Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: hibbs3 on August 14, 2008, 03:50:25 AM

Title: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on August 14, 2008, 03:50:25 AM
Just did some researching and stumbled upon the paolo soprani version of a D/C# box. Seems these things were imported to boston in the 50's, to compete with the baldonis. These paolos were, like the baldonis and walters, 19 / 4 key setups. Just wondering if anyone has ever seen / played / maybe even owns one? i would love to hear more about it.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Quebecois on August 14, 2008, 02:56:05 PM
Question: wouldn't this rather be described as C#/D (to follow the B/C convention)?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on August 14, 2008, 03:18:27 PM
nope, it was actually setup as a D/C# (played outside row in) like derrane plays
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on August 22, 2008, 05:17:08 PM
These were imported by the O'Byrne-DeWitt company - generally I've only seen two versions. The 50's model with the all silvery grill (known as "pepperpot" for some reason) and the later 60's with celluid grill. Both 4 voice LMMM treble with 2 couplers to take out the low reed.

I've never tried one, but I've heard that they were very very nice. More compact than the standard paolo, but still with the 4 voice treble and same button size/spacing.

They just about NEVER appear for sale, and from the rumours of the accordion world, they are very very pricey when they do. Never seen one for sale myself...

//Lars
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 23, 2008, 04:57:01 AM
These were imported by the O'Byrne-DeWitt company - generally I've only seen two versions. The 50's model with the all silvery grill (known as "pepperpot" for some reason) and the later 60's with celluid grill. Both 4 voice LMMM treble with 2 couplers to take out the low reed.

Lars,

You haven't come across the grey 1940s model then? This is mine:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10100032-1.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10100032-1.jpg)

They were probably designed by Jerry O'Brien (Joe Derrane's teacher at O'Byrne de Witt's, for anybody reading this who doesn't know), and are tuned with two middle reeds on one coupler, adding bassoon and piccolo on the master - so LMMH like a 4-stop melodeon. This is the model (with his name on it) that Jerry is holding in the photo (with the young Joe Derrane) that was used for the CD cover, and you can tell from listening to his recordings that it is what he played on them himself.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/jerryobrienjoederrane2.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/jerryobrienjoederrane2.jpg)

It was advertised as the "Model 700, O'Byrne de Witt Professional De Luxe Model, 8 sets of reeds. New Low Price $199.50", whilst the "Model 800, Brand New Professional Model O'Byrne de Witt-Baldoni Chromatic Accordion" which I also have (below) was $249.00. That one came to me in its original case, with the owner's initials G.O'B on it (unfortunately not J.O'B!  ;)) and with a pile of Jerry O'Brien's music (the owner was no doubt a pupil), it's tuned LLMM (the same as most contemporary Baldoni, Bartolis) and is similar to the one Joe Derrane is holding in the same photo.

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Baldoni-OByrnedeWitt.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Baldoni-OByrnedeWitt.jpg)

There was also a 2-voice Paolo Soprani "Model 600, O'Byrne de Witt Professional Model, 4 sets of reeds. New Low Price $129.50".

Quote
I've never tried one, but I've heard that they were very very nice. More compact than the standard paolo, but still with the 4 voice treble and same button size/spacing.

I like mine a lot, and it's as you describe.

Quote
They just about NEVER appear for sale, and from the rumours of the accordion world, they are very very pricey when they do. Never seen one for sale myself...

I won't comment on prices, except to say they don't sell for as much as full-size Paolos, though they are rare and as far as we know there are only two of the 2-coupler grey ones in Ireland, mine (#156) and John Brosnan's, and the numbers of them are (if I remember rightly) only 6 apart. However there are a few more of the 2-voice ones around, including a black one that Jackie Daly used to play (which he'd added a third voice and more basses to).

edited photos
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on August 23, 2008, 04:42:35 PM
I believe that Lars and Hibbs are going to have a serious case of accordion envy ;D.

Chris
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 24, 2008, 12:15:42 AM
I believe that Lars and Hibbs are going to have a serious case of accordion envy ;D.
Chris,

Maybe I should post a picture of my early 1930s, 6-voice, single-row Baldoni, Bartoli as well?  ;)

Only, seeing that most people here have probably never seen, let alone experienced one of these incredible boxes in the flesh, I'll link instead to a clip of my friend Anders Trabjerg playing his mid-1930s, 8-voice, 1.3-row D/C# Baldoni, Bartoli (below) for set dancers: Clare Lancers Set. Figure 3 (http://ie.youtube.com/watch?v=KELhz077OOs)
 
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Anders1.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Anders1.jpg)    (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/baldoni13row2.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/baldoni13row2.jpg)

edited photos

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on August 24, 2008, 04:33:38 AM
Stephen, I know just what you mean - I just came back from Ireland this Thursday after a week staying with Anders and all his boxes;)

I'd love to see one of those D/C#-paolos in the flesh - I play a 6v single row baldoni myself and a 3v 50's paolo, so that would be great to try out the reverse rows for real. I have a D/C# baldoni for sale, never really got the hang of the reverse row system, but perhaps with a paolo it's easier than on the huge buttons of the baldoni.

Thanks for the pic. of the grey - I just remember me and Hibbs3 having a discussion about Jackie Dalys excact box off-list!

Hmm... I'll just go find that Jerry & Joe CD and have a listen myself!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 24, 2008, 05:53:17 AM
Hmm... I'll just go find that Jerry & Joe CD and have a listen myself!

The presentation may be naff, and the listing hard to find, but (like the Bobby Gardiner one) you can get these from Germany (off eBay): IRISH ACCORDEON - AKKORDEON DERRANE O'BRIEN 1 - CD NEU (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/IRISH-ACCORDEON-AKKORDEON-DERRANE-OBRIEN-1-CD-NEU_W0QQitemZ350089677443QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item350089677443&_trkparms=72%3A12%7C39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A12%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14) and IRISH ACCORDEON - AKKORDEON DERRANE O'BRIEN 2 - CD NEU (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/IRISH-ACCORDEON-AKKORDEON-DERRANE-OBRIEN-2-CD-NEU_W0QQitemZ350088931443QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item350088931443&_trkparms=72%3A12%7C39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A12%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14), as well as IRISH ACCORDEON - AKKORDEON J. DERRANE - CD NEUWARE (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/IRISH-ACCORDEON-AKKORDEON-J-DERRANE-CD-NEUWARE_W0QQitemZ350091024639QQcmdZViewItem?hash=item350091024639&_trkparms=72%3A12%7C39%3A1%7C66%3A2%7C65%3A12%7C240%3A1318&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on August 24, 2008, 10:35:01 AM
Oh, I've got it. Just have to pull it out and give it a good hard listen:)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 24, 2008, 12:57:06 PM
Oh, I've got it. Just have to pull it out and give it a good hard listen:)
Oh, I get you, I must do the same.  :(

I wonder if Anders ever gives lessons...

Anyway, it was raining hard yesterday, so I didn't bother going, but the sun is out now and it's time to go to Tullamore, for the Fleadh!  :)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on August 27, 2008, 10:56:49 PM
Stephen,

That grey D/C# you have:

Does the pallets open directly for both rows, or is there a lever-action for the row of pallets closest to the keyboard as on my mid 50's?

What does the basses play? I assume D/G - D/A, but other configurations have been seen.

Do you know what the reeds look like? I know some of the earliest greys had slightly smaller scale reeds (which supposedly produces a fuller, somewhat louder sound).

Sometime you just HAVE to show me around your collection... suddenly my 3 paolos and 2 baldonis seems like just a drop in the sea...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 29, 2008, 12:59:40 AM
That grey D/C# you have

One thing I didn't mention yet is that both mine and John Brosnan's have been converted to C#/D, and we both (quite independently) put the lowest and highest notes of the D row onto the C# one, so there's effectively an 11-button D row. Apart from a handful of "returned yanks" (Irish people who've come home from living in America) and Anders, there's just about nobody who (regularly) plays D/C# in Ireland.

It has the lever-action for the row of pallets closest to the keyboard as on your mid 50's one?

The basses do play D/G - D/A.

Quote
Do you know what the reeds look like? I know some of the earliest greys had slightly smaller scale reeds (which supposedly produces a fuller, somewhat louder sound).

It's the only Paolo I've got, so I've nothing to compare it with, but I suspect it was made around 1947.

Quote
Sometime you just HAVE to show me around your collection... suddenly my 3 paolos and 2 baldonis seems like just a drop in the sea...

That's more than I have in the way of "playing" accordions, but I have a pretty extensive one of early accordions and concertinas, including four Demian accordions and Wheatstone's first concertina. You'll be welcome, in fact Anders is threatening to come down for a few days sometime...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on August 30, 2008, 06:35:33 AM
What can you tell me about this particular "Baldoni" in D/C#, if anything? I've only got a few pictures...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on August 31, 2008, 05:04:40 PM
That grey D/C# you have

One thing I didn't mention yet is that both mine and John Brosnan's have been converted to C#/D, and we both (quite independently) put the lowest and highest notes of the D row onto the C# one, so there's effectively an 11-button D row. Apart from a handful of "returned yanks" (Irish people who've come home from living in America) and Anders, there's just about nobody who (regularly) plays D/C# in Ireland.

Well, Charlie Harris plays some D/C#, from what I've been told. He used to play a white/green 19/2 4v in his time with Shaskeen - as seen on one of their album covers. Now he plays 1½ row (8v) but still D/C# (that is, when he's not pulling his grey paolo).

Danny Mahoney just got himself an old Baldoni D/C#, and even though he's famous for his B/C, there may still be a chance he'll give it a go for real.

Well, I'm coming over for a couple of months after christmas, so I just might drop by for coffee and box-o-holic talk.;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 31, 2008, 11:32:49 PM
What can you tell me about this particular "Baldoni" in D/C#, if anything? I've only got a few pictures...
Ryan,

I'd need to see it in the flesh really, but I wonder if it isn't a later version of my red O'Byrne-de Witt Baldoni Bros  one (the couplers suggest a 1950s date), with most of the lettering missing?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on August 31, 2008, 11:48:09 PM
seems to fit..I often wondered about the lettering not being centered...but as I dont have the box at the moment, I can't tell you that there's any remenants of letters from anywhere else on the box. What I can tell you is it has a built-in pick up (at least 50 years old, nothing like todays pick-ups) and is it is louder than my 6 voice! The musette setting (She's a MMML) sounds like an identical twin to that "grey" paolo sound (mind now it still isn't a grey). Can you tell anything from these pics of the pick-up?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on August 31, 2008, 11:56:11 PM
Apart from a handful of "returned yanks" (Irish people who've come home from living in America) and Anders, there's just about nobody who (regularly) plays D/C# in Ireland.

Well, Charlie Harris plays some D/C#, from what I've been told. He used to play a white/green 19/2 4v in his time with Shaskeen - as seen on one of their album covers. Now he plays 1� row (8v) but still D/C# (that is, when he's not pulling his grey paolo).

Danny Mahoney just got himself an old Baldoni D/C#, and even though he's famous for his B/C, there may still be a chance he'll give it a go for real.

That's why I was careful to use the word "reguarly", but none of them (except sometimes maybe Anders) would take a D/C# out to a session instead of their C#/D or B/C.

In spite of what I've seen written elsewhere, D/C# has never been a system used in Ireland, it's very much an Irish-American thing.

Quote
Well, I'm coming over for a couple of months after christmas, so I just might drop by for coffee and box-o-holic talk.;)

 ;D Boxes are more dangerous than alcohol, and Baldonis are "the hard stuff"!  ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 01, 2008, 04:06:37 AM
I'm on the wrong side of the atlantic! It seems that all the boxes that were destined for this side are returning to the other side! I need to take a vacation..
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 01, 2008, 07:56:11 PM
I do know that Charlie Harris plays for setdancing on a regular basis on his baldonis.

Well, I guess I'm just another addict. Just back from Tønder Festival I'm "higher" than ever! Despite all the alcohol present, I preferred yanking the 6 voice over whiskey;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 02, 2008, 01:16:56 AM
I do know that Charlie Harris plays for setdancing on a regular basis on his baldonis.

Maybe he does, but I've never yet seen him play his D/C# outside his workshop. In my experience it's always a grey Paolo Soprani that he takes out to play, though he might take his ex-"Cuz" Teahan single-row Baldoni along for the odd tune too: http://travel.webshots.com/photo/2098258190077595374oMnIdB (http://travel.webshots.com/photo/2098258190077595374oMnIdB)

I'll ask him next time I see him.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 02, 2008, 03:10:11 AM
Can you tell anything from these pics ... ?

Not without my own to compare your pics to, but mine's back home and I'm in England for the last few days.  :(
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 04, 2008, 11:06:12 PM
There was also a 2-voice Paolo Soprani "Model 600, O'Byrne de Witt Professional Model, 4 sets of reeds. New Low Price $129.50".

And to my astonished delight, I was delivered of one of them this evening which unexpectedly walked in my front door - with a little assistance from a banjo dealer of my acquaintance. He said he was looking for a bellows pin for it (and if you'd believe that, you'd believe anything ::)), but needless to say he left with a good banjo instead...  :)

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/p10100062.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/p10100062.jpg)

The new arrival was found recently in the North Shore Boston area, and has probably been dwelling in a damp basement for a long time. It will need some careful nursing to return it to its former glory, but I have great hopes that it will make a full recovery.  ;D

edited photo
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 05, 2008, 01:03:39 AM
I guess it is true...the rich get richer,and it is indeed who you know  ;). But none the less, congrats on the new box, a beauty!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 05, 2008, 01:50:03 AM
Would john Lavelle fall under the D/C# category of players? Seems thats how hes playing, and all the pictures depict his fingers clearly set to the outside row...theres even a picture of him and 2 other chaps playing what look baldonis/walters...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2008, 02:20:48 AM
I guess it is true...the rich get richer,and it is indeed who you know  ;). But none the less, congrats on the new box, a beauty!

Thanks, it's a bit of a dream come true really, to get a grey (even if it is black!) Paolo Soprani that's about the same size as a Hohner, and it was totally unexpected tonight. But the condition of the internal woodwork seems worse than I first thought, though the exterior looks great. That's the effect of damp on the glue joins.  :(

Mind you, it's not too kind on my joints these days either...  ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2008, 02:24:18 AM
Would john Lavelle fall under the D/C# category of players?

Maybe, but I never heard of him before tonight.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 05, 2008, 03:55:00 AM
I guess none of any of these lovely boxes would even be considered for sale, would they ::) ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: TomB-R on September 05, 2008, 10:14:37 AM
Not a Paolo but some nice D/C# playing here
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hhpc8HHlmWk

and here

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0fCuK3k8Fk
(nice clear view of the fingering)
Both are Andre Bouchard, Joe Derrane influenced and inventor of the Bouchard "one-row+2/4" D/C# based box discussed on this forum.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 05, 2008, 10:14:55 PM
I guess none of any of these lovely boxes would even be considered for sale, would they ::) ;)

No.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 10, 2008, 11:04:53 PM
Stephen, do both your D/C# Paolos have wooden soundboards?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 02:32:50 AM
Stephen, do both your D/C# Paolos have wooden soundboards?

No, the 4-voice (which is maybe 1947) is plywood, the 2-voice (more like 1950ish) is aluminium.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 11, 2008, 03:11:12 AM
any idea on the date of this one?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 03:58:36 AM
any idea on the date of this one?

That looks nice!

Judging by the grille I'd say around 1953-4. It's the same design as the light-grey ones:
 
(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Grey_Paolo_front.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/Grey_Paolo_front.jpg)

edited photo
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 11, 2008, 04:30:56 AM
Thats the same box I compared it to when I first saw it, a D/D# like Joe Cooley was playing on the cover of the ``Cooley``album
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 11, 2008, 04:59:26 AM
Thats the same box I compared it to when I first saw it, a D/D# like Joe Cooley was playing on the cover of the ``Cooley``album

Which is the new one he was given when he went off to America in 1954, though that's not the box he's playing on the album, which was a later 3-voice red one!

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/cooley1969.jpg)

(And if anybody's got a D/D# one of those, that they don't have a use for, please let me know!)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 14, 2008, 06:11:30 AM
Stephen, any idea of O'Byrne DeWitt were the only people who imported these Paolos? or was there other shops around the states ordering them in as well?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 14, 2008, 02:08:16 PM
Well, as I already said of my own one:


(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P10100032-1.jpg)

They were probably designed by Jerry O'Brien (Joe Derrane's teacher at O'Byrne de Witt's, for anybody reading this who doesn't know), and are tuned with two middle reeds on one coupler, adding bassoon and piccolo on the master - so LMMH like a 4-stop melodeon. This is the model (with his name on it) that Jerry is holding in the photo with the young Joe Derrane that was used for the CD cover, and you can tell from listening to his recordings that it is what he played himself.

And Jerry O'Brien seems to have been very involved with O'Byrne de Witt's, but the black one I just bought doesn't have their name on it - so possibly some other shop sold them too, or perhaps it was made for them but without the O'Byrne de Witt name? Certainly it was found very much "on their turf" in North Shore Boston.

Thanks for letting me know the grey one you've found is tuned LMMM, which is what I suspected - and why I asked! I expect that in 1947 they still wanted an old "melodeon" sound, but by 1953-4 that'd changed to wanting a smoother and more "modern" accordion one.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 14, 2008, 03:09:06 PM
gotcha! Perhaps, and I'm willing to bet that someone else sold these boxes too. I know that O'Brien's box (like yours) sounded alot like a globe 4 stop almost when I heard it on those recordings with Derrane. But I asked Doug to keep it as close to it's original tuning as possible, which I'm sure is wet ;)  Lars sent me some Flanagan Bros. recordings the other day. Any idea what kind of box he might be playing? (Figured I'd ask seeing how you know everything ;D)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 15, 2008, 03:39:37 AM
I asked Doug to keep it as close to it's original tuning as possible, which I'm sure is wet ;)

That sounds like what I told Charlie Harris to do with my 6-voice Baldoni - "keep the flavour of it". 

Quote
Lars sent me some Flanagan Bros. recordings the other day. Any idea what kind of box he might be playing?

I don't think anybody actually knows what make it was, but somewhat similar instruments (masquerading as piano accordions) were being made by Guerrini in San Francisco. I've got one that I bought at a guitar show in LA about 10 years ago...

Quote
(Figured I'd ask seeing how you know everything ;D)

I'm glad to say that I don't, though I'm always trying to learn more. Hopefully I'll still be learning until the day they screw the lid on my final "box"!  ;D
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 15, 2008, 06:52:16 PM
how did your 6 voice turn out after? I only saw a picture of it when you had gotten it off ebay, in a MESSED state. You paid something like 26$ for it, if i remember right? Still not a bad deal in my opinion!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 15, 2008, 07:29:52 PM
Yeah, Stephen. It would indeed be lovely to see how it turned out. I've heard from a certain bearded boxplayer in Galway that it is absolutely fabulous! If it's any better than MY baldoni-bartoli 6v (and I've been told that it is) it's likely to be one heck of a machine!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 16, 2008, 12:40:17 AM
how did your 6 voice turn out after? I only saw a picture of it when you had gotten it off ebay, in a MESSED state.

Like this?

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Baldoni10keyedit.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Baldoni10keyedit.jpg)

BEFORE

Charlie reckoned it looked like it had been "dragged up 5th Avenue backwards!"   :(

Yeah, Stephen. It would indeed be lovely to see how it turned out.

Like this:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P1010005.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/P1010005.jpg)

AFTER

You paid something like 26$ for it, if i remember right? Still not a bad deal in my opinion!

That plus 600 euro to get it repaired, not forgetting Anders kindly finding some suitable replacement large mother of pearl buttons, but money very well spent.  ;D

But I still need to find a grille for it, or have one made.

I've heard from a certain bearded boxplayer in Galway that it is absolutely fabulous! If it's any better than MY baldoni-bartoli 6v (and I've been told that it is) it's likely to be one heck of a machine!

Does he like it that much? He usually complains about the new bellows being stiff...  ::)

But I think it may be LOUDER than his 8-voice!  :o

Here's a picture of me playing it at a session outside Gurteen, Co. Sligo a couple of years ago, it's an image that I stumbled acrioss on the internet:

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/mebaldonigurteen2006.jpg) (http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/mebaldonigurteen2006.jpg)

edited photos
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 16, 2008, 01:19:08 AM
Perhaps, and I'm willing to bet that someone else sold these boxes too.

I wouldn't be so sure, the evidence so far (including the one you're getting) is that these 19-key Paolo Soprani boxes all came out of Boston, which was O'Byrne de Witt's "turf".

Whilst the New York players mostly had instruments from Baldoni Bartoli, or Walters, which were decorated by the same guy in New York - which must be why the "Boston Baldonis" from O'Byrne de Witt were not similarly decorated.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 16, 2008, 01:39:33 AM
nice box!! Love to hear it! And I'd love to compare to my 1.5 row volume wise ;)

And I agree with your thoughts on the fact that Boston was O'B DW's turf.

Have you seen Coogan's old black (60's I'm assuming) Paolo D/C#? Whatever happened to that?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 16, 2008, 01:49:45 AM
or even more so, his old walters! (what a box!)

(he's furthest to the right standing up)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 16, 2008, 02:44:23 AM
Have you seen Coogan's old black (60's I'm assuming) Paolo D/C#?

I have, that picture's on Seán Quinn's site: http://homepage.ntlworld.com/sean_quinn/psoprani/psoprani6.htm (http://homepage.ntlworld.com/sean_quinn/psoprani/psoprani6.htm)

I'd say it's from the beginning of the 1960s, and the only one I've seen with the outside-row buttons larger, like the 1940s/'50s Baldonis.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 16, 2008, 02:48:23 AM
or even more so, his old walters! (what a box!)

I didn't see that one before though.

Unfortunately I only ever met Jim at the Messe (Music Trade Show) in Frankfurt a few times, when we'd both be going around the accordion makers, and we exchanged a few emails, but I never got to see any of his instruments.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 16, 2008, 02:55:24 PM
That picture comes from the Box Office website (Jim's old store, which is still in operation I believe.)

As I recall, I believe Anders has a similar box to Jim's old Walters, that he bought on ebay, along with his 8-voice from Luke O'Malley.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 16, 2008, 02:59:04 PM
Very interesting to hear about the Boston vs NY decoration on the boxes. Perhaps that could be part of the reason why the 4v baldoni I have for sale does not have any kind of decoration like my 6v, and most of the other baldonis/walters' (and the fact that it's one of the last Baldoni-Bartolis ever made).
http://www.flickr.com/photos/21478603@N06/2862037563/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/21478603@N06/2862038263/in/photostream/

I'm pretty sure I heard someone mention the history of Joe Coogan's old D/C# paolo somewhere... Didn't John Nolan have one just like it?

That Walters would be the white 19/4 one that Charlie Harris has now. A real tooter!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 16, 2008, 10:31:53 PM
Just finished talking with Doug from the button box, and we've been trying to determine the tuning to put on this grey he has (LMMM). Any idea what the relative tuning was on boxes like this? Lars and I had conversed about it before and said something like 15 cents, but I want to be sure before I tell him to go ahead. I'm looking for the classic Grey Paolo sound, nice, wet and loud! ;D
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 16, 2008, 11:14:02 PM
I was heavily considering the sound that Paddy O'brien's box has here :

http://www.juneberry78s.com/sounds/Paddy%20O%27%20Brien%20-%20Spike%20Island%20Lassies.mp3
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 17, 2008, 03:43:09 AM
(he's furthest to the right standing up)

Mind you, that's a very interesting photo, apart from Jim and his Walters: "Appearing from left to right: (front row) Denis Murphy and Jackie Riordan; (back row) Barney Monahan, Joe Mills, Gerry Campbell and Jim Coogan. This photo was from a newspaper article in 1963 regarding an affair held by the Erin Minstrel Society where the music was provided by the members of the Yonkers Ceili Club".

Joe Mills (of Aughrim Slopes Ceili Band fame, and seemingly the composer of "Cooley's Reel") rather sticks out in that company, with the one and only Paolo Soprani (probably in G/G#?), whilst Barney Monahan has what appears to be a very rare 23-key Baldoni, Bartoli.

Not forgetting the presence of the great fiddler Denis Murphy - I often used to meet his sister Julia Clifford in London, along with her husband, the accordionist John Clifford. Like plenty more of his generation, John had switched from single-row melodeon (on which he's said to have been very good) to PA, needing to play more chromatically in bands that had started to include Saxophones.  :o

 
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 17, 2008, 04:16:45 AM
Any idea what the relative tuning was on boxes like this? Lars and I had conversed about it before and said something like 15 cents

That tight?   ???

Quote
but I want to be sure before I tell him to go ahead. I'm looking for the classic Grey Paolo sound, nice, wet and loud! ;D

You can be sure that, whatever the tuning on Paddy O'Brien's box, it's "factory tuning", since it was brand new and there was nobody here tuning them back then (hence people tended to buy new accordions to make recordings, then "played them into the ground" before buying another new one!), in which case it could be more like 25 cents!   :o

But can't the Button Box tuner tell how it's tuned? (And if it was me, I'd want to play it before anything's done to it...)

FWIW, my own experience of the "light greys" is that they sound very sweet in a tighter tuning, but they don't have anything like the "cut" of the older dark-grey ones with the aluminium grilles, so if I was getting one done again now, I'd get it "wet".

I'll be taking my "new baby" to Charlie Harris in the next few days, if you like I'll ask him what he'd recommend...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 17, 2008, 10:51:53 AM
Yea that sounds great. See what Charlie says and get back to me, thanks!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Stiamh on September 17, 2008, 11:40:58 AM
I often used to meet his sister Julia Clifford in London, along with her husband, the accordionist John Clifford. Like plenty more of his generation, John had switched from single-row melodeon (on which he's said to have been very good) to PA, needing to play more chromatically in bands that had started to include Saxophones.  :o

Recently I got hold of a photocopy of an excellent 32-page booklet, written by Alan Ward, issued by Topic Records in the 1970s to accompany their series of LPs featuring the Cliffords, Denis Murphy and Padraig O'Keeffe.

According to Ward, John Clifford played a Hohner D/D# box (on the inner row, to the frustration of his frequent musical partner, Denis Murphy, who had to retune his fiddle to play with him). As you say, by all accounts he was a very fine player indeed.

"John worked most of his technique out for himself and was one of the first if not the first in the area to develop a 2-row style of playing with its greater flexibility and wider range of possible ornamentation. He probably sounded like the Dublin accordionist Michael Grogan whose records he much admired.... all those [Sliabh Luachra box players of John's generation] I have spoken to remember John with great admiration."

The story of his transition to PA came, as you say, in the London dance-band scene, but the details appalled me. In his own words, from the booklet:

"You know I went with them one night and I bought a new chromatic accordion on the never-never, you know, Francis Day and Hunter, 19 guineas - my God it was a fortune then you know - great big one, powerful. When I went out playing with them there was a piano accordion player, Julia on the fiddle, another chap drums, and piano. I was lost, different pitch. That's how I first started on the piano accordion, and that's why."

Presumably the great big chromatic accordion was a BCC#, which would explain why he wasn't lost on it until he tried to play with others. If only he had stuck with the D/D#... or had someone show him how to change over to BCC#. Tragic!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 17, 2008, 01:33:32 PM
Recently I got hold of a photocopy of an excellent 32-page booklet, written by Alan Ward, issued by Topic Records in the 1970s to accompany their series of LPs featuring the Cliffords, Denis Murphy and Padraig O'Keeffe.

Steve, and do you know something, I've actually got a copy of that booklet (in its other incarnation as Traditional Music No.5) sitting on my shelves, but I was speaking from memory of conversations across a bar table, from hazy Sunday lunchtime sessions 30, or maybe 35 years ago in the Irish Centre, Camden Town. I guess I should read it...  ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 17, 2008, 07:24:31 PM
The reason for me suggesting something like -15, 0, +15 cents is the LOW reed... I find the sound being much too harsh with the octave reed in there when you go over 15 cents diff. Had it been a 3v paolo, I'd say 20 without hesitation! (getting my own 3v C#/D out there from the present dry 15 soon).

Stephen, I'm glad you pointed the 23 key baldoni out. I really though mine was one of the only ones!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 19, 2008, 02:40:44 AM
Very interesting to hear about the Boston vs NY decoration on the boxes. Perhaps that could be part of the reason why the 4v baldoni I have for sale does not have any kind of decoration like my 6v, and most of the other baldonis/walters' (and the fact that it's one of the last Baldoni-Bartolis ever made).

Lars,

Well that's the conclusion that I've come to, which seems to make sense considering that the engraving/rhinestone inlay was done by this guy Augusto in New York, not by the factory in Italy. Maybe he was no longer working by the time yours was made, or maybe tastes had changed and such "shamrockery" was no longer seen as desirable?

(http://i17.photobucket.com/albums/b66/StephenChambers/Accordions/pic_leprechaun.gif)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 19, 2008, 01:37:16 PM
You can also see in the TG4 documentary on Derrane, that the 2 boxes that Jackie Martin (Derrane's close friend) bought from Walters when his store was closing had no decorations on them either (A black 2 row, and Derrane's famous 1.5 row he made that comeback on at Wolf Trap.)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 19, 2008, 04:23:22 PM
Lars,

Well that's the conclusion that I've come to, which seems to make sense considering that the engraving/rhinestone inlay was done by this guy Augusto in New York, not by the factory in Italy. Maybe he was no longer working by the time yours was made, or maybe tastes had changed and such "shamrockery" was no longer seen as desirable?

That could be the case. It also appears much different in construction than my 6v (and most other baldonis), so perhaps the last batch was made by a different italian company. I've been told that it's from mid 60's.

But I do prefer the fancy-schmancy-rhinestone flags ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 19, 2008, 05:11:17 PM
Stephen, will your 2 voice Paolo you just received be converted to C#/D as well?  :-[
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 04:29:21 AM
... maybe tastes had changed and such "shamrockery" was no longer seen as desirable?
... I do prefer the fancy-schmancy-rhinestone flags ::)

I love them myself, on a Baldoni or the like (and I saw a gorgeous Iorio like that, the other day, at Charlie's), but then there's something a bit brash, almost kitsch, about both the look and the sound of a Baldoni anyway...   ;)

But I'd hate that look on a grey Paolo Soprani, they're much classier!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 04:33:39 AM
Stephen, will your 2 voice Paolo you just received be converted to C#/D as well?  :-[

'Fraid so Ryan, it's a much better system for Irish-style playing. ;D But that won't harm the reeds and it could be very easily converted back again, at some future date. 

Anyway, I don't suppose I'll see it for another year or two now...  :(
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 04:46:16 AM
Just finished talking with Doug from the button box, and we've been trying to determine the tuning to put on this grey he has (LMMM). Any idea what the relative tuning was on boxes like this? Lars and I had conversed about it before and said something like 15 cents, but I want to be sure before I tell him to go ahead. I'm looking for the classic Grey Paolo sound, nice, wet and loud! ;D

I was talking to both Charlie and Anders about this, and basically they both agreed entirely with what I said about that model, though Anders even suggested possibly going (an extreme) 30 cents on the tremolo!!!  :o :o :o

They wouldn't go so far with one of the older dark-grey, aluminium-grilled boxes, which already have an inbuilt "edgy" sound to them (Charlie has his set at 15 cents), but feel the light-greys (which yours essentially is) need more "cut", whilst the old Italian factory "Irish" tuning was around 25 cents.

So you'd want to go at least 15 cents to get anything out of it, and maybe 25... But how was it tuned originally?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 20, 2008, 02:20:42 PM
Thats the thing, Doug hasn't been able to find out yet. When he emailed me first, he had all the reeds taken out for cleaning and re-valving. But he said when he gets it all together, he'll check the current tuning. I would have never thought that the light greys were 25-30 cents! :o But these guys know what they're talking about ;D thanks so much for the help :)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 02:28:00 PM
Danny Mahoney just got himself an old Baldoni D/C#, and even though he's famous for his B/C, there may still be a chance he'll give it a go for real.

Actually, it's not a Baldoni, it's an Iorio - it's the one I mentioned seeing (and hearing) at Charlie's.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 20, 2008, 02:40:22 PM
Iorio? Never heard of it....were they another maker of D/C# boxes for the NY & Boston area?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 02:58:13 PM
... he said when he gets it all together, he'll check the current tuning.

If it was me, I'd want to hear it before deciding how far to go with the tuning, not all boxes are the same, nor all players'/tuners' ears. In fact I've told Charlie that I'd like to hear mine before he tunes it (it's completely unplayable at the moment, with internal woodwork coming apart and a bellows full of holes  :(), though I want some "poke" off its two reeds and we're thinking around 20 cents...

Quote
I would have never thought that the light greys were 25-30 cents! :o But these guys know what they're talking about ;D

And I don't?  ::)

In fact plus and minus 25 (or 26) would still be regarded as "Irish tuning" by Italian manufacturers, though these days they might more usually be asked for "swing" (5 cents), "Americano" (10 cents) or "secco" (dry) tuning for today's more "polite" Irish players. Here's a March 1997 tuning chart from Victoria Accordions in Castelfidardo:

Tuning# Name Cents Apart
1 Dry 0
2 Giusto - + 5
3 American - + 10
4 Celeste - + 12
5 Japan - 11, + 13
6 German - + 14
7 Italian - + 16
8 French - + 20
9 Scottish - + 23.5
10 Irish - + 26

But Anders' 30 cents suggestion would definitely be extreme!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 03:22:16 PM
Iorio? Never heard of it....were they another maker of D/C# boxes for the NY & Boston area?

Iorio (http://www.syn-cordion.com/museum.htm) was a New York accordion factory. They are believed to have made for both Baldoni and Walters, though both my Baldonis were "Made in Italy".
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 20, 2008, 03:52:06 PM
I think 30 cents as well may be extreme ;) but 25 certainly sounds do-able. The only bad thing about this is the box is located in Massachusetts and I'm stranded on the island of Newfoundland ;D I won't get to play the box at all until it arrives here, so I'm shooting in the dark here. Thats why I'm asking for your skilled help ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 20, 2008, 04:14:23 PM
Stephen, I just thought it was Baldoni - though you must agree that it's rather un-usual for a Baldoni. But it really really looks nice!

Ryan - when I first got my 3v Paolo, I measured the reeds to between 26 and 28 cents across the range. When you're playing rather fast, it sounded really really nice! But: I think 20 is my limit.... I just find that the very wet tuning somehow sounds muffled when played along with a low (basoon) reed.

When I bought my 4v paolo from The Button Box, they said it would be overhauled and tuned to "swing" but came out almost all dry. But I don't think it should be a problem if you define number of cents to them.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 20, 2008, 07:03:51 PM
Yeah, that's my plan to tell them the exact cents I want. I think I would be happy with anything from 20-25, if I could find a suitable recording to compare to in the meantime to be sure of the sound. I want a nice wet sound, but want to stay away from the muffled sound you're talking about, Lars. ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 20, 2008, 09:01:58 PM
Stephen, do both your D/C# Paolos have wooden soundboards?

No, the 4-voice (which is maybe 1947) is plywood, the 2-voice (more like 1950ish) is aluminium.

Charlie Harris also showed me a grey 2-voice one that he has, with the aluminium grille. That one has a plywood soundboard, and the aluminium Paolo Soprani name is set-in on the bass end, whilst O'Byrne DeWitt is only glued on the surface of the treble end in white plastic letters that have mostly broken off.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 20, 2008, 10:54:54 PM
Hmm, that's weird, isn't it? Maybe a mix up at the factory? or maybe one of the first ones to be sent over?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2008, 12:16:49 AM
Hmm, that's weird, isn't it? Maybe a mix up at the factory? or maybe one of the first ones to be sent over?

I'm thinking more that it shows not all of them had the O'Byrne DeWitt name inlaid at the factory, and maybe it was sometimes stuck on later - or maybe not, as the case may be, like my black one...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 03:21:39 AM
Hmm, that's weird, isn't it? Maybe a mix up at the factory? or maybe one of the first ones to be sent over?

I'm thinking more that it shows not all of them had the O'Byrne DeWitt name inlaid at the factory, and maybe it was sometimes stuck on later - or maybe not, as the case may be, like my black one...

So your black one is older that your grey, yet younger than my soon acquisition, light grey one, yet the light grey which is perhaps a year older, has the O'Byrne DeWitt on it. None of these D/C# boxes were sold in Ireland at all, were they? I guess it wasn't the style.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2008, 05:19:07 AM
So your black one is older that your grey, yet younger than my soon acquisition, light grey one, yet the light grey which is perhaps a year older, has the O'Byrne DeWitt on it.

Um, not quite. I'd say my 2-coupler is the oldest of them, then Charlie's grey 2-voice, followed by my black one, all with the aluminium grilles, then your grey 2-coupler with the celluloid grille. But my point is that the badging of them isn't consistent.

Quote
None of these D/C# boxes were sold in Ireland at all, were they? I guess it wasn't the style.

That's right, the D/C# was a seperate Irish-American development in the 1930s, that started by adding a partial inside C# row to a D melodeon. It may have been inspired by Italian organetti that have a partial inside row of reversals.

Here in Ireland they were already starting to play "English-system" chromatic melodeons (soon to become known as "British chromatic" accordions), in C/C#, G/G# and B/C etc., influenced by Scottish players such as Peter Wyper and William Hannah.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 05:23:03 AM
Oops! I meant to say that the light grey was the youngest, and that your black was between your dark grey and my light grey. ::) Which was my point on it that the one inbetween lacked the O'Byrne DeWitt script.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 05:29:53 AM
So your black one is older that your grey, yet younger than my soon acquisition, light grey one, yet the light grey which is perhaps a year older, has the O'Byrne DeWitt on it.

Um, not quite. I'd say my 2-coupler is the oldest of them, then Charlie's grey 2-voice, followed by my black one, all with the aluminium grilles, then your grey 2-coupler with the celluloid grille. But what I'm saying is that the badging of them isn't consistent.

Quote
None of these D/C# boxes were sold in Ireland at all, were they? I guess it wasn't the style.

That's right, the D/C# was a seperate Irish-American development in the 1930s, that started by adding a partial inside C# row to a D melodeon. It may have been inspired by Italian organetti that have a partial inside row of reversals.

Here in Ireland they were already starting to play "English-system" chromatic melodeons (soon to become known as "British chromatic" accordions), in C/C#, G/G# and B/C etc., influenced by Scottish players such as Peter Wyper and William Hannah.



What exactly was the point of these C/C# and G/G# boxes, when most, if not all trad irish was / is based around D and it's associates (A, G, Em, Bm etc...)?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2008, 06:19:49 AM
What exactly was the point of these C/C# and G/G# boxes, when most, if not all trad was / is based around D and it's associates (A, G, Em, Bm etc...)?

You're assuming an awful lot!  :o

Then what's "the point" of flat pipes in C#, C, B, Bb? Why (if you check out the Stowmarket thread) is C the traditional pitch in Suffolk, or Cajun Louisiana for that matter? And why do the French play G/C boxes, and the Germans C/F???  ???

In fact traditional music has always tended to be played in the keys that instruments were available in locally, and the idea of everybody playing at "concert pitch" (= D) is a relatively recent one - you may be surprised to hear that it was only in the mid-1950s that both English and Irish button box players solved their problems of playing in D, with their adoption of the D/G and B/C systems respectively.

For my thoughts on the introduction of the semitone-tuned boxes into Ireland, you might like to check out this thread on Concertina.net: Irish Button Boxes, from Scotland (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2347&start=0&p=22950&#entry22950)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 01:10:33 PM
accidentally left out "irish" trad...another oops!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2008, 02:02:49 PM
accidentally left out "irish" trad...another oops!

It doesn't really matter in the context of what I was saying.

It may seem hard to imagine today, though I can still see vestiges of it, but the commonest key for all free reed instruments used to be C, and many of them were only available in whatever key(s) they came from the manufacturers in, rather than what was considered suitable locally. Not only that, but it was not until May 1939 that our "modern" International Concert Pitch of A 440 Hz was adopted (though it had already started to become accepted in the preceding few years), prior to which many different pitch standards were in use - for example there were four different civilian pitch standards in Britain (and hence Ireland) alone, plus a military band one, that went as high as half a semitone above 440, whilst German instruments could be tuned half a semitone flat of it, so a German D could be a British C#... (I've actually had problems over the re-pitching of a gorgeous c.1905 single-row Hohner because of this, the tuner not being aware of the problem, and not noticing the instrument was stamped D, tuned it to C# - I was not best-pleased!!!  :o Apart from anything else, what earthly use is a one-row in C#???)

But in Ireland, it was only in the mid-1930s that it became important for people to be able to play together, with the passing of the Dance Halls Act, and hence the starting of Ceili Bands. That was when "concert pitch" became an issue in Irish music, which had hitherto been largely solo and played at the fireside, or the crossroads.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 03:59:29 PM
Well now I completley understand everything ;) Where'd you learn all this?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 21, 2008, 05:25:42 PM
Where'd you learn all this?

The fruits of a life mis-spent in the company of musicians, instrument repairers, antique dealers, auctioneers, librarians (I used to be a librarian, but I'm alright now ;)), museum curators, collectors, not forgetting (very importantly) buying/selling/repairing/collecting old instruments, studying old catalogues and tutor books, but learning, learning all the time...  ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 21, 2008, 05:30:25 PM

The fruits of a life mis-spent in the company of musicians, instrument repairers, antique dealers, auctioneers, librarians (I used to be a librarian, but I'm alright now ;)), museum curators, collectors, not forgetting (very importantly) buying/selling/repairing/collecting old instruments, studying old catalogues and tutor books, but learning, learning all the time...  ::)

Sounds like a life well spent if you ask me! ;) Just wish I could be exposed to such people and marvels, but the local heritage and tradition around here is vastly different, but still interesting!

I've also often wondered how many of these gems of accordions remain in people's closets, basements or attics, stored away, never to be played again. The odd one does get lucky and is reborn again. If we could only invent some kind of accordion-calling device to awake them from the depths of which they currently lie! :o
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 22, 2008, 02:25:47 AM

 Apart from anything else, what earthly use is a one-row in C#???)


About as much use as a one-row in F#, I guess.

Both F# and C# single row boxes turn up quite regularly in Australia, and I note the comment about German pitch, which could well account for it. However, some I've seen are clearly marked with the key of F# or C#. and on one 1950s Serenelli 4 stop I recently repaired, G#.

However, the commonly accepted theory in Australia (right or wrong) is that these were special orders imported to enable the accordion to be played in tune with stringed instruments which were deliberately de-tuned because of climatic concerns.

I have met with older fiddle players, for instance, who always tune a semitone flat because of fears of putting too much strain on the neck.

I'm sure that this sort of thing happened in other parts of the world too. Still happening? Pretty well died out now here.

I do wonder about my old 1930s wooden Hohner 3 row, tuned to (and stamped) F#/B/E. A flat version of a common G/C/F perhaps?

Apologies for thread drift....

MC



Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 23, 2008, 12:31:40 PM

 Apart from anything else, what earthly use is a one-row in C#???)


About as much use as a one-row in F#, I guess.

Both F# and C# single row boxes turn up quite regularly in Australia ...

Malcolm,

I guess there's always the odd exception, and where more likely to find it...  ???

So maybe I should add "... except in Australia" to what I said.  ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on September 23, 2008, 04:36:59 PM
Stephen,

I should perhaps have added: "Often seen, but rarely heard these days" in regards to F# and C# boxes. I've not heard of any Oz based string players detuning the semitone in recent years..

So in answer to your question "what earthly use is a one-row in C#???", I would have to reply "not much". About the same use as my F#/B/E I suppose.

But 70 years ago, it may have been a different story....



Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 24, 2008, 02:26:02 AM
a newer topic made me propose this question : why did these d/c# boxes have 4 basses, and have all 4 setup so there was 2 bass and 2 chord buttons for D on the push? Standard 23 button Paolos at the time had 8 bass, and I realize that these things were "just extended melodeons", but why not get a full range of basses to add to that BIG sound these boxes generally produced? I saw from Lars' example that in the 60s the baldoni bartoli co. developed an 8 bass model, to which it had B/C chords and basses on a D/C# box! :o but why wasn't it developed til so late?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 24, 2008, 03:04:49 AM
... why did these d/c# boxes have 4 basses, and have all 4 setup so there was 2 bass and 2 chord buttons for D on the push? ... I realize that these things were "just extended meloseons" ...

I think you've answered your own question - for the very reason that these boxes were "just extended melodeons"! On a single-row melodeon you only get the "oom-pah" bass pair for the home key that the instrument is pitched in, but on the D/C# boxes you get those basses for both the home key of D "on the push" (D/A), and also for G "on the pull" (D/G), and hence both pairs of basses play D on the push. It's really very simple when you're playing the box, as long as you don't confuse yourself by thinking about it too much when you aren't...   ???
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 24, 2008, 11:05:12 AM
Haha! I know these things were considered "extended melodeons", but they're capable of almost everything a normal 23 button C#/D box would be. I believe an Iorio that was mentionned earlier has 6 basses on it, D/A D/G A/E, which is only missing the F#/Bm to have all the buttons a 23 button box would. But you're right, it is very easy, and does provide a classic "oom-pah" sound :P
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 24, 2008, 11:08:10 AM
and might it have had something to do with keeping the instruments cheaper?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: triskel on September 24, 2008, 12:08:18 PM
and might it have had something to do with keeping the instruments cheaper?

A Baldoni was more expensive than a Paolo Soprani, I don't think cheapness entered into it, just where they were coming from. They're an unusual example of a box that was actually designed by the people who were going to play it, rather than musicians having to adapt to a "factory model".
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 24, 2008, 01:56:55 PM

A Baldoni was more expensive than a Paolo Soprani, I don't think cheapness entered into it, just where they were coming from. They're an unusual example of a box that was actually designed by the people who were going to play it, rather than musicians having to adapt to a "factory model".

Oh ;) I forgot about hearing that these boxes were infact usually custom built to the player's wants and needs. I just think it's strange that you see many more baldonis than the Paolo Soprani equivalent, if these Paolos are as good as I hear they are, and also that they were cheaper! :o Weren't the Baldonis and Paolos mostly made in Italy?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on September 24, 2008, 08:00:09 PM
Ryan,

Keep in mind that the B/C bass setup of my blue baldoni was in fact a mistake. The different design also suggest that it perhaps was made elsewhere than the 50's itlalian made ones.

But no worries -it's been changed to playing around D:)

Another thing about the bass issue is the playing style. Though you have the same notes in the same bellows direction on a D/C# as you do on a C#/D, most players doing the D/C# thing will play it more "rough", or "melodeon style". A few rolls here and there, but not nearly as many as they (we) would playing 'inside out'.

Or maybe I'm just assuming??
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 24, 2008, 11:49:56 PM
Another thing about the bass issue is the playing style. Though you have the same notes in the same bellows direction on a D/C# as you do on a C#/D, most players doing the D/C# thing will play it more "rough", or "melodeon style". A few rolls here and there, but not nearly as many as they (we) would playing 'inside out'.

Or maybe I'm just assuming??

That seems logical. When playing my 1.5 row, I do play it more rough and melodeon style, as compared to the way I play my C#/D. The box just seems to make you play it rough, well thats the way it feels to me ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on September 25, 2008, 01:06:48 AM
Stephen,

how many of these boxes do you know of in existance? I know you have 2, John Brosnan has one, Charlie Harris another, and Chris Moran, and from what I hear, Paul Groff has one as well. And of course the one currently waiting at the button box. But are Groff's and the one at the button box the only ones left in D/C#, as the others, from what I hear, have been converted to C#/D (Although I have no idea how Harris' is still configured...)?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on December 18, 2008, 03:05:36 PM
http://profile.imageshack.us/user/hibbs3/images

beauty!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: boxlad on December 18, 2008, 05:08:40 PM
Are the O'Byrne DeWitt Paolo Sopranis like the one Hibbs3 is getting from the Button Box really that rare? Are there only less than ten known of in existence or in use anyway not counting the chance of a good few tucked away in attics??  :-\ I cant believe this! Its amazing :o :o :o By the way how is it coming along?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on December 18, 2008, 05:53:46 PM
I ended up letting the DC# Paolo go, as the 8v Baldoni struck more heart strings on me than that Paolo did ::)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on December 19, 2008, 09:49:08 PM
heres a link to the two pics, an awesome 20 key DC# Walters, and a beautiful Paolo Soprani DC#

http://profile.imageshack.us/user/hibbs3/images
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on December 27, 2008, 09:16:16 PM
I've uploaded most of my picture collection of "peculiar old boxes" to flickr.com username: lars_jakabov or just search "baldoni-bartoli" to find them. Lots of old D/C# boxes among all the paolos.

Edit: This might work: http://www.flickr.com/photos/21478603@N06/
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on December 28, 2008, 03:44:15 AM
quite the pic collection lars   ;)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: Lars on December 28, 2008, 12:02:51 PM
Well, you've seen most of them before, Ryan:)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: boxlad on November 26, 2010, 03:40:02 PM
It never fails to amaze me where these boxes turn up. This one was in a house down the road from me in Co. Waterford for the past 50 years and I never once saw it until last weekend! It is identical to Jim Coogan's black paolo. A lovely box..


 
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: pgroff on November 26, 2010, 04:16:50 PM
Thanks for sharing the pic Ray!

If we can trust the labeling on the couplers, this one is LMMM....

and no "O'Byrne DeWitt" or Baldoni badge on this one.

These various D/C# 4-bass Paolos really are wonderful accordions, with a featherlight left hand side, and I wish they could be re-issued (with just a couple more melody buttons squeezed in on the right side!).

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on November 27, 2010, 04:25:34 AM
Awesome!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: boxlad on November 28, 2010, 12:11:34 AM
I agree completely Paul. Great boxes for sure!  And by the way this box is for sale so PM me anyone that wants to make an offer. My friend has neither internet nor even decent phone connection... nor an idea of what he wants for the box but is open to offers   
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: hibbs3 on November 28, 2010, 04:45:40 AM
I've sent you a PM
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: boxlad on November 30, 2010, 12:33:30 PM
Following numerous enquiries about this box I just wanted to let you all know the following:
1. I won't be able to get decent photos for some time as the box is a long distance from where I live. As soon as I can, I will post them up.
2. I will also post a detailed description of the instrument as soon as I get a chance to examine it fully.

Thanks
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: pgroff on March 04, 2013, 02:13:51 PM
Hi all,

Hope no one objects to my digging up this very old thread. 

Just to add to the information above, here's a comparison of two D/C#, 19 key, 4 bass accordions made by Paolo Soprani for export to the USA.

The one on the left was sold by O'Byrne DeWitt in Boston and is in LMMH.  The one on the right, with an "arrowhead" shaped blue badge, turned up in New York and was likely sold there.  That one is in LMMM.  The blue badge box is very similar to the one once owned by Jim Coogan (RIP).  I remember when Jim got his, he was really  happy to have found it and seemed to prefer it to many boxes he had owned and sold over the years.  Unlike Jim's box, the blue badge box shown here does not have smaller buttons for the inside, C#, row.  Also I think that, compared to his, this one has a little different shape for the "cutout" area in the accordion casework around the four bass buttons.

The two Paolos shown here are similar in having aluminum soundboards and celluloid-covered metal grilles. Each of them has four melody reedblocks crammed into a very small body, so they both have a more muted, less crashy sound from the inside row of buttons -- and each sounds more even with the grille off.  Probably each would sound more balanced between the rows if given a customized, very open, naked metal grille.

The couplers on the OBD box give a choice of MM or LMMH; on the blue badge box the options are MMM or LMMM.  The blue badge box is slightly bigger, especially around the keyboard.  The larger keyboard dimensions actually offer noticeably more comfort when playing from the outside row -- better location for anchoring the thumb, less cramped for the fingers, and also less chance of knocking the couplers unintentionally.  I think there was an evolution of the design here, probably prompted by feedback from the players.  Other differences include the bass side cutout around the bass buttons, the air button (a long bar on the OBD, a round button on the blue badge box) and the bass grille design.  The OBD box has sturdy and well-machined hardware to hold a swiveling thumb strap; no thumb strap at all on the blue badge box.  The blue badge box has the rear-of-keyboard plate perforated to let out some sound.

Obviously both boxes are vintage Paolos and they sound and play that way.  But the blue-badge one has the more familiar Paolo voicings, including the MMM musette sound, really ringing in the upper notes, that reminds me of Cooley.  I don't know what accordion Tommy Liddy used with the Belhavel Trio, but this Paolo has a deep, gutsy LMMM sound on the outside row that's perfect for his tunes.  The OBD is very Baldoni-like in LMMH but sweet in MM like some of the prewar German melodeons when played MM.

We saw in this thread that, despite their rarity, Paolo Soprani made a wide variety of these D/C# boxes for American players over the years, in parallel with the styles in which they made the boxes for export to Ireland, Scotland, and England. The subtle differences between these two black boxes are just part of the story.

PG

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: pgroff on February 06, 2020, 06:45:34 PM
Here's a blue-badge 2 voice MM student model Paolo DC# box, probably from the 1960s. Shown with the blue-badge LMMM 2-coupler 4 voice model that I already posted above.  Although the two boxes seem quite similar apart from the number of reeds and the couplers, there are some notable differences:

Slight differences in the treble grille perforation pattern.
White vs black in the body inset around the four bass buttons.
Adjustable bass side strap in the 2 voice model (not adjustable in the fancier 4 voice model!). This may indicate a later time period or not, but actually it could be that young students might need that adjustable strap more than adults - both because they're growing and because the box might sometimes be passed back and forth between student and adult teacher.
Wooden soundboard in the 2 voice model, aluminum soundboard in the 4 voice model.

Note that the light colored pattern in the bellows tape on both boxes is yellowed. Originally this would have been white to match the white buttons. Evidence for that: here's an anonymous photo that was for sale on ebay as a 2X2 slide some years ago - showing a box similar to these two! Note the color of the bellows pattern when it was new.

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: boxcall on February 06, 2020, 10:39:21 PM
Here's a blue-badge 2 voice MM student model Paolo DC# box, probably from the 1960s. Shown with the blue-badge LMMM 2-coupler 4 voice model that I already posted above.  Although the two boxes seem quite similar apart from the number of reeds and the couplers, there are some notable differences:

Slight differences in the treble grille perforation pattern.
White vs black in the body inset around the four bass buttons.
Adjustable bass side strap in the 2 voice model (not adjustable in the fancier 4 voice model!). This may indicate a later time period or not, but actually it could be that young students might need that adjustable strap more than adults - both because they're growing and because the box might sometimes be passed back and forth between student and adult teacher.
Wooden soundboard in the 2 voice model, aluminum soundboard in the 4 voice model.

Note that the light colored pattern in the bellows tape on both boxes is yellowed. Originally this would have been white to match the white buttons. Evidence for that: here's an anonymous photo that was for sale on ebay as a 2X2 slide some years ago - showing a box similar to these two! Note the color of the bellows pattern when it was new.

PG
Hi PG
Cool boxes! , the grille on the four voice is reminding me of Darth Vader.

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: richard.fleming on February 08, 2020, 08:55:30 AM
The LMMH box is very like the rare and sought-after Pepperpot model except it lacks the pepperpot grille; in fact it has a grille pattern unlike anything I've ever seen before. Could that be because it was marketed as an O Byrne DeWitt, to distinguish it from ordinary Paolos?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: tirpous on February 08, 2020, 04:26:27 PM
Quote
The LMMH box is very like the rare and sought-after Pepperpot model except it lacks the pepperpot grille; in fact it has a grille pattern unlike anything I've ever seen before. Could that be because it was marketed as an O Byrne DeWitt, to distinguish it from ordinary Paolos?

As it happens there is a 1949 Gray with a similar grille (same pattern anyway) on Benny McCarthy's web site linked in this current thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25028.msg297776/topicseen.html#new (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25028.msg297776/topicseen.html#new)  under photos  /  box pics.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: pgroff on February 08, 2020, 04:43:04 PM
Quote
The LMMH box is very like the rare and sought-after Pepperpot model except it lacks the pepperpot grille; in fact it has a grille pattern unlike anything I've ever seen before. Could that be because it was marketed as an O Byrne DeWitt, to distinguish it from ordinary Paolos?

As it happens there is a 1949 Gray with a similar grille (same pattern anyway) on Benny McCarthy's web site linked in this current thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25028.msg297776/topicseen.html#new (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,25028.msg297776/topicseen.html#new)  under photos  /  box pics.

Yes, that's a known Paolo Soprani grille pattern. Some have claimed it's from the late 1940s but I would have guessed early 1950s myself. It shows up in Paolos made in the Irish keys (BC, DD#, etc) as well as in the Irish American system (shorter rows, 4 basses, DC#). I think all the Paolo button accordions that I've seen with that grille pattern were either black or grey, not sure I've ever seen a red Paolo Soprani button accordion with that pattern.   But it does show up (rarely) on Paolo Soprani piano accordions in many colors.

Here's Tom Dunne with one in black or dark grey; I think this is a 2 coupler LMMM BC with 23 melody keys and 8 basses:

https://irishamerica.com/2011/10/comhaltas-making-music-for-sixty-years/

Here's Andrew McNamara playing a Paolo with this grille pattern, on which the celluloid has been removed from the grille, exposing the underlying metal:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNqhbcQPTNo

PG

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: tirpous on February 08, 2020, 06:24:53 PM
Hmm, I guess Mr. McNamara is no fan of celluloid and couplers on grilles - years earlier he was already playing a similarly modified box: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX9WfdP11JU&feature=youtu.be (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX9WfdP11JU&feature=youtu.be)

On another subject, I tend to associate the ( )  or ((   )) grilles, like those in the 1st picture in Reply #112, with red badge.  Would the blue badges indicate an earlier date of manufacture ??
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: pgroff on February 08, 2020, 06:33:07 PM
Hmm, I guess Mr. McNamara is no fan of celluloid and couplers on grilles - years earlier he was already playing a similarly modified box: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX9WfdP11JU&feature=youtu.be (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DX9WfdP11JU&feature=youtu.be)

On another subject, I tend to associate the ( )  or ((   )) grilles, like those in the 1st picture in Reply #112, with red badge.  Would the blue badges indicate an earlier date of manufacture ??

I don't think so, for this "type" of blue badge (arrowhead shaped).

There are other types of blue badges that I associate with 1950s boxes.

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: odonovanchris on March 01, 2020, 03:44:15 AM
Here is a Paolo I picked up a few years ago from a chap in Denmark. It appears to be of similar era to the above paolos (early 50s ish) however the grille pattern is different again and red in colour. It was originally G/C LMM which I had converted to B/C MMM. Beautiful sweet tone out of it and it is very lightweight. The only issue is the stepped keyboard which will be an upcoming project to tackle!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani D/C#
Post by: komat on July 01, 2021, 12:52:50 AM
And these two recently popped up through The Button Box.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal