Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: swig on August 21, 2011, 09:30:36 AM

Title: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: swig on August 21, 2011, 09:30:36 AM
I'm trying to get my sound much closer to the English style as demonstrated by John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, John Spiers etc. The more I listen, the more the key seems to be in the bellows control, giving emphasis at certain points. My playing, whilst OK technically, is  way too smooth and lacks that rhythmn that gives English music its unmistakable sound. Any tips ?
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 21, 2011, 11:17:55 AM
Whilst the basic movement of the bellows is powered by the left hand (assuming you're right-handed) much of the rythm is provided by the right hand.  Regardless of which way you hold the keyboard - thumb on the edge or morris clasp - the heel of the hand presses or even bumps the keyboard giving accents to the dynamics.  Of course when pulling, the left hand has to take over giving a momentary sharp tug.

In addition, whether playing along the row or across the rows, more rythm is achieved when playing stacatto phrases.  Some people's styles are almost completely stacatto, a very light touch with the fingers dancing to the music - others intersperse this with smoother phrasing, creating  greater diversity which can lend emphasis to the individual phrases.

Rob.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: swig on August 22, 2011, 11:37:57 AM
Thanks Rob, That's really useful information
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2011, 12:26:23 PM
Whilst I don't disagree with what Rob says, the LH does also have a part to play. It's a combination of using both. the trick is to do it purposefully and with intention, rather than just as a consequence of waggling the bellows.

I think cross-rowing also plays a part.  This allows you to drive the rhythm according to the needs of the music rather than because the mechanics of the instrument insist on bellows changes at particular points.  You can play smoothly or lumpily according to the rhythm you want to get across.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 22, 2011, 12:31:55 PM
Another technique which is rarely described, although often used, is to anticipate the first beat of the bar by using the bellows to sound the note just before the beat actually occurs, and, at the moment of actual arrival of the beat, lift the fingers off the buttons to create a staccato note with a gap immediately afterwards.

The effect you are trying to achieve is a sort of errr-RUP where the 'RUP' is the arrival of the downbeat. Works well when playing a fistful of RH buttons! Much easier to demonstrate than to describe. Use it sparingly!

John Kirkpatrick is the absolute master of this method.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Cooper on August 24, 2011, 01:50:03 PM
Whilst I don't disagree with what Rob says, the LH does also have a part to play. It's a combination of using both. the trick is to do it purposefully and with intention, rather than just as a consequence of waggling the bellows.

I think cross-rowing also plays a part.  This allows you to drive the rhythm according to the needs of the music rather than because the mechanics of the instrument insist on bellows changes at particular points.  You can play smoothly or lumpily according to the rhythm you want to get across.

I completely agree with the first part your saying. But for some reason many people focus on touching the right buttons at the right time. It is very often the usage of the bellow that makes the master really the master.

You should be conscient of the fact that EVERY movement you make, not just with your arms, but with your entire body, will be heard through your bellow. This is not a bad thing, you can and should use that.

I don't quite agree with your next line. When playing in the right scale on 1 row your bellowmovement will almost always have the right "cadance" (is that an English word?). At the very least you should make a decision every time you start playing a tune whether you want it to have the inlbuilt cadance, or if you want to go for a smoother approach using more rows. I think the power of our bisonoric instrument (over a normal accordeon) is to use that bellowmovement.

greetz,
W
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on August 24, 2011, 07:50:11 PM
I'm trying to get my sound much closer to the English style as demonstrated by John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, John Spiers etc. The more I listen, the more the key seems to be in the bellows control, giving emphasis at certain points. My playing, whilst OK technically, is  way too smooth and lacks that rhythmn that gives English music its unmistakable sound. Any tips ?

Back to the debate about the 'English' sound....you really need to try for your own sound and to hell with the rest.....

You mention three players who all sound different but in their own way 'English'..better to go your own way - don't copy people..
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 24, 2011, 08:36:23 PM
I'm trying to get my sound much closer to the English style as demonstrated by John Kirkpatrick, Pete Coe, John Spiers etc. The more I listen, the more the key seems to be in the bellows control, giving emphasis at certain points. My playing, whilst OK technically, is  way too smooth and lacks that rhythmn that gives English music its unmistakable sound. Any tips ?

Back to the debate about the 'English' sound....you really need to try for your own sound and to hell with the rest.....

You mention three players who all sound different but in their own way 'English'..better to go your own way - don't copy people..

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: ladydetemps on August 24, 2011, 08:59:50 PM
I know this isn't as techical advice as others will put forward but...osmosis, just immerse yourself in the music and take every opertunity to play with english style players. The style you want will then gradualy seep in.
I didn't think I'd got a style till I tried playing an Irish tune and it sounded English.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Cooper on August 24, 2011, 09:22:57 PM
You mention three players who all sound different but in their own way 'English'..better to go your own way - don't copy people..

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.

 ;D I am glad it is not. It is impossible not to be influenced by what culture you're in, what you hear etc. Don't copy people is an advice i like. Because you will always be using building stones from around you. If you listen to and play with English-stylists you are bound to sound English, no matter if you try to copy or not.

I still think it is good to know WHAT you are doing exactly to make it sound that way. Focussing on the bellow like the first poster hypothesized is an excellent startingpoint.
:-)
W
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Owen Woods on August 25, 2011, 01:13:38 PM

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.

I disagree. The fact that there was listed three melodeon players whose styles are utterly different yet all are considered fundamentally english implies that merely copying others is not the only way. I think that taking inspiration from the playing of others but ultimately trying to carve out your own sound is a good path to follow.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 27, 2011, 12:01:56 PM
Very strange. How exactly do people think that things like music, language and culture are transmitted then?

Despite the claims, the avid consumption of recordings and videos by people on this forum tells a story in it's self.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Theo on August 27, 2011, 12:03:54 PM

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.

I disagree. The fact that there was listed three melodeon players whose styles are utterly different yet all are considered fundamentally english implies that merely copying others is not the only way. I think that taking inspiration from the playing of others but ultimately trying to carve out your own sound is a good path to follow.

And of course the "tradition" for English melodeon is a relativly recent thing anyway.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 27, 2011, 12:28:59 PM

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.

I disagree. The fact that there was listed three melodeon players whose styles are utterly different yet all are considered fundamentally english implies that merely copying others is not the only way. I think that taking inspiration from the playing of others but ultimately trying to carve out your own sound is a good path to follow.

And of course the "tradition" for English melodeon is a relativly recent thing anyway.

Indeed, and that is true of so many of our supposedly ancient (and I'm not just refering to folk traditions here) traditions.

However, even if it is relatively recent, I doubt that you'd deny that it does exist.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Theo on August 27, 2011, 02:21:31 PM
However, even if it is relatively recent, I doubt that you'd deny that it does exist.

Indeed not. Just thinking that the English traditional meloden styles that we hear today have evolved over the past half century or so and will continue to evolve.  So we should be open to re-interpretation and development of that style.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Anahata on August 27, 2011, 03:07:28 PM
the English traditional meloden styles that we hear today have evolved over the past half century or so and will continue to evolve.  So we should be open to re-interpretation and development of that style.

This is not just true of English music - Irish and Scottish box playing styles have also changed over the same period, so I don't think the changes are an indication of the "newness" of English melodeon playing - just something that happens all the time.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Theo on August 27, 2011, 03:19:49 PM

This is not just true of English music -


Probably true of all traditions,  if they don't evolve they become fossilized.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on August 27, 2011, 04:10:35 PM

Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.

I disagree. The fact that there was listed three melodeon players whose styles are utterly different yet all are considered fundamentally English implies that merely copying others is not the only way. I think that taking inspiration from the playing of others but ultimately trying to carve out your own sound is a good path to follow.

Agreeing with UKBert, and restating my point - all three players mentioned above have their own style, which is accepted as English and I'm sure they didn't copy from anyone. You can be inspired by others and absorb bits of what they do to come up with a style of your own which is still 'English'. There is no point of being a clone of a particular player and restricting your own unique approach to music - why sound like other people if you can sound like yourself..

My own inspiration has been drawn from absolutley every kind of music I have encountered, from 50's Rock 'n' Roll, 60's Pop, Blues, Irish, Scottish, French, English etc.
Traditional folk music from the playing of Steeleye Span, Dave Swarbrick, Richard Thompson, John Kirkpatrick, Andy Cutting - the list goes on...

As Theo said, things will always develop..and still sound English..

Recently my eyes have been opened to another style of playing, by Anahata - he has some great tunes in his head, lovely stuff..

Alan
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: jb on August 27, 2011, 04:51:07 PM
Well, that's the end of tradition, culture, French, English or Chinese music.
I prefer to err on the side of playing for enjoyment, rather than out of a sense of duty.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Tufty on August 27, 2011, 09:23:36 PM
Styles will of course continue to develop and that is a good thing but I would hate to see the style that first attracted me to the instrument disappear. Back in the 70's there were lots of good P.A players around but that smooth sound held no attraction for me, it was hearing the East Anglian style of box playing - mostly on the row even when a 2 row was used - that hooked me on melodeon. I do feel that this style is rather looked down on by some people at present, certainly by some people running workshops. If Bob Cann was able to go to some workshops today he would be told that he was doing it all wrong!
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 27, 2011, 10:11:00 PM
Styles will of course continue to develop and that is a good thing but I would hate to see the style that first attracted me to the instrument disappear. Back in the 70's there were lots of good P.A players around but that smooth sound held no attraction for me, it was hearing the East Anglian style of box playing - mostly on the row even when a 2 row was used - that hooked me on melodeon. I do feel that this style is rather looked down on by some people at present, certainly by some people running workshops. If Bob Cann was able to go to some workshops today he would be told that he was doing it all wrong!

That makes two of us   8)

(I'm sure there are more here of course).
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 27, 2011, 11:32:08 PM
I prefer to err on the side of playing for enjoyment, rather than out of a sense of duty.

Well said that man! I love the music of the British Isles and the music I've heard from many other parts of the world so I play tunes the way I first heard them regardless of their perceived origins. I principally play English music but I'm a sucker for a great melody no matter where it comes from.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Gary P Chapin on August 28, 2011, 12:25:13 AM
I find that I'm becoming much more "on-the-row" since getting my new, lighter box. I am not sure why, but unless there are specific reasons not to do so, I find myself liking the in'n'out.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: IanD on August 28, 2011, 11:51:32 AM
Whilst the basic movement of the bellows is powered by the left hand (assuming you're right-handed) much of the rythm is provided by the right hand.  Regardless of which way you hold the keyboard - thumb on the edge or morris clasp - the heel of the hand presses or even bumps the keyboard giving accents to the dynamics.  Of course when pulling, the left hand has to take over giving a momentary sharp tug.

In addition, whether playing along the row or across the rows, more rythm is achieved when playing stacatto phrases.  Some people's styles are almost completely stacatto, a very light touch with the fingers dancing to the music - others intersperse this with smoother phrasing, creating  greater diversity which can lend emphasis to the individual phrases.

Rob.

I'd agree that a lot of the "punch" comes from the right hand, not hammering the bellows which is what a lot of people seem to think :-)

I was once asked what I did with the basses to get real lift and punch into a tune, so I stopped playing them and it was still there, much to the bemusement of the questioner.

I often emphasise the beat by "punching in" harmony notes on the treble end, while keeping the tune going -- not playing harmonies all the time (which is too smooth), just on the beats where emphasis is needed. Another trick combined with this which saves bellows and reed stress (and avoids "bellows clatter") is to start to squeeze the bellows just before the beat, build up pressure and then hit the note(s).

Also too much playing across the rows takes a lot of the life and lift out of English-style tunes -- I do it only when really necessary.

And gaps in the music are your friend, don't be afraid of them :-)

Cheers

Ian
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Lester on August 28, 2011, 11:59:51 AM
Another way of emphasizing "punch" is to lift off notes sharply. This is my main learning point from a Katie Howsen workshop.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: IanD on August 28, 2011, 02:06:35 PM
Another way of emphasizing "punch" is to lift off notes sharply. This is my main learning point from a Katie Howsen workshop.

Agreed -- like I said, gaps are your friend, so get those fingers *off* those buttons sharpish!

(unless you want to sound like a -- how shall I put it politely? -- "foreigner")

Ian

P.S. See Flanders & Swann, "A Song of Patriotic Prejudice"...
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: swig on September 01, 2011, 09:04:57 AM
Well _ just been to Shrewsbury Festival and spent 3 hours in workshops on playing for English Country Dance, led by JK himself !
Tips I took away.

Spend some time practicing tunes very slow and very staccato. This develops all the skills for playing.
Strong accent on 1st and 3rd beats in the bar (4/4) and 1st and 4th (6/8)
Start playing bass side first and drive the off beat so that you get a 'lift' into the beat. Only when you've got that going bring in the melody.
Keep chording very simple

Off to practice !
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 01, 2011, 09:16:42 AM
Another way of emphasizing "punch" is to lift off notes sharply. This is my main learning point from a Katie Howsen workshop.

Agreed!  It sounds daft but the way you take your fingers off the buttons is probably more important than the way you put them on.  I think of it as like plucking an invisible string!!
george
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Lester on September 01, 2011, 09:19:31 AM
Another way of emphasizing "punch" is to lift off notes sharply. This is my main learning point from a Katie Howsen workshop.

Agreed!  It sounds daft but the way you take your fingers off the buttons is probably more important than the way you put them on.  I think of it as like plucking an invisible string!!
george

I knew we would have to agree on something sometime  ;D
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 01, 2011, 09:51:03 AM
Erm.... don't people read older posts on the thread?  ;)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7641.msg95097.html#msg95097
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Lester on September 01, 2011, 09:53:43 AM
Erm.... don't people read older posts on the thread?  ;)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7641.msg95097.html#msg95097

Never did understand what the "Grumpy Old Git (sometimes)" bit meant, now I know   ::)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 12:11:29 PM
Erm.... don't people read older posts on the thread?  ;)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7641.msg95097.html#msg95097
So the answer is 'No' then  ;D
Just as melodeon styles evolve, so do the answers on the forum to the same  question!
Re 'English',  I believe a musical tradition takes a lot from the landscape around the people involved, which is why English tunes sound different from Scottish tunes and more importantly are played in different styles. There is obviously a lot of variation within the style, some of which may be regional, but there is still an overriding, regional 'e.g. 'English' style. I wonder if the regional styles bear any relationship to the respective regional spoken accents?  (:)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Howard Jones on September 01, 2011, 08:29:58 PM
you should make a decision every time you start playing a tune whether you want it to have the inlbuilt cadance, or if you want to go for a smoother approach using more rows. I think the power of our bisonoric instrument (over a normal accordeon) is to use that bellowmovement.

I think that's the point I was making.  The internal rhythm in a tune is often more subtle than the regular in-out of playing up the scale will allow.  By choosing when to cross the rows and when not, you can take control over the bellows, rather than have the bellows movement dictated by the need to change direction to play a particular note.  The same sequence of notes might be played differently depending on the rhythmic effect you want to achieve at that particular point in the tune.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on September 01, 2011, 09:01:40 PM
Don't neglect the basses.... The 'English' style from the '70s revival was all 'Um Pah, Um Pah', giving a driving rhythm no matter what or how smooth the right hand was playing. Then the french influence started to appear, with the occasional held chord crossing across the basses, which now seems to predominate in the younger players to my mind at the expense of rhythm.

But of you listen to some of the really old players  e.g Albert Farmer, Peter Wyper, Jonny O'Leary, they played the Um and the Pah at the same time, with a strong pulsing rhythm, and again no matter what or how smooth the right hand was playing.

Hence my advice is to practice playing basses only, explore different way of playing them, but concentrate on driving the rhythm. i.e Push it from the left hand to support the right, not the other way round.

Also, remember what the bellows are there to do - provide pressurised air to the reeds. Avoid snapping the bellows at all times (the most common fault with melodeon playing). Think of how a harmonium works - the bellows provide a constant pressure to the reeds, the sound only comes out when you press the keys. A melodeon is just the same - think about keeping the pressure onto the reeds at all times with the bellows.

Final point - if you want rhythmic playing, then play up and down the rows, not across. That gives natural breaks when you have to change bellows direction (remembering the above point!)

Enjoy



 
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 11:05:41 PM
Also, remember what the bellows are there to do - provide pressurised air to the reeds. Avoid snapping the bellows at all times (the most common fault with melodeon playing). 
What does this mean? (I might be doing it! :P)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on September 01, 2011, 11:15:42 PM
Watch anahatas youtube videos, then watch yourself playing in front of a mirror, and compare!  Inexperienced players have an extra sound as the belows folds SLAP together as they play.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 01, 2011, 11:25:55 PM
Also, remember what the bellows are there to do - provide pressurised air to the reeds. Avoid snapping the bellows at all times (the most common fault with melodeon playing). Think of how a harmonium works - the bellows provide a constant pressure to the reeds, the sound only comes out when you press the keys. A melodeon is just the same - think about keeping the pressure onto the reeds at all times with the bellows.
Sorry, but I totally disagree with all this. The bellows have much more use than to simply 'provide a constant pressure to the reeds'. To do as you suggest is to completely ignore the wonderful possibilities which the bellows provide for strong rhythmic attack, or subtle dynamics and expression, or somewhere in between. The melodeon with both its push/pull and its cross-row technique allows you to play very expressively indeed, by combining the keyboard action with varying bellows pressure.

Even the harmonium, where the air is pushed through the reeds by the pedal action, allows you to use varying air pressure as part of the dynamics (in contrast to the American reed organ - what some Americans confusingly call a 'melodeon', where the pedal action sucks air through the reeds via a reservoir and is less responsive to pressure changes as a result).

In my own playing, and in my workshops, I try to teach people to shape the notes by using the bellows. The bellows are to a melodeon player what lungs are to a singer. I'm sure you wouldn't attempt to sing simply by keeping your lung pressure constant and just opening and closing your mouth to start and stop the sound. So it is with the melodeon. There may be times when you want to keep the bellows constantly pressurised and just use the buttons to produce a rectangular block of sound. You can make some very acute, accented Stravinskian staccatos like this, which might be fine for a dotted hornpipe, but hardly appropriate for a gentle waltz, where you might want to ease the notes beautifully from the bellows, making a shaped swell and decay, like the waves coming and breaking on the shore.



Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Ollie on September 01, 2011, 11:39:28 PM
Watch anahatas youtube videos, then watch yourself playing in front of a mirror, and compare!  Inexperienced players have an extra sound as the belows folds SLAP together as they play.

It depends very much on the instrument. My Pokerwork slaps together like a very slappy thing on Slap Day, but neither my Erika nor my Beltuna do.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on September 01, 2011, 11:52:58 PM
As someone trained in Bel Canto singing technique (as opposed to Con Belto)singer, when singing a passge you think of the lungs as providing a constant pressure coumn of air to the vocal chords - you then use teeth/lips/glottis/note placement to do the rest, i.e separate the notes and change volume. It's a fallacy that you need more air to make more volume when singing - one practice technique is to sing in fronty of as candlfe flame and not make it flicker! Critically, you don't go puff puff puff and exhale on every note.  That was the point I was trying to make.

I fullty agree that in trianed hands the bellows do much more , but IMHO if you try and teach that to beginners they don't master the basic concept that you dont have to push/pull the bellows every time you make a note!

Would you agree?

 
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 02, 2011, 12:06:54 AM
As someone trained in Bel Canto singing technique (as opposed to Con Belto)singer, when singing a passge you think of the lungs as providing a constant pressure coumn of air to the vocal chords - you then use teeth/lips/glottis/note placement to do the rest, i.e separate the notes and change volume. It's a fallacy that you need more air to make more volume when singing - one practice technique is to sing in fronty of as candlfe flame and not make it flicker! Critically, you don't go puff puff puff and exhale on every note.  That was the point I was trying to make.
That's interesting and I do understand what you mean. I am also a clarinettist and we would use a similar technique to support the column of air in the tube of the instrument. But with the melodeon we don't have the added refinements of mouth/throat physiology. So we have to make as much use as possible of the bellows and the buttons in combination, and to me this means using the bellows as something more than a full pressure/no pressure switch.

Quote
I fullty agree that in trianed hands the bellows do much more , but IMHO if you try and teach that to beginners they don't master the basic concept that you dont have to push/pull the bellows every time you make a note!

Would you agree?
Maybe not with absolute beginners, but as soon as possible I would start to introduce some bellows technique for note shaping/dynamics.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Lester on September 02, 2011, 08:24:33 AM
Bellow slapping has its place in the gamut of melodeonating

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7MnV2NCzbw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7MnV2NCzbw)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on September 02, 2011, 09:57:52 AM
Hi Steve - I'm with you all the way.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Anahata on September 02, 2011, 10:12:01 AM
It depends very much on the instrument. My Pokerwork slaps together like a very slappy thing on Slap Day, but neither my Erika nor my Beltuna do.

Yes, when I read the bit about slapping the bellows my first reaction was to think: OMG - do I do that?
Apparently I don't, but it's quite possible that it's actually my Oakwood that doesn't. The bellows on that instrument was VERY stiff when I first had it and it's far from sloppy even now.

Actually, I think I do play with quite a percussive action on the bellows, something I learned in my early days of playing piano accordion and trying to give it the same punch as a melodeon.

By the way, somebody mentioned applying bellows pressure before pressing the button for best attack on a note. I think I've seen that advice given by John Kirkpatrick too.

The only advice I can offer on bellows control (other than excellent stuff already posted) is that the pressure should be governed only by the demands of the music, and not by the limitations  of the instrument. That's quite a hard thing to do but it only needs practice...
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 02, 2011, 10:36:25 AM
just a thought  - why are we talking about 'bellows control for English tunes'.  Surely ( fine) bellows control is crucial to playing any type of music well on a box.    Listening to what is coming out of the box and using   bellows control to make it sound better can make a huge difference to whatevr is being played   .this applies equally whether cross rowing or playing on the row and irrespective of teh 'nationality' of the muisic.

 I teach beginners bellows control & technique right from the start whether on diatonic, piano or continental boxes & it pays dividends by making playing  more refined and satisfying by avoiding the' bloody great air pump 'or 'bear hug'   approach used by many!

george ;)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Anahata on September 02, 2011, 11:00:23 AM
why are we talking about 'bellows control for English tunes'

Good point.
The original poster is specific about wanting to "sound more Enqlish", and assumes it's something to do with bellows control, but seemingly hasn't posted an example of his playing, which could result in some much more constructive and better focused suggestions.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Theo on September 02, 2011, 11:06:50 AM
I'm with you there George,  good bellows control is arguably more important than pressing the right buttons,  once you know which buttons to press.  It is where the rythm should come from first,  what Mr Cutting calls "the heartbeat of the music"
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 02, 2011, 11:38:12 AM
.  It is where the rythm should come from first,  


Which those who  came to my friday workshoip at whitby ( adding layers of rhythm)  should hopefully now have a better understanding of  -or am I being too optimistic!!!

george ;)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on September 02, 2011, 02:13:20 PM
Spot on Tufty!  As you spotted in the Elsinore, I favour the 'stay on one row' approach. It gives more natural bounce, and sounds more like the players who played before we got the French influences. That includes Pete Coe and big John K, as well as Bob Cann, Oscar Woods, Martin Clarke (Leeds Band), George Tremain, and the like.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Sandy Flett on September 02, 2011, 02:57:50 PM
..... my friday workshop at whitby ( adding layers of rhythm)  .....

george ;)

I would really like to learn more about this "layers of rhythm" (and am not the only one I suspect). Any chance of a brief description, George, ideally with an illustrating sound sample or two?
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Peter G on September 02, 2011, 06:50:29 PM
I don't think I have a strong enough left arm to make the bellows slap - yet! ;D
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: BenFarmer on September 03, 2011, 03:05:58 PM
To get the bellows slap technique, as with everything else, you don't need to push it hard, but be just very aware of your bellows pressure and hold it at a silly angle to start with.

I'm a one-row player, who happens to play a much bigger instrument - everything comes out punchy and fun.  I like it this way, as I can get all smoochy when I want to too, by crossing the rows, or give it a bit of thump by not doing.  Some times it's nice to cross the rows just even when you don't need to - to keep that alternating bellows thing going (or for a particular chord of course).
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 03, 2011, 04:49:25 PM
..... my friday workshop at whitby ( adding layers of rhythm)  .....

george ;)

I would really like to learn more about this "layers of rhythm" (and am not the only one I suspect). Any chance of a brief description, George, ideally with an illustrating sound sample or two?

Sandy, I have emailed yhou a copy of teh handout I used for the workshops. 

george
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Sandy Flett on September 03, 2011, 05:57:29 PM

Sandy, I have emailed yhou a copy of teh handout I used for the workshops. 

george
Many thanks. Really useful to have the various effects named and described. Some I am aware of doing, some I may be doing intuitively, but also a couple I will be trying out. "Pulsing" is the one I have found hardest to do effectively when I want it.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Lyn on September 04, 2011, 08:29:57 AM
I know as a raw beginner it will be a long time before I am ready for this........but I can't wait til I can join the happy band of Slappers on this forum......
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 05, 2011, 10:29:50 AM

Sandy, I have emailed yhou a copy of teh handout I used for the workshops. 

george
Many thanks. Really useful to have the various effects named and described. Some I am aware of doing, some I may be doing intuitively, but also a couple I will be trying out. "Pulsing" is the one I have found hardest to do effectively when I want it.

If anybody else wants a copy email me  georg.egarside@btinternet.com

george
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 05, 2011, 10:39:16 AM
I don't think I have a strong enough left arm to make the bellows slap - yet! ;D


just to clarify things - bellows 'slap' whatever it is ,is NOT the same as bellows 'pulsing'  pulsing is a very gentle pulsing of the basic rhythm eg 2/4,4/4,6/8.3/4  etc  applied  using   wrist action as an overlay to the  normal pushing or pulling as dictated by the particular bit of a particular tune. .  A simple and easy example to try is in the first 4 Bars of 'daisy daisy'  which are all played on the push (G row) and which all have only one note.  Whilst playing each long note GENTLY pulse the bellows in a 3/4 rhythm i.e.  PUSH, push, push  etc,  It is not a technique to be used throughout a tune  but one that can be added to parts of a tune where it is convenient so to do

george
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Cooper on September 05, 2011, 11:56:04 AM
I only just got to watching the video on slapping,.... btw why t.h. would you want to do that? I mean, it's funny and all, and goodd for a laugh if you play that bike-pump-polka, but does anyone really use that technique when playing something nice?
W
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 05, 2011, 12:03:49 PM
I have just watcvhed the slapping vid  and as an addition to my last post I would say that bellows slapping is not even a very distant relative of bellows pulsing!

george ::)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 05, 2011, 03:05:25 PM
I agree about the slapping being specific to the box - my Pokerwork and Hohner 40stop are very prone to it when playing with gusto, but it's a rare occurence on the others.

Simon Care did a workshop yesterday at the Bunkfest and was teaching us to put more bounce into dance tunes by learning to play staccato melody with a more legato bass and pulsing the rythm in with a momentary "shove" from the heel of the right hand.  Apologies if he should disagree with my description of his technique, but it sounds wonderful when he does it!

Rob.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Sandy Flett on September 05, 2011, 03:31:50 PM
..... pulsing is a very gentle pulsing of the basic rhythm eg 2/4,4/4,6/8.3/4  etc  applied  using   wrist action as an overlay to the  normal pushing or pulling as dictated by the particular bit of a particular tune. .  A simple and easy example to try is in the first 4 Bars of 'daisy daisy'  which are all played on the push (G row) and which all have only one note.  Whilst playing each long note GENTLY pulse the bellows in a 3/4 rhythm i.e.  PUSH, push, push  etc,  It is not a technique to be used throughout a tune  but one that can be added to parts of a tune where it is convenient so to do

george

Simon Care did a workshop yesterday at the Bunkfest and was teaching us to put more bounce into dance tunes by learning to play staccato melody with a more legato bass and pulsing the rhythm in with a momentary "shove" from the heel of the right hand.  Apologies if he should disagree with my description of his technique, but it sounds wonderful when he does it!

Rob.

So, two ways of pulsing. Do they give a different effect? Is one easier to do effectively than the other? After many years of playing melodeon I am still amazed at how much you can get out of such a basically simple instrument, with rhythmic effects being my latest "must have some of that". Bob Cann was a master at pulsing, with bellows only ever slightly open, yet Dan Quinn is also a master at it but can often be seen with bellows wide open. As many techniques as there are players?
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 05, 2011, 05:16:44 PM
[ george

[/ Rob.

So, two ways of pulsing. Do they give a different effect? Is one easier to do effectively than the other? After many years of playing melodeon I am still amazed at how much you can get out of such a basically simple instrument, with rhythmic effects being my latest "must have some of that". Bob Cann was a master at pulsing, with bellows only ever slightly open, yet Dan Quinn is also a master at it but can often be seen with bellows wide open. As many techniques as there are players?

[/quote]

1.  Jimmy Shand was sthe absolute master of 'pulsing with minimal bellows opening amd fonm a distance  sometimes didn't seem to be moving anything!

2.   the result of pulsing using fine left hand wrist movements and /or right hand shoves won't be that different, the latter being more appropriate for one strappers such as Simon Care 'cos the heel of tehe hand is in situ pushing against edge of keyboard & he plays with quite a wide bellows opening.  The wrist movement probably works better for 2 strappers who normally have thumb on edge of or behind keybord  and many of who tend to play with 'tighter' bellos than one strappers. It  would however be diffficult to produce a steady rhythm with he  heel of hand  but tit would put emphasis on a particular note.

 An intersting addition/variation for two strappers is to shake the edge of the keybord with the thumb whilst getting on with the normal business with the fingers.  This produces a sort of warbling effect  that is quite different to  pulsing  a fixed eg 4/4 rhythm.

george

Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Sandy Flett on September 05, 2011, 07:01:29 PM
Anybody willing to put up demonstration sound samples that "isolate" these effects? It is quite difficult to hear exactly what the masters are doing in a general band recording.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 05, 2011, 07:10:00 PM
Anybody willing to put up demonstration sound samples that "isolate" these effects? It is quite difficult to hear exactly what the masters are doing in a general band recording.

how does one do that , can it be done using web cam & the computers microphone wherever that is.
Mine has a 'sound recording' facility built in that will record about 60 secs worth of sound  but I don't think it works together with webcam

george the luddite
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Owen Woods on September 06, 2011, 12:03:18 AM
Best example of bellows pulse on a melodeon is this IMHO: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkpA45JtPEs
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 06, 2011, 08:19:16 AM
Superb rendition, but I'd say that all the 'texturing' in this video is happening French style by playing 'en croche' (in 'hooks'= quavers), and by playing minor 9 and sus right hand chords to get 'fizz' into the riff.  His bellows movement barely changes when he switches to long scale runs and a bit of blues scale (approx 1'30').  In contrast the  'English pulse' is nearly all on the bellows, and the French find it challenging! ;D

  Botto's  Zague zague (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCW__NbNo0c) uses much the same technique, a bit slower

Grrr, I narrowly missed Cyrille 2 weeks ago when he played Thursday and Friday at Boombal festival 2 weeks ago. Very much on my 'see' list .. but you can only drive the length of France 'so' fast  :-\
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Owen Woods on September 06, 2011, 11:38:19 AM
I disagree. He is definitely using the bellows to give a pulse to it, not just fingers.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: george garside on September 06, 2011, 02:31:27 PM
agreed! If yoiu watch the top pleats of teh bellows you can  see the puling taking place from time to time

george
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: pikey on February 13, 2012, 05:31:55 PM
Here is a superb example of bellows control and tight playing - it's as if he forgot to undo the bottom strap!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmE6rFDW1vs&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Peadar on February 14, 2021, 01:53:41 PM
Waking  up another old thread- and Pikey''s reference to driving of rythm with um - pah basses (which is all the really old players had) - are there any videos out there of this type of playing on spoon bass boxes? It appears that 5-6 years ago there was a You-tube video of Luke Daniels playing a 19/4 but that video isn't there anymore.

 
Don't neglect the basses.... The 'English' style from the '70s revival was all 'Um Pah, Um Pah', giving a driving rhythm no matter what or how smooth the right hand was playing. Then the french influence started to appear, with the occasional held chord crossing across the basses, which now seems to predominate in the younger players to my mind at the expense of rhythm.

But if you listen to some of the really old players  e.g Albert Farmer, Peter Wyper, Jonny O'Leary, they played the Um and the Pah at the same time, with a strong pulsing rhythm, and again no matter what or how smooth the right hand was playing.

Hence my advice is to practice playing basses only, explore different way of playing them, but concentrate on driving the rhythm. i.e Push it from the left hand to support the right, not the other way round.

.........

Final point - if you want rhythmic playing, then play up and down the rows, not across. That gives natural breaks when you have to change bellows direction (remembering the above point!)

Enjoy

Edited to  Luke Daniels 19/4 i.e. a 4 bass semitone box.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 14, 2021, 02:20:44 PM
I can intimate that some French … rather admire the percussiveness of the “anglais” style.

And it is still used there. Stéf Milleret offers a tune played totally on row in his ? 2nd season of teaching videos.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Dick Rees on February 14, 2021, 05:01:47 PM
Best example of bellows pulse on a melodeon is this IMHO: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkpA45JtPEs

Great playing...of a schottis from Malung, Västerdalarna, Sweden.  Often called "the B-minor schottis", the melody is attributed to fiddler Böl-Olle.  Here's a link to a blog in French containing further links to a "straight" version and a "modern" setting.  Interesting to see the folk-process in action.  Cyril has added an amazing altitude to finish it off.

https://loblogdeujoan.blogspot.com/2015/01/lo-shotish-lescotisha-de-monsur-bol-olle.html?m=1
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: LoonBox on February 16, 2021, 12:23:40 AM
Best example of bellows pulse on a melodeon is this IMHO: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkpA45JtPEs

Great playing...of a schottis from Malung, Västerdalarna, Sweden.  Often called "the B-minor schottis", the melody is attributed to fiddler Böl-Olle.  Here's a link to a blog in French containing further links to a "straight" version and a "modern" setting.  Interesting to see the folk-process in action.  Cyril has added an amazing altitude to finish it off.

The French blog link isn’t showing.  😉
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Dick Rees on February 16, 2021, 12:34:00 AM
Now it is.  Don't know where it went the first time.

Thanks.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: tirpous on February 16, 2021, 04:53:12 AM
Quote
Now it is.  Don't know where it went the first time.

Maybe Thelonious Monk could tell us !  ;)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 16, 2021, 07:54:05 AM
Waking  up another old thread- and Pikey''s reference to driving of rythm with um - pah basses (which is all the really old players had) - are there any videos out there of this type of playing on spoon bass boxes?

I answered Peadar's question a few days ago, but I wanted to add to it in order to make the point that rhythmic drive comes not solely from the basses and chords but from the whole instrument, especially the coordination of the right-hand side and the bellows. This is particularly what drives great English music (to return to the original thread topic).

As I point out in my melodeon workshops, it's the way you play the melody which determines the rhythmic drive: gaps between the notes, using the bellows and treble buttons to anticipate the beat and grow into the actual beat arrival with a sudden stop, etc. John Kirkpatrick is the absolute master of this, and John Spiers is also doing it in the first linked video below.

Adding the basses and chords is good, but they are nothing on their own other than 'oom-pah', whereas you can play melody only, yet still make it sound good and rhythmically exciting. Put it all together, both sides, bellows and good fingering, and the result is magic.

But you need to have the sound that you want to achieve in your head first, a conceptual model, if you like, of rhythmically-driven English-style music.  If you can't 'hear' that magic sound in your mind first, how can you play it?

Here are some examples of rhythmic playing on one-row four-stop instruments with spoon basses/chords, as requested by Peadar:

Our own Squeezy John here:
https://youtu.be/BAEmmrcEFX0?t=664

Paul Young:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UtJbJHC-w7w

Anahata:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1i6O1qzNAY

Lester:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tx6s3LhOQAg

I'm sure there are many more out there on YT.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on February 16, 2021, 09:05:01 AM
I totally agree with Steve, it's not just the basses and chords that drive the tune.
It is a constant disagreement I have with one morris friend who insists it's the bass end that gives the oomph to dance to, but dancing to a good fiddler can be just as rhythmic and uplifting and fiddles don't have a bass end!

As Steve says, you have to hear the tune in your head first.
Possibly a second step after hearing it in your head is then to play just the melody, developing it into the rhythm you seek. The left hand then compliments the melody.

Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 16, 2021, 12:21:11 PM
I totally agree with Steve, it's not just the basses and chords that drive the tune.
It is a constant disagreement I have with one morris friend who insists it's the bass end that gives the oomph to dance to, but dancing to a good fiddler can be just as rhythmic and uplifting and fiddles don't have a bass end!

As Steve says, you have to hear the tune in your head first.
Possibly a second step after hearing it in your head is then to play just the melody, developing it into the rhythm you seek. The left hand then compliments the melody.

It's also more than just hearing the tune in your head; it's hearing in your head how the tune needs to be played to give that rhythmic drive that is so important when playing for dancing, morris or otherwise.

This tune is a great example of what I meant earlier - anticipating the beat with a 'zip' or 'err-up', silence when the beat actually falls, and all the rest of this great style. For me, this is what English traditional dance music is all about.
John Kirkpatrick - The Abram Circle Dance (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPjDIzxaxtQ)
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Julian S on February 16, 2021, 12:37:33 PM
That's the way to play it ! (Now is that me on the album cover ? - looks like my pokerwork with velcro on the grill - feels like a lifetime has gone by since I left SB)
John's playing for dancing has always been superb - I loved playing alongside him when I was in the side.

Julian
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Steve_freereeder on February 16, 2021, 12:44:16 PM
John's playing for dancing has always been superb - I loved playing alongside him when I was in the side.

Great! What an experience for you! (:)
I am envious, although I did play alongside Barry Callaghan (of Hardcore English fame) for a few years - he taught me a lot about English tunes and playing for dancing.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Jesse Smith on February 16, 2021, 03:43:37 PM
I totally agree with Steve, it's not just the basses and chords that drive the tune.
It is a constant disagreement I have with one morris friend who insists it's the bass end that gives the oomph to dance to, but dancing to a good fiddler can be just as rhythmic and uplifting and fiddles don't have a bass end!

This tune is a great example of what I meant earlier - anticipating the beat with a 'zip' or 'err-up', silence when the beat actually falls, and all the rest of this great style. For me, this is what English traditional dance music is all about.
John Kirkpatrick - The Abram Circle Dance (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPjDIzxaxtQ)

Well, that's a perfect example, isn't it? Just listening to the intro phrase played by itself on the right hand you can hear how strongly it communicates the beat and rhythm of the tune.

John played this in his online Morris tunes concert last month. Interesting to watch the base of his right hand thump against the keyboard on the downbeats. John Spiers is a big proponent of that as well.
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 16, 2021, 05:16:35 PM
John Kirkpatrick - The Abram Circle Dance

Was off to Abram in the 1990s, pre internet, and called local police as to time of dancing. Got a WPC. “What”!

I described it as best I knew … “you’re having me on” … then she put the phone down 😳
Title: Re: Bellows Control for English Tunes
Post by: Peadar on February 16, 2021, 06:05:37 PM
Steve - Thanks for your reply but the subsequent discussion make it clear that I am after raising the wrong  question in the wrong thread.
I was particularly interested in the "old melodeon" style that Pikey was referring to and how that applied to Scottish traditional music.
I was really looking for videos of Scottish traditional music played on spoon bass 2 rows -in particular semitone boxes.
Wrong thread for the question.
 It appears that 5-6 years ago there was a You-tube video of Luke Daniels playing a 19/4 but that video isn't there anymore.

 

But if you listen to some of the really old players  e.g Albert Farmer, Peter Wyper, Jonny O'Leary, they played the Um and the Pah at the same time, with a strong pulsing rhythm, and again no matter what or how smooth the right hand was playing.



As you say - the thread's about English playing styles. I'll take my "heretical Scottish notions"* into another thread.

*English Legal term for conflicting Scots Law principle

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal