Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 12:14:42 PM

Title: concertinas
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 12:14:42 PM
Just playing with the idea of branching out to a concertina. Main reason being its portability Does any one have advice about which type (English or Anglo?) is easier to learn for someone who is used to the melodeon?  :||:
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Lester on September 01, 2011, 12:33:18 PM
Despite what people may tell you there is very little copy across between melodeon and concertina. Yes the Anglo is push/pull but the melody is in the dusty octave where not many of us play and the bass/chord needs a deal of work with multiple fingers.

You may guess from this that I play an English  ;D

Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: jackson10 on September 01, 2011, 12:39:02 PM
I learned english concertina before starting to play melodeon, but it to me the english concertina layout feels the most intuitive. I bought an anglo about 2 years ago to try that system and have not got the hang of it. When I bought the english years ago I was playing many tunes on it within a few days.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Theo on September 01, 2011, 01:07:10 PM
This question has been discussed over and over and over again on concertina.net.  The conclusion always seems to be:

1 Experienced players are nearly all advocates of their own chosen system being the only one worth considering
2 Some people seem to click with one system rather than another, but the only way you can find what suits you is to try it


there is very little copy across between melodeon and concertina. Yes the Anglo is push/pull but the melody is in the dusty octave where not many of us play and the bass/chord needs a deal of work with multiple fingers.

and another difference between anglo and melodeon is that the relation between the rows is different so anything you play across the rows on melodeon will not work on anglo.

I dabble with English and anglo in the course of repairing them, but decided a couple of years ago to make fiddle my second instrument because it is quite different.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: IanD on September 01, 2011, 01:20:16 PM
Just playing with the idea of branching out to a concertina. Main reason being its portability Does any one have advice about which type (English or Anglo?) is easier to learn for someone who is used to the melodeon?  :||:
[/quote

I played Anglo concertina before melodeon, and found it easy to switch -- at least, on the tune -- because if you stitch both ends of an Anglo together you pretty much have a 2-row melodeon (with no basses, obviously).

Though I can still play the Anglo I now find it difficult to go back to the much more restricted range.

If you want portability buy a Preciosa, they're not much bigger or heavier than an Anglo -- and a lot cheaper than a decent one, probably about half the price even if you buy the ready-converted D/G one that Theo's got ;-)

Ian
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: waldoB on September 01, 2011, 02:12:37 PM
I started a C/G Anglo after a B,C,C#. I find that with the C row as the central starting row with both, the sharps and flats fall comfortably with either instrument. Learn scales from the C row, and you'll know all the notes. Swapping between the two is not a problem.  Quite a challenge learning and playing left hand chords on the Anglo, but very satisfying.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Peter on September 01, 2011, 06:01:44 PM
This leads me on to thinking that I could convert my 2 1/2 row CF club to match the Anglos CG layout. What are the disadvantages of doing this, apart from ruining a prefectly good Hohner?

Peter
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Lester on September 01, 2011, 06:49:27 PM
This leads me on to thinking that I could convert my 2 1/2 row CF club to match the Anglos CG layout. What are the disadvantages of doing this, apart from ruining a prefectly good Hohner?

Peter

Try contacting Chris Timpson on concertina.net who owns an Anglodeon (made by Stormy Hyde) which is exactly what you are talking about I think.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 10:50:50 PM
Thanks gentlemen I'm aware that the answer to most questions on squeezeboxes is 'depends' but that does give me something to work on Second answer is 'try one and see' which I shall do in  due course. Unfortunately Ed Rennie's beginners workshop at dartmoor didn't include concertinas this year  :(
Showing my further ignorance What is a Preciosa?  ??? :||:
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Peter G on September 01, 2011, 10:54:53 PM


I dabble with English and anglo in the course of repairing them, but decided a couple of years ago to make fiddle my second instrument because it is quite different.
[/quote]
Mm Thought of the fiddle before I took  up the melodeon , but decided I couldn't put my partner and the dogs through the screeching cat phase!
 ;D
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Theo on September 01, 2011, 11:16:05 PM
Hohner Preciosa is the smallest practical melodeon made by Hohner in the 1930s.  Its a two voice club system, 25 treble buttons, 8 bass all in a case smaller than a Castagnari Lilly.   A remarkable design.
Here is a youtube example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POsAsKADGH4  (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=POsAsKADGH4)
and another http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YD0PIq0hJpc (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YD0PIq0hJpc)

These are both the more common early type, there is a scarcer later model like the one I have for sale shown here. This one can also be found in a dark reddish brown celluloid finish.

Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 01, 2011, 11:21:10 PM
Dear god I'm tempted. I even have the cash. I also have a wife with a vengeful eye. Hmm.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Theo on September 01, 2011, 11:36:36 PM
Dear god I'm tempted. I even have the cash. I also have a wife with a vengeful eye. Hmm.

Its very easy to hide - will fit in a shoe box!
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 01, 2011, 11:44:10 PM
Plus Anglos in skilled hands are by far and away a superior instrument to the English  (that should spark some debate....)

Debate? I think not!  :D
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 01, 2011, 11:45:47 PM
Its very easy to hide - will fit in a shoe box!

Theo really, that's not helpful at all.  >:E
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Owen Woods on September 01, 2011, 11:59:53 PM
If it helps, from just playing around with other people's 'tinas, English is WAY easier than anglo. I'd get a duet though.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Howard Jones on September 02, 2011, 12:13:08 AM
To get back to the question, I played anglo before taking up melodeon and found the latter quite easy to get to grips with because I was already used to the idea of push-pull, which for many novice players on both instruments is a major hurdle.  Similar concepts about use of bellows and the air button also apply, although the way they are applied are somewhat different.

However apart from these there really isn't much else which can be taken from one to the other.  Except in the most basic terms (ie playing a scale up the rows) the fingering is in fact quite different.  I find this is actually a plus, since it means that some tunes which aren't particularly easy or satisfactory to play on one instrument may be ideally suited to the other.

The only way to know which concertina suits you is to try them.  Unlike ukebert, I don't find English easy, I can't handle the way the scale is constantly swapping between hands, and I want to pump the bellows.  However if I were starting again, I might consider a duet - but which system?  Many hours have been spent on concertina.net arguing the merits of the various types, but as Theo has pointed out, without coming to a conclusion.

Another point to consider is which concertina players have inspired you to take up the instrument?  Although this doesn't always work - for me, it was Tony Rose who played English, but I didn't know the difference and just got a concertina, which turned out to be an anglo.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2011, 10:52:01 AM
Its very easy to hide - will fit in a shoe box!

Theo really, that's not helpful at all.  >:E

21x21x12cm, 2kg  >:E

Ian
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 02, 2011, 04:12:09 PM
This one can also be found in a dark reddish brown celluloid finish.

That's not how most people describe the colour of mine...  You must have polite friends!  They don't sound like a concertina, but the tone and harmonics are somewhat similar - but then you don't often hear a two-voice concertina.

Actually the transition from along the row styles to and from melodeon and anglo is pretty simple, cross-rowing is more difficult to transfer as it is an inverted mirror image (I think) - but you have an idea whether it is available.  It seems to help that they are just sufficiently different that you don't try to play one with the fingering of the other.  Simple three chord trick accompaniments on the left hand are simple in the home keys, but that style doesn't do justice to what the instrument can achieve.  The anglo player in the ceilidh band often "suggests" that I drop a chord as it clashes with the accompaniment he can do. 

If you want to pump the bellows on an English, why not?  I wish more PA players would.

Rob.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 02, 2011, 10:44:04 PM
21x21x12cm, 2kg  >:E

Ian

This, of course, simply compounds the felony.  ::)
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Ollie on September 03, 2011, 01:59:37 AM

If you want to pump the bellows on an English, why not?  I wish more PA players would.

Rob.

One of my favourite concertina players is Robert Harbron, who plays EC in a very punchy, 'melodeon-like' way. Here is a brilliant example of his playing - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7PUpgTLiIY
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: doktorfolkenstein on September 03, 2011, 05:03:17 AM
I started playing Anglo before the melodeon, and oddly enough initially found that the melodeon left hand tripped me up as I was so used to individual notes for both hands; although when I tried learning PA ages ago stradella bass drove me insane so I sold the infernal thing. And in only tangentially related news, on vacation last week I let a family friend who had PA lessons inflicted upon him as a child and still keeps the instrument around for special occasions take a shufti at my old crappy Hohner Anglo; the push/pull totally mystified him, even after I explained how similar it was to a harmonica...
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 03, 2011, 08:13:11 AM
One of my favourite concertina players is Robert Harbron, who plays EC in a very punchy, 'melodeon-like' way. Here is a brilliant example of his playing - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7PUpgTLiIY

Fabulous dance too - I just love experimental Morris.  Their stick dance somehow 'out-Litchfields' Litchfield  :o Thanks C
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Theo on September 03, 2011, 08:49:09 AM
Rob is a great example of how you can get a huge rhythmic drive without having an um-pah bass.  It's all in the bellows!
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 03, 2011, 11:02:32 AM
I did a full day tunes workshop with Rob Harbron some time ago which wasn't instrument specific but the concertinas were out in force. Rob developed his punchy style because he wanted to play in Irish sessions and was told that he had 'the wrong kind of concertina for ITM'. In addition to frequent bellows reversals Rob developed a technique that requires lots of practise to get right. Unusually he rests the middle of the bellows across his knee rather than one end of the concertina, carefully controlled foot tapping now adds some real punch in places. Some Irish style anglo players tap a non playing finger on the opposite end to the note being played to create an explosive pop, the bellows across the knee and foot tapping has a similar effect and then some. Moving the foot up and down without actually tapping it on the floor creates a circular, throbbing pulse which is very effective.

It was interesting to see that Rob now uses wrist straps, this adds quite a lot of stability and helps with bellows control on the pull.
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: malcolmbebb on September 03, 2011, 11:19:13 AM
I was persuaded to start with an Anglo, and went from there to melodeon as well. Still very much a beginner in both. However, I find I can easily move G row melody from a C/G to D/G melodeon and back, and similarly D row from a D/G Anglo to D/G melodeon.

The fact that I'm on a different hand doesn't seem to affect matters. But obviously, I only play simple tunes.

The concertina is very portable and seductively easy to just pick up and play. No straps, doesn't matter too much whether your chair has arms.

Working away from home, the melodeon wasn't getting practised. But (fair warning:  >:E) I now have a Liliput which is much easier to pack (it fits in my holdall and is roughly the same size as a Preciosa) and it's now giving the concertinas a run for their money.

Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: oggiesnr on September 03, 2011, 03:24:42 PM

I did a full day tunes workshop with Rob Harbron some time ago which wasn't instrument specific but the concertinas were out in force. Rob developed his punchy style because he wanted to play in Irish sessions and was told that he had 'the wrong kind of concertina for ITM'.


Interesting as the first person I heard playing ITM on a concertina was Ali Anderson on an english and my first thought when I heard the traditional irish players playing this melodic style on an anglo was "what a waste of it's capabilities!  Why don't they use an English?"

But, in my defence, I was young then  (:)

Steve
Title: Re: concertinas
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 04, 2011, 07:21:21 PM
I don't know why ITM is played largely on anglos, people like Alistair can certainly keep up with the faster players and put as much punch into the tunes. I guess you would have to say it's become largely 'traditional', although by no means universal to use anglos for Irish music. One of the posters on concertina.net even has an English he built himself that has major modifications to help him play in the Irish style and jolly good he is at it too!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal