Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: waltzman on August 27, 2011, 01:38:31 AM
-
An ADG with a stradella bass nicely played.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZK07Lfc1Hk4&feature=related
-
Very nice. How common are boxes with this set-up?
I can't figure out if diatonic with stradella bass represents the best of both worlds ... or the worst of both worlds! ???
-
Very nice. How common are boxes with this set-up?
I can't figure out if diatonic with stradella bass represents the best of both worlds ... or the worst of both worlds! ???
Other than the fact that the inside (G) row is not a full row, the idea of having a diatonic treble with stradella bass is called an accordeon mixte in French. Among 3 row setups, it's less popular than the usual (12 bass); however, it is a known setup (offered as an option by Castagnari apparently -- if you ask them -- since Castagnari mixtes pop up on French diato classified every so often), not a freak one-off.
-
I know someone who has a Hohner box looking very similar to that one, with D/G club tuning on the RH side and 12x4 stradella bass. It's the only one I've ever seen.
-
There was a chap at a local session who used to bring a great big Dino Bafetti ADG with Stadella bass. The G bass was marked-up, as opposed to the usual C button. I remember it was very heavy, and sparkly.
-
Listening to ADG3row, the particular tune obviously benefits heavily from the diatonic right hand, the usefulness of the stradella bass is less clear.
-
Listening to ADG3row, the particular tune obviously benefits heavily from the diatonic right hand, the usefulness of the stradella bass is less clear.
Listen to the old virtuosos of the système mixte like Emile Vacher and you'll get a better idea of how the basses are to be used - a player can do whole runs with the left hand much like the left hand of a piano player. Something like counterpoint melody on the basses becomes possible and there is a full selection of chords in addition to having the flexibility of unisonoric bass/chords. In this way the right hand is free to choose its phrasing, combining bouncy push/draw passages with slick phrases in a single bellows direction. The music careens around in a jaunty style that is quite dynamic, a playful and wonderful style in the hands of a skilled practitioner and not something that is seen today as much as in the past. I'd love to see the films of Georges Méliès set to a score performed on the système mixte!
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
-
Listen to the old virtuosos of the système mixte like Emile Vacher and you'll get a better idea of how the basses are to be used - a player can do whole runs with the left hand much like the left hand of a piano player. Something like counterpoint melody on the basses becomes possible and there is a full selection of chords in addition to having the flexibility of unisonoric bass/chords. In this way the right hand is free to choose its phrasing, combining bouncy push/draw passages with slick phrases in a single bellows direction. The music careens around in a jaunty style that is quite dynamic, a playful and wonderful style in the hands of a skilled practitioner and not something that is seen today as much as in the past. I'd love to see the films of Georges Méliès set to a score performed on the système mixte!
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
It's obvious that human beings are capable of extraordinary virtuosity on any type of instrument, given enough time & commitment. I guess that one of the things that attracted me to the melodeon is the fact that it's possible to produce a very rich & satisfying sound without having to be a "virtuoso"! I don't know if trying to play a "mixte" accordion would create extreme mental & digital confusion for me as a budding DBA player.
There are a couple of interesting looking examples on US Ebay right now:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/280727946662?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_1363wt_1398
http://www.ebay.com/itm/120767671945?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1413
-
Those two examples are old enough to need full overhaul before you would enjoy playing them. Overhaul costs likely to be considerably more than the cost of purchase.
-
Listen to the old virtuosos of the système mixte like Emile Vacher and you'll get a better idea of how the basses are to be used - a player can do whole runs with the left hand much like the left hand of a piano player. Something like counterpoint melody on the basses becomes possible and there is a full selection of chords in addition to having the flexibility of unisonoric bass/chords. In this way the right hand is free to choose its phrasing, combining bouncy push/draw passages with slick phrases in a single bellows direction. The music careens around in a jaunty style that is quite dynamic, a playful and wonderful style in the hands of a skilled practitioner and not something that is seen today as much as in the past. I'd love to see the films of Georges Méliès set to a score performed on the système mixte!
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
It's obvious that human beings are capable of extraordinary virtuosity on any type of instrument, given enough time & commitment. I guess that one of the things that attracted me to the melodeon is the fact that it's possible to produce a very rich & satisfying sound without having to be a "virtuoso"! I don't know if trying to play a "mixte" accordion would create extreme mental & digital confusion for me as a budding DBA player.
There are a couple of interesting looking examples on US Ebay right now:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/280727946662?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_1363wt_1398
http://www.ebay.com/itm/120767671945?ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1423.l2649#ht_500wt_1413
I brought up Emile Vacher because he is (was) a widely known player whose work nicely illustrates how one can play an instrument with diatonic treble side and stradella basses on the left side. Maybe not everyone's cup of tea but you seemed curious about usefulness of stradella bass in a system with a diatonic right hand. I don't agree, though, regarding the limitations of the DBA and virtuosity. Système mixte is a diatonic system that is still played by people of varying skill levels, and should present no more of a challenge to learn than the BCC# with stradella basses or learning to create interesting bass accompaniments on a 'standard' diatonic accordion with only eight bass buttons (something I have yet to master).
I'm watching those auctions right now. Although I'm not going to bid (baby coming soon, not bidding on anything! (:)), just idling on the sideline. Try ebay.fr for more examples of the system many are posted with low opening bids and no takers. I don't know if it's shipping or disinterest that prevents them from selling? ???
-
I don't know if it's shipping or disinterest that prevents them from selling? ???
I think they are fairly specialized and at the same time, once you have one that you are satisfied with, it's all you need (unlike diatos!).
Here's a great example that I found -- I really enjoyed this clip:
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/accordeon-mixte-revisited.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/accordeon-mixte-revisited.html)
-
I don't agree, though, regarding the limitations of the DBA and virtuosity. Système mixte is a diatonic system that is still played by people of varying skill levels, and should present no more of a challenge to learn than the BCC# with stradella basses or learning to create interesting bass accompaniments on a 'standard' diatonic accordion with only eight bass buttons (something I have yet to master).
Well, I wasn't implying that the DBA doesn't allow for virtuosity, nor conversely, that stradella bass represents a extraordinary challenge, but that the DBA has a beautiful economy of means in producing a full, rich & expressive sound which is what (for me, at least) makes it particularly appealing.
But yes, I'm tempted by that pretty old Soprani ... :-\
-
I almost forgot about this famous example of mixte system playing -- Renato Borghetti plays 2.4 row boxes with stradella bass.
Again, here is a video that I found on YouTube:
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/what-every-diatonic-accordion-listener.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/what-every-diatonic-accordion-listener.html)
-
And a bit of gaucho kitsch:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CV_nklJ5g0&NR=1 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CV_nklJ5g0&NR=1)
I think you might have to drink a lot of mate to play this style!
-
This is very interesting and very tempting but maybe its one step too far for me! I am playing a standard 3 row but am also playing stradella bass with a PA so it does seem to be a very logical step to combine them both but then maybe I'd get totally mixte up!
I am always amazed at how good people at playing these instruments - surely Gaucho country isn't a hotbed of mixte accordion players.
-
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
they must have sold them all... quite a few CBAs though.....
-
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
they must have sold them all... quite a few CBAs though.....
Several finished this week or last week, with no bids. Also check the sales not just auctions.
I am always amazed at how good people at playing these instruments - surely Gaucho country isn't a hotbed of mixte accordion players.
The Chamamé musicians (similar region as where Borghetti is from) use all sorts systems, including club systems and accordions like the one in the video from Andy. They use the basses to great rhythmical effect.
-
Does anyone here know the gentleman playing in the OP? The accordion - an Exclusive? - looks like a new accordion.
Personally, I found the PA with stradella basses entirely logical to play from the start & the diatonic more confusing, but the ergonomics of a PA just don't seem right & once I got past the initial issues, the DBA seems more natural ... & just more fun!
-
Listening to ADG3row, the particular tune obviously benefits heavily from the diatonic right hand, the usefulness of the stradella bass is less clear.
Listen to the old virtuosos of the système mixte like Emile Vacher and you'll get a better idea of how the basses are to be used - a player can do whole runs with the left hand much like the left hand of a piano player. Something like counterpoint melody on the basses becomes possible and there is a full selection of chords in addition to having the flexibility of unisonoric bass/chords. In this way the right hand is free to choose its phrasing, combining bouncy push/draw passages with slick phrases in a single bellows direction. The music careens around in a jaunty style that is quite dynamic, a playful and wonderful style in the hands of a skilled practitioner and not something that is seen today as much as in the past. I'd love to see the films of Georges Méliès set to a score performed on the système mixte!
There are loads of old "mixte" accordions on French Ebay, they often don't sell.
I have thought for years that a systeme mixte is the way to go. My problem is that I am shying more and more away from big boxes, to the extent that I won't be able to get my dream systeme mixte for many years, not unless I sell up all of the other boxes that I have. I want an ultra small, ultra light 3 row 4 voice 48 bass. Ultra small, ultra light. About the size of Miklos' Co-op I would think. Not going to happen unless I make the thing myself and even then unlikely.
-
I want an ultra small, ultra light 3 row 4 voice 48 bass. Ultra small, ultra light. About the size of Miklos' Co-op I would think. Not going to happen unless I make the thing myself and even then unlikely.
All that in ultra small, ultra light will mean compromising on the quality of sound. Think of the difference in sound between a Mory and a Tommy, especially the bass.
There now that should open the can of worms into the hornets nest. ;D
-
I want an ultra small, ultra light 3 row 4 voice 48 bass. Ultra small, ultra light. About the size of Miklos' Co-op I would think. Not going to happen unless I make the thing myself and even then unlikely.
All that in ultra small, ultra light will mean compromising on the quality of sound. Think of the difference in sound between a Mory and a Tommy, especially the bass.
The Cooperfisa Perla 300/A is light and small only when compared to other chromatic button accordions: it is 5.7 kg and of the size of a Hohner Corona/Club III/Corso. I used to have an 11-kg Borsini 4-voice LMMM for a number of months and to my surprise it was not much louder at all than the 2-voice Cooperfisa Perla 300/A. I was able to play the 2-voice Perla even louder than the Borsini, actually, because of the much ligher body, which made a more dinamic bellows control possible, I think. I've already sold the 11-kg monster, definitely not my style. Now I am for a 3-voice LMM CBA that is less than 7 kg.
-
Ah, Miklos, it all depends on the context! For me a Hohner Corona is big and slightly heavier than I would want to play. I'm used to a two voice diatonic which weighs about 3kg!
-
I want an ultra small, ultra light 3 row 4 voice 48 bass. Ultra small, ultra light. About the size of Miklos' Co-op I would think. Not going to happen unless I make the thing myself and even then unlikely.
All that in ultra small, ultra light will mean compromising on the quality of sound. Think of the difference in sound between a Mory and a Tommy, especially the bass.
There now that should open the can of worms into the hornets nest. ;D
Or think of the difference between a Club IIB and a Preciosa :P I would say "altering" rather than "compromising"! It would require a lot of experimentation to see how small it could go without the basses sounding pants.