Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Prestidigitator on September 22, 2011, 12:52:03 PM
-
I dragged an old 1140 one-row in C out of the cupboard where it has lain for a long while, to assess it for some DIY tlc.
Apart from the usual wheezes, missing valves, loose reed plates, crumbling wax and so forth, the push on the top button (E push, B pull) sounds truly dreadful. I've taped over the reeds in turn, and find that one is fine at E6, albeit at an unsatisfactory pitch, whilst the other one comes back as D#6. The B pull is OK, so the problem seems limited to this one reed and not the whole plate it's on.
The reed doesn't look too bad on the top (it's still in the box), and I am wondering why it's out of tune. Could it be rust underneath? If not, can I just retune it by filing/scratching it at the tip? Or is anything else recommended?
-
Hi Prestidigitator,
Hard to know for sure without the instrument in hand, but since you mention loose reed plates and crumbling wax -- those can have an effect on the pitch of a reed tongue. And yes, rust or dust on the reverse side of a reed (as well as missing reed leathers / valves) can also affect the tuning.
Also, it's interesting that you mention the pull note on the #1 button of your key of C 1140 is "B." Based on the many I've seen of this model, I would expect that note to be "G." * If it really is sounding as a B, maybe someone has swapped reedplates or tried to retune the reedtongues for your #1 button.
PG
*Melody notes I expect on this model (press / draw), in order of increasing pitch: E/G G/B C/D E/F G/A C/B E/D G/F C/A E/B
-
Pgroff,
Thanks for your reply.
In button terms, I'm at the bottom of the instrument but the top of the scale i.e. at the knee end not the chin end - hence E/B.
The reed plate, which has no valves, seems pretty well waxed in with no gaps (unlike some towards the chin end), so it could well be rust underneath. I suppose I'll have to remove it to check.
If it isn't rust, do you think I should then retune the reed from D# to E by filing? It's not exactly a blue-chip box, so I have a bit of leeway to experiment, although I'd naturally prefer to get it right rather than wreck it if at all possible!
Peter
-
Hi Prestidigitator,
Sorry for misunderstanding you! Sure sounds like rust, dust, or dirt, etc. and that you'll need to clean those reed tongues and retune them.
Good luck with the work.
PG
-
I always think its less confusing to always refer to up & down from a musical rather than an anatomical perspective
george
-
I always think its less confusing to always refer to up & down from a musical rather than an anatomical perspective
george
Chinmost or kneemost ;D