Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Cooper on September 06, 2011, 09:55:12 PM
-
Hey!
I was wondering if you lot had useful applications on your molbile phones, considering folk or melodeons.
I've got a Nokia, so i think it is Symbian that i use.
folderplay is a useful player. It just plays from folders instead of having to make playlists or having to use labels on the mp3's. Many of my files are unlabeled as they come from lp's and not cd's...
i use the voicerecorder a lot. just the inbuilt one, for remembering tunes that i just made up.
the musicians swiss knife,... i have it on my phone, but hardky ever use it. Ity's mostly a metronome
chromatic tuner. dont use it for my melodeons, but for everything else :-)
Anything that you find very useful or fun?
W
-
Zaps ABC is pretty useful (Android) - I keep all my Morris tunes in abc on the phone and can then either view them as dots or play them as MIDI files
-
Tunepal seems quite good. It's a bit like 'folk shazam'. You play a tune at it and it identifies it, shows you the ABC and dots, and directs you to youtube videos of it. The database (mainly thesession.org and a few others) seems to be rather skewed towards Irish music but it's fun testing it, and it has potential at sessions.
I also use Tunebook, which sounds similar to Zaps ABC. It's great as a way of 'finding the dots' and a library.
Hohner DeeGee/CeeEf etc are fun. A melodeon on your iPhone. Great for irritating your wife when you haven't got your melodeon to hand....
D
-
Tunepal seems quite good. It's a bit like 'folk shazam'. You play a tune at it and it identifies it, shows you the ABC and dots, and directs you to youtube videos of it. The database (mainly thesession.org and a few others) seems to be rather skewed towards Irish music but it's fun testing it, and it has potential at sessions.
I also use Tunebook, which sounds similar to Zaps ABC. It's great as a way of 'finding the dots' and a library.
Hohner DeeGee/CeeEf etc are fun. A melodeon on your iPhone. Great for irritating your wife when you haven't got your melodeon to hand....
D
A friend of mine has Tunepal. Great fun! More fun testing it than using it though.
The one that I want is Tunebook (I think it is), which takes a page full of abcs and converts them to a tunebook with dots. Amazing thing. Means that you can get yourself a tunebook with hundreds of tunes in within a few minutes and completely for free.
-
Are there any meldoeon simulator apps for Android yet?
-
Yes.
-
Assuming the 'yes' was in answer to my question - I see I didn't phrase it correctly - what name(s) melodeon apps exist? iOS progs I can find, accompanied by requests for Android etc versions, but not tracked down an Android app. Thanks
-
As my first ever shiny new Android phone is waiting for me at home today, I'm interested too - but a quick Google search for "Android" and "melodeon" suggests that there's lots... (http://app.downloadatoz.com/search.php?q=melodeon&cx=006498651367527826191%3A-wr9plctlpc&cof=FORID%3A10&ie=UTF-8)
-
As my first ever shiny new Android phone is waiting for me at home today, I'm interested too - but a quick Google search for "Android" and "melodeon" suggests that there's lots... (http://app.downloadatoz.com/search.php?q=melodeon&cx=006498651367527826191%3A-wr9plctlpc&cof=FORID%3A10&ie=UTF-8)
all iPhone AFAICT
I've been corresponding with seisiuneer of this parish, who says he's going to be working on converting his iPhone apps to Android in the next few months.
Isn't it strange how things synchronise? my new Android phone arrived yesterday.
-
I just got myself an android phone, so i went around and look for stuff.
Not much to find i think? All those melodeon-thingies are for iPhones.
Couldnt find tunebook,...and tunepal is quite expensive, dont they have a trial-version or something?
I did see an android version of a English Concertina :-)
W
-
Tunepal expensive? Maybe the pricing is different over here (USA) but I only paid $4.63 (2 cups of coffee at Starbucks).
In my first job as an apprentice in the Royal Navy back in 75 I earned £22 a fortnight but beer was cheaper then and we didn't have cell phones!
-
Tunepal expensive? Maybe the pricing is different over here (USA) but I only paid $4.63 (2 cups of coffee at Starbucks).
In my first job as an apprentice in the Royal Navy back in 75 I earned £22 a fortnight but beer was cheaper then and we didn't have cell phones!
I agree that tunepal seems far worth it. Not only for the storing of tunes but the best feature (although its not correct 100% or all that close) is the shazam-like feature that can tell you the name and dots of a tune just by listening to it at a session. I've even tried just singing/lilting a tune and its pretty good at getting that as well.
As my first ever shiny new Android phone is waiting for me at home today, I'm interested too - but a quick Google search for "Android" and "melodeon" suggests that there's lots... (http://app.downloadatoz.com/search.php?q=melodeon&cx=006498651367527826191%3A-wr9plctlpc&cof=FORID%3A10&ie=UTF-8)
all iPhone AFAICT
I've been corresponding with seisiuneer of this parish, who says he's going to be working on converting his iPhone apps to Android in the next few months.
Isn't it strange how things synchronise? my new Android phone arrived yesterday.
I've tried a lot of seisiuneer's ipad/ipod session instrument apps and have enjoyed everyone i tried. i'm almost tempted to pay the extra money for an ipad over an android tablet. almost....
-
We're in the process of porting many of the accordion apps over to Android, the three-row versions for Android tablets first. Just make sure you get one that supports the "Ice Cream Sandwich" or "Jellybean" versions of Android as the previous versions had terrible audio latency issues. Also, we're targeting the 7" and larger tablets initially for the full-size accordion apps, not the phones.
-
We're in the process of porting many of the accordion apps over to Android, the three-row versions for Android tablets first. Just make sure you get one that supports the "Ice Cream Sandwich" or "Jellybean" versions of Android as the previous versions had terrible audio latency issues. Also, we're targeting the 7" and larger tablets initially for the full-size accordion apps, not the phones.
I am excited for this! I have been hoping for this since I tried them on the iPad
-
We're in the process of porting many of the accordion apps over to Android, the three-row versions for Android tablets first. Just make sure you get one that supports the "Ice Cream Sandwich" or "Jellybean" versions of Android as the previous versions had terrible audio latency issues. Also, we're targeting the 7" and larger tablets initially for the full-size accordion apps, not the phones.
You have my vote. I have an ASUS Transformer waiting to be cloned to a box. Also have Samsung Galaxy S2 phone - awesome device.
-
We'll also probably bring the 2-row over once the 3 row are complete, then bring the iPhone versions over for the Android phones.
I'm hoping some of these will be done by Christmas. It's been a lot harder than we thought...
-
Couldnt find tunebook,...W
the tunebook equivilant for andriod is aABC music browser created by Steve Merrony
It can show abcs as sheet music, play them back etc, and has a search function. Works fine for me.
Louise
-
Tunepal expensive? Maybe the pricing is different over here (USA) but I only paid $4.63 (2 cups of coffee at Starbucks).
In my first job as an apprentice in the Royal Navy back in 75 I earned £22 a fortnight but beer was cheaper then and we didn't have cell phones!
Well, yes. I wasnt very clear and perhaps a bit spoiled. So far the only apps i payed for were 25ct in the googleplay-celebration action. Most of them were for free. All the apps i bought are very useful and about 20times cheaper. It's still not a lot of money,..on that i agree.
But i would like to try before i buy, mostly because i want to know how many tunes from my scene it knows. Breton-music lies in there, so for those it could work. I dont do much Irish et.
We'll also probably bring the 2-row over once the 3 row are complete, then bring the iPhone versions over for the Android phones.
I'm hoping some of these will be done by Christmas. It's been a lot harder than we thought...
I am very curious and would love to try it out sometime,
Couldnt find tunebook,...W
the tunebook equivilant for andriod is aABC music browser created by Steve Merrony
It can show abcs as sheet music, play them back etc, and has a search function. Works fine for me.
Louise
And you need to import your own database from somewhere? (just to be sure what kind of app it is)
W
-
And you need to import your own database from somewhere?
Yep, you have to have your abc files on the phone. The app just reads, displays and plays them
-
Tunepal expensive? Maybe the pricing is different over here (USA) but I only paid $4.63 (2 cups of coffee at Starbucks).
In my first job as an apprentice in the Royal Navy back in 75 I earned £22 a fortnight but beer was cheaper then and we didn't have cell phones!
Well, yes. I wasnt very clear and perhaps a bit spoiled. So far the only apps i payed for were 25ct in the googleplay-celebration action. Most of them were for free. All the apps i bought are very useful and about 20times cheaper. It's still not a lot of money,..on that i agree.
But i would like to try before i buy, mostly because i want to know how many tunes from my scene it knows. Breton-music lies in there, so for those it could work. I dont do much Irish et.
Tunepal uses online collections to search for its tunes. You could search them on your computer and see how many Breton or whichever tradition you're looking for.
From the tunepal website (www.tunepal.org (http://www.tunepal.org)):
tunepal.org currently has a database of over 16,000 tunes from these collections: thesession.org, Henrik Norbeck, O'Neill's 1001, Ceol Rince na hÉireann, Johnny O'Leary of Sliabh Luachra, The Microphone Rambles, John Tose (Welsh Tunes), Jack Campin (Scottish Flute Tunes), The Company of Fyfers & Drummers, the Nottingham Music Database and Aird's Airs.
As an Irish player I know just about every tune I look for comes up on one or both of the first two collections.
-
We're in the process of porting many of the accordion apps over to Android, the three-row versions for Android tablets first. Just make sure you get one that supports the "Ice Cream Sandwich" or "Jellybean" versions of Android as the previous versions had terrible audio latency issues. Also, we're targeting the 7" and larger tablets initially for the full-size accordion apps, not the phones.
Can I add an iPhone version of my C/F declubbed 2.5 row Liliput to the list please? :)
In fact, what would be ideal would be an app where you could have a 2.5 row iPhone melodeon and can define what notes are played by what buttons. Then you could have whatever layout you liked!
-
In fact, what would be ideal would be an app where you could have a 2.5 row iPhone melodeon and can define what notes are played by what buttons. Then you could have whatever layout you liked!
Plus, this would be ideal for testing potential layouts (within the limitations of the artificial interface), at least to get a feel for wether it will do what you want before ripping into a perfectly good box.
-
Something to consider: user-definable layouts, e.g.: number of rows, buttons per row, note assignment, etc. for both sides. Would be neat of not too difficult to do.
-
datunerLITE and gStrings are both free and work on Android.
They are very good and accurate tuners .
-
Just started playing with Tunepal on my Android.
Simple questions:
- where do I put an ABC file on my android so that Tunepal will 'import' it and search it/
- anyway to get it to search 'english' abc databases
otherwise think I might hit the refund button :(
Thanks, Andy
-
If it's the same as the iPhone Tunepal...
Do My Tunes - Edit, then click Add Tune. You can then paste the ABC into the window that comes up, over the "bare bones" ABC that comes up as a default. Then save it and there it is.
There is a section where you can choose what "Tune Books" it looks under. I think to add one you may have to contact the developer.
-
If it's the same as the iPhone Tunepal...
Do My Tunes - Edit, then click Add Tune. You can then paste the ABC into the window that comes up, over the "bare bones" ABC that comes up as a default. Then save it and there it is.
There is a section where you can choose what "Tune Books" it looks under. I think to add one you may have to contact the developer.
It is the same as the iphone version. I've used both.
Also another way I suppose you could add a tune would be to add to the actual tunebook collection. Like submit a tune to thesession.org and then you'll be able to search for it in tunepal. Probably not the best way to go about adding one but it should work.
-
Simple questions:
- where do I put an ABC file on my android so that Tunepal will 'import' it and search it/
- anyway to get it to search 'english' abc databases
I put my abc files on my external sd card and it just found them when hit the More button and selected ABC file to view and Import an ABC file to bring into My Tunes. I also copied a file to the internal sd card and it found that file also...
Don't understand the question search 'english' abc databases. Are you searching for the word english?
-
Simple questions:
- where do I put an ABC file on my android so that Tunepal will 'import' it and search it/
- anyway to get it to search 'english' abc databases
I put my abc files on my external sd card and it just found them when hit the More button and selected ABC file to view and Import an ABC file to bring into My Tunes. I also copied a file to the internal sd card and it found that file also...
Don't understand the question search 'english' abc databases. Are you searching for the word english?
I'll try again, I've copied some ABC files into a folder on the phone but it doesn't find them.
'English' as opposed to Irish, Welsh and Breton databases.
Andy
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
W
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
[/color]
For many years I have used "Sibelius" with very good results.
Over the top most of the time as I used to play in a small band and trad arrangements of tunes are widely available. Came in very useful when we wrote our own stuff.
There are many cheaper products around.
davied
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
W
If you're looking for an Android freebie you could try Maestro or Musical Note Pad Free. I've got Maestro installed but only really played around with it a bit so not sure about whether the output is something that your desktop can handle. Could be worth a try though?
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
[/color]
For many years I have used "Sibelius" with very good results.
Over the top most of the time as I used to play in a small band and trad arrangements of tunes are widely available. Came in very useful when we wrote our own stuff.
There are many cheaper products around.
davied
Before I started playing mostly trad I also used Sibelius. Since picking up trad I don't use it or anything like it anymore.
I can't play anything from reading ABC now, I always have to convert it to sheet music or just don't use it at all. I don't know if that isn't an option but there are lots of free converters for ABC to dots.
http://www.concertina.net/tunes_convert.html (http://www.concertina.net/tunes_convert.html)
This is the easiest one IMO.
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
W
As I understand it the whole point of abc is that it can easily be rendered into standard notation. The abc Notation website (http://abcnotation.com/)lists lots of software.
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
W
I've started using Musescore (http://musescore.org/). It's FREE and totally brilliant! There are versions for PC and Mac (not sure about Linux). It doesn't take too long to learn how to use it. I was writing scores for 4-part clarinet choir within a couple of hours or so. See attached PDF file.
As well as written notes, you can insert all sorts of musical symbols: dynamics ppp - fff, hairpin crescendos and diminuendos, multi-section repeats, seemingly unlimited staves, up to four voices per stave, etc, etc.
There is also an excellent synthesiser playback facility, so you can listen to what you are writing. From multi-stave parts you can also extract individual parts. So you can write/transcribe a symphony in full orchestral score and then extract the individual player's parts. Beautiful output in a variety of formats, including PDF. It also handles transposition flawlessly.
I can't recommend it highly enough. Superb value for zero money!
-
As I understand it the whole point of abc is that it can easily be rendered into standard notation. The abc Notation website (http://abcnotation.com/)lists lots of software.
Exactly. It is possible to play from 'raw' abc, but it's beauty is that it's easily convertible into standard notation. There's plenty of free software - I use ABC Explorer - and websites where you can paste text. For simple one-line stuff (ie most folk tunes) I find it easier to use than a score writer. It would even be possible to transcribe Steve's four-part Pavanne using abc but it would be a bit of a faff, and for that a score writer is arguably better.
The beauty of abc is that you don't need to have the the software available, you can write it in any text editor or even jot it down on a piece of paper - it takes up far less space than ruling out musical staves. So if you're travelling it's ideal. Of course, you do have to learn the grammar, but the basics are pretty simple.
Steve Mansfield has imo the clearest explanation of abc:
http://www.lesession.co.uk/abc/abc_notation.htm
-
As I understand it the whole point of abc is that it can easily be rendered into standard notation. The abc Notation website (http://abcnotation.com/)lists lots of software.
Exactly. It is possible to play from 'raw' abc, but it's beauty is that it's easily convertible into standard notation. There's plenty of free software - I use ABC Explorer - and websites where you can paste text. For simple one-line stuff (ie most folk tunes) I find it easier to use than a score writer. It would even be possible to transcribe Steve's four-part Pavanne using abc but it would be a bit of a faff, and for that a score writer is arguably better.
The beauty of abc is that you don't need to have the the software available, you can write it in any text editor or even jot it down on a piece of paper - it takes up far less space than ruling out musical staves. So if you're travelling it's ideal. Of course, you do have to learn the grammar, but the basics are pretty simple.
Agreed! Sorry, I didn't mean to give the impression that I've stopped using ABC - far from it - and it is convenient in exactly the way Howard has described.
But Cooper was asking about methods other than ABC so I thought it was a suitable opportunity to put in a word for Musescore.
Horse for courses, and all that....
-
I'll be taking a look at Musescore too!
-
I think musescore works on linux too. I'm sure I ve got a copy. Don't remember why I'm not using it all the time...
-
As I understand it the whole point of abc is that it can easily be rendered into standard notation. The abc Notation website (http://abcnotation.com/)lists lots of software.
Exactly. It is possible to play from 'raw' abc, but it's beauty is that it's easily convertible into standard notation. There's plenty of free software - I use ABC Explorer - and websites where you can paste text. For simple one-line stuff (ie most folk tunes) I find it easier to use than a score writer. It would even be possible to transcribe Steve's four-part Pavanne using abc but it would be a bit of a faff, and for that a score writer is arguably better.
The beauty of abc is that you don't need to have the the software available, you can write it in any text editor or even jot it down on a piece of paper - it takes up far less space than ruling out musical staves. So if you're travelling it's ideal. Of course, you do have to learn the grammar, but the basics are pretty simple.
I can see the positive sides of abc, not arguing with those. But i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, only to be able to convert it to dots later, when it is just as possible to write it in dots straight away.
Musescore is a program for your desktop, right? (i am using harmony assistant there) I was looking for something on the road, so for my android-phone. I have found "music composition" and "prelude composer" so far. Both seem fairly easy to use. I think they both export midi, which works fine for importing in any desktop-composing program. I havent tested either of them extensively, so i cant say more atm. Thx Anahata for the ideas for maestro and musical not pad. If i am not completely happy with the two i downkoaded i will download those. I chose for the other two because they had more stars in play store :-)
W
-
Do any of you guys use a program to write actual dots (instead of abc)? Abc is still a bit abacadabra to me, and it would help me if i could write down simple stuff while travelling. Preferably with an output thatmy desktop can work with.
W
I've started using Musescore (http://musescore.org/). It's FREE and totally brilliant! There are versions for PC and Mac (not sure about Linux). It doesn't take too long to learn how to use it. I was writing scores for 4-part clarinet choir within a couple of hours or so. See attached PDF file.
As well as written notes, you can insert all sorts of musical symbols: dynamics ppp - fff, hairpin crescendos and diminuendos, multi-section repeats, seemingly unlimited staves, up to four voices per stave, etc, etc.
There is also an excellent synthesiser playback facility, so you can listen to what you are writing. From multi-stave parts you can also extract individual parts. So you can write/transcribe a symphony in full orchestral score and then extract the individual player's parts. Beautiful output in a variety of formats, including PDF. It also handles transposition flawlessly.
I can't recommend it highly enough. Superb value for zero money!
Thanks Steve, good tip!
I havent heard Earl of Salisburys for years - and I've never used my tongue to play it..... ;)
-
i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, ..
That is a bit defeatist! Enough abc to write out most folk tunes took me about half an hour to learn. It really is not difficult.
-
i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, ..
That is a bit defeatist! Enough abc to write out most folk tunes took me about half an hour to learn. It really is not difficult.
Yep its quite quick start by cut n pasting from existing abc till you get the hang of the format.
-
i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, ..
That is a bit defeatist! Enough abc to write out most folk tunes took me about half an hour to learn. It really is not difficult.
It's probably about as easy to learn as it would be to learn a new transcribing software anyway
-
I can see the positive sides of abc, not arguing with those. But i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, only to be able to convert it to dots later, when it is just as possible to write it in dots straight away.
ABCExplorer shows the "dots" while you are typing in the ABC, which is almost as good.
But the problem is there is no such thing as "dots" on a computer - only the representation that a particular program chooses to represent the dots. If you write it "in dots" with some graphical program and want to post it to a melnet thread, what do you do? You can post a PNG image of the dots which is fine for reading, but if I want it in a form I can manipulate (include in a collection, transpose, print at better resolution, add harmony parts, correct errors, add chords...) I have to manually transcribe it (to ABC is my choice, but whatever...)
You can convert ABC to graphics or PDF, but most music scoring programs can't convert or export to ABC. And not just that: their output generally isn't usable in any way except by someone else with the same program.
A common file format is needed. There is some work going on with ABCXML but I don't think it's widely supported yet. GNU Lilypond at least has an open format that anyone else can use, but it's not widely used except by the one program. ABC is used by a lot of free software, but it would be good if more commecrcial desktop scoring programs could import and export it.
Thx Anahata for the ideas for maestro and musical not pad.
Not me, it was peggy_pokerwork.
-
ABC is used by a lot of free software, but it would be good if more commecrcial desktop scoring programs could import and export it.
Musescore can import ABC files (but not export to ABC as far as I know).
-
A common file format is needed. There is some work going on with ABCXML but I don't think it's widely supported yet.
MusicXML is supported by most of the major music programs.
-
A common file format is needed. There is some work going on with ABCXML but I don't think it's widely supported yet.
MusicXML
Which is, of course, what I meant. :|bl
-
i dont want to invest time in learning how to write in abc, ..
That is a bit defeatist! Enough abc to write out most folk tunes took me about half an hour to learn. It really is not difficult.
It's equally not that difficult to learn to write tunes down in standards notation i.e Staves! Particularly as most of our tunes are in G, or D, in 4/4, 6/8 or 3/4, Using mstly single notes and half notes, with a range usually of no more than 1 and a half octaves, and without many accidentals! :D
-
It's equally not that difficult to learn to write tunes down in standards notation i.e Staves! Particularly as most of our tunes are in G, or D, in 4/4, 6/8 or 3/4, Using mstly single notes and half notes, with a range usually of no more than 1 and a half octaves, and without many accidentals! :D
True! But, and it's a big but, I currently have 350 tunes in ABC that can be displayed as manuscript, or ABC or peeped at me in my iPhone. With manuscript I would need a big folder and would not be able to ring people up with it.
-
ABC is used by a lot of free software, but it would be good if more commecrcial desktop scoring programs could import and export it.
Musescore can import ABC files (but not export to ABC as far as I know).
Hey i wrote a rply yesterday, but dont see it now...
Anyway, i use Harmony assistant, and that can both import and export abc-files. Midi-files work quite good as well for bringing it from one program to another,
And when using a program that can import and export abc-files when i need to bring them to people/machines/files who need abc only there is no need for me to actually learn to read or write it, as dots work fine, and are a visual aid too,
W
W
-
It's equally not that difficult to learn to write tunes down in standards notation i.e Staves! Particularly as most of our tunes are in G, or D, in 4/4, 6/8 or 3/4, Using mstly single notes and half notes, with a range usually of no more than 1 and a half octaves, and without many accidentals! :D
True! But, and it's a big but, I currently have 350 tunes in ABC that can be displayed as manuscript, or ABC or peeped at me in my iPhone. With manuscript I would need a big folder and would not be able to ring people up with it.
Very true, and btw congrats on the amazing new ABC source of wonderful tunes! I was more thinking about the first scribbling down of a tune in a session or when it's in your brain afterwards. But on felection I agre that if scribbled in ABC its easier to then convert to the dots, or replay it with one of the tools to see if you've got it right.
Off to learn ABC ..... ;)
-
I was more thinking about the first scribbling down of a tune in a session or when it's in your brain afterwards. But on felection I agre that if scribbled in ABC its easier to then convert to the dots, or replay it with one of the tools to see if you've got it right.
I wouldn't do that - if I wanted to scribble something down I'd draw 5 line staves and put in the dots (or bring blank manuscript if I was expecting to need to do this) - but that's because I can read the dots well enough to know if it's right, but I can easily make mistakes when writing/typing ABC.
Similarly, when I transcribe ABC on the computer, I check it by displaying the dots generated from the ABC. I suppose I would resort to ABCMIDI and playing it back to listen to if it was complicated, like multi-part harmony or something that wasn't very tonal - but I don't do that very often.
-
As I don't usually carry around a ruler and as I can't draw straight lines, any attempt to draw a 5 line stave quickly ends up a mess. Also I can't read the dots well enough to know if I've got it right. I can jot down a tune in ABC on the back of a beermat if that's all there is to hand.
Even though I'm not great at reading, when I'm writing out ABC in ABCExplorer I also refer to the displayed notation, although ultimately I have to rely on playing it back to be sure it's correct. My main purpose in using ABC is in fact to create notation, for the simple melodies I'm transcribing I find it easier to use than score writers.
-
As usual, it's horses for courses, each to his own, etc.
Having read this thread through, I'm converted to the merits of ABC (and spell checking.....), so I can have both conventional music notation and ABC at my disposal.
BTW with practice it takes seconds (if that) to draw 5 roughly straight lines on a piece of paper, and I tend to write a tune in G no matter what it's played in! I've got pages and pages of tunes remembered and quickly notated in my Time Manager ( a posh Filofax), noted in no time at all, and there as an aide memoire. In this age of technology, I'm now swaying towards ABC, because of all the useful tools that are around for it.
However, I still recommend people learn how to read and write traditional notation. e.g for checking if the suggested tune in Tunepal is actually the one you are listening to!
-
As I don't usually carry around a ruler and as I can't draw straight lines, any attempt to draw a 5 line stave quickly ends up a mess.
I always have a little moleskin music-notationbook in the pocket of mmyjacket. Before i found that, i was carrying a ballpoint pen around with 5 tips.
W
-
Someone pointed me to "scorecleaner note". An iPhone-app that hears your melody and writes the thing in dots. Does any of you know how well that works? And since i have no iPhone, do you know of a working Android app that does the same?
W
-
Someone pointed me to "scorecleaner note". An iPhone-app that hears your melody and writes the thing in dots. Does any of you know how well that works?
I would guess not very well in the context where that might be useful.
In other words, if you sit in a quiet room and sing the melody accurately, it might give good results, but picking up a tune in a noisy session in a crowded pub requires some quite tricky signal analysis, which the human ear-brain combination does remarkably well. I'd be impressed if a smartphone app could do that.
But I don't know - I've never tried it, and audio processing software is getting cleverer all the time.
-
I have invested 69p and will report back :)
Apparently it hates chords.
I had some for the PC which was pretty good unless you had a one track version of something in which case it produced wallpaper. Quite accurate wallpaper, but you'd have needed 6 arms to play it even if you could decode the dots.
-
Crucial note in the app description - requires an Internet connection as analysis is done in the cloud.
H
-
There is also Tunepal which takes audio input, but instead if just rendering it as notation it searches online abc databases to match the tune. My limited experience has been that it does not usually identify the tune correctly, but others I know have had more success.
-
Amazon Appstore now has a music app has "free app of the day"
I haevnt tested it completely, but from what i saw it has a tuner that you can tell if you want ET, just or any of the other known ways to tune something.
(apart from that it has a metronome and a recorder)
W
-
As a Sibelius user, I have Scorch on my iPad. It reads pdfs as well as Sibelius documents so can be a useful place to store a gig list. I'm also a Tunebook fan, I have a pretty extensive collection on there now, but it's only useful if you know the name of the tune first. I do use Tunepal sometimes and it works ok for me although I'm never look up anything too obscure.
One which is worth a mention, and which I'm sure I heard about originally on Melnet, is Anytune which allows you to slow the tempo of a recording whilst maintaining the pitch in order to facilitate picking out a difficult tune or working out chords, basses etc.
Dave
-
I have Tunebook on my iPad, and find it a very handy way to search up tunes in ABC on the web and convert that to notes on a staff. It does not transpose, nor support editing. For that, I use EasyABC on the Mac. That one is very handy, because it readily transposes tunes, and makes it quite simple to edit the ABC code and see the results on the staff. Easy ABC doesn't have a handy tune list as part of its interface; you save them as individual files.
I have found editing useful because, as rank beginner, I find it often the case that the transcription of a tune one often bears scant resemblance to the recorded version of that tune which prompted you to go looking for it in the first place.
Sometimes, this is because the transcriber is attempting to render an ornamented and complexified version of the tune, rather than the skeleton on which all that finery is hung. For a beginner, it's extremely useful to have just the bare bones to start with. So I sometimes edit out the fancy stuff, so I can just get the tune down pat.
Other times, the lack of correspondence between the transcribed tune "Joe's Old Hat" and the recorded version of "Joe's Old Hat" seems to be simply a matter of folks calling different tunes by the same name.
I encountered this often in learning what we call "Old Time" tunes in the US -- basically string band music from the Appalachians and the South from the late 1800s and early 1900s or so. Folks who recorded mountain fiddlers and banjo pluckers during the folk revival in the 1960s took the names their subjects gave tunes as gospel, and they ultimately became part of the canon. So, now you will occasionally find some performer announce that he is about to render "Fred Lambert's version of Pretty Fair Miss" (learned from a George Mitchell recording) and cut loose with a perfect "Cripple Creek", evidently too reverent of The Tradition to realize that Fred got the names of the tunes mixed up -- or perhaps was demonstrating that tune late in the evening after several turns at the Mason Jar. (Names all made up to protect the innocent).
Greg
-
I use Tunebook on iPad and edit with it quite a lot. In my current version there's a "share" button to the left of the "play" triangle and "edit tune" is the top option.
It doesn't transpose. I do.. Edit.. Select all.... Copy, then go to
http://voluntocracy.org/Music/Transpose.html (http://voluntocracy.org/Music/Transpose.html)
Paste it in..... Transpose......copy......back to Tunebook.....new tune.... Select all..... Paste.
A bit of a fiddle but I've got quick at it.
I would dearly love to be able to start play from anywhere, and it doesn't, so what I do is to use the editing to break tunes into smaller segments for learning, so I can start playing ie at the start of the B part without listening to everything else first.
I've also written tunes from scratch in the edit mode, so yes it does edit.
Steve
-
Well, by golly, Steve! You are the man. Not sure how I missed that obvious edit function, but glad to know it's there! (Likely another instance of failing to RTFM).
Thanks for the tip!
Greg
-
Not sure of this is the right thread, but...
Just downloaded the Amazing Slowdowner for iPad (free version) and have linked it to my Spotify account. Initial impression is positive. Also have bagged the Ins Tuner which I will be using soon...!
Mike