz in G or bourree in C...or am I to just figure it out by trial and error?
I'm all for practice, but don't want to make this harder than it needs to be. Thanks.
-
Very rare for there to be "the" bass line for any given tune.
If you're thinking about which bass notes/chords to use, then in my opinion the best approach is to experiment with whatever sounds good or interesting.
If you're thinking about rhythm/feel, and in particular if you want to be true to the (e.g. dance) style of the tune, then it's a good idea to check out youtube clips by good (box) players. Every now and then there is relevant discussion on this forum, e.g. here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7393.0.html) and here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4876.0.html).
-
I would say that there is no 'standard' bass/chordal accompaniment for French tunes (no more than for other genres). Many tunes have developed from bagpipe or hurdy-gurdy music, and so work well with a drone-type accompaniment.
Your best bet is to listen to some French traditional music and take it from there. Youtube is your friend.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcNTVnAaEpA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jDqkaSs1Dg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YydKg93O7_E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqAL2jBL1As
I'm sure you get the idea....
Edited to add - jb has written much the same while I was composing mine....
-
Hello, BB you can find better books then the mel bay...
http://boutique.mustradem.com/index.php?cPath=24&language=en&osCsid=e131199c0a10c19e6db5fc123f286371
book one will help you very much book two will give you much good advice
book three is just fun to read if you never get to it too play in. but alot of your questions
can be answered there. they are written in french and english. rather costly but for
the money you have wonderful references and a road to follow that I would hope
please you.. ear training and watching others play is just part of the whole...
have a good time
-
I should have have remembered this earlier.....
Bernard Loffet's website includes a large collection of French tunes in tablature so you can see the bass/chords which go with the tunes.
See here:
http://diato.org/tablat.htm#tabs
(you may need to scroll down)
Click on the 'png' option to see the tunes in tablature.
There is also an explanation of how the tablature works near the top of the page on the left.
The tablature will be written out for G/C melodeon, but it will still work on any other system - it will just come out at a different pitch.
-
I'm all for practice, but don't want to make this harder than it needs to be. Thanks.
If you are in England look for an opportunity to get to a workshop by Andy Cutting.
-
Thanks everyone for the replies. I think the following quote gets to the question I was attempting to get at, which is which bass/chord to use with each measure of the tune. Or more loosely, is there a general framework, free to be ignored, like start a G tune with G, then C, then....go to the moon and finally end on G. Something like that.
If you're thinking about which bass notes/chords to use, then in my opinion the best approach is to experiment with whatever sounds good or interesting.
The rhythm as I understand can be all over the map depending on what kind of feel you're looking for.
Larry - I agree the Pignot-Milleret books are great and I'm working through the first one (about 1/2 way!).
Steve - all great links.
Theo - I'm in the Western US, but nowhere near the coast. So far, my "workshops" have been in this forum, Youtube, and a number of other sites. Its no substitute for a living tutor, but is working remarkably well at this stage in the game.
-
The question I was attempting to get at, which is which bass/chord to use with each measure of the tune. Or more loosely, is there a general framework, free to be ignored, like start a G tune with G, then C, then....go to the moon and finally end on G. Something like that.
You can't apply a framework like that rigidly to any tune, but you will notice that certain sequences seem to come up frequently.
For a tune in G, for instance:
- Likely to start on G
- Even more likely to end on G
- penultimate chord likely to be D
- C - D - G is a common sequence (a.k.a. IV-V-I which is the same concept expressed in terms that work in any key
- This kind of "three chord trick" formula really doesn't get you much further than that. You have to listen to the tune and decide what fits, by experiment if necessary. Trips to moon optional. Remember on a D/G box E minor is an option sometimes for interesting results, but involves row crossing.
-
This site has loads of European and some British/Irish tunes available in pdf tab format for G/C box with suggested chords, and you can also have a listen to the tune line if you're not a good reader. Some of them may be the same as those in your book:
http://www.diatonia.net/