Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Ptarmigan on August 16, 2008, 02:00:13 PM

Title: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on August 16, 2008, 02:00:13 PM
Following on from my first dumb Melodeon beginners question!  ::)

Here's another!  :-[

Does anyone here actually wear TWO straps?

I started off squeezing myself into both of them, but felt like I was getting ready to be carted off in a wee yellow van.

I've since removed the left, Bass end, strap & I must say it feels much, much more comfortable & I can use the bellows much more easily now.

If this is so for everyone, why do they bother with the Bass bracket & strap at all?

Cheers
Ptarmi
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill Young on August 16, 2008, 02:28:24 PM
Following on from my first dumb Melodeon beginners question!  ::)

Here's another!  :-[

Does anyone here actually wear TWO straps?

I started off squeezing myself into both of them, but felt like I was getting ready to be carted off in a wee yellow van.

I've since removed the left, Bass end, strap & I must say it feels much, much more comfortable & I can use the bellows much more easily now.

If this is so for everyone, why do they bother with the Bass bracket & strap at all?

Cheers
Ptarmi
??? What are you talking about? Did you have a shoulder strap attached to the BASS side of the melodeon? Both shoulder straps are attached to the treble end, so that the bellows are free to move. The only strap on the bass end is the one over the wrist. What is the Bass bracket you mention?
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on August 16, 2008, 02:43:04 PM
Sorry Bill, I obviously didn't make that clear.

On the top, & bottom, of the treble end of my Hohner Melodeon there are two brackets - right beside each other, but at a slight angle from each other. They are clearly angled to suit either shoulder.

Speaking of the Bass strap. I must admit, I find that to be very tight indeed, a bit uncomfortable & makes it a little difficult for me to use the bass buttons. Is it a simple job to replace this strap with a slightly longer one?

Cheers
Ptarmi

P.S. I suspect that both shoulder straps would have to be worn if one were standing up to play!
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill Young on August 16, 2008, 03:54:13 PM
Sorry, I misunderstood your reference to Bass. We would usually refer to left and right straps.

If you do a search on old posts, you'll find many references to one and two straps, each having their adherents. A lot would depend on the size/weight of the instrument, and whether playing seated or standing. I've recently put two straps instead of one on a small size box, because with one it was flapping about too much.

With regard to the bass hand strap, depending how it's fixed, you may find that additional mounting screw holes can be put in your existing strap to lengthen it. If it's a Hohner with external mounting screws, it will be obvious if it can be lengthened. If it is fixed internally, you'd need to take off the bass end plate to see. If lengthening isn't possible, replacement straps are available e.g from Charlie Marshall; Allodi Accordions; and possibly Theo - see Shops and Repairers (http://info.melodeon.net/links/shops) on the main website
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill Young on August 16, 2008, 04:07:44 PM
If lengthening isn't possible, replacement straps are available e.g from Charlie Marshall; Allodi Accordions; and possibly Theo - see Shops and Repairers (http://info.melodeon.net/links/shops) on the main website
Hmmm, having given that reference, I see Charlie Marshall's website is being reconstructed. He usually advertises on eBay, and he has a lot of parts currently listed HERE (http://search.ebay.co.uk/_W0QQfrtsZ0QQsassZcharliecgm).
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ellie on August 16, 2008, 04:27:52 PM
Quote from: Ptarmigan
Speaking of the Bass strap. I must admit, I find that to be very tight indeed, a bit uncomfortable & makes it a little difficult for me to use the bass buttons. Is it a simple job to replace this strap with a slightly longer one?

I've had the opposite problem with mine-  twice thus far I've had to make extra holes to make it smaller - the leather seems to stretch fairly quickly if you're playing regularly.

I'm a two strap lady - cannot play at all with one - it's a mystery to me, all these players that can do it!
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: TooManyButtons on August 22, 2008, 09:42:42 AM
 I'll play with either one or two - but have a serious preference for one strap with a footrest (if standing), only one if seated. I just don't seem to be able to extract anything like the response from the box if I use the left strap - everything becomes a wrestling match and eventually the left strap falls off the shoulder, no matter how tight it is.

 If anyone has any ideas, I'd love some to try as well...

Cheers!
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lester on August 22, 2008, 09:48:43 AM
I'll play with either one or two - but have a serious preference for one strap with a footrest (if standing), only one if seated. I just don't seem to be able to extract anything like the response from the box if I use the left strap - everything becomes a wrestling match and eventually the left strap falls off the shoulder, no matter how tight it is.

 If anyone has any ideas, I'd love some to try as well...

Cheers!

Don't use two straps  ::)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: TooManyButtons on August 22, 2008, 10:18:43 AM
 ;D ;D ahem - when you can't get a seat or a footrest at a session? (ok, find another session  :P
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on August 22, 2008, 10:34:15 AM
One of the melodeon players in our morris side puts the strap over her head, so it's on her left shoulder. She's the only person I've noticed doing that, but it works for her. It's more stable than just hanging the strap on your right shoulder and it can't fall off.

Edit: spelling
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lester on August 22, 2008, 11:34:30 AM
;D ;D ahem - when you can't get a seat or a footrest at a session? (ok, find another session  :P

If you look at my avatar you will see how I manage with just one strap. Mind you have used my ample stomach as a rest for many years, but as it is now rapidly disappearing (hint for Witney people it would be really good to say things like "My you are looking thin Lester") I may have to reconsider.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on August 22, 2008, 12:21:17 PM
Lester, I notice you have a small one, { Melodeon I mean } .  ;D

So I'm wondering if perhaps different rules apply when using a tiny Lilly as opposed to how you would use a strap, or two straps, when playing something like an old Hohner, which must surely be at least twice the size of that little one of yours & twice as heavy, too?


Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lester on August 22, 2008, 12:32:13 PM
Lester, I notice you have a small one, { Melodeon I mean } .  ;D

So I'm wondering if perhaps different rules apply when using a tiny Lilly as opposed to how you would use a strap, or two straps, when playing something like an old Hohner, which must surely be at least twice the size of that little one of yours & twice as heavy, too?

Just shows how fat I was, it is actually a Tommy. I have always played with a single strap on Pokerworks, Ericas, Toomy, Elfique (current) and even a Connemarra 3. So dispite what you may have heard sixe doesn't matter
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Pushpull on August 22, 2008, 02:10:06 PM
Just shows how fat I was, it is actually a Tommy. I have always played with a single strap on Pokerworks, Ericas, Toomy, Elfique (current) and even a Connemarra 3. So dispite what you may have heard sixe doesn't matter
I would agree with Lester that size doesn't matter. I think most players I see use 1 strap even on some quite big boxes. I, being weedy and possibly a bit rubbish too, use two even on a Tommy.

Roy.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on August 22, 2008, 02:23:30 PM
Fair enough guys.

However, I'll be honest, what worried me was the thought that perhaps lots of players were going with one strap, simply because they were under the impression that it wasn't regarded as COOL to be seen using two straps!  ::)

Now I have never, ever been a follower of fashion & I've always resisted the urge to follow the crowd, like a sheep.

So I'm really keen to know what is the best way to use one strap or two
A: for comfort
&
B: for ease of playing

Lester, if you think you had a wide middle ~ you should see mine, so you'd know that clearly I don't really give a hang what I look like, myself. I couldn't care less about my self image. I'm far too long in the tooth for all that nonsense!
I just want to be able to play the darn thing with ease & comfort.
With that in mind, I would like to start off the RIGHT way.
So I'm delighted to be getting all this feedback.

Cheers
Ptarmi
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Pete Dunk on August 24, 2008, 07:51:20 PM
Does anyone here actually wear TWO straps?
I do for one. Here you go again with a question that is really a matter of personal preference, there simply isn't a right or wrong answer. My box came with a single strap and I didn't like playing like that at all, so I bought a pair of straps for a 96 bass accordion which are pretty long to start with and I have the right hand strap on it's longest setting and the left hand one notch shorter. I find it comfortable and stable, other players might consider this ridiculous but they're not playing my box from my perspective.

If you have two straps then try all of the options (one, two, longer, shorter ...) and decide for yourself. Like you I've never been a victim of peer pressure or fashion, in fact when I was young I used to watch which way the sheep (siblings, school friends etc) went and deliberately did the opposite (even if the sheep were going in the right direction!)

Pete.  ;)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on August 24, 2008, 08:15:06 PM
Yes Pete,

I do realise it's all a matter of choice, but still I am curious to hear how folks came to their own decision for using one or two straps.

The young folks here won't remember this, but I learned to drive when you didn't HAVE to wear your seatbelt, but right from day one I always have, quite simply because not only did I feel much safer, but I also felt much more comfortable with my seatbelt on.

I find I have a little more freedom with just one strap on, but I must say I prefer the solid feeling I get with two straps on & the box pressed firmly against me. So I think I'll be going with two straps, after all.

Thanks guys
Ptarmi
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Theo on August 24, 2008, 08:17:43 PM
I use two straps too.  Played with one strap for years, but could not manage standing.  When I was asked to play outside of some clog dancers I used a second strap, and now prefer two straps for the freedom of movement it gives.   I still sometimes use one strap when sitting in a session.

It is entirely a personal choice, find what suits you.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lars on August 24, 2008, 08:45:44 PM
I find that two straps gives me more freedom for doing rolls and other ornamentation on a two row. I find that I start playing more or less just up and down the rows when I use a single strap.

But then, when I play my one-row I use only one strap.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Quebecois on August 24, 2008, 09:58:56 PM
Two straps here too. Stability, control, and freedom of playing standing or sitting. I tried one strap, and found out that my hands had to both maintain the melodeon in position and play, which was neither effective nor comfortable. I use simple 1-inch wide leather straps (not padded).

My father played for decades with a thumbstrap and the melodeon on his knee, then switched to using two straps when he got his Corso.

 

Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lester on August 25, 2008, 11:06:33 AM
One strap only. Find two constricting and uncomfortable as it (IMO) forces my wrists in to an unnatural position. Put probably just that:
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: pipives on August 25, 2008, 11:25:38 AM

Does anyone here actually wear TWO straps?

Cheers
Ptarmi

I used to wear two straps all the time, but it really is personal preference.

With myself it came down to size & weight of melodeon and me! I started playing when I was 8 so had to wear two straps to keep control of the thing. Then when I was about 15 my parents  spoilt me (early 18th birthday present) with a 3 row 3 voice saltarelle, so i had to have it on two straps coz of the weight of the beast.

Recently however, I've gone back to playing 2 voice 2 rows (old hohners tweaked a bit) and being fully grown now (i Hope) can manage them comfotably on 1 strap as they're very light compared with what I was used to!
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Stiamh on August 25, 2008, 02:02:10 PM
Being able to use one strap when seated is a knack that just comes with practice. Before it did, I tried using two but the left one always fell off. Also experimented with various other extreme possibilities such as sitting on the left strap, or poking my head through a single long right strap and winding it around my back.

But If I did want to play standing, I don't think I could deal with using just one. It generally makes you look too silly anyway. Of course Lester with his ample girth and minuscule melodeon definitely has panache.  :P But those long skinny players with their 18-bass l/h cabinet drooping down at groin level - do they imagine they come across like Jimmy Page, or what?
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Alison Scott on August 26, 2008, 12:23:13 PM
I use two straps (and play small boxes only). For Morris it's stable when standing (I don't take a hard case out with me so would be stuck for a footrest a lot of the time). When seated I have observed that my left strap slips off my shoulder a lot of the time so I suspect I am in practice only using one strap; the second is redundant. But I'm not about to change straps every time I stand up!

Saul Rose plays an enormous box with one strap. I've heard it's not good for your back, but I'm not sure there's any actual evidence one way or the other.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: george garside on August 26, 2008, 03:46:08 PM
I use two straps (and play small boxes only). For Morris it's stable when standing (I don't take a hard case out with me so would be stuck for a footrest a lot of the time). When seated I have observed that my left strap slips off my shoulder a lot of the time so I suspect I am in practice only using one strap; the second is redundant. But I'm not about to change straps every time I stand up!

Saul Rose plays an enormous box with one strap. I've heard it's not good for your back, but I'm not sure there's any actual evidence one way or the other.

2" wide padded shoulder straps shouldn't fall off - the other way of keeping them on when seated is to use a backstrap  which I personally don't like but they seem to be slowly gaining in popularity.  As far as one strap there is plenty of evidence (anecdotal in the main) that it can contribute to back problems and slao shoulder & neck problems  as can playing all the time with bellows at full stretch & being waved oround in all directions!

george
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill Young on August 26, 2008, 06:27:42 PM
. . . When seated I have observed that my left strap slips off my shoulder a lot of the time so I suspect I am in practice only using one strap; the second is redundant. But I'm not about to change straps every time I stand up!

It may be that your left strap is not tight enough.
The Roland accordion group on Yahoo published an article on accordion strap adjustment. Although it is aimed at piano accordion players, it may be of interest/use to melodeon players. I certainly endorse its recommendation of Neotech straps, from personal use. I've attached a .pdf of the article.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 08, 2008, 12:27:09 PM
I've tried everything I can think of .  I still play the Pokerwork on one strap - but really only for Border Morris, so the tunes are generally not too demanding and, of course, the box is quite light and slightly limited by its agricultural action.  My Castagnari Trilly requires two straps due to the weight (around 5 kgs), whether for North West Morris or Ceilidh.  I may even go back to using a backstrap if we start using tunes with particularly fast, rythmic and energetic bellows changes or quick access to the accidentals!  I recently managed to acquire a Castagnari Max which plays beautifully on a single strap, being light and with fast action as I was finding it incerasingly difficult each year to play a Hohner four-stop with the gusto I liked.  Yes, I even put the Hohner's strap over my head at times if my back was playing up, making me even more round shouldered so the strap slipped off.

However, if playing seated and in a more composed manner than the typical Morris bash, I am most comfortable curled round the box with a single strap!

Rob.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Sandy on September 08, 2008, 11:41:06 PM
It's much easier sorting your bra straps out!!!
maybe a strapless melodeon would be a test for all!!!
(sorry, am I allowed to say that?)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: george garside on September 09, 2008, 10:01:43 AM
just a thought, but the left strap lipping off the shoulder    could be down to

- having a tendency to lean to the left as many one strappers seem to do
- drooping rather than standing or sitting upright with shoulders back ( which is much better for posture)
- using much greater bellows opening than is required for the tune resulting in the left shoulder dropping and the left arm forming a slope for the straps to slide down
-  incorrect strap adjustment - left strap should be shorter than right to bring keyboard under chin - both straps adjusted so that top of box is roughly an extended handwidth below the chin when looking strait ahead.
- wearing slippery garments
- not using reasonably wide straps


 probably   other reasons as well

george





Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Ptarmigan on September 09, 2008, 10:58:38 AM
Quote
It's much easier sorting your bra straps out!!!
maybe a strapless melodeon would be a test for all!!!

Ah but Sandy, would it be safe for someone to play a strapless Melodeon, while wearing a strapless Bra?  :o
{Of course, I've absolutely no intention of trying that out myself ........ honest! :-[ }

Strange I know, but these are things us men think about ......... all the time!  ;)

Mind you, it sounds about as safe as it might be, for a man to play a Piano Accordion in a Nudist colony, while seated!

(http://bestsmileys.com/lol/4.gif)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: george garside on September 09, 2008, 12:15:22 PM
Quote from:  about ......... all the time!  ;)

Mind you, it sounds about as safe as it might be, for a man to play a Piano Accordion in a Nudist colony, while seated!

[img
http://bestsmileys.com/lol/4.gif[/img]


only dangerous if he gets a bit exited! :o
george
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill Young on September 09, 2008, 03:07:58 PM

Mind you, it sounds about as safe as it might be, for a man to play a Piano Accordion in a Nudist colony, while seated!

Definitely an occasion to keep the bottom bellows strap fastened!
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on September 09, 2008, 03:20:22 PM
I've just bought a Hohner Club IB off of German Ebay. It doesn't have a thumbstrap and it has no shoulder straps, but does have strap brackets. I've been playing it quite happily sitting on my knee with no straps for a few days now. I'm not quite sure how that works, but it does. Yesterday I put a strap on it and found it awkward, both sitting down and standing up, because my left wrist was pressing into the rear edge of the bass end. I'll have to try a longer/shorter/two straps to see if that works better. Ho Hum  ;D
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: smiley on September 11, 2008, 05:53:21 AM
I've solved the problem of the left strap dropping off my shoulder by attaching the strap top & bottom through the loops of the right hand strap, rather than attaching it to the box itself. I got the idea from watching Oliver Diviney playing once. Hope you can follow what I'm describing.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: george garside on September 11, 2008, 09:58:15 AM
I've solved the problem of the left strap dropping off my shoulder by attaching the strap top & bottom through the loops of the right hand strap, rather than attaching it to the box itself. I got the idea from watching Oliver Diviney playing once. Hope you can follow what I'm describing.


this is also a useful way of trying out 2 straps if your box only has  a one strap bracket and there is no reason why it should not be then kept that way if it feels ok.  The only reason I can see for it preventing the lef strap slipping offf shoulder is because the left strap will be at a slightly different ange than when attached to bracket, shortening the left strap should do much the same in theory but as we are all of different dimensions whatever floats yer boat!

george
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: joe on September 11, 2008, 12:21:05 PM
I think there isnt a correct answer to 1 or 2, preference seems to be the order of the day. I play with 1 strap and find its fine for playing sitting, standing, lying, upside down, etc. I dont have any trouble reaching any buttons on the R hand either.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Quebecois on September 11, 2008, 05:14:41 PM
Has anyone ever tried using a  ;D neck strap with a lightweight box?!?
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bill the Farmer on September 11, 2008, 05:27:27 PM
I know a man who plays a fiddle with one   :o
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Lester on September 11, 2008, 05:29:04 PM
Has anyone ever tried using a  ;D neck strap with a lightweight box?!?
Yes! but there again the box in question was a Wheatstone Aeola 48 key English Concertina. As it happens I found it really uncomfortable.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: george garside on September 11, 2008, 06:17:36 PM
it may well at worst bugger up the neck muscles and at best  not help with posture. Strangulation is of course a resonable possibility  but  then those so effected would not be here to worry about it!

george ;)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 11, 2008, 07:50:22 PM
Strangulation is of course a reasonable possibility but then those so effected would not be here to worry about it!
There seems to be a lot cheering coming from the general direction of Concertina.net, or is that just my imagination?  ;D
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Quebecois on September 12, 2008, 02:53:01 PM
I might be tempted to try the guitar strap setup, where a wide strap goes over the left shoulder, and down under the right arm.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Doug Anderson on September 22, 2008, 07:27:49 PM
At the Northeast Squeeze-In this past weekend it appeared that most (maybe all) of the semitone DBA players were using one strap and most (maybe all) of the quint DBA players were using two straps. It certainly looked like an image thing. I also saw two quint DBA players using back straps as well.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Bryson on September 22, 2008, 10:20:22 PM
What's a "quint DBA player" or have I missed something?
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Stiamh on September 22, 2008, 10:23:52 PM
What's a "quint DBA player" or have I missed something?

It's a misprint for "quaint diatonic button accordion player" - and means anybody playing a D/G, C/F, G/C, etc.  ;)
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Doug Anderson on September 22, 2008, 11:53:52 PM
What's a "quint DBA player" or have I missed something?
It's a misprint for "quaint diatonic button accordion player" - and means anybody playing a D/G, C/F, G/C, etc.  ;)
Sorry for the confusion. Steve has it right :-) It's a box with the inside row tuned five semitones above the outside row.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: The Hohner Droner on September 29, 2008, 09:42:20 PM
I use two shoulder straps and a thumbstrap. I figure that, as I have paid £800 for the melodeon, I'm going to use every bit of it. Mind you, there are still a few buttons unused. I wonder if I could get a few quid refunded?
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Quebecois on September 29, 2008, 09:59:37 PM
Sorry for the confusion. Steve has it right :-) It's a box with the inside row tuned five semitones above the outside row.

Errr... I think a "fourth" is in fact 5 semitones, a "quint" (or fifth) is 7 semitones.
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: strad on December 21, 2008, 05:08:06 PM
This topic brings up the question - Is two straps one too many or one strap one too few?? ;D
Title: Re: One STRAP too many?
Post by: Howard Jones on January 11, 2009, 07:40:12 PM
I always used always to play with one strap.  Sitting down I'd cross my legs and brace the instrument against my thigh, and push against the shoulder strap.  Standing was a bit more difficult but I seemed to manage.

Part of the reason was that two straps didn't seem cool, all the players I admired seemed to use only one.  The other reason was that using two straps seemed to lash the instrument close against my body, and I found it awkward to play like this.

Now I'm older and more decrepit, I've found that playing cross-legged for too long can bring on sciatica.  But I've found a way of attaching the top of the right strap to the left strap (rather than to the bracket) which holds the instrument tight so it doesn't move about but allows the box to hang away from my body a bit, which I find is a more comfortable angle for playing.  So now I've changed to playing with 2 straps (I never was cool anyway).

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal