Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Steve C. on August 27, 2011, 09:55:16 PM

Title: Gb-B???
Post by: Steve C. on August 27, 2011, 09:55:16 PM
I was just looking around at some of my bookmarked melodeon sites and was looking at the EXCELSIOR 8BF which is available in G-flat/B.

What is the purpose/advantage/usual use of this combination?  Never have seen/noticed it before.

Thanks, Steve
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: forrest on August 27, 2011, 11:10:15 PM
I was just looking around at some of my bookmarked melodeon sites and was looking at the EXCELSIOR 8BF which is available in G-flat/B.

What is the purpose/advantage/usual use of this combination?  Never have seen/noticed it before.

Thanks, Steve

Steve, this might sound slightly less odd as: F#/B. It's an old combination that is less popular than it was, say 80 or so years ago, but still a quint-tuned box. I have an old Hohner 3-row in F#/B/E made in the 30th's. The main advantage would be that one  can accompany a singer whose voice is more at home in one of those keys. If you watch performances of singers accompanied by guitar, you might notice the guitar often has a capo installed on the second fret. If the guitarist plays in the normal E or A positions, he will be actually be pitched in F# or B.
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: Theo on August 28, 2011, 12:16:52 AM
Remember that in German B means the same pitch that Engilsh speakers call B flat.  But Gflat Bflat would be a  very unusual combination - rows a major third apart. Bflat Eflat is more usual.
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: pgroff on August 28, 2011, 01:30:40 PM
Remember that in German B means the same pitch that Engilsh speakers call B flat.  But Gflat Bflat would be a  very unusual combination - rows a major third apart. Bflat Eflat is more usual.

True, Theo.  But if the keys quoted for the Excelsior mentioned in the original post were correct -- G flat (= F#) and B (in the english sense), the box would have the common interval of a fourth between the 2 rows.

The German Hohner F#/B/E boxes mentioned by j. w. forrest are labeled Fis H E, again with the rows tuned a fourth apart.  I have also seen H E and Fis H German boxes.

Another way to think about the keys of F#/B for an accordion/melodeon is that this could function as a very low pitch (A = 415) version of a G/C box.  Over the centuries, pitch standards in various parts of Europe have varied by several semitones and in many places, folk and traditional instruments have maintained pitches very different from the nominal modern A 440 "standard."  The need for a modern F#/B could be to suit a singer as j.w.forrest suggested, but also possibly might be wanted to achieve compatibility with other instruments (old or new) made to a different traditional pitch standard.

PG
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: Theo on August 28, 2011, 02:38:15 PM
Ah yes, I see,  suffering from post-festival tiredness after Whitby Folk Week, and not thinking straight.
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: Steve C. on August 28, 2011, 07:35:02 PM
This is what I was looking at:
http://www.accordion-o-rama.com/Two%20row%20button%20accordions.htm#Excelsior%208BF

"F#"/B: what was I thinking?  Weird to see it written as Gb. Makes sense.
Title: Re: Gb-B???
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 28, 2011, 08:43:11 PM


Oh man, that vendor is a blast from the past.  Never again! Although sometimes I chuckle when I think about the owner's behavior.  And we do have something to thank him for --- his way of treating people actually inspired Rich Morse to found the Button Box!
Title: F#/B
Post by: melodeon on August 28, 2011, 11:18:47 PM
I seem to recall I got a private message suggesting I cast aspersions on the integrity of the folks that run Accordion o Rama

So I won't tell you just how bad they are; how rude, how obnoxious and largley ignorant of matters diatonic.
Title: Re: F#/B
Post by: Owen Woods on September 04, 2011, 11:51:35 PM
I seem to recall I got a private message suggesting I cast aspersions on the integrity of the folks that run Accordion o Rama

So I won't tell you just how bad they are; how rude, how obnoxious and largley ignorant of matters diatonic.

The fact that you haven't told us these things has been duly noted ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal