I'd not heard of them but a search here offered this topic from last year http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5564.0.html
Frans v d Aa advised that he prefers these Ciccarelli over Binci and sent me the attached photo.
Ciccarelli seem a new maker. I'd never heard of them Does anyone have experience please?
The issue seems to be that Ciccarelli make every reed a different length Chris
The issue seems to be that Ciccarelli make every reed a different length Chris
Andy, did the reed plates fit straight into a Hohner without modifying the blocks?
... I do recall that concertina manufacturers bragged about fitting 'Long Scale Reeds' to the high end models. This suggests that long and slim is superior to short and broad to create the same general mass.
Andy, did the reed plates fit straight into a Hohner without modifying the blocks?
The issue seems to be that Ciccarelli make every reed a different length Chris
Makes it pretty obvious that the the reed blocks have to be made to suit the reed plates, not uncommon of course but the blocks for these reeds will be taller in general. Not the same subject at all really but I do recall that concertina manufacturers bragged about fitting 'Long Scale Reeds' to the high end models. This suggests that long and slim is superior to short and broad to create the same general mass.
It would be interesting to see a box built without weighted reed tips but I fear the bass end would be very deep ( box end to bellows of course ).
Its not so much that long or short scale reeds are inherently better, but they are different. Jeffries concertinas use very short scale reeds, still quality reeds, but differnt sound and response.
For example long scale should speak quicker, but use more air for the same bellows pressure.
This is fascinating stuff. The balance of the overall reed thickness, length, width at the root and tip (which of course governs the angle of taper), the profile and general set are all variables and there is no 'correct' method of producing a perfect reed because such a thing doesn't exist. Seems to me an accordion tech is a bit of a juggler. :o
I assume you played on them?
Its not so much that long or short scale reeds are inherently better, but they are different. Jeffries concertinas use very short scale reeds, still quality reeds, but differnt sound and response.
For example long scale should speak quicker, but use more air for the same bellows pressure.
Not the case with Ciccarelli in my experience. Very nice people and an absolute pleasure to deal with.
One thing that may be an issue here is that Ciccarelli apparently have a much shorter waiting time than Binci or even Voci Armonihce. So for the melodeon maker it's probably also less time consuming and more flexible to deal with Ciccarelli than Binci.
I got a Luukinen Elene II C/F with Binci professional reeds and a Lilja III D/G with Ciccarelli reeds. But it's really hard to compare, and I love to play both. All I can say for sure is that both types of reeds sounds and feel really great.
What long scale reeds give you is dynamic range. (whether you think that's good or bad...)
One thing that may be an issue here is that Ciccarelli apparently have a much shorter waiting time than Binci or even Voci Armonihce. So for the melodeon maker it's probably also less time consuming and more flexible to deal with Ciccarelli than Binci.
I got a Luukinen Elene II C/F with Binci professional reeds and a Lilja III D/G with Ciccarelli reeds. But it's really hard to compare, and I love to play both. All I can say for sure is that both types of reeds sounds and feel really great.
It had occurred to me there might be a timing issue. Binci took nearly 2 years on my last commission. Long ago - my Casta Mory was also delayed for 'anches'
As for having both types - I think such diversity is wonderful. This is an adventure.
| I need to explain BINCI/Ciccarelli: My basic prices were based on BINCI Semi hand made reeds (BINCI Typo A Mano). When I started with Ciccarelli Hand Made Reeds they were about the same price as the cheapest BINCI 'Typo A Mano' (not hand made). The extra for BINCI Hand Made (for your accordion) was list €230,- but this is their 2005 price. Really I need to ask at this moment €258 more for BINCI A Mano At the time BINCI stopped making Typo A Mano, I came in contact with Ciccarelli. Now you pay only €183 more. I'm really happy with the Ciccarelli reeds, they make better and better work for lower price. (BINCI were also cheap in the beginning). I was one of the first accordion makers use BINCI, Now I'm one of the first use Ciccarelli. This is a risk for me, as BINCI is very popular all over the world. At this moment I'm making a new accordion for David Munnelly, in D/D#. He wants to use it in his David Munnelly Band, and new band Samurai. After a time all people might talk about CICCARELLI and forgot BINCI..? |
Frans has also asked me how to use this forum and I've sent some screen shots. Hope to hear him here soon. Which model are you getting? Michael The compact 9/10/11 with 18 bass - or as per his video - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzHJps91O6g | (http://www.harmonicahoek.nl/archief/2009/2009_08_30/serie/07.jpg) |
Had this from Frans van der Aa (I've tweaked the English a little for clarity,it's not his mother's tongue)
At the time BINCI stopped making Typo A Mano, I came in contact with Ciccarelli. Now you pay only €183 more. I'm really happy with the Ciccarelli reeds, they make better and better work for lower price. (BINCI were also cheap in the beginning).
(BINCI were also cheap in the beginning).
what does that mean in this case, Frans? I mean, can you describe the differences in sound and playing between the different kind of reeds? and between the different kind of makers? (Antonelli vs Binci vs Ciccarelli for example)?
... and the most important: Excellent Quality..!..
I'm for the first time on Melodeon.net...
Here a little story about my 30 years making accordions and special about the reeds:
I start exact 30 years ago with making diatonic accordions... 1981 .....VanderAa..... 2011 and make till now 222 accordions.
After two years making accordions in 1983 I use for the first time BINCI REEDS... This reeds was from the old Nazzareno Binci.
After about two years he work for me, Nazzareno dead and finished the BINCI reeds.
(In that time BINCI Nazzareno make only parallel reeds, I like this old style BINCI reeds ad most from all till now..!
After I use for some years SALPA reeds, the SALPA reeds was from good quality, later Salpa incorporate with Antonelli with the name Voci Armoniche. I tray in the beginning Voci Armoniche, bud I don't like, it was complete different from SALPA.
After about three years no BINCI reeds... Claudio BINCI (a nephew) start his factory with making again BINCI reeds.
Typo a Mano, A Mano and A Mano double revet. This last I never use for they are about 7 mm more long, not good for the size of my small COMPACT accordions. From that time I use standard BINCI Typo a Mano and against more price BINCI A MANO.
For about 3 years ago Jugens Ciccarelli start his company with making CICCARELLY reeds...
He make 5 different style reeds: EXPORT Quality, typo a mano, Extra Quality, Special Quality and TOP Quality
I use now standard in my accordions: EXTRA QUALITY, and against more price: TOP QUALITY.
I like CICCARELLY for a lot reasons: Nice contact, shorter delivery time, more cheap, and the most important: Excellent Quality..!
Ciccarelli use always the best length reed for the correct tone, in almost every, Dural reed house, are two different lengths reeds.
Does anyone know about the recent situation with Ciccarelli?
I ordered from him a year ago, and he keeps delaying, saying he is suffering some serious problems with his hands. I hope this does not mean that he will stop production, as his reeds are among the best I have tried out there.
He made all the reeds for the last Emmanuel Pariselle course in April. And very good they are too. Just speculating but it is possible that he prefers to deal with customers who place larger orders.
I've used his standard hand mades, the special type, and the extra type. All sound good and are very responsive. The differences between the 3 is a little unclear to me, but the specials I think are what some call "bombates", the top of the reed is ground to a slight dome shape, and the extra type are flat topped but ground at an angle. Diatonix probably has more experience with them and could tell more about the differences than anyone.