I'm also grappling wi the bass buttons for the first timeThis refers to the number of fingers that different players use to operate the bass/chord buttons.
What does it mean 'using 2/3/4 fingers' for bass?....
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.
I think, in my vast experience :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)
I'm trying the bass with a four finger approach but whenever I use just my pinky and ring fingers to play bass and chord, the other two fingers stand up in the air. Does anyone else have this problem? Is there any advice on how to train the other fingers to remain on the buttons? Or is this just a pecularity of my hand and I'll have to figure it out on my own?I believe LDT demonstrated this problem on her videos and was worried observers may be offended by the "gesture". I too have too short a little finger to use it except in extremis, i.e. when I've got totally out of position. It seems to depend mainly on the shape of one's hand.
I'm trying the bass with a four finger approach but whenever I use just my pinky and ring fingers to play bass and chord, the other two fingers stand up in the air. Does anyone else have this problem? Is there any advice on how to train the other fingers to remain on the buttons? Or is this just a pecularity of my hand and I'll have to figure it out on my own?I believe LDT demonstrated this problem on her videos and was worried observers may be offended by the "gesture". I too have too short a little finger to use it except in extremis, i.e. when I've got totally out of position. It seems to depend mainly on the shape of one's hand.
When playing faster, I've noticed that my left hand stays more in contact with the keys, whereas my right hand moves higher and starts dancing to the music!
Rob.
I think, in my vast experience :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)
| Back in approx '92 I broke my right index finger (which shouldn't have been anywhere near that motor mower)! Forced me to relearn and play all my tunes with the other 3 fingers. In retrospect this worked wonders mobilising my own 'pinkie' |
| 1. Start with Em using I+M fingers 2. Pinkie to D pull (ie the near one) 3. Index finger to pull C |
'Feels right' is surely important. But 4 finger bass end play is such a useful skill that I think it's something we should emphasise to learners. They won't for example get to those nice bass runs without it. (I'm sure someone here will immediately contradict this)!
Thanks Lester. I was starting to worry that we'd not disagreed for some time. ;)
If you try playing this standard 'accordion' riff with just two fingers then there is basically only one way of playing it, and it doesn't sound very good or interesting. As soon as you get the hang of it with three fingers, there are several different (and even interesting) ways of playing it, in terms of phrasing and dynamics.
But each to their own. ::)
We've done this one to death, then dug it up to play with the cadaver :Ph
It seems I'm the Burke and Hare person that can be blamed for this cadaver.
The thing about forums is that every so often, new people come along - like me and the original poster!
The only other way around it is to have a FAQ where such things are answered in depth, but it then relies on moderators who inevitably are overworked and have other things to do in their real lives!!!
Sorry if I've trodden what is obviously old ground, but please take heart - it has been very helpful to me, and thanks to all the posters. The posts have been read, re-read and duely thought about in depth, and greatly appreciated. When you're new to something, being able to ask a question and get an immediate reponse to help out is just so good, not only does it help there and then, but it keeps your momentum going too..... it really is excellent.
take care folks
TB
One more idea - that hasn't been aired here yet. Try to learn where the sounds are on the basses, not "this finger goes on this button", however many you use. Hit the right button with whatever finger is handy - goes for right hand too - and you'll be learning the instrument rather than learning tunes with a fixed fingering pattern. It'll serve you well if you ever need to busk along with tunes you don't know well. The aim is to play basses instinctively as the chord sequence moves on. (:)
'Feels right' is surely important. But 4 finger bass end play is such a useful skill that I think it's something we should emphasise to learners.Is there something to learn from QWERTY keyboard here?