Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Steelarts on August 17, 2011, 03:27:40 PM

Title: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Steelarts on August 17, 2011, 03:27:40 PM
I currently play guitar at an Irish session that I attend but I'm thinking that I'd like to start playing the squeezebox too.  I don't know why, but I'm really struggling with my D/G to get an Irish tune and playing English tunes seems a doddle by comparison.  So that got me thinking that a B/C box might be in order.  I started doing some research (as you do) and, as usual, Sod's Law dictates that when you do something else will get thrown into the equation.  This is namely the C#/D box.  Now Mally says on his website that C#/D "Come's a poor second," compared to a B/C. But I found a chap on YouTube who is very much pro C#/D and sings it's praises compared to B/C; the advantage it seems is keeping the notes closer together and playing 2 notes per button whereas the B/C seems to be single notes all over the place.  Of course this means the C#/D bellows is working in and out much more than the B/C which is smoother as there seems to be less changes of direction.

Have I got this right?  Are there any other advantages or disadvantages of either system that I'm missing? C#/D boxes seem much rarer than B/C also. I know that in the end it's down to individual choice but is either one easier to learn than the other? OR should I just persevere with my D/G?
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Steelarts on August 17, 2011, 03:33:03 PM
Sorry, I've only just noticed a similar thread but it's more about the actual instrument than the advantages/disadvantages of each system it seems:|bl :|bl :|bl
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: nfldbox on August 17, 2011, 03:53:54 PM
There are many threads on this topic. I am biased in favour of BC but I certainly see the attractions of C#D--in my case partly because I periodically hammer away at a D one-row, which for a BC player is a completely different animal.
But look in the threads for comments by Steve Jones. While his bias is towards C#D, he has provided the most extensive and well-reasoned assessments of the two systems.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 17, 2011, 04:28:22 PM
As Terry says, the topic has been discussed at length in many different threads. I'd just say that if you are struggling to get an Irish tune going on the D/G, I don't think either B/C or C#/D is going to make it easier.  :-[ If English tunes are a doddle by comparison, well, that's because... discretion being the better part of valour I won't pursue this line of thought.

The chap on YouTube, if it's the one I'm thinking of, has other clips up there showing tunes on C#/D for Irish box beginners - most of them could be adapted to D/G with very little change.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: LDbosca on August 17, 2011, 06:06:52 PM
I won't get into the merits of each as they're both great, but one thing to consider is that it is much easier to find a B/C teacher than a C#/D teacher. It could be a factor.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: TomB on August 17, 2011, 06:26:40 PM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 17, 2011, 07:12:01 PM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Theo on August 17, 2011, 07:32:14 PM
I know that in the end it's down to individual choice but is either one easier to learn than the other? OR should I just persevere with my D/G?

Well you can get a slight flavour of what a BC box would be like for playing in G, by playing in A on the D row of your DG box.  It is not exactly the same of course becuase you dont have any G#s on the adjacent row on your DG, but apart from that it is exacly the same pattern of pushes and pulls.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: george garside on August 17, 2011, 07:37:01 PM
Theo really meant plauing in A on the D row of your DG box!!

george ;)
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Theo on August 17, 2011, 07:38:00 PM
Doh!  Of course I did.  I'll edit the original post.

And George probably meant 'playing'  ;D ;D
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: TomB on August 17, 2011, 07:46:03 PM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.

I know I'm biased 'cos I learnt to play on a BC from the outset, but I really find the C#D setup unintuitive. Like any other system, it favours some tunes and not others, as does the BC but I feel the effort I have to put in to play in any other key than D outweighs the advantage of having a D row. For a while I played a DD# box and found that a lot easier than the C#D.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CMZZgEtoBbQ   this makes me want to go out and buy a DG  :D
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 17, 2011, 08:03:22 PM
I know I'm biased 'cos I learnt to play on a BC from the outset, but I really find the C#D setup unintuitive.

Believe it or not Tom, many English speakers find French unintuitive. Is this a reasonable guide to the merits of either language?

Quote
I feel the effort I have to put in to play in any other key than D outweighs the advantage of having a D row.

Effort outweighs advantage? OK...  :D

Just remember our OP has a D row already. Like the man you linked to.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: LDbosca on August 17, 2011, 08:10:32 PM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.

Hmm, I wouldn't agree with that, no reversals and going back on yourself between E and F (if I'm right) make it trickier.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Owen Woods on August 17, 2011, 08:40:23 PM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.

Surely the equivalent would be playing in Bb on a B/C?
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: george garside on August 17, 2011, 09:29:25 PM
which makes me truly grateful for the third row!

george ;D
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: TomB on August 17, 2011, 09:35:13 PM
 .. and playing in Bb on a B/C is (IMHO) not the easiest key to play in. Dead easy on a BCC# of course  >:E
Playing in C,G,D or A on a BC you don't get those strange reversals in the middle of the button board, I always find those really strange.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 18, 2011, 03:55:16 AM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.

Surely the equivalent would be playing in Bb on a B/C?

Yes it would, of course, but my point is that B/C players play in D all the time, and until you get used to it, D is a pretty awkward key coming from a box where you play on the row. And Luke, while I agree in theory, in practice it all depends on the tune. I just tried a few standard D tunes in C on my C#/D (Maid behind the bar, Silver spear, Humours of Drinagh) and I really don't think they are very much more awkward than they are in E (i.e. comparing playing those tunes in Bb and D on a B/C). The difference is the effort B/C players have put into mastering D major. Try them in Bb and let us know!
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Pat. on August 18, 2011, 06:49:25 AM
B/C  for listening C#/D[ push and draw for dancing] .I could go on  and on but thats what it boils down to as far as I am concerned ,I am sure some one else will explain further but I am off to work now and I am running late.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: nathanfisher on August 18, 2011, 08:11:35 AM
Steelarts,

I have been switching back and forth between the B/C and the C#/D ever since I started playing the button accordion 5 or 6 years ago.
The first one I bought was a B/C because it seemed to be the choice of modern accordion players and there were more teaching materials available for the B/C and none for the C#/D. I played the B/C for a little over a year and learned a small selection of tunes teaching myself. Then I saw Jackie Daily play a C#/D in concert with Patrick Street and I decided to switch. I traded my B/C in for a C#/D Dancemaster.  I immediatey noticed that tunes using arppegios were a lot easier. I later sold my Dancemaster back to Michael and bought a used C#/D Lilly. I played that for a couple of years then traded it to Michael for an old Hohner double ray with 12 basses but this time I bought both sets of reeds so that I could change them out on a whim if I felt like it. After I got the two sets of reeds I mostly stuck with the C#/D since that is the system I had been playing. I felt secure though knowing that I had the B/C reeds ready to go. Lately I have been working out on the B/C but noticing that the notes are more spread out and most of the time the sequencing is more difficult. I will say that the B/C is more fluid or smoother in some spots while tricky in other areas, especially in the second octave. Now here is the part you might find amusing. I decided to trade my C#/D reeds back to Michael in trade for a new set of TaM D/G reeds!!! Honestly there are not that many extra notes that I pull off of the C# row and I thought that there would be more useful notes on a G row of a D/G that I could use for Irish music. You can go to the keyboard layout section on this website and compare the notes for yourself and see what you think. For me playing a B/C is like doing a crossword puzzle. Playing the B/C helps exercise my brain and coordination and makes me a better C#/D player. I know this is an odd story but I thought you might enjoy it!

Nate
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1f8Cc-9rpI&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Theo on August 18, 2011, 09:57:28 AM
And to add to Nates move to DG:   in one way it combines advantages of both BC and C#D, because you can play on the row if you want bouncy dance music, but you can also play smoothly because you have even more reversals than a BC.  For D major all notes are available on pull except for D, and all notes are available on push except for E and C#.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: TomB on August 18, 2011, 10:16:07 AM
Welcome to the (endless) discussion, Nate. It seems odd that you choose to ditch the C#D system over the BC if you feel happier with C#D, or do you see the DG as an extention of the C#D ?  The down side though is that on the DG you lose the Eb, Ab and Bb notes (unless you have a 'helper' row).
I'm definately going to have to have a look at DG's at Whitby next week, anybody want to lend me one?  :||: :|bl
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: LDbosca on August 18, 2011, 11:23:27 AM
Not easy to play in C / Dm on a C#D box,  that covers a lot of Irish tunes.

C major on C#/D is no harder than playing in D on a B/C, really. If you practise the tunes will come.

Surely the equivalent would be playing in Bb on a B/C?

Yes it would, of course, but my point is that B/C players play in D all the time, and until you get used to it, D is a pretty awkward key coming from a box where you play on the row. And Luke, while I agree in theory, in practice it all depends on the tune. I just tried a few standard D tunes in C on my C#/D (Maid behind the bar, Silver spear, Humours of Drinagh) and I really don't think they are very much more awkward than they are in E (i.e. comparing playing those tunes in Bb and D on a B/C). The difference is the effort B/C players have put into mastering D major. Try them in Bb and let us know!

I play a few tunes in Bb alright, I still wouldn't be recommending it for a beginner. I know D is cross-rowing as well but you've a nice "E F# G" and "A B C# D" on one bellows direction, plus the reversals.

Anyway, we could go on about this one all day...and I think we have before! ;)
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: nfldbox on August 18, 2011, 01:52:30 PM
I can't believe that I am chiming in on this yet again but given all the usual participants have already said things here goes. Given how often you play in D, BC is more difficult at the beginning: I can remember that period all too well. Once you have it, it tends to play more smoothly in most of the standard tunes. I love the bounce of "D played in D" and it is sometimes hard to achieve on BC but then the standard for BC tends to be smooth playing.  As to which is more difficult on difficult tunes in difficult keys: guess what? Some are horrible on C#D and some are horrible on BC. And some are horrible on both.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Steelarts on August 19, 2011, 11:09:20 AM
Thanks guys, I really didn't expect such an array of wonderful replies.  It really has been incredibly informative and fascinating reading. First off, Steve Jones; I think it was your video I saw of the Cameronian Reel.   It was excellent by the way.

Also reading through some of the previous posts on BC v C#D it almost sounds as if there were political and/or class issues involved in the past as to which system was employed.  And I was picking up that C#D wasn't allowed at the Fleadh because the embellishments to the tunes on it were detracting from the "traditional" tunes and BC was more in keeping with fiddle and whistle.  I hope I'm correct in my understanding of this?

There is no doubt in my mind that BC seems much smoother.  I was watching a YouTube video of Finbarr Dwyer playing and he was just amazing.  But, the 'bounce' of playing on the row also has an appeal to me however. SO...................

Here's another question.  Most of the tunes our session plays are either in D or G with the occasional foray into different keys. "Bill Sullivan's" is one tune that springs to mind that's in A.  But I'd say 98%+  are in D or G.  This being the case, is there much point in my buying a BC or C#D?  As C#D plays most of the D tunes on the row anyway, what would be the advantages/disadvantages (if any) of getting this box over a DG?  Okay, I understand I get the G# and can then play the A tunes.  Unfortunately there's no G# accidental on my Excelsior Chiltern. :(

So here's where my thinking is going. What if I traded the Excelsior towards a 2.5 row DG box?  I could still play Morris on it and if I worked hard on it (as I'd have to if I learn BC), I could learn to play Irish stuff too, or is this always going to be a compromise? Or is BC really the place to be for Irish music for it's fluidity?
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Theo on August 19, 2011, 11:45:06 AM
A couple of partial answers.

Playing in A on a DG:   try it because it will give you a feel for A on a C#D,  two tunes to try that have no G# are Britches full of Stitches, and if you manage that Athol Highlanders.  Many other A tunes have G#s that can me missed out without ruining the tune eg Stool of Repentance.

I would strongly advise thoroughly exploring the box you have before going to the expense of trading it for a different system.  It's not just the box, to get the great playing that you have heard requires a lot of study as well.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Steelarts on August 19, 2011, 11:54:09 AM
thanks for that advice Theo
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 19, 2011, 04:55:32 PM
As C#D plays most of the D tunes on the row anyway, what would be the advantages/disadvantages (if any) of getting this box over a DG?  Okay, I understand I get the G# and can then play the A tunes. 

As well as a G#, you would get all the other missing notes. This doesn't really make C#/D (or the B/C) a fully chromatic instrument, in the sense of being able to play in any key easily, but it does mean you are never stuck for an accidental.

The placement of accidentals on a semitone box which has the main row on the inside is extremely handy. I have found this makes playing a variety of tunes with lots of accidentals a bit of a doddle and a lot of fun (admittedly most of them not hardcore Irish trad btw). It also makes playing 5-note rolls (if that floats your boat) very easy, and fast pseudo-slides into an important note from a semitone below are very satisfying too.

But the choice of a semitone box over your D/G depends, to my mind, on what music you want to be able to play, and perhaps to your experience of and level of your commitment to Irish music. From what you said in your original post and just now, and echoing Theo's advice, I would strongly recommend you stick with D/G and get to grips with Irish tunes on it. As Tim Edey and other fine but less stellar players have shown, you can certainly make a great job of Irish tunes on D/G, in a style that would be appreciated in Ireland. (Fluidity is not the only way, and besides you can be pretty liquid on D/G if you want to explore all the cross-rowing possibilities.)

If one day you find yourself becoming a true believer, with Irish music taking over all the musical space in your life and mind, you can always think again. 
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: nemethmik on August 19, 2011, 05:40:02 PM
If one day you find yourself becoming a true believer, with Irish music taking over all the musical space in your life and mind, you can always think again.
Very well said, Steve.
I am a fanatic of European folk music of any kind: from Bulgaria, Rumania, Croatia, Hungary to Italy, France, Ireland and Norway. I've travelled all accross these countries and visited all possible folk music festivals. I can say that Irish music is exceptional in a sense that the Irish has absorbed and will be absorbing all kinds of instrument ever invented on Earth: bouzukis, banjos, mandolins, piano, button, diatonic accordions, saxophones, fiddle, spoons, bones, bodhran, bagpipes of any nature, you name it, and so on and forth. What I mean is that, if you want to play Irish music on a DG, GC or Hohner Morino C/F club system accordion just do it. If you do it well, you will have a camp of followers shortly, and you can publish books and make good money of it; no kidding. :)
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: nathanfisher on August 21, 2011, 11:36:28 PM
In response to TomB,

No I didn't ditch the C#D for the B/C. I am playing the B/C more regular now and starting to enjoy sliding around on the keyboard! BTW, I can still play C#D fingering on my B/C when I play on the C row to get Dmin.

Also in response to your post I did ditch the C#/D for the D/G!!!! I can still play on the straight row of D and so much more. I wish I would have gotten some D/G reeds for my accordion a long time ago. Now for those who are interested in playing Irish Music on a D/G there is the new Tim Edey teaching DVD.

Back to Steelarts original post. Which is easier to play? I think the C#D may seem easier to learn when you are starting out where as the B/C has a steeper learning curve. In the end, It is going to take a lot of practicing to master either system. For straight row playing I think the D/G has more finger variations than a C#D.  I tend to shy away from playing my box at the Irish session because they play the music so fast and because pubs are generally noisy  and it is hard to hear yourself play. 
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Steelarts on August 31, 2011, 10:48:13 AM
What I mean is that, if you want to play Irish music on a DG, GC or Hohner Morino C/F club system accordion just do it.

Strange you should say this.  At our session a week ago, I was talking to one of the box players.  She is Finnish and plays a GC but she can also sight read/play which seems to be a great help.  I struggle because a lot of the tunes we play are known by different names i.e. what we play at the session is often called something else when I listen to Comhaltas "Foin Seisiún".  Does anyone know if there is a list of AKA's for these tunes anywhere?

Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Stiamh on August 31, 2011, 02:12:38 PM
I struggle because a lot of the tunes we play are known by different names i.e. what we play at the session is often called something else when I listen to Comhaltas "Foin Seisiún".  Does anyone know if there is a list of AKA's for these tunes anywhere?

I don't know of a simple list of alternative names but an awful lot of tunes are to be found in the Fiddler's Companion ( http://www.ibiblio.org/fiddlers/ ). Alternative titles are given. The alternative titles are themselves listed in the index with cross-references to the main entry.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: Theo on August 31, 2011, 02:41:57 PM
Some of the tunes listed onThe Session include alternative titles.
Title: Re: B/C v C#/D for Irish music
Post by: sticky fingers on August 31, 2011, 05:31:14 PM
A-ha, the great debate! D/G is just perfect for a great many irish tunes, but not all!, maybe a 23+5 button d/g box with extra low notes and accidentals, or even a 3 row c#d/g!, damn, i knew this subject would resurface again. good luck sf
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal