Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: nomad on August 17, 2011, 09:51:47 PM
-
Hi
I have an old accordion which I have been trying to return to playing condition. It is not of any value, I just thought I would like to try my hand at doing various repairs.
I am now ready to start doing some tuning, the thing is I have read about what to do and how to do it, but it is never as easy as you think.
For example. the F# shows as F at +35cent, (I am using a tuning ap on my phone) so I thought for it to be F# all you need to do is file the tip of the reed, to raise it up, I ended up with the note sounding as a B.
I also have a low F that is showing it sounding as A#+20 cent.
Can anyone point me in the right direction, and is there any does anyone know of any web sites that explain the relationship of each note, or is it just as simple as looking at a scale, for example, if F# was showing as G all you need to do is flatten the reed by removing metal from the bottom of the reed to make it sound as F.
Note sure if i have explained it very well, but I hope you can catch my drift.
thank You
-
Before you start filing huge amounts off the reeds it might be best if you try another tuner or check the tuning against another instrument, ideally a piano.
It would be very unusual for the reeds to be this far out of tune, unless they were on the point of breaking or were very rusty.
Also if the accordion has more than one voice try sounding one reed only, as multiple reeds sounding at one time could throw your phone into a state of serious confusion.
???
Martyn
-
Hi
I did test the tuner against an accordion that is in perfect tune after down loading it and I was surprised at how accurate it was.
I made up a tuning table with an old set of bellows to enable me to sound one read at as time, just as you suggest. It is a 2 voice box, and am I right in thinking that the 2 reeds should be offset from one another, I,E one reed at a - and the other at a +
Am I starting off in the right direction?
Thanks
-
I did test the tuner against an accordion that is in perfect tune after down loading it and I was surprised at how accurate it was.
Nobody's questioning the accuracy of your tuner, but changing a reed from F# to B is a gross change, analogous to doing brain surgery with a tower crane...
It is a 2 voice box, and am I right in thinking that the 2 reeds should be offset from one another, I,E one reed at a - and the other at a + Am I starting off in the right direction?
Common practice is for one bank to be at A=440 concert pitch and the other a few cents sharp, but there's a very credible school of thought that says tune one set a few cents flat and the other a few cents sharp. Search melnet for "Dedic Tuning" and you'll find plenty of references.
Also you need to think carefully about how much offset to create between the reeds for the sound you want, and how that offset changes from the low notes to the high notes. Search for references to "wet" and "dry" tuning - there's a lot of useful info here on melnet. In fact, just search for "tuning", and make sure you understand what's been said before filing away any more metal. You can't put it back once it's gone...
-
Agent the tuner showed the F# reed had gone up to B did the reed sound as if it had changed that much?
Tuners sometimes get confused and lock on to a harmonic. If your tuner has the ability to select the note manually you can avoid that. It's also important to keep your ears involved!
-
Yes, it certainly sounds like you are on the right track. I always work from A440 and use Viennese (Dedic) method of tuning.
For instance if you wanted an offset of 14 cents at A440 (a nice warm tremolo) rather than using conventional tuning where the low reed would be tuned to 0 and the high reed +14 cents I would tune to +7 / -7 cents. Increasing the offset below this and decreasing above to keep the tremolo (beating) regular.
There is a perfectly good reason (and a lot of debate) for this method of tuning but it makes sense when you think about it. The basses are tuned to 0, so if the right hand is tuned conventionally, it will be very slightly out of tune (sharp) with the left. With Dedic tuning it will be in tune.
There has been much discussion on this subject in the past and very interesting and informative it is too.
But proof of the pudding is in the eating as they say. Just listen to a Bb/Eb Erika or a Club Modell II (1930s) Dedic tuned. It will almost certainly turn you to jelly :o
Martyn
-
Hi Theo
No it didn't sound as though it had changed that much, and I had only removed a very small amount from the tip. Am i correct in saying that if you have an F and it needs to be F# you file the tip. If you have a D and it needs to be C# you remove metal from the bottom of the reed.
I am not bothered about waisting anything, this is just an old box that i want to practice tuning on, and see if I can get my head round it, and even actually mange to get it right.
i have found it difficult to get at the reed that is inside the reed block, without waisting the leather valve, is this normal? Would it be easier to remove it if you need to tune the inside reeds?
Thanks for all the replies you are all very knowledgeable.
Thanks
-
Probably the simplest way of supporting the inner reed would be to use a brass rod pushed in through the corresponding hole in the reed block to lift the reed and support it while it's being worked on.
You can usually hold the valve back without causing any damage to it. A piece of stiff card or better still a very thin piece of sheet brass cut to size works a treat.
Martyn
-
I think Theo has hit the nail on the head - the tuner is locking on to a harmonic. Are you using an external mic or the integral one in the tuner (I'm assuming it's a small electronic tuner)? I've found that small tuners are quite prone to picking up harmonics, especially if you have them lying on top of the tuning table while you're working. Try different positions for the tuner (or mic), and also try varying the bellows pressure at which you sound the reed - varying air pressures can emphasise harmonics, which in the overall playing picture may well help to richen the sound, but only confuse the issue when you're trying to tune. Also, if you're working with the reeds still in the block, make sure that only the reed you're tuning is sounding - sympathetic vibrations from other reeds can be very confusing to an electronic tuner.
-
Hi,
I don't have an external Mic, the tuner is an app that I down loaded to my phone, I will try it in other positions.
Does anyone know if there are any good dvds or books that explain and show you how to do tuning. Or is it just a case of getting stuck in and learning from your mistakes.
Thanks
-
Ah - I've no experience of using a phone as a tuner, so I can't offer any opinion. I have several electronic tuners, and surprisingly I've found one I picked up from Aldi (because it was too cheap to turn down!) is every bit as accurate as both a Korg and a Boss I use regularly. Nice clear scale and pretty good at getting past the harmonics. www.talkingreeds.com (http://www.talkingreeds.com) has some useful information.
-
Hi,
I don't have an external Mic, the tuner is an app that I down loaded to my phone, I will try it in other positions.
Does anyone know if there are any good dvds or books that explain and show you how to do tuning. Or is it just a case of getting stuck in and learning from your mistakes.
Thanks
I've had very good results with the Peterson strobe tuner app on an iphone, but no experience of others.
Am i correct in saying that if you have an F and it needs to be F# you file the tip. If you have a D and it needs to be C# you remove metal from the bottom of the reed.
Yes, though not exactly the bottom of the reed to lower pitch, more the lower half to third of the reed, just look for previous tuning marks for guidance.
i have found it difficult to get at the reed that is inside the reed block, without waisting the leather valve, is this normal? Would it be easier to remove it if you need to tune the inside reeds?
It is essential to do the final tuning with the reed in situ and the valve in place because the pitch will change compared with the reed dismounted. There are special tools to help get at the back reed, I've posted some pictures here (http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.110159238166.95032.709188166&l=5be6150682&type=1) and here (http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.498005193166.268921.709188166&l=03278200f1&type=1)
If the leather valves are old and stiff and/or not lying flat then this may make it more difficult to get the reeds to sound correctly. You can sometimes improve the behavior of the valve by struking it firmly with a smooth hard edge eg screwdriver blade, while supporting the valve with a flat plate slipped underneath.
-
Hi, thanks for the link to the talking reeds web page. I had a quick look at it. It looks very good, I will print off the pages and have a good read at it tonight.
Thanks
-
There is a little bit on youtube on tuning accordions, but there is much more really good info on tuning harmonicas, and the concept is largely the same. Good that you are practicing on an old clunker, there is a definite feel to it accompanied by a corresponding learning curve.
-
Thank you all, for all the helpfull information.
I think on one of my first attempts i might have been heavy handed with the file.
I have also came up against another strange thing, I have a C# that is in tune on both the push and pull, and sounds fine when you play it. The only thing is it is very quiet, in comparison to all the other notes. Is this to do with the spacing of the reed from the plate?
-
Possibly, but if the valves are not lying flat or closing properly that will make the reed quieter. Could also be dirt/gunge/glue in the gap beside the reed tongue, especially near the root of the reed. Wax that is not holding the reedplate firmly is another possible cause, though tis usually results in horrible noises.
-
Thanks, will look at it again tomorrow, theres more to this tuning than I first thought, and the time involved is horrendous. But very satisfying when you manage to get a note to sound the way you want it to.
-
Time is rather related to experience to be fair and some old clunkers are tuned to the old pitch of A=435 which means you have a lot more work to do. Getting a reed to speak nicely is yet another black art, the whole business takes a while before it's not impossible.
I can tune a reed in less than a month now and some of them even speak nicely. ::) Where in the world are you nomad? There may be a melnetter nearby who dabbles in reed mangling tuning.
-
Hi Tallship
I am up in Scotland, there are a few accordion repairers around, but none that I know well enough to ask them to give me a crash course in learning the black art of tuning. They also make a living out of it, so maybe they would be reluctant to share there skills, and trade secrets
-
You could try re positioning your phone/microphone. That can make quite a difference, particularly on the bass reeds.
Martyn
-
What part of Scotland? I'm in ne England.
-
Hi theo.
I am from lanarkshire