Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Alison Scott on August 11, 2008, 01:46:48 PM

Title: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Alison Scott on August 11, 2008, 01:46:48 PM
I keep reading things that explain how easy the melodeon is to play. I've now been playing for 2 1/2 years. I practice most days, and I even play scales sometimes. I've joined a morris side in an effort to improve my playing. I play in sessions, I play with others at the folk club in an attempt to cure my nerves. I play slow tunes, fast tunes, easy tunes, complex tunes, and lots of different rhythms. I've been to several workshops.

I would like, just once, to be able to play something, no matter how simple, so that I think it sounds ok. Not, you know, good. Just ok. What I'm finding is that the more I practice, and the more I listen to other melodeon players, the greater my understanding of the complexity and range of the instrument. And the more I understand, the more I realise how limited my ability is and how vastly much more I need to do in order to play tolerably well. At first I used to think 'oh, if I just practice a bit more, I'll get the hang of it.' But I no longer think that's the case. Instead, I strongly suspect that the more I play, the greater the gulf between my playing and my expectations will become.

Should I pack it in now?
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: C age ing on August 11, 2008, 02:38:28 PM
Neither.
You are expecting perfection which after two and a half years of anything is not to be expected, just ask my girlfriend. :-[
Do others complain about your ability? If not you are that very common thing, your hardest critic.
Relax, you are perfectly normal, just remember even the maestros are not satisfied with their own performance, which is why they use far less skilled mentors.
Old and for once, wise Bill.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Lin Leighton on August 11, 2008, 03:19:30 PM
Thats funny Alison - I was only thinking that very same thing myself (about myself) just this weekend, and Ive been "playing " for almost six years now!!   ::)

Anyone around from the good ole days when I first joined and during my initial first stages will remember that I posted continuosly that I hated basse, and I concentrated on learning large quantity of tunes melodies, but didnt worry too much about the basses.  Well just recently I have found that I am looking more and more at "bettering" basses (hah ha)  and I came to the same conclusion as you  ;)  There is sooooooooooooooooooooooooo  much to learn and not enuff time, so listen to c age ing ( well someone has to!!)  and just enjoy yourself, thats the main thing!!

Lin
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Lester on August 11, 2008, 03:27:04 PM
After 25 years I still wish I was much better and, more to the point, that there was nothing new to learn. Melodeoning is like climing a never ending hill, just as you crest the top of the hill there is another crest in front.

Mind you it would be really boring if we were all Squeezy and he would be out of a job!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: joe on August 11, 2008, 04:03:26 PM
The crests analogy is spot on! I think that sometimes, ability is inversely proportionate to perceived ability.

Mind you due to lack of practise recently, I have actually gone downhill which is a bit depressing. I used t go back to melodeon or fiddle after a while not practising and actually feel like I could play it a lot better, but not so much recently.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: OwenG on August 11, 2008, 04:17:12 PM
When I feel that I'm not progressing I sometimes flip my box over and play left-handed to remind myself what it was like when I started playing. It makes playing anything the 'right' way round seem easy!!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Quebecois on August 11, 2008, 04:49:22 PM
I much prefer people who are aware of their limits and level of playing to those who think they are "experts" and aren't!

Learning to play any instrument is a long journey! Don't get depressed, be patient, enjoy your playing, do your best, keep working smartly and over all, keep the fun factor up!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: C age ing on August 11, 2008, 05:28:22 PM
I much prefer people who are aware of their limits and level of playing to those who think they are "experts" and aren't!

Learning to play any instrument is a long journey! Don't get depressed, be patient, enjoy your playing, do your best, keep working smartly and over all, keep the fun factor up!

I wonder if telling someone that it is a "long journey" helps?

Alison, it is really a series of short easy journeys and "being aware of their limits and level of playing" generally leads most trainees to under estimate their abilities and discourage them from experimenting.
One thing is absolutely certain, you are a much better melodeon player than me.
See what I mean by self doubts being the worst enemy?
Old but ex trainer trainer Bill.

Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: TomB-R on August 11, 2008, 06:01:22 PM

I wonder if telling someone that it is a "long journey" helps?


"The longest journey starts with a single footstep...."
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Quebecois on August 11, 2008, 06:25:32 PM
I wonder if telling someone that it is a "long journey" helps?
Yes it does!
A long journey doesn't mean it has to be sad.

I have seen too many people (especially kids) take up an instrument and expect to play everything they wanted within a few hours of practice, then get depressed.

You can make your learning a fun and productive journey as you progress, step by step... lots of happy steps!

Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Ellie on August 11, 2008, 06:37:36 PM
Well, I was at a bellydance workshop on Sunday when exactly this topic came up, about the learning cycle, and how different people respond to it. One of the main points I found helpful was that she suggested going back to beginners classes, partly to re-learn the basics (always useful), and partly to show how much you have improved by comparison. I guess you could do the same by keeping a sort of 'learning diary'. Look back to what you were writing 3 or 6 months ago and see how much you've improved, probably without even realising it. Funnily enough, this is more relevant to my melodeon playing than my  dancing  ::)

Workshops can be either inspiring, or they can cause this sort of reaction of 'I'm never going to be that good' - which is when you go and look back at your own progress :) Certainly don't give up! Perhaps giving yourself some short terms goals as well as long term goals - specific things to aim for. It's a bit like writing a list of thing to do and putting 'write list' at the top so you've got something to cross of straight away (or am I the only person that does that?) - it's all about making yourself feel positive about your progress and remebering how far you've come :)

Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Matthew B on August 11, 2008, 07:30:07 PM
All of the above it true.  It could always be better.  There's always a new horizon, which is one of the things that keeps it interesting.  But I've also found that even now, at this early stage in my own learning, there are the really good days.  Think of the time when something that seemed impossible suddenly works, or you figure out a tune, or a chord or a fingering that has always eluded you in the past, or you're playing for a dance and the dancers jump and swirl beautifully, and there you are squeezing away.  Don't forget to notice those magic moments in your search for some higher perfection.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Falseknight on August 12, 2008, 12:28:40 AM
Been playing guitar for about 37 years now and I'm still learning.  Mind you, the problems I encounter now are not eh ones I started with - in fact teaching beginners is very hard now because I lack understanding of their difficulties.

I've had an 18 year gap in melodeon.  The first surprise has been how quickly things have come back, the second surprise is how much more clearly now I understand what is going on with the instrument.  As soon as we stop learning,we might a well stop playing - so don't be worried by the thought of the long journey.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: C age ing on August 12, 2008, 06:28:41 AM
I wonder if telling someone that it is a "long journey" helps?
Yes it does!
A long journey doesn't mean it has to be sad.

Good teaching practice tells us that suggesting that something is hard, makes it hard. If you are the only teacher available, you can make a mint out of pupils by telling them it is a hard, long journey and they need regular twice weekly lessons, that is until you've knocked all the enthusiasm out of them, when file for bankruptcy.

What a good teacher/trainer/coach does is gently encourage the pupil into apparently discovering things for themselves. It has to be a joint journey where, during the apparent 'down' periods, the pupil is reminded of all the gains that they have made. The object is for the pupil to own all their knowledge.

Alison, think about all the things you can do now that you couldn't do previously. Realise that learning is not a smooth curve, it is periods of progress followed by a period where the brain re shuffles the new knowledge. That seems like regression but in fact you retain the previous learning, and then find that it all comes together again and the new knowledge makes comfortable sense. You are a perfectly normal person suffering the perfectly normal and needless self doubts.
Go for it Alison!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Itu on August 12, 2008, 07:08:49 AM
I don't know if this applies, but I started learning to play the violin at age 11. Where I grew up at there were no other people that played violin and I had to travel an hour each way for my lessons. I went to my lessons every week, practiced every day and thought that I played just fine. I then tried out for a youth symphony and was accepted. It was then that I realized that I didn't know as much as I thought I did and was not as good as some of the other people that I was now forced to play with. But I kept going and got through it, probably not well though. Since there were no ther violin players in the area, I frequently got asked to perform at the local churches and convalescent homes. Most of the time I was accompanied my friend on piano, or I did a duet with my uncle. I was still young and this helped to build my confidence in my playing.

After many years of doing this,I quit playing all together for about a year. My grandparent's neighbor had an old violin and asked me if I could help them get it repaired. Neither one of them played and asked me if I would come over and play for them sometime. I was scared to death since I had not touched a violin for over a year. I decided that I needed to practice before I went over there, so I dusted off my strings and pulled out some familiar music. I was astounded at the sound. I called my mother up and told her that she had to come over and hear this. So I played for my mother as sort of a trial run. She told me that she could not believe the difference in how I used to sound compared to now. She told me that before that my practice sessions could get very annoying, but she wasn't about to say anything.

I have no idea what happened in that year other than the fact that I learned how to play the marimba and the tympani. I guess that during that year my understanding of music deepened and I had time to analyze my techniques, so when I went back to the violin it showed. Sorry if I am long-winded at times. I know I can get carried away.  :-[
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: GuyWyatt on August 12, 2008, 07:54:44 AM
Some years ago I used to teach karate. Often students would come to me and say that recently they were pleased that recently they had got a lot better, or depressed that they had gone backwards, or frustrated becuse they had hit a plateau. They were almost always wrong. For any student who was working hard and consistently they were improving consistently. But... the mind and the body progress at different rates. If your mind gets ahead of your body you become more critical of your performance. If your body moves ahead of your mind you are less critical and then think that you are doing well. What applies to physical skills like karate also applies to music. As your critical faculties improve your are more critical of your playing and have a better appreciation of thhe skills of others. You can find yourself depressed by that. But be clear that this is a sign of your improvement, not the contrary.

Sometimes, incidentally, even I am astonished by how pompous I sound.

All of the above is easy to say of course....

Cheers
Guy
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 12, 2008, 10:45:31 PM
All the comments above not only make me feel a lot less dispraxic, but also flatter me about my musical skills. I like being flattered (but money is the best form of it!) Look out when we meet at Whitby, George  - I seem to be an expert! ;D

Chris-the-not-at-the-moment-anonymous.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: mber on August 13, 2008, 01:20:44 AM
All the advices are correct, even the contradicting, because, you see, for each is it's own.
Some will get hardened and work more if they realize how bad they are and what a long journey it is.
Others will get disheartened and quit, they need to be honed and encouraged, pumped up and guided.
Yet other others will have so much confidence in their talent (perceived or real), that no matter how they do, they enjoy it.
There is, of course, the realistic view that is not easy to obtain objectively: that is - am I talented or not?
That depends on the goal and general cultural upbringing. For different people been "talented" means different things.
Are you keenly aware of the nuances of good players' playing and are you of the opinion, that if you don't play like them, learning to play is not worthy? Then it is time to pack up. Life is much more, than spending countless hours on useless practice. But if you play for kids, that happily dance and it makes it worthy for you - keep on. They will remember it as bright moments of their lifes.
May be you used to play other instrument, but felt you don't appreciate the system or sound, and went to accordion because you liked it better. Only to find that your previous progress was better, faster, and more promicing. Then perhaps you should go back.
My Uke playing is pretty good, without any effort from me, but I'm drawn to buttons. My accordion playing is heavy, cumbersome and takes lots of practice to lighten up. My Concertina playing is so raw, I don't even know whether it's good or not. Sometimes I like my playing, sometimes I am so frustrated, I want ot whack it to smithereens. My harmonica playing is very impressive, but I am not moved by the sound as much.
You guessed right, I went forth and back.
Record yourself, phrase by phrase, trying to get the spacing, the accents. And if you are so expectant, by all means, get yourself the best instrument, you'd get for your 18 year old musically inclined child, on his/her birthday. Treat yourself nicely, don't let anything and anybody stand between you and your instrument. If you do, Pack up.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: flipper on August 20, 2008, 12:49:17 AM
Do not let comments by other people get you down. I almost gave up playing just a few months ago because of comments made by another player and playing has been my life for almost 20 years. (the person concerned had been playing for about a year). I after a lot of soul searching realised that playing was far too important to me to be put off by someone else and so decided to just play but find new places to play where this person wasn't. I am now enjoying playing again and hope not to meet up with him ever again. Like you I don't feel that I am a good player but I enjoy it and it gives me great pleasure, you can't beat the feeling when the music comes together and the muscians are grinning at each other because it is such fun and you all laugh when you finish the tune. That is what playing is all about and it doesn't have to be professional standard just fun.

sue
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Martin J on August 20, 2008, 09:54:34 AM
Elsewhere on the forum I have applauded those who listen to their own playing.  It's great to do this but don't be hard on yourself, enjoy what you do well and try to fix the weak spots.  I've been playing just over thirty years and I learn something new about me lodeons every week.

I ran JK's melodeon workshop at Bideford until he got there (held up in traffic) and in 40 minutes taught 11 people to play a passable version of Jump at he Sun, (only Ian knew the piece)  Many had never cross rowed before, most had never used their accidentals and there were four different keyboard layouts.  When John arrived the group played the tune for him.  It only happened because each person helped their neighbour.  Hopefully people took away ideas and concepts they would use in other tunes.  The point I'm trying to make is that sessions and workshops are invaluable but not just for learning a specific tune it's the ideas and methods you can take away and use in other pieces.

Keep enjoying and keep listening - you will become very good.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Stiamh on August 20, 2008, 01:33:34 PM
... taught 11 people to play a passable version of Jump at the Sun...

[digression mode on]Shudder... You should be impeached for that. I never liked the piece and played it to death in a dance band I was a member of in the 1970s. That tune is one of the reasons I was glad to leave England. I thought I had heard the last of it until... nearly 20 years later it came back to haunt me. Somebody returned to Montreal from a visit to the St. Chartier festival with the thing, and worse, a small number of players have latched on to it.

Amusingly, when I asked the perpertrator where she had got the accursed thing, she told me it was called "John Patterson"  ;D

This was the same girl who once told me she had been listening to a great fiddler called Martinez. Took me a minute to work that one out, and 10 minutes to stop laughing after.[digression mode off]
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Martin J on August 20, 2008, 02:16:10 PM
strange, JK actually did shudder !!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Alison Scott on August 20, 2008, 03:12:33 PM
Thanks for all the good answers everyone. I should confess to having had my tongue a little in my cheek when I originally posted; I do have 'down' moments, but mostly I just keep working through them.

I wanted to elicit some thoughts and reactions; and we might want to store this thread as an answer to one of the questions in our not-yet-written FAQ.


Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on August 20, 2008, 04:59:36 PM
I wanted to elicit some thoughts and reactions; and we might want to store this thread as an answer to one of the questions in our not-yet-written FAQ.
Thank you, Alison, for picking up the FAQ idea. I thought I was nearly alone in the wilderness  ::)
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Fi on September 19, 2008, 12:56:16 PM

Well, I haven't been in here for ages, and also I haven't really played for ages either.

I took the box to morris last night and I seem to have regressed to how I played after I'd been playing for about a year, or possibly worse  (I've been at it for longer than that, even managed to play solo for a couple of dances with my old side!). Found I had fingers all over the place, basses non existent, lack of ability to breathe and play simultaneously etc etc  :(

It's all a bit dispiriting really...I'm hoping if I can be manage to play for half an hour or so each day an ability to play tolerably ok may come back (I'll have to have a word with the little chap and see if I'm allowed ::)) or I'll have to take up the jangly bottle cap stick instead!
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on September 19, 2008, 01:26:41 PM
It's all a bit dispiriting really...I'm hoping if I can be manage to play for half an hour or so each day an ability to play tolerably ok may come back (I'll have to have a word with the little chap and see if I'm allowed ::)) or I'll have to take up the jangly bottle cap stick instead!

It's called a Lagerphone.  ;D
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Lester on September 19, 2008, 01:40:06 PM
It's called a Lagerphone.  ;D

Bl00dy odd! I have not heard of Lagerphones for years and years until in the last few weeks there was a group* on Folk on Two who used one, a bloke at a local folk club sang a Wurzel's song whilst accompanying himself with one and now they turn up here.

Can't remember who they were but the line up was Accordion, Banjo and Lagerphone, the three instruments on the top of my hate list but it sounded really good  :o
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Dazbo on September 19, 2008, 02:19:08 PM
isn't the lagerphone another aussie import we've (here in the UK) got to thank the Sainted Rolf Harris for?
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on September 19, 2008, 02:24:15 PM
It's called a Lagerphone.  ;D

Bl00dy odd! I have not heard of Lagerphones for years and years until in the last few weeks there was a group* on Folk on Two who used one, a bloke at a local folk club sang a Wurzel's song whilst accompanying himself with one and now they turn up here.

Can't remember who they were but the line up was Accordion, Banjo and Lagerphone, the three instruments on the top of my hate list but it sounded really good  :o

One of the dancers in our ladies side hurt her foot, and dug out the side 'instrument' a couple of years ago. She was very good on it. Very important is the knackered kiddies trainer on the bottom, and the small axe handle to play it with. Also some German walking stick enamelled badges nailed on.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Waltham on September 19, 2008, 02:26:12 PM
The name's an Aussie import, but the instrument's been around much longer.  When you hear a Jingling Johnny (as they're called round these parts of 'Ampshire) played really well it's wonderful, far too often they're badly played by people who assume there's nothing to it.  Bit like melodeons really.
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Fi on September 19, 2008, 05:42:50 PM

Well you know I never knew it had a proper name! We call ours the BootStick as it has a small child's purple (our colours) DM Boot on the end (instead of a knackered trainer... )
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Simon W on September 20, 2008, 01:03:45 PM

isn't the lagerphone another aussie import we've (here in the UK) got to thank the Sainted Rolf Harris for?

Might be German - there are some right fancy models made by this accordion maker
http://www.schneeberg-harmonika.de/Teufelsgeige/
Bit more expensive than a broomstick and some bottle caps though!

Simon
Title: Re: Am I thick or just clumsy?
Post by: Peter G on September 20, 2008, 01:58:25 PM
I was under the impression that the lagerphone was an Australian invention , having encounterd it there when I emigrated in the 70s It was played with immense skill by a bloke in the Bushwackers band- the best performances I saw live depended on notches cut into the vertical bit so it could also be played like a washboard extending its versatility
I think the band in question on R2 may have been the Groanbox boys, whom I saw at Burnham on Sea recently. Amazing and well worth seeing. (thoroughly inspiring for someone new to the squeezebox, but not quite so much as Mary from the Bag of Rats whom I thank for the free advice afterwards.
Re practising I'm very new to all this but I am aware that in meditation practice a period when everything goes pear shaped after a period of progression is seen as a sign that a major step forward is about to occur, so if suddenly you feel you are back at square one , hang on in there, don't lose trust and enjoy the forthcoming  benfits of your endeavours!
Best wishes to all
Pete
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal