Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy in Vermont on August 21, 2011, 09:36:39 PM

Title: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 21, 2011, 09:36:39 PM
From another thread:

I don't have any hang ups about makers sourcing mechanical parts or reeds from expert manufacturers and as for bellows and straps ...  ::). Choosing the right parts and creating an top quality instrument from them can hardly be described as 'assembly'

No, but having an entire instrument chassis, reedblock, and keyboard made somewhere else, then installing reeds is certainly assembly -- albeit skilled assembly since reedwork is not simply fungible labor!

If Gaillard's reedwork person started to say that she "made" or "built" Gaillard accordions, wouldn't that be ridiculous? For that matter, it wouldn't even be appropriate for her to say that she "assembled" Gaillards.

Again, this description isn't about Loffet but about the meaning of manufacturing; producing; and assembling.  Based on the above-cited text, as well as other remarks in another thread, I think there are some gaps in people's knowledge of where accordions come from and what the norms of production are, and how that plays out in representations of "making" accordions.

There is a French website that attempted to get to the bottom of which parts were outsourced/generic and which were made in-house by each "maker" --- it's interesting to see how the makers' self-description could influence the 'picture' of where the boxes were made.  For instance, one maker's description referred to the "artisanal production" of his melodeons, when the pictures showed badged Serenellinis -- in fact, the same models one could get by simply picking up a phone and calling Serenellini.

Also, the word "design" is thrown about rather liberally, and in general seems to refer to what I would call "specifying," as in specifying wood varieties, keyboard configurations, how many voices, how many bass and treble buttons, what kind of decor.

For single-maker shops -- shops where an individual is associated with building the melodeon -- the norm is to make the chassis, reedblocks, and keyboard in-house.  Most single-builder shops buy bellows, straps, buttons, treble and bass mechanical parts from suppliers; and reeds are sourced from a small number of Italian reedmakers or suppliers. This could be called "producing" or "making."

Any less than that amount of in-house work -- i.e. having the reedblocks, chassis, and/or keyboard made by a company that makes its own boxes, in its own design, shifts the maker's work more toward "assembly."  Some exceptions would be special contracts with workshops or machinists to make parts that are uniquely designed for the maker.

Any more than that standard amount of in-house work can be regarded as a bonus.  Several of the builders in Quebec, for instance, make their own bellows (again, from components that are purchased from Italian suppliers).

Certainly, if a single-maker shop managed to make its own reeds, that would be an exceptional amount of in-house work and I suspect that maker would be able to command prices that are much higher than the norm -- see the single-maker concertina shops.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 01:19:24 AM
Andy, I feel the pain everyday in my day job, regulating medical devices.

In medical, it's called "own brand labeling" (OBL) and is the legal definition of the "company placing the product on the market under their own name"; they become the manufacture, regardless of who actually designed, built and packaged the product.

I have inspected factories that the OBL'er had never even been to.

There is a lot of this in musical instruments as well, not to mention toasters, flat screens, mobile phones, lap tops, etc. etc.

Not going to be easy to reverse the trend, as the "manufacturer/namer" paid their money and feels justified in marketing the box as theirs.  And legally justified they are.

But I know what you mean.  Maybe let's you and me take a trip to Castelfidardo and buy 100 boxes; in the meantime, let's think up a good name and "look".  (no rhinestones, please)

We ship them to Vt. and you "work magic" on them to set them apart from the run of the mill other companies that are doing the same thing.  My thought is we add either a siren or birdcall button, like some of the old concertinas had.  ::)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 22, 2011, 05:15:36 AM
The World has changed, albeit Colin Dipper makes own bellows, reeds and even threads his own bolts! But Colin has a 15+ year wait (if it ever comes) and would not I think describe himself as a businessman.

Doubters should perhaps read Adam smith, or play one of the re-reeded Italian boxes Oakwood do. We all rave about those! In the end its build quality, sound and price/value that matter to me.

Ooo! I'm just watching an Alpine sunrise!  (:) (:)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Howard Jones on August 22, 2011, 08:43:50 AM
Colin (Dipper)has a 15+ year wait (if it ever comes) and would not I think describe himself as a businessman.

I think that's something of an exagerration.  When I asked Colin about this (admittedly three or four years ago) he told me the wait then was around 4 years, unless you wanted something unusual.  He claimed the stories about long waiting periods were put about by concertina dealers who want to encourage people to buy second-hand.  It's true that your concertina will only be ready when it's ready, and the waiting period is only a guideline, but I don't think it's as long as as often suggested, and certainly not 15+ years (unless anyone has evidence to the contrary).

As the owner of a Dipper, I can only say it's worth waiting for.  However I've already annoyed enough people on concertina.net by revealing how long I waited for mine, so I won't repeat it here.  Suffice to say I was very lucky with the timing of my enquiry.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 22, 2011, 12:29:53 PM
Saw Colin and Rosalie last month in France and mine is no closer. Ok Id asked for a franglo.  To be fair I got the long wait off a board, but speaking personally, 8 years+ now.

My point however was - they seem to buy NOTHING in.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 01:26:05 PM
Chris, I agree, real craftsmanship is a beautiful thing when you can find it.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 22, 2011, 02:48:31 PM
The World has changed, albeit Colin Dipper makes own bellows, reeds and even threads his own bolts! But Colin has a 15+ year wait (if it ever comes) and would not I think describe himself as a businessman.

Doubters should perhaps read Adam smith, or play one of the re-reeded Italian boxes Oakwood do. We all rave about those! In the end its build quality, sound and price/value that matter to me.

Ooo! I'm just watching an Alpine sunrise!  (:) (:)

I'm not sure what you mean by "doubters should perhaps read Adam Smith," it is precisely because I HAVE read Smith that I assert my judgment on this matter.  If you want a fungible instrument than Adam Smith is the way to go, no doubt.

The success of many of these products -- such as the Oakwood/Baffetti, relates to the price-to-quality ratio.  Not everyone has the resources to buy a Gaillard! (And not everyone wants to play one out in the rain or in a pub.)  My point is to preserve the distinction.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 22, 2011, 05:04:04 PM
Gaillard defo makes all the woodwork (started as a cabinet maker) and the blocks which are very important. So +2 at least there. But he outsources reed fit and fettle, and when I xrayed mine, there is a load of metal in there. Maybe he makes that maybe not. I think all play to their strengths apart from Colin, man of all trades it seems.

Sort of begs the question whether Stradivarius quality woodwork ( 8) it all vibrates!) suffices if the reeds wobble or warble? I'll not take it in the rain, just heard thunder  ::)

BG's #2 daughter C is here, I'll ask about the "innards".

Ee, I only logged in for't' cricket score!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 05:28:57 PM
Good example of fighting the good fight are the Button Box R. Morse-series concertinas.

They are pretty much hand made in Mass. by their craftspeople.  They buy the reeds of course.  But from what I saw when I was there, they do it all.

I think they do sub out CNC routing of the reedpan.

Pretty much "a mano" for $US 2200.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 22, 2011, 06:16:44 PM
Gaillard defo makes all the woodwork (started as a cabinet maker) and the blocks which are very important.
As in he and he alone does the woodwork?

Most accordion factories will engage a carpenter, so what's the difference if different parts are made by different people. If anything, the maker who does everything himself claims to be an expert in every field which seem unlikely.

Rather than paying a premium and waiting 5 years for a hobbyist to produce your accordion, would you not be better off just paying half the price (for a similar quality box) to a maker who has the good sense to hire expert staff?

Would it not be fair to say that the more you pay - in general - the better the box will be? Of course, with certain makes there is a premium for the brand, but an expensive box will be manufactured using the highest expertise available.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Stiamh on August 22, 2011, 06:19:37 PM
Gaillard defo makes all the woodwork (started as a cabinet maker) and the blocks which are very important. So +2 at least there. But he outsources reed fit and fettle, and when I xrayed mine, there is a load of metal in there. Maybe he makes that maybe not.

He told me the levers and mechanisms were made for him (laser-cut) in Italy, to his own design. The grilles are made by a shop, somewhere in France IIRC. I think he buys in the leather valves, too, and rejects a fair percentage of them as substandard, because he showed me a box of them and pointed out which ones were no good in his estimation.

PS @ Sandwich, cross-posted: yes he does all the woodwork himself. If you had looked at one of his boxes I don't think the term hobbyist would come to mind.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: LDbosca on August 22, 2011, 07:28:21 PM
Gaillard defo makes all the woodwork (started as a cabinet maker) and the blocks which are very important.
Rather than paying a premium and waiting 5 years for a hobbyist to produce your accordion

You've never played a Gaillard, have you?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 22, 2011, 07:33:13 PM

PS @ Sandwich, cross-posted: yes he does all the woodwork himself. If you had looked at one of his boxes I don't think the term hobbyist would come to mind.

I'm sure they are top quality boxes. Leaving aside the use of the term hobbyist... if he employed a few more people, he could sell them at a reasonable price and reduce the leadtime to zero. If he's in charge of quality control then what's the difference? It's not like Rembrandt painted every stroke himself.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 22, 2011, 07:38:05 PM
You've never played a Gaillard, have you?
No I haven't. Now, maybe I'll change my opinion when I play one but as far as I am concerned you'd want to have your head examined to pay the sort of cash he charges.

A great resource for this website would be a list of single-builder shops.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on August 22, 2011, 07:50:30 PM
You've never played a Gaillard, have you?
No I haven't. Now, maybe I'll change my opinion when I play one but as far as I am concerned you'd want to have your head examined to pay the sort of cash he charges.

A great resource for this website would be a list of single-builder shops.


To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: LDbosca on August 22, 2011, 07:54:10 PM
You've never played a Gaillard, have you?
No I haven't. Now, maybe I'll change my opinion when I play one but as far as I am concerned you'd want to have your head examined to pay the sort of cash he charges.


I imagine any opinion you might have should be based on not just the prices but some consideration of the quality for the price. They're concert-quality instruments for serious players and, yes, they come at a price, but compared with the jump in quality from slightly lower priced instruments they are very much worth it.

Another way to look at it is (in my experience, having tried Peter Hyde's instruments, Castagnaris, Saltarelles, Van Der Aas, Hohners, old and new paolos, etc., the only other option at a competing standard is a Doug Briggs box...and that's about 5000 euro and a 7 or so year wait.


PS @ Sandwich, cross-posted: yes he does all the woodwork himself. If you had looked at one of his boxes I don't think the term hobbyist would come to mind.

I'm sure they are top quality boxes. Leaving aside the use of the term hobbyist... if he employed a few more people, he could sell them at a reasonable price and reduce the leadtime to zero. If he's in charge of quality control then what's the difference? It's not like Rembrandt painted every stroke himself.


In the words of BG himself "I could make more boxes...but I don't." I think he enjoys slow, perfectionist work, rather than maximum profit-making.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 22, 2011, 08:09:20 PM
In the words of BG himself "I could make more boxes...but I don't." I think he enjoys slow, perfectionist work, rather than maximum profit-making.
Nicely put. Fair play to him I suppose. He can hardly be blamed for the high demand.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 22, 2011, 08:11:42 PM


To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Why do you say that, can you elaborate on this a bit?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: rees on August 22, 2011, 08:16:29 PM
In the words of BG himself "I could make more boxes...but I don't." I think he enjoys slow, perfectionist work, rather than maximum profit-making.

That's how I work too. There are far more important things to be doing. Playing the melodeon for a start.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Stiamh on August 22, 2011, 08:43:46 PM
In the words of BG himself "I could make more boxes...but I don't." I think he enjoys slow, perfectionist work, rather than maximum profit-making.

More words of BG: "If I wanted to make money, I would sell accordions, not make them."
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: oggiesnr on August 22, 2011, 08:46:39 PM
Chris, I agree, real craftsmanship is a beautiful thing when you can find it.


.. and very expensive to boot!  In fact so expensive that either the maker is not really making a decent return or that it kills all but a very limited market.

I suppose it also depends what you're looking for in a box.  The technology exists to build the case, the reed blocks, in fact all the wooden bits of a melodeon (and finnish them) without them being touched by human hand, now if that was done in one shop by the guy whose name was on the box (and could afford the kit) would we consider it as "made" by them or would we just sniff?

Steve
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 22, 2011, 09:09:30 PM
From another thread:

I don't have any hang ups about makers sourcing mechanical parts or reeds from expert manufacturers and as for bellows and straps ...  ::). Choosing the right parts and creating an top quality instrument from them can hardly be described as 'assembly'

No, but having an entire instrument chassis, reedblock, and keyboard made somewhere else, then installing reeds is certainly assembly -- albeit skilled assembly since reedwork is not simply fungible labor!

If Gaillard's reedwork person started to say that she "made" or "built" Gaillard accordions, wouldn't that be ridiculous? For that matter, it wouldn't even be appropriate for her to say that she "assembled" Gaillards.

Again, this description isn't about Loffet but about the meaning of manufacturing; producing; and assembling.  Based on the above-cited text, as well as other remarks in another thread, I think there are some gaps in people's knowledge of where accordions come from and what the norms of production are, and how that plays out in representations of "making" accordions.

There is a French website that attempted to get to the bottom of which parts were outsourced/generic and which were made in-house by each "maker" --- it's interesting to see how the makers' self-description could influence the 'picture' of where the boxes were made.  For instance, one maker's description referred to the "artisanal production" of his melodeons, when the pictures showed badged Serenellinis -- in fact, the same models one could get by simply picking up a phone and calling Serenellini.

Also, the word "design" is thrown about rather liberally, and in general seems to refer to what I would call "specifying," as in specifying wood varieties, keyboard configurations, how many voices, how many bass and treble buttons, what kind of decor.

For single-maker shops -- shops where an individual is associated with building the melodeon -- the norm is to make the chassis, reedblocks, and keyboard in-house.  Most single-builder shops buy bellows, straps, buttons, treble and bass mechanical parts from suppliers; and reeds are sourced from a small number of Italian reedmakers or suppliers. This could be called "producing" or "making."

Any less than that amount of in-house work -- i.e. having the reedblocks, chassis, and/or keyboard made by a company that makes its own boxes, in its own design, shifts the maker's work more toward "assembly."  Some exceptions would be special contracts with workshops or machinists to make parts that are uniquely designed for the maker.

Any more than that standard amount of in-house work can be regarded as a bonus.  Several of the builders in Quebec, for instance, make their own bellows (again, from components that are purchased from Italian suppliers).

Certainly, if a single-maker shop managed to make its own reeds, that would be an exceptional amount of in-house work and I suspect that maker would be able to command prices that are much higher than the norm -- see the single-maker concertina shops.

I used to do some work for Martyn Banks of Oakwood Instruments, a sort of outworker on piecework. I wasn't involved in any way in the production of the Oakwood melodeons but I was around at the time and saw quite a bit of the R&D that went into them. All wooden parts would have been designed, made and finished in house. As I recall the metal parts of levers were bought in from Italy but were individually shaped to fit, one by one by my good friend Ian Carrington who worked with me elsewhere for many years. The reeds would no doubt have been Binci but I've no idea who fitted them or tuned them.

Martyn Banks is a great designer and has a thorough knowledge of the physics of musical instuments. He's also a wizard at jigging up jobs to create mini production lines for wooden parts so there is some question about the expression 'hand made'. Every piece of wood used will have been selected and sawn by Martyn himself, the machined parts will have been carefully assembled and glued up by hand probably by him, finishing will have been by hand as the workshop had none of the large belt sanders seen in the videos of German and Italian accordion manufacturers. It was also Martyn's job to spray finish every single instrument that's ever left the workshop.

I'm not sure where that leaves Oakwood on the scale of 'proper makers' but I can tell you that Martyn will have been heavily involved in the making and particularly the setting up of each one. In the end of course, being the astute business man he is, he decided buying and selling was more profitable when it came to squeezeboxes.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 22, 2011, 11:40:45 PM
Probably Mr/Ms Sandwich and others might just chill a little regarding the price of instruments and their value.

I think the forum has gone here before: Golfs are pretty good transportation, even entertaining, but it sure is nice (if you have the extra $) to drive an A4 instead.

In the overall scheme of musical instrument prices, even the most precious boxes are not "that" expensive.

We have also drifted from Andy's original position regarding badge engineering and I agree with him that it seems at the minimum "weird" to pay extra for the "same thing with a different name".

But the value added approach (the Oakwood Dino Binci) sounds reasonable. Thought with our pitifully devalued dollar, one costs the same as a Tommy, nearly.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: streb on August 23, 2011, 01:39:14 AM
I agree with tallship. To be considered a "maker", in my opinion, one also needs to be the designer of the instrument, even if that design is based around pre-existing components.

What about luthiers who make violins by copying the surviving instruments of the old masters? Are they makers or manufacturers? Rhetorical question - discuss.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 23, 2011, 03:07:12 AM
I agree with tallship. To be considered a "maker", in my opinion, one also needs to be the designer of the instrument, even if that design is based around pre-existing components.

What about luthiers who make violins by copying the surviving instruments of the old masters? Are they makers or manufacturers? Rhetorical question - discuss.

Oakwood melodeons were squarely in the definition that I outlined above.

I'm not sure that I would agree that "maker" necessarily includes design.  Marcel Messervier Sr. and Marcel Messervier Jr. designed the accordions that they currently build.  If Marcel Jr. had a child who learned to continue to make these outstanding accordions, and chose to do so with no alteration of the design (unlikely, but possible), I would still consider Marcel III (or Marcie) to be a maker.  I don't believe that innovation is necessary.  However, I do think that the status of a shop would be different if they produced instruments that were essentially fungible with instruments made elsewhere.  There are plenty of examples of this in the field of dozens of Cajun shops (garages?) where instruments are assembled from components made entirely by one maker.  If I call that maker and tell him that I want the parts to make a Cajun box in curly maple with stainless buttons, black leather straps, and red/black bellows, I can hardly be said to have "designed" the instrument.

Violin-making has a different set of norms. It could be instructive to compare them (as I have, in discussion with a friend who makes them) but I think that it risks missing the point: norms have developed for single-builder shops, small shops, and small factories that make melodeons.  If you want to discuss the standards of violin-making, there are some great forums out there.  The question is, what norms have developed for melodeon makers, and in what ways to some shops excel (or fall below par)?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: oggiesnr on August 23, 2011, 07:07:41 AM

We have also drifted from Andy's original position regarding badge engineering and I agree with him that it seems at the minimum "weird" to pay extra for the "same thing with a different name".


This is where one of the points of discussion centres, buy an of the peg box and put your name on it and charge a premium is one thing, buy off the peg parts (and'or specify how you want those parts made) assemble said boxes and tweak to your satisfaction then that becomes something different.

You then get to the larger companies like Castagnari where essentially they're a production line with different specialists/workers making different parts, essentially the only differences between them and a chinese shop is scale and the fact that they produce a quality instrument, the process is the same.

Steve
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2011, 09:24:30 AM
To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Why do you say that, can you elaborate on this a bit?

Why, because if you buy second hand you can get a box at half the price. Plus of course I'm developing into a torchbearer for vintage hohners...
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Guy on August 23, 2011, 10:01:12 AM
To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Why do you say that, can you elaborate on this a bit?

Why, because if you buy second hand you can get a box at half the price. Plus of course I'm developing into a torchbearer for vintage hohners...

But if no-one bought new, then there'd be no new instruments coming on to the market, and the whole debate about "making" would vanish as there'd be no "makers". And the price of second-hand would rocket...
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 23, 2011, 10:50:01 AM
The comments about Dipper are interesting. I'm not sure what happens now, but when I had my first English concertina, it was tuned to concert pitch by John and Sue Holman. Originally leather workers, they made the boxes for instruments, then bellows for Dipper being friends and only a few miles away. They progressed onto tuning and were excellent, sadly stopping in the late 80's. At that point, Dipper used ' local artisan workers' to produce an excellent product.
I once took a Jeffries anglo to John for tuning and we discussed the level of workmanship on them,  as I believe they are considerd the best anglo's made. Their insides were somewhat crude compared to my Lachenal  English. John said the metal ends were stamped out 'under the arches' in London by people paid piecework to do so, and others manufacturing their respective parts then assembled in one place. If I scroll upwards, I think this was the exact point someone made about Stradavari violins.
What ever the instrument, it appears most people employ others to do some of the work as they haven't the total skills, or cannot afford to make it all themselves as the product would be too expensive.
It has always gone on.........  it does not bother me so long as the assembly and finished product is good.

I think people bring this process into question when a complete melodeon is re-badged and this ups the price considerably for no workmanship being involved, and worse, in some cases the complete product has not been quality-checked.
That then leaves a sour taste in the mouth and a hole in the pocket for a re-tune/fettle of a new instrument that should not need such treatment.
Q
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 23, 2011, 11:44:21 AM
But if no-one bought new, then there'd be no new instruments coming on to the market, and the whole debate about "making" would vanish as there'd be no "makers". And the price of second-hand would rocket...
The makers would return from exile and banish the second-hand hawkers, beginning the cycle all over again.


What about luthiers who make violins by copying the surviving instruments of the old masters? Are they makers or manufacturers? Rhetorical question - discuss.
I think it's fair to say that the violin as an instrument has achieved perfection. It cannot be improved upon, so there's no harm in embracing the technology to recreate the work of the old masters. The accordion, on the other hand, perhaps because of its inherent diversity, can't really achieve the same criteria of harmonious completion and closure. It's a contraption that you could build in your shed if you put your mind to it. It's these characteristics that most appeal to me.

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2011, 12:06:16 PM
To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Why do you say that, can you elaborate on this a bit?

Why, because if you buy second hand you can get a box at half the price. Plus of course I'm developing into a torchbearer for vintage hohners...

But if no-one bought new, then there'd be no new instruments coming on to the market, and the whole debate about "making" would vanish as there'd be no "makers". And the price of second-hand would rocket...

Hmm, true, but that isn't much of an incentive to spend an extra £1000 on every purchase...
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 23, 2011, 12:33:39 PM
FWIW Norbert Pignol sees Gaillard as a superb worker in wood. He opined to me years ago that BG accordeons were the world's best. But he thinks all the metalwork and reeds are Italian. "No one makes their own bellows"

So what makes a maker? I can say I've seen Bertrand's DESIGN evolve over 20 years.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Clive Williams on August 23, 2011, 01:32:30 PM
FWIW Norbert Pignol sees Gaillard as a superb worker in wood. He opined to me years ago that BG accordeons were the world's best. But he thinks all the metalwork and reeds are Italian. "No one makes their own bellows"

So what makes a maker? I can say I've seen Bertrand's DESIGN evolve over 20 years.

I think he's probably right too. I don't think I've played anything as nice as the ones I tried at his stall in St Chartier a few years back. The man's a genius.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: LDbosca on August 23, 2011, 01:34:50 PM
To be fair, as far as I'm concerned you'd want to have your head examined if you buy any new box.
Why do you say that, can you elaborate on this a bit?

Why, because if you buy second hand you can get a box at half the price. Plus of course I'm developing into a torchbearer for vintage hohners...

But if no-one bought new, then there'd be no new instruments coming on to the market, and the whole debate about "making" would vanish as there'd be no "makers". And the price of second-hand would rocket...

Hmm, true, but that isn't much of an incentive to spend an extra £1000 on every purchase...

Sorry to stick on the BG thing but imagine the price of the box increased rather than decreased....I'd buy the new one! Plus custom layouts etc.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2011, 01:45:43 PM
Sorry to stick on the BG thing but imagine the price of the box increased rather than decreased....I'd buy the new one! Plus custom layouts etc.

Aye, but that is very much an unknown quantity. For something like BG then his boxes will probably increase in value after he has stopped making, but there are precious few who will do that and they are all horribly expensive to begin with! If you want a custome layout then buy a cheaper second hand box and get your friendly neighbourhood repairer to mod it for you.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 23, 2011, 02:04:36 PM
Uke, I had been thinking the same thing, came up when I decided I must have a Stoney Steps layout DG.

So I call my favorite tuner guy and ask him for a quote retuning my Pokerwork DG with low notes only.  Actually, it was quite expensive to move all the reeds up and add new ones at the bottom.

So much so that my significant other (she who must be obeyed) said, innocently, "why don't you just buy a new one".

Is that love or what?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on August 23, 2011, 02:08:06 PM
Uke, I had been thinking the same thing, came up when I decided I must have a Stoney Steps layout DG.

So I call my favorite tuner guy and ask him for a quote retuning my Pokerwork DG with low notes only.  Actually, it was quite expensive to move all the reeds up and add new ones at the bottom.

So much so that my significant other (she who must be obeyed) said, innocently, "why don't you just buy a new one".

Is that love or what?

Actually converting from third buttons start to fourth bottom start can be quite expensive and on a pokerwork might not be worth it. Still cheaper than a new one though!

And I must admit to being jealous of you there :P My other half is a whistle player and hasn't quite got round to the fact that melodeons are significantly more expensive than whistles...
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 23, 2011, 02:17:16 PM
"No one makes their own bellows"

That's incorrect as a point of fact.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 23, 2011, 02:22:42 PM
Having just converted from 3rd to 4th button start, ( yes for Stony steps  :D ) I confirm it is expensive due to all the reeds requiring moving, shoe-horning in other reeds then the tuning requiring checking. More importantly a tad annoying after spending out on a box. Being a beginner I simply didn't know why a 4th button start with low notes was such a good idea. See the major thread elsewhere on this site about this topic before I ramble on about it again!
One huge advantage about ordering a bespoke box as opposed to one off the shelf, is that you can specify exactly your layout, and save the messing around and extra expense of having it converted afterwards. Also you order the exact make and model you want. Buying second hand has it's advantages, but only if you know exactly what you want to buy, and that these makes and models appear frequently enough on the second hand market.
Q

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 23, 2011, 04:20:43 PM
Sorry to stick on the BG thing but imagine the price of the box increased rather than decreased....I'd buy the new one! Plus custom layouts etc.

Aye, but that is very much an unknown quantity. For something like BG then his boxes will probably increase in value after he has stopped making, [...]

As far as I can tell, the prices have increased.  For that matter, the prices of used Castagnaris have also increased. This assumes that you hold onto the (used, good condition) box long enough that the new prices increase in the meantime.  Then, even if you sell for less than a current (new) one, the value of your box will have increased. 
I can confirm this in the case of several boxes that I have owned and later sold -- two different Castagnaris, a Melodie, and a Gaillard.
As long as the instrument is in good shape (no "abusive" wear or damage), it makes sense for the used prices to compare favorably with new boxes for which a buyer will have to wait.  I do believe that the sometimes deflated prices of used boxes reflect the buyers' attitude that something has been sacrificed, when in fact, if an instrument has received a proper '2nd' tuning and maintenance (after at least a year or two of play) and there is no damage to the bellows, the buyer is actually receiving value added (compared to a new box).
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 23, 2011, 04:54:54 PM
Actually converting from third buttons start to fourth bottom start can be quite expensive and on a pokerwork might not be worth it. Still cheaper than a new one though!


I've no idea how much it would cost to have a box changed from 3rd to 4th button start, but I've recently declubbed a 1930s Bb/Eb Hohner Club II, changed it to 4th button start and swapped the half-row so that the whole keyboard layout matches my D/G Saltarelle, and it cost me a lot of hours, a bit of headscratching, a LOT of frustration, and only a few quid in parts (I had a couple of old past-restoration Hohners and a box of old Hohner bits that I could raid for replacement reeds etc).  It took longer than I anticipated, and I made a fair few mistakes, but I learned a lot and the satisfaction is ENORMOUS!!

Graham
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Lester on August 23, 2011, 05:11:10 PM
So I call my favorite tuner guy and ask him for a quote retuning my Pokerwork DG with low notes only.  Actually, it was quite expensive to move all the reeds up and add new ones at the bottom.

Suppose it is dependant on what you call 'quite expensive'. It is a relatively easy job on a pokerwork especially as Hohner seem to use the same reed blocks as the C/F box but add a strip of wood on the bottom of the reed blocks which is easily removed, it's only waxed in, thus not requiring any woodwork to accommodate the larger reeds as they are moved down the block. When I did mine in the last month it did not even need very much remedial tuning after moving the reeds but then I decided to retune it to Viennese tuning. But as Theo stated in a previous run around this subject the task may reveal other work that is worth, or needs doing. So on a box in good condition a few hours work plus two new, or reclaimed reeds and the job is done.

It took me a total of ~8 hours to remove the reeds, clean them up, fit new valves, reinstall the reeds in new position, retune the box to Viennese tuning, restrict the treble action.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 23, 2011, 08:25:32 PM
Andy: Unless I'm mistaken, there seems to be very few Castagnari's for sale second hand in the UK, apart from Lilly's making regular appearances.
It begs the question - do you order a new one and be certain that in 'x' months/years time you will get what you wanted, or wait  and see if Lady Luck will deal you a second hand one?
Interesting question!
Q
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 23, 2011, 08:32:15 PM
Lester, sounds about right:  8 hours x (low est. US$ 40?) =  320 - treble already padded out = ~US$300.

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Lester on August 23, 2011, 08:44:10 PM
Lester, sounds about right:  8 hours x (low est. US$ 40?) =  320 - treble already padded out = ~US$300.



I'm much cheaper than that  ;D
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 23, 2011, 09:27:31 PM
Andy: Unless I'm mistaken, there seems to be very few Castagnari's for sale second hand in the UK, apart from Lilly's making regular appearances.
It begs the question - do you order a new one and be certain that in 'x' months/years time you will get what you wanted, or wait  and see if Lady Luck will deal you a second hand one?
Interesting question!
Q

There are always used Castagnaris for sale on French diato sites with classifieds; also, there is at least one German website with used Castagnaris.  Of course, you are less likely to find a G/C when you go that route.  But for G/C and even A/D...
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 23, 2011, 10:09:36 PM
As you say, that's our problem over here in D/G land, no body else has 'em!
Q
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: rees on August 23, 2011, 11:37:31 PM
I have 50, s/h,  D/G Castagnaris in my back shed. I'm just waiting for the prices to go up.  >:E  :o  :|glug
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Theo on August 24, 2011, 12:40:38 AM
Well in that case Lester you are not valuing your work enough.  Look at the labour rate you are charged when you have your care serviced,  reed work is of at least a similar skill level to car maintenance.

Btw 8 hours for that particular job seems excessive in the extreme, once you have completed your apprenticeship you should be able to bring that down by more than half.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Lester on August 24, 2011, 12:50:37 AM
Well in that case Lester you are not valuing your work enough.  Look at the labour rate you are charged when you have your care serviced,  reed work is of at least a similar skill level to car maintenance.

Btw 8 hours for that particular job seems excessive in the extreme, once you have completed your apprenticeship you should be able to bring that down by more than half.

I agree that 8 hours is a long time but, as you say, I am still serving my apprenticeship which is why my rates are low at this time of my career. Get it now whilst it's cheap!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: blafleur on August 24, 2011, 01:46:11 AM
Not sure if what I'm doing would be considered making, assembling, or producing, what I do know is I'm having great time with it. ;D

Deciding on what I buy and what I make is simple, if what I want isn't available, or not to my liking, or I feel I can make better, I make those things.  Some things, such as straps and bellows, I'd like to make, but at this point, it's not worth it for the time I'd spend learning how, and the fact that such good materials are available. But one day.......   

Some things I will never consider making, stop rods, buttons, and of course, reeds.  I turn my own stop knobs, but it is not a good return on money for time, that's just one of those things I just choose to do anyway.  One thing I wrestle with is the guy who engraves my logo has offered to laser cut the sound holes for very cheap.  I don't have a logical reason for not letting him, I would just feel I'm turning loose of too much out of my hands.

In the end, doesn't all that really matters is a person getting an accordion he is happy with, regardless of the process it took to put it in his hands?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 02:12:47 AM
In the end, doesn't all that really matters is a person getting an accordion he is happy with, regardless of the process it took to put it in his hands?

Monsieur,
You of all people should realize that part of that person being happy with his accordion is knowing the integrity of processes involved in building it. ;)
I'm actually surprised that it's not clear that sourcing the stop rods is not the same as sourcing fulling assembled (and generic) bass boxes, keyboards, and reedblocks, and that kind of sourcing is different from contracting someone to make specific components to your designs and specifications.

And Rees, as to your post above: had you bought 50 D/G Castagnaris in 2001, and saved them to sell today, I'm sure you would have done better than had you invested the same amount of money in the stock market!!!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: blafleur on August 24, 2011, 03:08:50 AM
 part of that person being happy with his accordion is knowing the integrity of processes involved in building it. ;)


Those are the people I'm hoping to deal with.  The Cajun music market, for the most part, could care less about aesthetics other than tradition, and mainly care about sound and playability, and some of that is based on what they've been exposed to.  That's why so many Cajun accordion builders vary so little from each other, but each has loyal followings.  But, I do times are a changing, even there.  

My point wasn't to argue with what you said, just to muddy the water a little.  8)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 24, 2011, 09:35:52 AM
I have 50, s/h,  D/G Castagnaris in my back shed. I'm just waiting for the prices to go up.  >:E  :o  :|glug

 Are they those counterfeit ones you made ?  ;D mory
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Fidjit on August 24, 2011, 10:22:14 AM
Hmm. Interesting. How far back should one go to make something? First plant the seed for the tree ? Dig out the ore for to smelt to steel for the reeds ? Process the pulp to cardboard for the bellows ?

Ok I didn't do all that. But I thoroughly enjoyed my time assembling some and MAKING MOST of the parts on the two courses I was on with Emmanuel. All I can say is, "If you haven't tried it don't knock it"

My 2 & 1/2 row G/C is for sale if anyone is interested.

Cheers   :|glug

See you at Witney

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 24, 2011, 12:54:05 PM
Clara confirms that her dad, Bernard in essence evolved the designs and makes the woodwork and some internal structures to support Italian mechanisms and Binci reeds. We established that reed set and tuning was outsourced, last year. Yet a lot of people would consider Gaillard a top box. Some would say the best.

So what "makes" a maker?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 24, 2011, 01:11:50 PM
Theo is probably right, the labor rate "should" be about $65-80, even a little higher for some work, and not including parts/materials,  but as an "old friend of the firm" who sends in his boxes every year for a tune up, I usually get a pretty good price.

I never grudge spending the money on people who know what they are doing; the cost of not f^%$#@* it up is "priceless".
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: melodeon on August 24, 2011, 04:11:44 PM
Let's take another couple of instruments and compare to melodeon making:


There are many "makers" of the Original Fender Telecaster guitars.

Let's take one who orders bodies and necks from one of the many suppliers.
All the controls and knobs  , tuners and pickups are ordered. The maker farms out the finishing.
He asembles the instrument and puts his name on it.

The next "maker"  makes the body from patterns supplied by others, orders a neck and fits pieces as above
but shoots his own finish.

The next" maker"  makes the body from a pattern, makes the neck, orders all the parts and finishes the instrument.

The next guy departs slightly from the original pattern, makes his own neck, fits bits by others and does his own finishing.

Who is a "maker" ?



BANJOS...

Shell, resonator, neck all supplied by others.  All the parts supplied by others. Finishing by others.
Assembled in house.

Above but the "maker" finishes his own product.

Above but he makes the neck.

Above but he makes the shell, the neck, all the wood bits... does his own finishing...


Who is the "maker".




Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Lester on August 24, 2011, 04:15:45 PM
Let's take another couple of instruments and compare to melodeon making:


There are many "makers" of the Original Fender Telecaster guitars.

Let's take one who orders bodies and necks from one of the many suppliers.
All the controls and knobs  , tuners and pickups are ordered. The maker farms out the finishing.
He assembles the instrument and puts his name on it.

The next "maker"  makes the body from patterns supplied by others, orders a neck and fits pieces as above
but shoots his own finish.

<snip>

Who is the "maker".

They are all makers to a greater or lesser extent. What I would do is play the guitar and if  I liked it and I liked the price I would buy it otherwise I wouldn't - simples.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Graham Spencer on August 24, 2011, 04:22:07 PM

BANJOS...

Who cares...? ;D >:E

(Just joking - honest!)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Theo on August 24, 2011, 04:32:50 PM
I'm amazed at how much interest this discussion has generated.  It is really nothing new. In the 19th century Wheatstone concertinas were made by many craftsmen many if whom were outworkers or subcontractors.  Nobody seems to have been worried by this as it's probably been the norm on manufacturing of all sorts from the early industrial revolution. The only thing that isxduffetent today is that cheap transport means that the subcontractors may be on the other side if the planet, instead of being a few streets away.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 04:36:27 PM
Hmm. Interesting. How far back should one go to make something? First plant the seed for the tree ? Dig out the ore for to smelt to steel for the reeds ? Process the pulp to cardboard for the bellows ?


Chas, this has been previously discussed.  If you read my first post, I refer to 'norms' that are established in practice. If someone went to the lengths you describe, they would simply be exceeding the expectations that normal practice has established.  

I've encountered the same issue in woodworking (with hand tools). I have a small table in my workshop that is nearing completion.  I started with 'rough' boards from a sawmill.  I dimensioned and flattened the boards with handsaws and various bench planes.  I used various joinery saws, specialized joinery planes, and chisels to make all the joints -- mortise & tenon joints, 'half-blind' dovetails (for the drawer front), dovetails (drawer back), grooves (for the drawer bottom). When the table is finished, I can say that I made it without power tools.  I know that powered saws were used to take down the tree and to saw the rough boards at the sawmill.  Since it is not within the norm of furniture-making to fell a tree and process rough boards, I think it is fair for me to say that I made the table "with hand tools."  I do think that it would be ridiculous if someone was to assemble a table of the same design from parts that they received from a kit supplier and then claim that there was no difference.

I thoroughly enjoyed my time assembling some and MAKING MOST of the parts on the two courses I was on with Emmanuel. All I can say is, "If you haven't tried it don't knock it"

The process that occurred at those workshops most resembles a small workshop where the course participants are workers, making accordions under the supervision and guidance of a master (Pariselle).  There is nothing wrong with that of course! (I would love to take one of these courses!)  

As to Chris's mention of Gaillard's 'external' tuning/reedwork -- this compares to having someone IN his shop doing the work, as far as my description in the original post; it is simply a different economic arrangement, which is certainly NOT comparable to branded instruments etc.  For this reason, Gaillard's system of production falls into the most favourable category that I described above, regardless of whether the tuning is in-house.  The production style  that falls below the norm (for single-maker shops) is where pre-made (and generic) chassis, reedblocks, and keyboards are assembled in a shop; in which case, 'assembled and finished' is a more appropriate label.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 04:59:36 PM
I'm amazed at how much interest this discussion has generated.  It is really nothing new. In the 19th century Wheatstone concertinas were made by many craftsmen many if whom were outworkers or subcontractors.  Nobody seems to have been worried by this as it's probably been the norm on manufacturing of all sorts from the early industrial revolution. The only thing that isxduffetent today is that cheap transport means that the subcontractors may be on the other side if the planet, instead of being a few streets away.

There are finer distinctions being made here; and no representation of novelty was made.

The scenario with Wheatstone, as you described it, would receive high marks from me.  If Wheatstones were instead constructed with major components being fungible parts (such as reedpans, the bodies, and the fretwork 'ends'), that would resemble the kind of shops that fall 'below the norm' in the rubrics that I described. 

At any rate, Wheatstone simply would not be in the 'single-maker' or 'small shop' categories; more like a large (albeit spread out) workshop or small factory -- something comparable to Castagnari but spread out into piecemeal home workshops rather than being made in a single building.  And that itself could be something to strive for.

For the record, I'm not "worried" by the manners of production described -- what I find problematic (but certainly not "worrisome') is the lack of awareness.  But God help us if we yearn for 19th c. standards of public awareness of production processes, yikes!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 05:06:23 PM
Bee's, Bonnet's and One particular personnel crusade as far as I can tell, someone's enjoying the attention though  ;) it got boring when it was on the last post ZZZZZZZZZ

{above post flagged for moderators}.

If people don't want to read a thread, they need not read it, and if they don't want to participate, they are free to read without posting (for any number of reasons).
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 24, 2011, 05:11:20 PM
It really is a crazy thread, getting a little bit circular, but, you do have to love the folks (any folks) who do something you can't do, and do it well.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 24, 2011, 05:29:05 PM
I'd personally give the little comment above  a "1" out of 10 on the internet personal attack scale, and that purely on its "attention" gambit, speculative at best.

Up to the Mods. To be fair I've always mused as to why honourable members bother to make posts in the "this is to hard/boring/exotic for this forum/a wet Wednesday/my small brain" genre. When others are making argued, or even researched points  ???
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 05:43:05 PM
To be fair I've always mused as to why honourable members bother to make posts in the "this is to hard/boring/exotic for this forum/a wet Wednesday/my small brain" genre. When others are making argued, or even researched points  ???

.. well they must get something from it  ;)

Right, Chris, I recall something like this happening to a theoretical thread on which you provided some very useful information. (And thanks for putting it on your website.)

Unlike our moderator, I'm not actually surprised at the interest in this topic.  If one looks in the archives (including the old forum), there is quite a bit of "fetishism" regarding the circumstances under which melodeons are made; lots of borderline worship of the builders (as well as awe for semi-mysterious/magical ways of the "tuner"); lots of loyalty to a particular maker or brand (I'm most interested in the Oakwood fixation -- I've always wanted to play one after reading so many glowing reports -- they sound wonderful -- but a recent post -- was it Ian Dedic? -- mentioned several that sounded like they had some serious design flaws?); and so on.  I've been part of it as well, with pleasure!

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: blafleur on August 24, 2011, 06:11:53 PM
 I do think that it would be ridiculous if someone was to assemble a table of the same design from parts that they received from a kit supplier and then claim that there was no difference.


But also to be considered by the end user, if it is not the "maker", is to what quality was that "maker's" work.  It cannot be assumed that because a particular crafts person made everything himself, that both he and his customer wouldn't have been better served if some items had been purchased from a better source, at least until he gets better at it. 

You may build an awesome table from hand tools, but some others might make a wobbly gap jointed mess without power tools.  I do agree that the more craftsmanship a person exhibits with his own hands, the more impressed I am, but for someone buying a product, the end result is usually the most important thing ( but i do concede not always).  So if a person puts together an accordion with products he made himself to a fair standard (the best he can with his skills) and made a fair accordion, and the guy across town made few if any components, but bought most from quality sources and ended up with a great accordion because of his skill in putting together those components, which accordion would the average player want?   

Like you, Andy, I enjoy making things with my own hands, out of pure personal satisfaction, and I only hope that what I do is worth being appreciated by at least some, and if not now, hopefully in time.  But I also know that many will never care what parts I made with my own hands, I just know that I will. ;)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 07:22:20 PM
You may build an awesome table from hand tools, but some others might make a wobbly gap jointed mess without power tools.  I do agree that the more craftsmanship a person exhibits with his own hands, the more impressed I am, but for someone buying a product, the end result is usually the most important thing ( but i do concede not always).  So if a person puts together an accordion with products he made himself to a fair standard (the best he can with his skills) and made a fair accordion, and the guy across town made few if any components, but bought most from quality sources and ended up with a great accordion because of his skill in putting together those components, which accordion would the average player want?   

I understand your point, Bryan, and I agree -- there are plenty of examples where a single-maker shop puts out instruments that are sub-par in quality, both in terms of playability and aesthetics.  That's really another topic altogether --- and I believe it is touched upon by the post above, which referred to "hobbiests."
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 07:28:07 PM
I guess its not the subject matter, more the domineering viewpoint and the manner of expression and dismissal of others views that erks, still each to their own and I guess that includes me. mory (brain the size of a planet) ;D still not making assumptions

Anything to contribute to the topic, Mory? Or just insults? You might not find it interesting, but the thread has been viewed nearly a thousand times within a brief period of time, and there have been many participants. You could easily have written an off-list message rather than derailing the thread, since what you had to say had nothing to do with the topic that the rest of us are discussing.

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 24, 2011, 08:34:57 PM
since you ask Andy I do. there is no such thing as a hand made box. the lineage of production surely includes the tools one may class as hand tools etc and without over simplifying (first cut down a tree etc) all processes suggest an element of cooperation from other humans, we didn't make all the elements of human achievement by individual endever but by consensus, some times to our good and sometimes to our detriment, we have consensus in box making and it precedes this debate in the form of all the box's here before this debate, the production and methods employed being a conglomeration of those elements discussed that have become a set of rules to construct "a Box", now they can vary but the rules exist because that's how our boxes are made, what this thread is witnessing is an attempt to draw those rules under a new banner, but who is defining these new rules, it doesn't feel consensual, as many posts by others seem to be dismissed, so who is the rule maker and who is defining those rules, I agree with various aspects you bring up but that doesn't make them any more "right" than it makes others "wrong" just take a read back over the whole thing back to the Loffett post etc lots of hard words and if it were possible you could almost feel the anger in some of your responses were not all in agreement and that's good but rules are arrived at in a developing thing like this gradually, gently, as a process of time and event, so as I've said before Andy peace brother peace. mory


sorry for the delay I timed out lost the lot and had to start again
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 24, 2011, 08:55:37 PM
I was of course generalising and the ""too much for my brain" is a simple and AFAIR straight quote from a "non contributary" contribution to a discussion about a year ago. As I say I remain mystified why people post such things and see no reason why anyone in this thread should take anything personally

Someone felt attacked, I really thought the comment not worth an emotion. Please see my posts in other threads. If I've got nothing to say - I try to keep my council (barring the occasional bad joke) Chris
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 24, 2011, 09:32:38 PM
your alright Chris no worries (:)

removed "offending" posts out of deference to Andy's feelings.          mory
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 24, 2011, 09:47:17 PM
with so many eminently playable and beautiful sounding box's out there a few tunes would surely suffice. I wonder when the question first raged or were players just happy to be playing, is it just a "more, more" thing? are we really just talking about elitism here, mines better than yours, I have my suspicion's  (:)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 24, 2011, 10:29:35 PM
since you ask ... I do. there is no such thing as a hand made box. the lineage of production surely includes the tools one may class as hand tools etc and without over simplifying (first cut down a tree etc) all processes suggest an element of cooperation from other humans, we didn't make all the elements of human achievement by individual endever but by consensus, some times to our good and sometimes to our detriment, we have consensus in box making and it precedes this debate in the form of all the box's here before this debate, the production and methods employed being a conglomeration of those elements discussed that have become a set of rules to construct "a Box", now they can vary but the rules exist because that's how our boxes are made, what this thread is witnessing is an attempt to draw those rules under a new banner, but who is defining these new rules, it doesn't feel consensual, as many posts by others seem to be dismissed, so who is the rule maker and who is defining those rules, I agree with various aspects you bring up but that doesn't make them any more "right" than it makes others "wrong" just take a read back over the whole thing back to the Loffett post etc lots of hard words and if it were possible you could almost feel the anger in some of your responses were not all in agreement and that's good but rules are arrived at in a developing thing like this gradually, gently, as a process of time and event, so as I've said before ... peace brother peace. mory

Again, this is a manner of personal attack. You condemn me for expressing disagreement.  I looked back over the Loffet thread and stand by my comments there.  Because the Loffet thread, early on, took a direction away from Loffet, and yet some posters continued to post regarding Loffet, I created this thread because I thought it was appropriate (and should have been done sooner, to avoid misunderstanding).  In the new thread, I attempted to delineate a line of inquiry on a topic that interests me (as it interests at least some other posters here as well). In keeping the dialogue going, I have responded to specific points in many posts; the only time I "dismissed" a statement was my response to Chris's citation of Pignol -- it is a point of fact that there makers out there who do make their own bellows, including Maugein in France and at least three builders in Quebec. I also cautioned that a several topics were off-course -- such as the violin-building topic -- although they are certainly interesting and could be a great (and separate) thread. In doing so, I was accused by a single poster of seeking attention and "boring" him; meanwhile, the thread that I started attracted around 1000 views.

At least your last post addresses the topic.  You seem to be expressing your own "rule" that there be consensus; if I follow your argument (and I apologize -- I don't intend this as a criticism, but it is difficult for me to follow your argument because of the lack of punctuation), you believe that one should not hope for an accordion built by one set of hands, let alone a "handmade" accordion.  To that, I can only say that I'm trying to articulate a different idea than what you are opposing -- I never proposed a single set of hands, nor implied that a melodeon should be built by hand tools only, nor have I stated that a melodeon should be built without cooperation.  However, calling all "multiple-hands work" cooperation fails to distinguish Gaillard (who employs a tuner for reedwork) from Saltarelle.

There has been no privileging of the "single-builder (or small) shop" over the small factory, simply a distinction made between the two; I made observations about single-maker shops because I believe that many melodeon players place special value on the artisans, yet there are different levels of work being done by the shops. (And since you brought it up: I believe that Bruno Priez has actually built melodeons completely by hand with the exception of reeds and some recycled parts.) It also seems like you think that I made "rules" for melodeon builders, when my posts above refer to norms that the practices of melodeon builders themselves have established -- the only "rules" that I'm proposing are ways for us to distinguish where the practices lie in relation to the norm.

Again, I think that these are great topics: 1. Can a melodeon be made completely by hand(tools)? 2. What are the differences between single-builder shops and factory-made instruments? and 3. how are these differences important to different players/mel.net participants?
And to Chris: this "I know what I like" is exactly what I would like to get to, ultimately, and first I felt it necessary to make this foray into distinctions in production processes/relationships/methods.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 24, 2011, 10:38:15 PM
Personally I think that at heart of this discussion is the nature of value and commodity production in capitalist society. Then again, I would :D

There is no natural process that says a particular melodeon is worth £1,000. This is a value that humans assign to an inanimate object because it has become that magical and mysterious thing, a commodity.

In reality a Melodeon is an accretion of a web of social interactions and relationships that are mostly hidden from us. It's commodity value is arrived at by a set of social forces and interactions that are mostly hidden from us.

There may be a dire need for shoes in a certain area. The social value of and need for shoes may be immense, but if the commodity value is not right, then the objects will not be manufactured. The real human, social interrelationships are obscured by layers of custom, attitudes and primitive adherence to precepts of private property and the belief in such things as the knowing nature of "the market". Have you ever noticed the BBC news reports where after some event the presenter will ask a reporter, "what do the markets think?". The "markets" themselves think nothing in reality but we have reduced layers of human relationships into a process of commodity trading.
 
I would say the true social value can only be brought out from an understanding of the social relationships (and social solidarity) that makes a melodeon possible and nessesary ... but that's not how Capitalism works. Capitalism obscures the human process and makes a fetish of the commodity and the supposedly natural market forces and property relationships that determine commodity value. So, in our Capitalist system, this discussion is never ending and always unsatisfactory.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: jb on August 24, 2011, 11:52:53 PM
Wow. So much to disagree with in that old marxist hocus-pocus. It's hard to know where to start.
( btw ... "shoes"?)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 25, 2011, 12:00:23 AM
Wow. So much to disagree with in that old marxist hocus-pocus. It's hard to know where to start.
( btw ... "shoes"?)

150 years and still haunting you eh   ;)

Um, shoes. I presume you've seen shoes or are you claiming that as a Marxist invention?   :P
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 25, 2011, 01:06:08 AM
Will some one just tell us what we think !
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 25, 2011, 01:27:38 AM
Not to get back to close to Andy's original post, but I find myself more naive than usual about who makes what and how.

My own bias is that tuning is a red herring, does not matter who does it as long as they do it to your specification (free reeds being the unusual musical instrument that comes to you "already tuned")

But everything else, well, I guess I really don't know who does what and how.

Always assumed that most "manufacturers" bought springs and pallets and buttons and reeds and straps, a lot of other parts, from companies that specialized in the manufacture of those parts.

Then the manufacturer/builder built there own frames and reedblocks and keyboards and soundboards and grills, etc. pretty much from free stock and put them all together in their own methods of screwing and gluing.

Pretty much what the recent photo show from Lester's Blog looked like.

But, apparently, this is the exception, not the rule.

Since it's apparent from the posts that many members have pretty detailed knowledge of who does what, could you give me/us some outline:  who's doing it all (growing the trees! no one probably) but who comes close, who has the middle ground, who is "badge engineering" "renaming" someone else's work, etc.

Especially interested in the facts/opinions regarding Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Bafetti, Beltuna, a lot of the Italian makers I get all confused about (Serenellini, Serenelli?)

Also, Van der AA and the Dino Oakwood Binci (who exactly makes it and why is it so expensive?)

Not looking for snark or dirt, just some honest opinion and insight.

Thanks, Steve
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: mory on August 25, 2011, 01:32:54 AM
I think something is leading you to misinterpret me Andy because we are in agreement , the rules are there yes, its the placement of criteria around the habits of existing practices to define a makers right to bear his own name as the "maker" I am not so sure about  and by that I mean who is defining those criteria and it seems to be you, thats not deflamatory, it just is, maybe a detailed run down on an imaginary box outlining all the aspects you think put a box into one catagory or another would help, it might help the French next year to, I spent about an hour putting together a humourus piece but then felt it might still offend so I scrapped it, the rules you say I seem to be putting on are there, not mine, the consensus being the builders and buyers and associated events over time, not some thing I am demanding, what I am saying to you as kindly as I can is that you seem to be over riding that existing consensus with a set of criteria of your own, defining that, in a way that is actualy quite an insult to the work they do that brings us such joy. I am at peace with myself Andy and with you also, I do feel you've been taking us all on a roundabout of a journey so Good night from me I'll catch you tommorrow. mory
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 01:41:43 AM
Personally I think that at heart of this discussion is the nature of value and commodity production in capitalist society. Then again, I would :D

Andrew, I'm with you on the general theory and would make some finer distinctions.  There's very little capitalism involved in the production of melodeons in single-maker and small shops, and even most of the small factories are not, strictly speaking, "capitalist" endeavors. If you're talking about Hohner, then capitalism would be more appropriate; but Gaillard, at least in his melodeon-making endeavor, is not a capitalist. (For those who aren't Marx-heads, making/selling something is not the same as acting as a capitalist.)

I think that your general statement -- that the production is hidden from view -- is right on point here. What do you think about this: Is the problem that there are some individuals engaged in the act of making something in a manner that defies the dominant ways in which production occurs today? And there are pressures that result in some seeking solutions that edge production toward the anonymous/hidden/fungible/etc.?

I've often been amazed at the economics of the small-scale builders like Gaillard --- they do seem to running on more motivational fuel than "money begetting money," don't they?

To GCFMan/Steve: thanks for continuing to post on-point.  Great questions.  Diatosoldo posted a link in the recent Loffet thread -- a French site that attempted to do what you are asking for.  It's tricky -- I already noticed that some of the info on the site is not necessarily accurate, but it is interesting to read it, because it is obvious that they ruffled some feathers as well.  If this kind of info gets posted, I hope that people try to stick with facts that they observed, and if they are referring to a source, citing it so that others can check it out.  Information gets quoted without reference and becomes a further voice that looks like proof in the future.  As an example: the late Jim Coogan used to sell Maugein in the U.S., and stated that the reeds were Binci; Maugein's materials show photos of their own reed production; and that French site mentioned above says that Maugeins contain another brand of reeds.  It could be that all of this info is correct, just not detailed enough (like: perhaps at one time or another, each source was used); or it could all be false.  

(The info on the Oakwood/Baffetti Binci seemed very up-front (to me) and was detailed in another thread.)
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Christopher K. on August 25, 2011, 03:30:18 AM
The issue in this discussion that is interesting to me is a question of prestige and the problems that arise when broad or uninformed language attributes prestige when none is due.

The awareness that Andy is talking about is important because there is a legitimate measure of pride and prestige associated with the products of craftsmen who complete their work independent of outside contractors. The word "maker" implies the prestige associated with a single-shop, single-origin, handmade instrument of which there are several notable examples available today (I think the grow-your-own-trees counter argument is a hyperbole). Below this, there are several other classes of operation in decreasing levels of self sufficiency, as Andy described.

A problem arises when players and dealers casually use the same language to denote different types of operations without knowing what actually transpires within the shop. The market is very competitive and broad language is especially unfair to operations that do a maximum, if not all of the required work, under their own roofs. Some companies illegitimately benefit from this attribution of prestige via broad language, and I believe some quietly tie themselves to the length of a word that implies they do work which they might not do. On the other hand, including such details on a website might just be an honest oversight, and not always the willful omission of the truth. It might be more of a problem that there isn't an English word (that I can think of) which is specific enough to describe the other classes.

I am skeptical when companies are not forthcoming with the details of what and how they manufacture their products, because I know that prestige is built into the price that I pay. This isn't exclusive to accordions - it's true with practically everything. I'll name coffee and tea as my pet peeve examples of products for which it is difficult if not impossible to get a straight answer from producers about sources, growers, etc.

Just how important it is to know what transpires at the plant, or how much this matters to a consumer of a product that performs in an exemplary manner, is a matter of opinion that is almost irrelevant to the discussion. I think these issues are independent of the consumer's right to know what transpires at the plant, and the craftsman's right to be distinguished as such in a diverse market. I'd love for Congress to require Saltarelle to disclose its sources, I'd love for the Cajun "garage" builders to be turned out to the public, and I'd love for real craftsmen and luthiers in the United States and abroad to be given the respect they deserve by reaping dollars from the market that are proportionate to the prestige built into their instruments.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: melodeon on August 25, 2011, 04:56:29 AM
Excellent post. !!!  and to the heart of the matter.

Some "makers" are coat-tailing and charging for what really is not there... as an example.. Saltarelle.
Read their website then look at one of their accordeons then add to that the knowledge that the instruments are
made in Italy .. implication is that you are getting an instrument from France that is hand crafted to the highest standard...
Here on Melnet... many die hard Saltarelle owners/players will concede they are not the value of a Castaganri when it comes to
design, material and workmanship. Simply do not live up to the "image" created by marketing hype; and of course, not made in France by Saltarelle.

It is a shame that some true hand builders cannot get the same amount of money for their boxes as some of the big boys, not being able to compete with slick web sites and clever ad copy.

Another example of a product not matching the hype would be the USA marketed Gabbanellis.

I appreciate Hohner for their honesty and solid value boxes as much as I do Castagnari. Both a good value and no BS.

I have another observation.... just as high end mandolins became coveted by the new age yuppie, so did melodeons... perhaps not so much , but I see it as a profiling accessory to some.  Some marketeers know this so cater to it. Not unlike the new wee puntable dogs.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 25, 2011, 07:29:18 AM
Quote
  It is a shame that some true hand builders cannot get the same amount of money for their boxes as some of the big boys, not being able to compete with slick web sites and clever ad copy.

Hmmm. The Gaillard and van der Aa websites are actually quite slick. A function of their expensive product, perhaps. Maybe, but that product contains many man hours and I'm not convinced that a maker with larger output of boxes that don't have the perfection factor isn't on a level field of play.

In the end I feel the melodeon market is quite like that for cars. We have our old bangers, our utilitarian models, our top end ones in which there is nothing that'll annoy, but at a significant premium for the labour involved.

I'm not all that hung up on HOW it's made. I think innovation is good. If a particular item can be sourced at the right quality an my maker can stand by that? I'm cool even if its the box. I actually don't see accordion as furniture or art and am far more interested in performance.

Now the car analogy breaks away. Cars depreciate whereas a top maker's melodeon will often appreciate!

So for me it starts with a price/quality/performance thing and reputation is actually a good metric of that.

But they are ALL makers. They optimise in their own ways and target different parts of the market.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 02:56:46 PM
I'm not all that hung up on HOW it's made. I think innovation is good. If a particular item can be sourced at the right quality an my maker can stand by that? I'm cool even if its the box. I actually don't see accordion as furniture or art and am far more interested in performance.

My personal experience is that they tend to line up, hand-in-hand. Gaillards and Castagnaris outperform every other melodeon that I've ever tried (I believe that I've handled and played over 200 melodeons but at some point I lost count -- in any case I have been able to make personal comparisons whenever I've had the chance).  Melodie and Messervier take a seat very close to the top.  I've never played an Oakwood but can imagine they are up in the top ranks.  My positive experience with other melodeons is often qualified to "bang for the buck" ratios.  (Thus, I love Saltarelle Irish Bouebes that I've tried -- I think they are a good value; I also like the Hohner XTreme 3 row boxes.)

Chris, you mentioned in your post above that you know what you like, and I assume you like your Gaillard and your Oakwood, so are you sure that the performance is really divorced from manner of production?

But they are ALL makers. They optimise in their own ways and target different parts of the market.

Are you saying that Saltarelle "makes" melodeons? As opposed to "has them made"?  I'm not arguing against you, I just wonder whether your statement is in direct opposition to the criticism of broad terminology in Chris K's post above?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 25, 2011, 05:17:11 PM
Making has to involve more than screwing your badge on? From what I hear Saltarelle may soon get kicked out of the St Chartier Brownies for this. Though interesting that you like their kit!

"What I like"? A quote from a different thread, same day, in the context of one-liners that say nothing.  :Ph
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 25, 2011, 05:24:16 PM
The word "maker" implies the prestige associated with a single-shop, single-origin, handmade instrument of which there are several notable examples available today (I think the grow-your-own-trees counter argument is a hyperbole). Below this, there are several other classes of operation in decreasing levels of self sufficiency, as Andy described.

A problem arises when players and dealers casually use the same language to denote different types of operations without knowing what actually transpires within the shop. The market is very competitive and broad language is especially unfair to operations that do a maximum, if not all of the required work, under their own roofs.
Sounds like you want a single-malt accordion. What you're implying is that a "hand-made" box (which was made in the one shop) is superior than one which wasn't, when this may not be the case at all.

To me, it's about quality control. If the maker is too busy to machine the wood, he gives the specifications to a carpenter (who is an artisan worker anyway). If the work produced isn't up to scratch, it's rejected.

Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Quote
I'd love for Congress to require Saltarelle to disclose its sources
Senator Sandwich can disclose this for you RIGHT NOW!  It's Baffetti.

I was there on a USA trade mission with Captain Benjamin Franklin "Hawkeye" Pierce recently.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 25, 2011, 05:30:24 PM
I know that many of you also follow other groups, and I always get a kick out of the alternative viewpoints one sees (though limited in scope to 3 rows) in reyesforum.

Gabanelli's rock!  Castagnari's overpriced fancy junk! Bass buttons, why even have them!

It's a good group though, lots of stuff for us GCF minorities.

Not to mention the t-shirts.  BTW, if you have a Hohner, you must get the skeleton shirt.  Now THAT rocks!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 25, 2011, 05:32:31 PM
Gabanelli's rock!
Are they good? There website is so crappy that I just presumed they weren't up to much.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 05:35:24 PM
Though interesting that you like [Saltarelle's] kit!

Yes, relative to the price -- so, like I said my praise is limited to the ratio of bang to buck!  I don't need to place that kind of qualification on my praise of Gaillard.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 05:42:36 PM
Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Can you explain what the affectation is? Because I'm pretty sure that the same would apply to playing a melodeon (at all) in "this day and age." Viva the unzeitgemaesse Betrachtungen!

As for "all reeded instrument makers," are you serious?  There are a handful of concertina makers who make their own reeds (Suttner, Carrol, Kensington, Dipper, and some others I don't recall off-hand), many harmonica makers who make their own reeds.  I'm not certain what is going on with Maugein but perhaps someone who has actually been in the factory can explain.  Does Hohner make its own reeds (in some factory in China)?
At any rate, I think that we have determined that MOST single-builder and small melodeon shops buy their reeds from one or more of several sources.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 25, 2011, 05:45:35 PM
Though interesting that you like [Saltarelle's] kit!

Yes, relative to the price -- so, like I said my praise is limited to the ratio of bang to buck!  I don't need to place that kind of qualification on my praise of Gaillard.

The bias in favour of Gaillard makes the whole discussion sort of lop-sided.

'm sure they are great boxes, but are they any better than Martin Connolly's Kincora which are handmade?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 25, 2011, 06:04:22 PM
Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Can you explain what the affectation is? Because I'm pretty sure that the same would apply to playing a melodeon (at all) in "this day and age." Viva the unzeitgemaesse Betrachtungen!

As for "all reeded instrument makers," are you serious?  There are a handful of concertina makers who make their own reeds (Suttner, Carrol, Kensington, Dipper, and some others I don't recall off-hand), many harmonica makers who make their own reeds.  I'm not certain what is going on with Maugein but perhaps someone who has actually been in the factory can explain.  Does Hohner make its own reeds (in some factory in China)?
At any rate, I think that we have determined that MOST single-builder and small melodeon shops buy their reeds from one or more of several sources.

I was talking about orchestral reeded-instruments, i.e. 12 note music.
It's all very well to traipse the earth in search of the purist form of the accordion, but as accordion players, we must accept that we can never be in the same bracket as maestros of the violin, for example.

By "affectation", I meant misguided purists who refuse to use any components not made in their own shed. And that kind of leads onto the "cut down your own tree" point...which is why the prestige bestowed on 100% handmade makers may, in some cases, be misguided.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Fidjit on August 25, 2011, 06:07:28 PM
Excellent post. !!!  and to the heart of the matter.

Some "makers" are coat-tailing and charging for what really is not there... as an example.. Saltarelle.
Read their website then look at one of their accordeons then add to that the knowledge that the instruments are
made in Italy .. implication is that you are getting an instrument from France that is hand crafted to the highest standard...
Here on Melnet... many die hard Saltarelle owners/players will concede they are not the value of a Castaganri when it comes to
design, material and workmanship. Simply do not live up to the "image" created by marketing hype; and of course, not made in France by Saltarelle.



It's a matter of taste. What do you prefer ? Of all the makers. So many are very good.
I would like one of each please.  Still learning about all the differences.
Personally not keen on Castaganari sound. Although a box they stopped doing I would love to have. If Steve is ever willing to sell his. So I compromise with my Conamara II

I went to meet George R. The inventor of Saltarelle boxes. The originals he did then he leased it out to Italians. A business thingy for him.

Cheers  :|glug
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 06:19:45 PM
I was talking about orchestral reeded-instruments, i.e. 12 note music.
In which case, your original statement was incorrect?


By "affectation", I meant misguided purists who refuse to use any components not made in their own shed. And that kind of leads onto the "cut down your own tree" point...which is why the prestige bestowed on 100% handmade makers may, in some cases, be misguided.

Could you be more specific?  Why are such purists misguided? (And where are they -- I don't know of any unless you included the Bruno Priez example -- so if you mean Priez, how is he "misguided")  Why is the prestige (attributed by Christopher K above) "misguided," in your view?
Or are you suggesting that there are no differences? Please elaborate.

As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?  They appear to be made in small numbers in a shop that makes all the wooden components.  Gaillard is simply used as an example above, which along with Castagnari has trumped the performance of all other boxes that I've tried. I'd be happy to learn if there are others in that category; I have also never tried a Briggs.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: oggiesnr on August 25, 2011, 06:50:25 PM

As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?  They appear to be made in small numbers in a shop that makes all the wooden components.  Gaillard is simply used as an example above, which along with Castagnari has trumped the performance of all other boxes that I've tried. I'd be happy to learn if there are others in that category; I have also never tried a Briggs.

This is where it gets tricky.  Not tried a Gaillard, tried lots of Castagnaris and I wouldn't want one if they were half the price, they hold no magic for me and so I cannot see why, as a semi mass produced (not "artisan" box) they command the premium.

Steve
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 25, 2011, 07:26:37 PM
Who said "single malt" box?  Very good analogy, and better than my cars.  Yes, BG is just a convenient paradigm. I'm sure there are others.

Happens I've got one and was willing to spend my compo money from a bike accident and wait 3  years for it.I picked BG from among 20 or makers at st chartier.

Only van der Aa came close for something you hold and play, and want to own. I'm off to see Frans on Saturday.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: sandwich on August 25, 2011, 07:54:06 PM
In which case, your original statement was incorrect?
Yep, my mistake

Could you be more specific?  Why are such purists misguided? (And where are they -- I don't know of any unless you included the Bruno Priez example -- so if you mean Priez, how is he "misguided")  Why is the prestige (attributed by Christopher K above) "misguided," in your view?
Or are you suggesting that there are no differences? Please elaborate.
Potentially misguided. I think it's a reasonable assumption that a percentage of a handmade box isn't made by the maker.
As for the differences...I wouldn't really know. Maybe it can't really be known, because - and I think this is what Christopher K was getting at - there are no industry standards.

I don't mean to come across as bashing the purists, I had a look at the cajun maker's website and I think what that man is doing is commendable. Also, was a bit of a learning experience because I thought cajun music was "dukes of hazard" territory.

As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?
I was very impressed with the one I played. A great thing about these one-man-bands, is the personal touch. You know who you're dealing with. There's a lot to be said for that.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 25, 2011, 09:04:53 PM
A great thing about these one-man-bands, is the personal touch. You know who you're dealing with. There's a lot to be said for that.

I agree -- it's one of the reasons why I'm advocating a greater degree of transparency.  "Knowing who you're dealing with" is a good policy for buying meat, malt and melodeons. 
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Steve C. on August 25, 2011, 09:56:24 PM
Off topic:

Chris--are the small Van de AA's as small as they look?
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: melodeon on August 25, 2011, 11:51:20 PM
George Roux  the "inventor" of Saltarelle accordeons ?

George Rolux   .. the marketing director at Saltarelle

From my understanding..Originally started by 3 people, then just George...

I believe that Serenellini had much to do with the original Saltarelle models and still makes them under their own brand.  Mine was superior to the Saltarelle of the same model.

Geoge "invented" the outsourcing ,rebranding ,multi tiered marketing structure and underlying mystique of an otherwise modestly
produced instrument often needing extensive fiddling to perform.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 26, 2011, 02:20:48 PM
Off topic: Chris--are the small Van de AA's as small as they look?

Slightly smaller than  the oakwoods.9,10,11 rows. His big one is an 11,12,11.

Chris, on a related note (and connected to the topic of this thread) -- I just looked through the photo albums linked from Van der Aa's website.  As a woodworker, my immediate response is that (as far as I can see in photos) his workmanship is meticulous.  This is the first time that I've seen a single-builder shop making boxes that rival Castagnari for meticulous woodworking.  (Which is not to say that his boxes are furniture!)
It looks like he screws the reeds onto cork gaskets on the reedblocks -- very nice!  He also has some ingenious solutions to fitting four voices into a relatively small 3-row box; and his switches -- on treble and bass -- are hidden from view and yet in places where they could easily be reached mid-play.
There was one pic that revealed machinery in his shop -- looks like he uses CNC milling. 
Van der Aa's finishes look absolutely incredible.  In my experience, surface finishes, even when they are outstanding, often do not "photograph" well; however, his finishes appear flawless.  (I especially like the very dark charcoal-blue and the burgundy.
What a treat it will be to visit him and play his boxes!
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 26, 2011, 04:50:20 PM
Jeez, clever to pick up all that from website pics! Never been to his place and Sunday is just a little festival at Veldhoven. As I say above I'm a bottom liner,though his quote does say something about paint job, polish and revarnish!

Yes to all the above. Van der Aa's are "manifestly clever" and also a lovely thing to have in your hands. The switches are also just under ones thumb and much less ugly than castagnari's. Ed of this parish abandoned my present DG for a VDA and expressed no regrets last month when I PM'd him. I hope he might come in, as no one else seem to have one.

Glad at least one of my Luthers passes the Vermont test, whatever that is. Having tried the better Loffets in the summer, they are perhaps more bang per buck. I still call both makers in their own style. Just very different "missions"
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: LDbosca on August 26, 2011, 05:22:34 PM
As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos. 

They're not great (IMHO), I'd say a poor buy for the price. Like a Gaillard without the performance.
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 26, 2011, 06:40:11 PM
Glad at least one of my Luthers passes the Vermont test, whatever that is.

I obviously haven't expressed myself clearly: "your" luthiers (you play Gaillard and Oakwood, right?) both definitely pass the VT test for single-builder shop and small shop, respectively!

Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Owen Woods on September 02, 2011, 12:56:22 PM
This is the album in question, which will be of interest to anyone interested in melodeon mechanics: http://www.mijnalbum.nl/Album=CFE6DXII
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: Stiamh on September 02, 2011, 05:18:49 PM
As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.

They're not great (IMHO), I'd say a poor buy for the price. Like a Gaillard without the performance.

I'm really surprised to read this Luke. I've only had short goes on Kincoras but liked what I found. In fact just after I had received my 2-v Gaillard I got a chance to try a similarly configured Kincora side by side with it and I was chastened to discover that I liked the sound of the Kincora better. Damien Connolly only plays his dad's accordions, naturally enough I suppose, and I've heard him play at least 3 of them at very close quarters and also in concert (solo and in ensembles), and they all sound terrific. In particular the red MMM he was playing a couple of years ago had a very big, rich sound. 
Title: Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
Post by: LDbosca on September 02, 2011, 07:18:03 PM
As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.

They're not great (IMHO), I'd say a poor buy for the price. Like a Gaillard without the performance.

I'm really surprised to read this Luke. I've only had short goes on Kincoras but liked what I found. In fact just after I had received my 2-v Gaillard I got a chance to try a similarly configured Kincora side by side with it and I was chastened to discover that I liked the sound of the Kincora better. Damien Connolly only plays his dad's accordions, naturally enough I suppose, and I've heard him play at least 3 of them at very close quarters and also in concert (solo and in ensembles), and they all sound terrific. In particular the red MMM he was playing a couple of years ago had a very big, rich sound. 

Different strokes I suppose. I do know there's almost no one who plays them professionally, take that as you want to.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal