Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Steve C. on August 21, 2011, 04:24:14 PM

Title: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Steve C. on August 21, 2011, 04:24:14 PM
Stage 1:
Your first box. 
This is when you get your first box and drive yourself crazy trying to learn from the free book that comes with Hohners. (same book, same edition for past 40 years!)
Duration: hopefully not more than a few weeks, but for me, here in States, took years. (Did also have "1000 Fiddle Tunes and a few of the EFDSS minibooks).  Old Faht alert: this was also 35 years before Youtube.

Stage 2:
Melodeon net
This is when you discover "wait a minute!"  Opens up the wonder of the humble box.
Duration: lasts forever, probably.

Stage 3:
Desire
This is when you dedicate your life to playing like (choose: Anahata, DTN, Kirkpatrick, Hall, Clive, Tesi, etc.)
Duration: at least 6 months, probably longer, but if much longer than 12 months, can be fatal.

Stage 4:
Resignation
This is when you realize "not going to happen".
Duration: see #3.  Has been seen in clinical trials to occasionally take less than 10 minutes.

Stage 5:
Acceptance
Best part, lasts pretty much forever (?) you learn to have fun doing your own thing.  Incremental improvement.  Fun just to play.  No more striving. (at least not too much).

No peer review, yet, appreciate hearing of any other research findings.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 21, 2011, 05:19:35 PM
My first melodeon (a Hohner) didn't come with a free book!  I bought it in desperation at a really DISMAL folk festival that was so bad I drove umpteen miles to a music shop that sold melodeons and spent the rest of the week (yes, it was a week of misery "folk" events) trying to persuade a tune out of the damn thing. By the end of the week I could play a simple tune, and the rest, as they say, is history! No books, no teachers, just my ears and a generous sprinkling of good luck. ;D

Graham
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: forrest on August 21, 2011, 06:19:22 PM
  I was introduced to the diatonic box by listening to Sharon Shannon recordings back in the early 90's. As diatonic boxes are rare in the US and even more scarce in the western states, my hunt for an instrument bore no fruit for many years. In general, most music shops  here carry no accordions of any description. Guitar is King.
   My first "melodeon", found by ransacking the back room of a used junk store, was actually a small two-row Bayan made in the DDR. It had two rows of buttons and eight basses, and I had no way of knowing that it was not what I was really seeking, as it was bisonoric. I did my best to learn to hold this contraption and coerce some sort of recognizable tune from it. Imagine trying to emulate Ms. Shannon on a dilapidated out of tune Bayan! Such was my quest, until I realized I was not getting very far, very fast.
  Then, along came the internet and the auction sites, and all of a sudden, melodeons by the dozens were being unearthed out of closets and attics, and up for sale. There were other people talking about them, fixing them, learning tunes, etc. The rest is history.  :||:
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Howard Jones on August 21, 2011, 06:59:19 PM
Mine didn't come with a free book, either, which probable explains why I avoided the frustration Steve describes.  I just sat down with a copy of Fieldvole Music and tried to play the tunes.  Obviously I couldn't play them like Tony Hall as I have only the regulation issue number of fingers.  It helped that I already played anglo concertina, so some of the principles were familiar.

I think I played "Tripping Upstairs" out at the folk club inside a couple of weeks.  Looking back, it was probably pretty dire, but I think I had all the right notes, some of them in the right order, and more or less in time.  In mitigation, audiences' expectations of melodeon players hadn't then been raised by the likes of Andy Cutting et al.  I think I got away with it.

So I dodged Stage 1, rushed through Stages 3-4 and reached stage 5 inside  a couple of weeks or so  (:) However I disagree that this stage means avoiding striving.  Rather it means accepting that you should play it your way rather than trying to imitate someone else, but also accepting that you never stop learning and never stop trying to play better.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: juker on August 21, 2011, 08:49:38 PM
Love it! I bought the free book and must admit that it got me started. I am at stage 5, just wish that I lived somewhere where I could play some music with other people  :(
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: forrest on August 21, 2011, 08:56:49 PM
Love it! I bought the free book and must admit that it got me started. I am at stage 5, just wish that I lived somewhere where I could play some music with other people  :(

Same situation here....not many folkie folks where I live, a few bluegrassers, but instruments with bellows need not apply  :-\
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Owen Woods on August 21, 2011, 10:15:08 PM
To a lucky few there would be stage 6 - Become the subject of someone else's stage 3!
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 22, 2011, 01:54:48 PM
What happened to "denial" - I spend most of my life in a state of denial!  Problems?  What problems?

Rob.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: ladydetemps on August 22, 2011, 02:03:34 PM
I'd need to add a stage
You realize after seeing a melnetter play a melodeon that a anglo concertina is not a mini melodeon and what you really want is one of those fancy boxes. So you look up melodeons online every moment you get, looking at the pretty boxes.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Randal Scott on August 22, 2011, 02:24:06 PM
Then there's the sad old bastard who hasn't played his box in months--and only posts on forums because he likes his avatar...

Current obsession: bass clarinet

Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 22, 2011, 05:04:14 PM
Do you know, I don't really understand why it is, but you guys in the States by all accounts are so thin on the ground that it must be something of a trek for all of you, to find another player.  And yet, you have such a superb romantic and multi-faceted tradition of immigrant accordion players from different countries (as shown in that wonderful book 'Accordion Crimes') that you really ought to be whoopin' it up!  So why all the disillusion, what's happened to all your wonderful roots, you fortunate people?
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 05:22:55 PM
Chris:

2 words: Pop music
Alt 2 words: Lawrence Welk
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 22, 2011, 05:41:04 PM
'Pop music' - I heard of that one too!
'Lawrence Welk' - a new one on me, so I checked him out.  Weird!  Was that a bit like the Billy Cotton Band Show for us?  Neither look much like serious opposition for roots though.   I went to see 'Simpsons, the Movie' in Boston a year or two back, and was pleased to find that the audience were in fits over the subtle cultural references that I'm afraid were completely lost on us Brits!  So perhaps there's hope for us all yet.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Randal Scott on August 22, 2011, 06:38:38 PM
Not me!  I play all kinds of trad music: ITM, scandi, cajun, American old-time (Scots-Irish Appalachian), blues, bluegrass, new jazz, old jazz, a little flamenco, Afro-Carribean...there's no dearth of music.

Some even on box
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 07:26:53 PM
But part of the psychological problem, to this day, and even for folks too young to have watched the Lawrence Welk show, is you say " I play accordion" and that LW image pops up.

So uncool, it's still uncool.  Even our most local pipe band dropped "accordion" years ago.

The word "melodeon" is not normal vocabulary here, average person thinks it might be related to harmonium or some 18-19th century instrument.

The only saving grace is that Tex Mex is alive and well but hard to find outside of the CA through LA band.  I think we are keeping Hohner in business.

Anyway, that's why we get lonely. When I was coming up, there were ads "Don't be a loner, get a Hohner" but they were talking about the Marine Band or Blues Harp.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Randal Scott on August 22, 2011, 09:34:24 PM
Oh yes, I understand.

What the PA haters don't understand, though, is that there's nothing like BLUES and zydeco on a PA.  

Yes, no seriously :|glug.  If box were one's only axe, I would imagine it would get a little lonesome...  The good news is that, in the states, the whole Americana/alt-country/nuevo-folk scene is beginning to learn what a great sound accordians are--they're showing up everywhere.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 22, 2011, 10:36:23 PM
(as shown in that wonderful book 'Accordion Crimes')

You mean I should read this? There's a copy downstairs on the kitchen table. I thought it was a girl thing, highly improbable storyline ...
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Chris Brimley on August 23, 2011, 03:06:17 AM
Quote
I thought it was a girl thing

I found it a real eye-opener - made me realise a lot about what the States was once all about - and funnily enough, also the accordion!
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Malcolm on August 23, 2011, 06:51:11 AM
$0 years since I got my first melodeon but no free book.  How the hell do I get out of stage 1???
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Lyn on August 23, 2011, 09:19:01 AM
Must agree with LdT, there is an embryonic, pre-stage 1 stage. It's where you are quite happy with your own instrument (fiddle, for me) but find some tunes just lack something. So you go on youtube. And find a melodeonista playing that tune. Then you follow the thread, curiously headed TOTM and find a whole lot of other lovely tunes. And you get to think, y'know, this here melodeon thing, it really does sound nice, how strange I've never really taken much notice when I've heard them in sessions.

So you start checking out music shop sites. Faint at the prices. Talk yourself round. Sit up late in to the night/early morning reading old mel.net threads.

SUDDENLY (this has all taken 3 days) you are bidding for boxes on ebay (which was and remains a closed book to me) and 10 days later you are the proud possessor of one of these magical instruments, care of -yes, dear old mel.net.

No book. No knowledge of well-known players  - you gradually realise that many of your folkie tracks have a line-up which contains -YES! A box player! Re-listen to cd collection, yes, there they, are - Andy Cutting, Saul Rose, Andy Seward, Julian Sutton, John Spiers. They were there all the time!!

And there you are, up to your oxters in melodeonism, no escape. At the moment I'm emulating EVERYBODY and sounding like no-one,  but, oh it is fun. A whole new world has opened up to me. :|||:
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: juker on August 24, 2011, 11:10:57 AM
*Like*
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Steve C. on August 24, 2011, 01:19:08 PM
Lyn--Thanks for that one (oxters).

Need to add it to my "English" dictionary.

Last entry was "jammy dodger".
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: AirTime on August 24, 2011, 04:30:01 PM
Quote
2 words: Pop music
Alt 2 words: Lawrence Welk

You got that right!

Tell anyone you're playing the accordion & their eyes will register disbelief before they mask it with a look of polite interest!

Living in the GTA (Greater Toronto area) there are any number of former child PA players of various accordion-playing ethnicities who wouldn't be caught dead playing the accordion now.  I would say the interest in accordion playing - especially DBA playing - in North America, to the extent there is any, is related to a revived interest in "roots music".

For myself - Youtube is the absolute key. I would never consider having lessons & though I have two copies of the Hohner instruction book - one from the Fifties & one from the Eighties (not much difference!) - I haven't given (either of) them more than a cursory glance. Straight to youtube, filching tunes here & there - thank you everyone!
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: ladydetemps on August 24, 2011, 04:33:22 PM

Tell anyone you're playing the accordion & their eyes will register disbelief before they mask it with a look of polite interest!

tip: to save time take a picture/video on mobile of melodeon. When they ask what you play show them it.
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 25, 2011, 09:40:14 PM
Must agree with LdT, there is an embryonic, pre-stage 1 stage. It's where you are quite happy with your own instrument (fiddle, for me) but find some tunes just lack something. So you go on youtube. And find a melodeonista playing that tune. Then you follow the thread, curiously headed TOTM and find a whole lot of other lovely tunes. And you get to think, y'know, this here melodeon thing, it really does sound nice, how strange I've never really taken much notice when I've heard them in sessions.

So you start checking out music shop sites. Faint at the prices. Talk yourself round. Sit up late in to the night/early morning reading old mel.net threads.

SUDDENLY (this has all taken 3 days) you are bidding for boxes on ebay (which was and remains a closed book to me) and 10 days later you are the proud possessor of one of these magical instruments, care of -yes, dear old mel.net.

No book. No knowledge of well-known players  - you gradually realise that many of your folkie tracks have a line-up which contains -YES! A box player! Re-listen to cd collection, yes, there they, are - Andy Cutting, Saul Rose, Andy Seward, Julian Sutton, John Spiers. They were there all the time!!

And there you are, up to your oxters in melodeonism, no escape. At the moment I'm emulating EVERYBODY and sounding like no-one,  but, oh it is fun. A whole new world has opened up to me. :|||:

Classic post, the very embodiment of why I'm here, although I still can't play owt worth listening to after far too long. Salterelle Nuage eh? Pretty good starter box that is!  :D
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on August 29, 2011, 10:42:10 PM
Playing with you lot last Thursday helped me realise I'm definitely at Stage 5, albeit at my own level. There's hope in me yet! The church in which I serve does not know what is about to hit it!  :||: :|glug :||:
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: IanD on September 01, 2011, 04:27:26 PM
Stage 1:
Your first box. 
This is when you get your first box and drive yourself crazy trying to learn from the free book that comes with Hohners. (same book, same edition for past 40 years!)
Duration: hopefully not more than a few weeks, but for me, here in States, took years. (Did also have "1000 Fiddle Tunes and a few of the EFDSS minibooks).  Old Faht alert: this was also 35 years before Youtube.

Stage 2:
Melodeon net
This is when you discover "wait a minute!"  Opens up the wonder of the humble box.
Duration: lasts forever, probably.

Stage 3:
Desire
This is when you dedicate your life to playing like (choose: Anahata, DTN, Kirkpatrick, Hall, Clive, Tesi, etc.)
Duration: at least 6 months, probably longer, but if much longer than 12 months, can be fatal.

Stage 4:
Resignation
This is when you realize "not going to happen".
Duration: see #3.  Has been seen in clinical trials to occasionally take less than 10 minutes.

Stage 5:
Acceptance
Best part, lasts pretty much forever (?) you learn to have fun doing your own thing.  Incremental improvement.  Fun just to play.  No more striving. (at least not too much).

No peer review, yet, appreciate hearing of any other research findings.
r
I'd say get to stage 5 as fast as possible; stop trying to play just like [insert name here] -- because you never will unless you spend hours every day at it for several years, and then you'll still only sound like an imitation -- just take inspiration from wherever and play like *you* want to play. If the result doesn't sound quite like anyone else, so much the better ;-)

Ian
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: ladydetemps on September 01, 2011, 04:42:47 PM

I'd say get to stage 5 as fast as possible; stop trying to play just like [insert name here] -- because you never will unless you spend hours every day at it for several years, and then you'll still only sound like an imitation -- just take inspiration from wherever and play like *you* want to play. If the result doesn't sound quite like anyone else, so much the better ;-)

Ian

6. be found at a folk festival by someone recognizing your style of playing. ;)
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: pikey on September 01, 2011, 04:46:54 PM
Stage 7 - you realise that you haven't learned any new tunes for 30 years, and have forgotten most of the ones you learned back then, so go back to the book.......
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 01, 2011, 04:57:11 PM
6. be found at a folk festival by someone recognizing your style of playing. ;)

Got me worried there, as that's how I got onto melnet (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1027.0.html) in the first place!  

The problem is that it isn't very far off stage 7 - little Rosie finding grandad's old melodeon in the attic and asking "wot's this"?
Title: Re: The Five Stages of Melodeon Playing: A very short monograph
Post by: Steve C. on September 01, 2011, 07:12:44 PM
#6 = badge of honor
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal