Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: FREED on August 18, 2008, 04:50:21 PM

Title: Bass Position
Post by: FREED on August 18, 2008, 04:50:21 PM
Hello All, My first ever posting and as you will see I am an absolute beginner !!

I have just bought an old Hohner pokerwork D/G and starting to learn has been one of  my most fun experiences ever. I am starting to knock out a melody OK and even ( though it's shaky ) some accompaniment. My main problem is getting the bass end held in such a way that I can move round the basses. I  cannot seem to get a good position where I can operate the upper and lower buttons - or do I just need to stretch my fingers !!  Perhaps my bass strap is too loose or tight.

Any advice gratefully received.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Waltham on August 18, 2008, 05:14:55 PM
Many beginners tend not to put their left hand far enough through the bass strap, while individuals differ do consider having your hand far enough through that the strap is where a wristwatch would go.  And try that for a while before thinking about adjusting your strap.

But why "move around the basses"?  Get into the habit of using all for fingers on your left hand now and it will save all sorts of hard work later.  Yes, fellow forumites,  I'm aware that some very good players only use two or three fingers, and it doesn't change my advice.

Good luck!
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: sCANdanADIAN on August 19, 2008, 12:43:12 AM
I second Waltham's advice.Using all four fingers on a 12 bass instrument allows for nice bass runs and jumps into the minor keys.

Chris
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: FREED on August 19, 2008, 10:40:04 AM
Thanks for the replies. I dont push that far through the strap. I will try that and also see if I can get into the habit of using four fingers. 
Many thanks I will let you know how I get on.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: FREED on August 21, 2008, 02:05:45 PM
Yes you were quite right putting my hand further through the strap makes all the buttons accessible and holds the bass side much firmer - which was my real problem. Just have to get all four fingers working now. The air button is a little more difficult to manipulate but I'llget the hang of it.

Many thanks
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: TooManyButtons on August 21, 2008, 02:57:52 PM

 Note of caution: If you start to get an ache across the palm/back of hand when using the airbutton, rest it, and when you try again, loosen the strap a *little*
(Take Care!)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: FREED on August 22, 2008, 10:38:17 AM
Funny you should mention pains in the hands. I have played guitar for a long time and do suffer from what I think is probably carpel tunnel syndrome - numbness in the thumb and first two fingures occasional shooting pains in the second finger all of which seems to go temporarily when I hold my hands down. I hoped that the different action of practising melodeon would help but so far it hasn't.

I guess from what you say that squeeze box platyers can get something like this.  Thanks for the advice I will take it easy.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Peter G on August 24, 2008, 07:29:46 PM
I'm also grappling wi the bass buttons for the first time
What does it mean 'using 2/3/4 fingers' for bass? So far I've attacked 1 tune in each of D and G, using only the 2 bass buttons Fun and Ch as mally calls them, and fingers 1 and 2 Should I try using different fingers for the differnt keys or do I wait until I get onto the other 2 bass buttons in each key (the furtherest away fro the wrist ones!
PeterG  ???
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Steve_freereeder on August 25, 2008, 08:31:33 AM
I'm also grappling wi the bass buttons for the first time
What does it mean 'using 2/3/4 fingers' for bass?....
This refers to the number of fingers that different players use to operate the bass/chord buttons.
Ideally you should use 4 fingers. On an 8-button bass instrument, that means that all 4 fingers can be positioned to play either on one bass row or the other.
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.

Hope this helps. 
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 25, 2008, 11:09:41 AM
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.

I think, in my vast experience  :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: pipives on August 25, 2008, 11:27:24 AM
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.

I think, in my vast experience  :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)
[/quote]

Not all the young ones use 3 fingers! I try but have played using only two for so many years... I certainly can't use all four, my little finger's way to short to reach the C basses!
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: george garside on August 25, 2008, 01:39:07 PM
However - because of the inherent weakness in the little finger, many players only use index, middle and ring fingers. And some players only use two fingers.

I think, in my vast experience  :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)

Not all the young ones use 3 fingers! I try but have played using only two for so many years... I certainly can't use all four, my little finger's way to short to reach the C basses!
[/quote]

  there is absolutely no reason why 3 or 4 fingers should not be used  &  using them is perhaps handy if more than two buttons are to be pressed at same time!  However those who manage perfectly well with 2 fingers  haave little to gain by using more as    a melodeon bass keyboard is  small enough to get to the distant corners swiftly.

george
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: FREED on August 27, 2008, 03:22:40 PM
Many thanks for all your help.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: labradornl on July 20, 2010, 02:29:46 PM
I'm trying the bass with a four finger approach but whenever I use just my pinky and ring fingers to play bass and chord, the other two fingers stand up in the air.  Does anyone else have this problem?  Is there any advice on how to train the other fingers to remain on the buttons?  Or is this just a pecularity of my hand and I'll have to figure it out on my own?
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Quebecois on July 20, 2010, 03:10:27 PM
I use a mirror to remind me how weird the fingers in the air look like! I guess it's about training, try playing the bass side only and focus on leaving your unused fingers close to the buttons.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 20, 2010, 03:29:34 PM
I'm trying the bass with a four finger approach but whenever I use just my pinky and ring fingers to play bass and chord, the other two fingers stand up in the air.  Does anyone else have this problem?  Is there any advice on how to train the other fingers to remain on the buttons?  Or is this just a pecularity of my hand and I'll have to figure it out on my own?
I believe LDT demonstrated this problem on her videos and was worried observers may be offended by the "gesture".  I too have too short a little finger to use it except in extremis, i.e. when I've got totally out of position.  It seems to depend mainly on the shape of one's hand.

When playing faster, I've noticed that my left hand stays more in contact with the keys, whereas my right hand moves higher and starts dancing to the music!

Rob.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: **DTN** on July 21, 2010, 10:10:37 PM
I'm trying the bass with a four finger approach but whenever I use just my pinky and ring fingers to play bass and chord, the other two fingers stand up in the air.  Does anyone else have this problem?  Is there any advice on how to train the other fingers to remain on the buttons?  Or is this just a pecularity of my hand and I'll have to figure it out on my own?
I believe LDT demonstrated this problem on her videos and was worried observers may be offended by the "gesture".  I too have too short a little finger to use it except in extremis, i.e. when I've got totally out of position.  It seems to depend mainly on the shape of one's hand.

When playing faster, I've noticed that my left hand stays more in contact with the keys, whereas my right hand moves higher and starts dancing to the music!

Rob.

I'm guilty of lazy Bass with 2 fingers moving about! ,,, it works for me and i play a lot of bass melody! ..... occasionally 3 fingers ... but never 4!!!
DTN ;D
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: oggiesnr on July 22, 2010, 07:21:26 PM
I think, in my vast experience  :), that the majority of players up to ~5 years ago used just two fingers and it is probably still the majority. But fashion seems to be changing and 3 or 4 fingers are commonly used by younger players (I'm too old to relearn)

It's also a change reflected in the concertina world with a new generation of English players using wrist straps and using their fourth finger for the fourth row.

Steve
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Kautilya on July 28, 2010, 06:17:57 PM
It's just a question of copying and then practising what the expert aliens do:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmkDOzjfSSY
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: SteveC on July 30, 2010, 06:21:19 PM
I think relative finger length is also an issue here. My little finger is substantially shorter (relative to my other fingers) compared to other players I know. Stretching it to the C button was too much and I find I've settled happily into a 3 finger pattern.

So, check your body ergonomics and plan from there.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 09, 2010, 09:37:54 AM
Hmmmm.... I'm just starting up and read this with interest.
I'd *like* to use my little finger, but realise it is shorter than my index ( first ) finger and I've got very small hands!
I'm used to using my  ring finger, as an English concertina player, it is used a lot ( interesting comment above a bout  using 4 fingers on a concertina..... ).
I've currently been using 3 fingers as it 'feels right', and am starting to get going with the basses. P'raps I'll loosen off the strap and try getting my hand in further.
Images of " All creatures great and small" come to mind!!!!!!!!  :o
Ahem.
Sorry.
Will have another go!
cheers

TB
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 09, 2010, 09:55:35 AM
'Feels right' is surely important. But 4 finger bass end play is such a useful skill that I think it's something we should emphasise to learners. They won't for example get to those nice bass runs without it. (I'm sure someone here will immediately contradict this)!

There's a concept involved. I play (for D/G) my D/G and C/C buttons with ring/middle habitually, or little/ring if I'm working up to a run. One you've got something like thsi going - those agile index and middle fingers are doing the flash bit. Which is putting power where it is needed IMHO

Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 09, 2010, 10:08:32 AM
Chris: I find I'm habitually using my ring/middle for the C/C, finding my little one falling short,a and sometimes clipping the D/G when trying.
As a total newbie, I haven't any idea about bass runs, though totally see why good habits to start with will help later on.
Maybe I should try useing little/ring for D/G, thus getting the brain-finger co-ordination going for those fingers and keep ring/middle for the stretch over to C/C?
Might be a compromise if I really cannot get to the C/C with my little pinky after inserting the hand further.
Just a thought.....
cheers
TB
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 09, 2010, 10:22:32 AM
My advice would be to 'just force yourself' if you can -  for at least a couple of weeks.

[anecdote]
   Back in approx '92 I broke my right index finger (which shouldn't have been anywhere near that motor mower)!  
Forced me to relearn and play all my tunes with the other 3 fingers. In retrospect this worked wonders mobilising my own 'pinkie'
[/anecdote]

OK, a 'nice' bass run ... instead of playing a simple Em pull chord - try this (it's all on pull)

    1. Start with Em using I+M fingers
2. Pinkie to D pull (ie the near one)
3. Index finger to pull C

You can either do this as a simple run of basses, as chunked chords Em => Dpull= > C,
or as 'crossed chords Ebass+Em => Dbass+Em= > Cbass+Em - they all work
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2010, 12:47:08 PM
'Feels right' is surely important. But 4 finger bass end play is such a useful skill that I think it's something we should emphasise to learners. They won't for example get to those nice bass runs without it. (I'm sure someone here will immediately contradict this)!

As no one else has, I will disagree.

I get on quite well with only 2 fingers on the bass (including bass runs) and IMO so do most the players who started way back when when 2 fingers was the "right way". Maybe I am just lazy, but can't get on with 4 fingers as I can't reach the inside row with my little finger and 3 fingers just confuses me as my head has fingers labled as either bass or chord fingers (OK when using 2 or 4 fingers) but using 3 fingers means the fingers have to be bass/chord ambidexterous.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 09, 2010, 02:13:05 PM
Thanks Lester. I was starting to worry that we'd not disagreed for some time. ;)

I agree  ::)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: george garside on August 09, 2010, 03:21:01 PM
absolutely nothing wrong with using 3 or 4 fingers, but like Lester I get on perfectly well using just two so thats equally OK!  To me using more than 2 fingers for 8 buttons is a bit like overkill   when 3 or , for me,very occasionally 4 can manage to jump about as necessary with stradella bass.

following the  logic of 4 fingers for 8 basss  a 120 bass player would need  no less than 15digits!!

george ;D
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 09, 2010, 03:44:25 PM
Chris:
Am forcing - can you hear the grunts??? (!)

I've given up for a little while, my brain now completetly hurts.
Having *just* started to get some co-ordination going after bashing away for a week or so, I'm back to square one by using he little finger.
I find I'm now out of place on the buttons, and to enable me to get overto the inside C/C basses, I am now finding I'm accidentally touching the ( sensitive ) air valve with the ball of my thumb so dumping air very quickly.
Arghhhh!
At this point, I've given up for a little while to enable my eyeballs to return to their sockets and let my brain settle a bit. I often find there comes a point when it's better to quit and let it filter out in the grey matter. Often a problem one night is resolved as if by magic the next morning after it's sunk in a bit.
Will have another go soon!
cheers
TB
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Howard Jones on August 09, 2010, 06:37:47 PM
I'm not sure I agree with Lester that 2 fingers was the "old way" - I've been playing with 3 fingers for more than 25 years.  I can't say I really noticed what other players were doing at the time, so perhaps I was unusual.  It's certainly true that players now are trying more ambitious things with the basses, which encourages the use of more fingers.

Although some people can play very well with only 2 fingers, I do think it is worth trying to bring more into play.  It's clearly possible to play complex bass runs with only 2 fingers, but I believe it's easier with more. 

Once you start playing cross-row chords, fast bass runs, or a D drone alternating between pushed and pulled chords, then I think it's much easier to use at least 3 fingers, because it needs less of a change of hand position to reach the buttons

Whether to use 4 depends very much on the size of your hands and length of your fingers.  I can reach the C fundamental with my little finger but only by twisting my hand out of position.  Someone I give lessons to can't reach it at all.  I would say go with what's comfortable - if you can manage all 4 fingers that's great, if not try to use 3.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: GbH on August 09, 2010, 07:08:43 PM
I just tried playing a basic GgDg alternating bass patern with two fingers.  It sounds and feels horrible!

I don't think I'll ever understand the reason for using only two.  It doesn't make sense to me, when there are other fingers flapping about, doing nothing.
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 10, 2010, 06:50:38 AM
If you try playing this standard 'accordion' riff with just two fingers then there is basically only one way of playing it, and it doesn't sound very good or interesting. As soon as you get the hang of it with three fingers, there are several different (and even interesting) ways of playing it, in terms of phrasing and dynamics.

I think the bit where you say "as soon as you get the hang....." applies to playing with two fingers as well. You appear to say that playing with two fingers is inferior and all people need to do is get the hang of using three, my riposte is that all you need to do is get the hang of playing with two and you will find that   there are several different (and even interesting) ways of playing it, in terms of phrasing and dynamics. .

But each to their own.  ::)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Chris Ryall on August 10, 2010, 10:08:24 AM
But each to their own.  ::)

I agree. We've done this one to death, then dug it up to play with the cadaver :Ph  But I don't think I've shared how I personally started using my 3+4 fingers.

I was a trainee morris musician with Newcastle's Phil Ham and really got into the lovely tune "Dearest Dickie".   DD is one of the more lyrical morris airs, and I felt my 2 fingers and move your hand about left end really didn't do it justice.  The solution was in what I did on the right.  I experimented and found that the end of the B part which I'd played "up the G row" actually worked better as a simple cross rowed sequence. And moreover was then all on the pull :o  Another major learning experience!

Once I was playing that  longish stretch all pulling, it allowed me to develop and weave in the simple pull bass run I've described above. It feels a bit like patting head and rubbing tummy at first - but practice - practice - gotit!     "Dearest Dickie"s B music could now be played "as light as a feather". 

I then discovered that my morris team actually preferred it in the previous "style of the Yorkie Bar". Each to his own as they say   ;)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 10, 2010, 10:21:51 AM
We've done this one to death, then dug it up to play with the cadaver :Ph 

 ;D
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 10, 2010, 11:12:28 AM
It seems I'm the Burke and Hare person that can be blamed for this cadaver.
The thing about forums is that every so often, new people come along - like me and the original poster!
The only other way around it is to have a FAQ where such things are answered in depth, but it then relies on moderators who inevitably are overworked and have other things to do in their real lives!!!

Sorry if I've trodden  what is obviously old ground, but please take heart - it has been very helpful to me, and thanks to all the posters. The posts have been read, re-read  and duely thought about in depth, and greatly appreciated. When you're new to something, being able to ask a question and get an immediate reponse to help out is just so good, not only does it help there and then, but it keeps your momentum going too..... it really is excellent.
take care folks
TB

Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on August 10, 2010, 11:28:28 AM
One more idea - that hasn't been aired here yet. Try to learn where the sounds are on the basses, not "this finger goes on this button", however many you use. Hit the right button with whatever finger is handy - goes for right hand too - and you'll be learning the instrument rather than learning tunes with a fixed fingering pattern. It'll serve you well if you ever need to busk along with tunes you don't know well. The aim is to play basses instinctively as the chord sequence moves on.  (:)
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Lester on August 10, 2010, 12:15:11 PM
It seems I'm the Burke and Hare person that can be blamed for this cadaver.
The thing about forums is that every so often, new people come along - like me and the original poster!
The only other way around it is to have a FAQ where such things are answered in depth, but it then relies on moderators who inevitably are overworked and have other things to do in their real lives!!!

Sorry if I've trodden  what is obviously old ground, but please take heart - it has been very helpful to me, and thanks to all the posters. The posts have been read, re-read  and duely thought about in depth, and greatly appreciated. When you're new to something, being able to ask a question and get an immediate reponse to help out is just so good, not only does it help there and then, but it keeps your momentum going too..... it really is excellent.
take care folks
TB



As jb said part of the territory of such forums. But I have read each post in case there is a new gem of information that may help me in my endeavors as I do with nearly all posts on this forum. So going around a subject again is not a bad thing and may lead to enlightenment grasshopper *

* Dodgy reference to early 70's TV programme
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on August 10, 2010, 12:52:26 PM
Tony - good point, am trying to do that rahter than learn by numbers.

Lester - but I don't remember David Carradine playing a box, thought it was a flute!  ;)
Yep I remember it too!
cheers
TB
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: george garside on August 10, 2010, 01:29:14 PM
One more idea - that hasn't been aired here yet. Try to learn where the sounds are on the basses, not "this finger goes on this button", however many you use. Hit the right button with whatever finger is handy - goes for right hand too - and you'll be learning the instrument rather than learning tunes with a fixed fingering pattern. It'll serve you well if you ever need to busk along with tunes you don't know well. The aim is to play basses instinctively as the chord sequence moves on.  (:)

 indeed!

george ;D
Title: Re: Bass Position
Post by: Kautilya on August 21, 2010, 06:08:33 PM
'Feels right' is surely important. But 4 finger bass end play is such a useful skill that I think it's something we should emphasise to learners.
Is there something to learn from QWERTY keyboard here?
Only the other day I persuaded a 72 year old anti computer person to type in some info on ebay.
They started with one finger.
I stopped them immediately and, although they argued against me (they always do these beginners!)....
after about thirty seconds I had persuaded them (using the incentive of their need to type in their search words) to hover their eight fingers over the keyboard and SLOWLY (much faster of course than one finger)  pick out the letters with roughly the appropriate fingers... by forcing themselves to do this I find beignners very very quickly learn to use eight fingers and hit the right letters at eight times the speed they might have done had they been allow to persist with the bad one-finer habit. 

If the beginner is allowed to use one and then max of two fingers it fast becomed impossible to switch them over to eight finger mode.  I have proved this time and time again.  I did the same with my son when he was four or five and he learnt to touch type, without looking at his fingers, at great speed and learning takes very little effort............  He monitors his 'mistakes' by his eyes/brain watching what appears on the screen.. he does not look at the 'buttons'.

I assume for music you 'hear' your wrong or correct notes and so teach the brain/finger/ear linkages by hearing if it is 'right'. :||: :|||:

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal