Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Alan Morley on August 28, 2011, 07:25:27 PM
-
Every now and then you fall over some fantastic music by people you have never heard of, PLEASE have a look at this video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qcOjaS2REM&NR=1 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qcOjaS2REM&NR=1)
Brill musicianship on box and the harmonica play is out of this world. I'm still tapping my feet....
Alan
-
I feel I must disagree far to many notes that added nothing to the song
-
I feel I must disagree far to many notes that added nothing to the song
I am with you here. Speed is often the opposite of musicality. This is an example imo.
W
-
I still love it....:)
Great crowd pleasing stuff and showmanship from a young band playing great tunes/ songs and attempting to move things on.
If you see their videos on YouTube they have a similar approach to the Demon Barbers and combine dance with their music to good effect.
I'm sure they manage to engage with younger audiences and open up the world of traditional music to a wider audience, which has got to be a good thing.
Plus I personally have a lot of respect for musicians that can produce things that I can't, and draw inspiration and hopefully move on with my playing.
-
Blackleg Miner is a song not a tune and that is what got lost in the performance.
Steve
-
Good playing on melodeon and Will Pound a wizard on harmonica as usual, but the overall performance did nothing for me.
Much too fast and the song came over as having little or no understanding of what it was all about. But I guess these youngsters, talented though they are, have scarcely any memories of our coal industry and certainly no idea what it meant to be a miner.
'The Blackleg Miner' is a powerful, earthy and passionate song, full of understated menace and hatred. It's not one to be sung with a smile on your face.
Louis Killen has it just right, in my opinion:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iixlRu_6fko
-
I'm afraid I wasn't keen either, for all the reasons mentioned above. I didn't even get halfway through the video before I exited. Not impressed by the vocalist, either. Sorry!
Graham
-
Good playing on melodeon and Will Pound a wizard on harmonica as usual, but the overall performance did nothing for me.
Much too fast and the song came over as having little or no understanding of what it was all about. But I guess these youngsters, talented though they are, have scarcely any memories of our coal industry and certainly no idea what it meant to be a miner.
'The Blackleg Miner' is a powerful, earthy and passionate song, full of understated menace and hatred. It's not one to be sung with a smile on your face.
Louis Killen has it just right, in my opinion:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iixlRu_6fko
I suspect that most of the audience wouldn't know or care about the history of the song and will just enjoy bouncing around to it. The band look like they enjoy putting on a show and are there to entertain not educate - if they wanted to do the serious version they have the wrong audience there. I do agree with the comment about the girl singer though.
Also jump to 2 mins in and get past the song and listen the playing and the audience reaction at the end - check out their other material on YouTube.
-
I feel I must disagree far to many notes that added nothing to the song
I am with you here. Speed is often the opposite of musicality. This is an example imo.
W
Ever listened to Shooglenifty ?http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNWMwmwmz3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNWMwmwmz3U)
-
I feel I must disagree far to many notes that added nothing to the song
I am with you here. Speed is often the opposite of musicality. This is an example imo.
W
Ever listened to Shooglenifty ?http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNWMwmwmz3U (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNWMwmwmz3U)
i dont think i did, but thx for the link. This is a LOT better imo. And even though there are many notes per minute there, it isnt speed i am hearing. It lacks a melodeon though ;)
W
-
I have to agree with Almo that I enjoyed this clip. I would say the most detracting thing about the clip is the percussionist who seems to have a hard time keeping up. I also think the sound of his percussion is distracting (brushes?) I like these kind of combinations being a child of the 60's. The harmonica player was great and the performance was energetic. Another band I recently saw a clip of the Welsh band, Jamie Smith's Mabon. Jamie is a piano accordionist. I think they are a much tighter band rhythmically and that adds immensely to the sound . My two cents. Charlie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9pK4BB1shY
-
Mighty harmonica player. I'd like to hear him by himself, without the box.
-
Mighty harmonica player. I'd like to hear him by himself, without the box.
Will is an astounding young player!
Here's a YT video; there are others on there too, just search for 'Will Pound'
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmBXbGq90kg
-
If the band keep together and as they mature and gain experience, they'll be great.
Like all young and newish bands - there are lots of things to work on and tighten up, but they have loads of time..
-
You'll not be seeing this particular line-up of The OP (http://www.theqp.co.uk/) (for it is they) again. Or not very likely anyway. Laurel (Lolly, the dancer on this video) and Will (http://www.willpound.com/) (mouth organ) have gone on to pastures new.
Will is quite a live wire musically, he seems to explode off in all directions at once (mixing my metaphors). He's also great fun in a session though I will freely admit that much of his treatment of tunes is not really to my taste. However (!), he does it extremely well and seems to be making quite a name for himself.
I've seen The QP's performance of "The Blackleg Miner", and there are other videos of them doing it on Youtube and to be honest I think it's pretty wide of the mark. What a jolly, cheekie chappie that blackleg miner seems to be, eh?
Louis Killen? Yes, I've got that record and he recorded other versions as well. Dead on. Not that there can't be other ways of doing it of course.
-
Will could be found playing with various bands and musicians throughout Shrewsbury Folk Festival last weekend - this video features him playing with Martin Simpson Band
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q7h-DEH0dt8&feature=related
-
Will could be found playing with various bands and musicians throughout Shrewsbury Folk Festival last weekend - this video features him playing with Martin Simpson Band
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q7h-DEH0dt8&feature=related
Nice video - I was waiting for an Andy Cutting - rock 'n' roll / blues solo on melodeon bending notes... ::)