Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Brian G on August 15, 2008, 02:46:07 PM
-
Hello Again
I am getting close to buying a BCC# box with the stradella base system which I really want to learn. I am looking at one with 80 bass, like the Paolo Soprani Elite III. This box (16*5?)lacks the diminished chord row. Is this a big deal? When a piece of music calls for a dim chord can I substitute another?
thanks in advance for any assistance
Brian
-
That's exactly the system I play. I've never found the lack of a diminished chord row a problem. I suppose it depends on the music you want to play, but in my (fairly large) collection of Scottish music, which is the most frequent use of the BCC#, there's probably only a handful of tunes with diminished chords, and they're used infrequently. I'd probably play the chord before the diminished in its place, or the one after it, whichever sounds better. Or leave it out - it's past in a flash.
What kind of music will you play? Do diminished chords feature significantly? If not, you'll not miss them.
-
Hi Bill
I will play mostly Irish, Scottish (especially from my Jimmy Shand books which do have some dim chords) and Canadian Old Time fiddle music. I also play the fiddle. I do have some Canadian folk songs where I see some of those dim chords. But if the next chord up will do that will be fine.
thanks again for your assistance
Brian
-
If you're playing on your own you can use whichever chords you like, if you're playing in a group (in any sense) and the others are diminishing then you'd better diminish too, or hold your chords in abeyance. Of course you can play many diminished chords on the right hand of the B/C/C#; I would list all the possibilities but apparently that's not the done thing (mutter mutter).
In my view the diminished row on the stradella is far more useful than the 7th row 'cos you can fake a 7th with (say) Cmaj and B-flat bass, but there's no way you can fake a diminished. When I changed B/C/C# accordions from a 12x4 to a 8x6 I took out the 7th and dim chord rows to save my hand fouling on them, but recently I was trying to arrange a Carla Bley tune with an essential diminished chord and went to restore them, now I can't remember where I stored the relevant button shafts.