Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on August 29, 2011, 06:36:41 PM

Title: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 29, 2011, 06:36:41 PM
Ok - another chart for D/G - this time it's got ABC equivalents.
Please see very slight tweak - the F natural (G row) ABC equivalent now has an =.  This is now accurate in respect of the key signature of G major
This chart was produced in consultation with Lester Bailey - thanks Lester!! :|glug

See it here:-

http://web.me.com/les.titford/daddylongles/daddylonglestabs_files/DG%20Notes%20ABC.gif
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 29, 2011, 07:32:19 PM
Excellent stuff Les, it was so hard to figure out what was going on at the top and bottom ends and this adds a great deal of clarity.  ;D

But my box is 23 button with a fourth button start, bespoke low notes and no accidentals. You wouldn't want to leave a job half done would you?  ;)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 29, 2011, 07:41:09 PM
Excellent stuff Les, it was so hard to figure out what was going on at the top and bottom ends and this adds a great deal of clarity.  ;D

But my box is 23 button with a fourth button start, bespoke low notes and no accidentals. You wouldn't want to leave a job half done would you?  ;)
;D Hmmm - trouble is where would it stop? BC  GC  2.5  rows 3 rows Aaargh!!!

 :Ph :Ph :Ph
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 29, 2011, 08:01:24 PM

 ;D Hmmm - trouble is where would it stop? BC  GC  2.5  rows 3 rows Aaargh!!!

 :Ph :Ph :Ph

Well exactly. However it would only be fair to demand a sample box in each key for you to work from ...  ;D
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 29, 2011, 08:23:07 PM
Well, I must first of all say very well done - these look very useful and I have taken copies.

It would of course be unfair to ask Les and Lester to produce charts for all variants, but since in another thread D/G fourth button start with low notes was considered a desirable standard English box, I think that would be most unfortunate if omitted.  And it's such a small change...
 ::)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 29, 2011, 08:32:10 PM
Well, I must first of all say very well done - these look very useful and I have taken copies.

It would of course be unfair to ask Les and Lester to produce charts for all variants, but since in another thread D/G fourth button start with low notes was considered a desirable standard English box, I think that would be most unfortunate if omitted.  And it's such a small change...
 ::)

Unfortunately an agreed layout was never agreed, something about herding cats comes to mind
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: malcolmbebb on August 29, 2011, 08:39:18 PM
Well, a nice chart would set a de facto standard... >:E
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Theo on August 29, 2011, 09:52:05 PM
Well, a nice chart would set a de facto standard... >:E


Well, a nice chart would set a de facto another standard... >:E

Quote
Journalist to IT industry boss, discussing incompatible computer systems: "Why don't you have standards in the IT industry?"
IT industry boss "Oh we love standards in our industry, we have lots of them!"
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 29, 2011, 10:26:10 PM
something about herding cats comes to mind

Herding cats is easy. You want to try getting a consensus of accordion players.  ::)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lyn on August 29, 2011, 11:08:34 PM
(owner of 23 button, 4th button start box) erm.....I didn't like to ask..........
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: rees on August 30, 2011, 07:19:55 AM
This is a really useful chart. Well done those chaps.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: OwenG on August 30, 2011, 11:20:15 AM
Well, a nice chart would set a de facto standard... >:E

I know it's more work, but what about a blank chart so that people could fill in their own standard layouts???
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Theo on August 30, 2011, 11:29:56 AM
Of you are volunteering then yes I'm sure many would find it useful.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Aiberdeen Loon on August 30, 2011, 12:52:22 PM
I have attached a blank sheet for a 21 button setup and also sheets for B/C instruments with 21 and 23 buttons.
No abc as yet.
I hope this is useful to someone.

Alan
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: davidd on August 30, 2011, 04:20:31 PM
Perfect! Now I can put away my ruler and compass!
David
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 04:38:54 PM
I have attached a blank sheet for a 21 button setup and also sheets for B/C instruments with 21 and 23 buttons.
No abc as yet.
I hope this is useful to someone.

Alan

Very interesting Alan and very well done.  I see you B/C ers don't have so many useless squeaky notes as us D/G ers!!!

Many thanks also for the blank chart :|glug
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Aiberdeen Loon on August 30, 2011, 05:11:45 PM
I should have proof read the attachments before sending,  trying to do everything in too much of a hurry.  Please find attached cleaned up versions of the B/C charts.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 06:09:04 PM
I should have proof read the attachments before sending,  trying to do everything in too much of a hurry.  Please find attached cleaned up versions of the B/C charts.

B/C modern bass layout
On button 10  (C row) shouldn't the B note on the stave be red not the E?
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Martin J on August 30, 2011, 06:24:46 PM
For those like me who can't make head nor tail of a map laid on its side here's a blank where all the press and all the pull are on the same line.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 06:26:55 PM
For those like me who can't make head nor tail of a map laid on its side here's a blank where all the press and all the pull are on the same line.

That makes sense!!
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 30, 2011, 06:30:39 PM
For those like me who can't make head nor tail of a map laid on its side here's a blank where all the press and all the pull are on the same line.

That makes sense!!

Except, in my head, the push notes would be below the pull notes
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 06:34:59 PM
For those like me who can't make head nor tail of a map laid on its side here's a blank where all the press and all the pull are on the same line.

That makes sense!!

Except, in my head, the push notes would be below the pull notes
Yes, Lester I see what you mean - agreed!!
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Martin J on August 30, 2011, 06:45:05 PM
Turn it the right way up Lester, the Press notes are on top  ;D
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 30, 2011, 06:51:54 PM
Turn it the right way up Lester, the Press notes are on top  ;D

Yep, upsidedown ::)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Telemorris on August 30, 2011, 07:29:26 PM
I don't know why but I'm having a hard time figuring out how to edit these sheets to add notation and the letters for the notes on the buttons. What am I missing?

Thanks
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lyn on August 30, 2011, 07:47:08 PM
No, push notes on top, surely, the push comes before the pull? Or am I missing something? (probably, usually am...... ???)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 30, 2011, 07:52:31 PM
No, push notes on top, surely, the push comes before the pull? Or am I missing something? (probably, usually am...... ???)

No you arent missing anything it's just the way your brain is wired. To me the push side of a button is further from the bellows than the pull side of a button, hence push notes on the bottom, pull on the top in this diagram. But as the say on the internet YMMV  ;)
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 08:17:05 PM
No, push notes on top, surely, the push comes before the pull? Or am I missing something? (probably, usually am...... ???)

No you arent missing anything it's just the way your brain is wired. To me the push side of a button is further from the bellows than the pull side of a button, hence push notes on the bottom, pull on the top in this diagram. But as the say on the internet YMMV  ;)

I'm with you Lester - maybe it's an age thing!!  We're both the same age.

YMMV - hmm, had to look that one up.  I'll definitely be trying that one out on the family tonight!!

YMMV today, herding cats yesterday - what's next I wonder!!! ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 08:19:55 PM
I don't know why but I'm having a hard time figuring out how to edit these sheets to add notation and the letters for the notes on the buttons. What am I missing?

Thanks

If you've got a Mac (running Leopard or Lion) - use Preview to annotate the sheets.  If you're a Windows user, sorry....I can't help!
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lyn on August 30, 2011, 10:38:49 PM
ok, I give in, what does YMMV mean?
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Telemorris on August 30, 2011, 10:42:42 PM
YMMV = Your Mileage May Vary.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Telemorris on August 30, 2011, 10:43:58 PM

[/quote]

If you've got a Mac (running Leopard or Lion) - use Preview to annotate the sheets.  If you're a Windows user, sorry....I can't help!
[/quote]

Mac at home, PC at work. Will try on the Mac tonight. So Preview gives you musical notation? I never knew!
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 30, 2011, 10:51:07 PM


If you've got a Mac (running Leopard or Lion) - use Preview to annotate the sheets.  If you're a Windows user, sorry....I can't help!
[/quote]

Mac at home, PC at work. Will try on the Mac tonight. So Preview gives you musical notation? I never knew!
[/quote]
Not quite right - Preview gives you text you can position anywhere on the page. I use TableEdit for the notes and my wife puts it all together in Photoshop.  It's a bit of a rigmarole!!!
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Aiberdeen Loon on August 30, 2011, 11:00:46 PM
http://www.serif.com/free-graphic-design-software/?MC=FSSDRAWPLUS

I used this free drawing package which is excellent.
You can enter the notation by using text and selecting the appropriate font.
You can then save it as a PDF.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Martin J on August 31, 2011, 01:15:23 AM
No, push notes on top, surely, the push comes before the pull? Or am I missing something? (probably, usually am...... ???)
You'e not missing anything, in fact you are spot on the money.  I think I've figured out what Lester is doing.  Instead of reading a normal landscape page where a scale for g reads G, B, D, G etc along the TOP row in the top half of the circles he must be turning it on it's side into portrait mode.  As Lester says, we all seem to have our brains wired differently.

For me, my maps are easy to lay on the table and simply place fingers in position then read either top halves (Press) or bottom halves (Pull) to work out chords, fingering sequences etc.  Particularly useful if, like me, you are bass driven which sets the bellows direction before you choose the right hand fingering.  I find it easier to read a row of sequential letters rather than having to skip to every other letter when reading a sequence.  It's also the system used by Castagnari, Giustozzi and other Italian makers.

So, two different ways to choose from, whatever suits your mind set. :||: :|||:

Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2011, 07:36:13 AM
I think I've figured out what Lester is doing.  Instead of reading a normal landscape page where a scale for g reads G, B, D, G etc along the TOP row in the top half of the circles he must be turning it on it's side into portrait mode. 

Nope, I am reading it landscape just prefer the buttons labeled the other way. But I will defend your right to label them incorrectly 'til my dying breath  ;D
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 31, 2011, 08:10:26 AM
I think I've figured out what Lester is doing.  Instead of reading a normal landscape page where a scale for g reads G, B, D, G etc along the TOP row in the top half of the circles he must be turning it on it's side into portrait mode. 

Nope, I am reading it landscape just prefer the buttons labeled the other way. But I will defend your right to label them incorrectly 'til my dying breath  ;D

I can see both sides of the argument. Maybe it's better to used the original melnet method of side by side?
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Lester on August 31, 2011, 08:13:24 AM
I think I've figured out what Lester is doing.  Instead of reading a normal landscape page where a scale for g reads G, B, D, G etc along the TOP row in the top half of the circles he must be turning it on it's side into portrait mode. 

Nope, I am reading it landscape just prefer the buttons labeled the other way. But I will defend your right to label them incorrectly 'til my dying breath  ;D

I can see both sides of the argument. Maybe it's better to used the original melnet method of side by side?

 ;D
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 31, 2011, 10:21:23 AM
Ok - another chart for D/G - this time it's got ABC equivalents.
Please see very slight tweak - the F natural (G row) ABC equivalent now has an =.  This is now accurate in respect of the key signature of G major
This chart was produced in consultation with Lester Bailey - thanks Lester!! :|glug

See it here:-

http://web.me.com/les.titford/daddylongles/daddylonglestabs_files/DG%20Notes%20ABC.gif
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 31, 2011, 10:31:35 AM
Ok - another chart for D/G - this time it's got ABC equivalents.
Please see very slight tweak - the F natural (G row) ABC equivalent now has an =.  This is now accurate in respect of the key signature of G major
This chart was produced in consultation with Lester Bailey - thanks Lester!! :|glug

See it here:-

http://web.me.com/les.titford/daddylongles/daddylonglestabs_files/DG%20Notes%20ABC.gif
Just one final tweak please Les,  and I'll be happy!

On both the stave notation and on the letter names for the notes, please can we have the sharps shown as appropriate? I know you have a key signature at the beginning of the lines for G and D rows, but with the individual stave fragments being chopped up as they are (which is fine), it really needs to have the accidental # sign added to both the letter names and the notes, for all the F#s on both rows and for the C#s on the D row. Then it really will be musically correct. Please indulge me! Thanks!  (:)

Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 31, 2011, 10:40:43 AM
Ok - another chart for D/G - this time it's got ABC equivalents.
Please see very slight tweak - the F natural (G row) ABC equivalent now has an =.  This is now accurate in respect of the key signature of G major
This chart was produced in consultation with Lester Bailey - thanks Lester!! :|glug

See it here:-

http://web.me.com/les.titford/daddylongles/daddylonglestabs_files/DG%20Notes%20ABC.gif


Just one final tweak please Les,  and I'll be happy!

On both the stave notation and on the letter names for the notes, please can we have the sharps shown as appropriate? I know you have a key signature at the beginning of the lines for G and D rows, but with the individual stave fragments being chopped up as they are (which is fine), it really needs to have the accidental # sign added to both the letter names and the notes, for all the F#s on both rows and for the C#s on the D row. Then it really will be musically correct. Please indulge me! Thanks!  (:)



Hi Steve,

Funnily enough - my original chart did have all the F's and C's with individual sharps but I thought with the key signature at the beginning everyone would say this was wrong so I pulled them all out.  Also, when I consulted with Lester about the ABC - again, I had all the F's and C's with the ^ -  he said this was unnecessary as they would already be raised with the K:G and K:D in the tune header so I pulled them out.  I'll have a look at it though.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 31, 2011, 11:04:13 AM
Hi Steve,

Funnily enough - my original chart did have all the F's and C's with individual sharps but I thought with the key signature at the beginning everyone would say this was wrong so I pulled them all out.  Also, when I consulted with Lester about the ABC - again, I had all the F's and C's with the ^ -  he said this was unnecessary as they would already be raised with the K:G and K:D in the tune header so I pulled them out.  I'll have a look at it though.
This is all true in the context of a tune, both in standard music notation and in ABC. However, for a layout chart, I feel it is important to have exactly the notes which are played shown adjacent to the buttons. Not everyone who consults the layout chart is going to be familiar with ABC or the meaning of ABC headers. 
(And even in standard music notation for classical musicians, a very useful 'reminder' sharp or flat is sometimes shown next to a note, even though might already be in the key signature and therefore is, strictly speaking, unnecessary. This is especially useful if the music has modulated through a set of keys, and the composer/transcriber wants to be sure that the player mentally 'switches over' to the new key.)

Thinking about it even more, it is rather restrictive to have the key signatures of G and D majors shown at the beginning of the line. Not every tune playable on a D/G melodeon is in those keys and therefore won't necessarily have those key signatures. However, you do need the treble clef at the beginning as this fixes where the note actually is in the range of musical pitches. Just lose the key signature and have all the sharps, flats (and F naturals) as accidentals in their appropriate places.
Title: Re: D/G chart with notes on the stave and ABC equivalents
Post by: Daddy Long Les on August 31, 2011, 11:07:27 AM
Hi Steve,

Funnily enough - my original chart did have all the F's and C's with individual sharps but I thought with the key signature at the beginning everyone would say this was wrong so I pulled them all out.  Also, when I consulted with Lester about the ABC - again, I had all the F's and C's with the ^ -  he said this was unnecessary as they would already be raised with the K:G and K:D in the tune header so I pulled them out.  I'll have a look at it though.
This is all true in the context of a tune, both in standard music notation and in ABC. However, for a layout chart, I feel it is important to have exactly the notes which are played shown adjacent to the buttons.
(And even in standard music notation for classical musicians, a very useful 'reminder' sharp or flat is sometimes shown next to a note, even though might already be in the key signature and therefore is, strictly speaking, unnecessary. This is especially useful if the music has modulated through a set of keys, and the composer/transcriber wants to be sure that the player mentally 'switches over' to the new key.)

Thinking about it even more, it is rather restrictive to have the key signatures of G and D majors shown at the beginning of the line. Not every tune playable on a D/G melodeon is in those keys and therefore won't necessarily have those key signatures. However, you do need the treble clef at the beginning as this fixes where the note actually is in the range of musical pitches. Just lose the key signature and have all the sharps, flats (and F naturals) as accidentals in their appropriate places.
Yep -fair point.  I'll have a look.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal