Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Doug Barr on September 22, 2011, 03:29:42 PM

Title: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: Doug Barr on September 22, 2011, 03:29:42 PM
In general, what might be the difference in tuning(swing VS DRY) of Quebecois VS Irish one row boxes. What sound is most common?  Percents might be helpful.  Are they both in equal temperament or are some tweaked in any way?  Is there one setting that might be a compromise for both? Thanks  Doug
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: Andy in Vermont on September 22, 2011, 06:32:29 PM
In general, what might be the difference in tuning(swing VS DRY) of Quebecois VS Irish one row boxes. What sound is most common?  Percents might be helpful.  Are they both in equal temperament or are some tweaked in any way?  Is there one setting that might be a compromise for both? Thanks  Doug

Both are in equal temperament.
Quebecois boxes are generally tuned wet, but to different degrees according to player's preference, and there are two styles of tuning the middle reeds. In the more fashionable style today, one M reed is tuned "dead on," while the second M reed is tuned sharp (and the number of cents can reduce as you go up the keyboard; however, in general, the number of beats per second will rise.  The second tuning style involves tuning one middle set flat while the second middle set is tuned sharp. This was more typical when boxes were made with faux stops; players today, using boxes with working stops, prefer the former style because it allows you to switch off the sharp reed.

Perhaps Paul G will say something about Irish one-row boxes.

Cheers,
Andy
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: pgroff on September 22, 2011, 07:01:21 PM
Hi Andy and Doug,

I actually just replied to a message from Doug and recommended he contact you, Andy!

Re: Irish music, a lot of different sounds have been tried and preferences differ.  You could play nice Irish music on just about any melodeon with some practice and help from a teacher, but you probably will come to prefer a certain sound if you keep at this for a few years. . . maybe it will be the sound of a dry Castagnari, or a wet-tuned stock Hohner, or even an unequal-tempered pre-war Globe. Listening and playing as many boxes as you can, and finding a teacher whose style and sound you really like, are probably the best ways to accelerate the process of finding your own preferred sound.  It is reasonable to invest in a box now that might suit you for life, but on the other hand, be open to the possibility that you will want to get it retuned, or to swap it, as your perspective on the 1 -row changes with increasing skill and familiarity.

PG
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: diatonix on September 22, 2011, 10:18:40 PM
Are you sure about both being in equal temperament, Andy? One row instruments sound so much better when tuned to the just scale, no matter how "wet" some of the available register combinations might be.
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: blafleur on September 22, 2011, 11:30:36 PM
and the number of cents can reduce as you go up the keyboard
Cheers,
Andy

Andy, could you expand on that type of tuning?  John Roger mentioned that to me once, but can't remember what he said.  When you say "go up the keyboard", is that in scale, or physically?    Is there a rate that it reduces?
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: Andy in Vermont on September 23, 2011, 03:20:43 AM
and the number of cents can reduce as you go up the keyboard
Cheers,
Andy

Andy, could you expand on that type of tuning?  John Roger mentioned that to me once, but can't remember what he said.  When you say "go up the keyboard", is that in scale, or physically?    Is there a rate that it reduces?

If I have time on Sunday I might be able to chart it out.
Title: Re: one row Quebecois VS Irish box tuning(swing VS dry)
Post by: Andy in Vermont on September 23, 2011, 03:29:59 AM
Are you sure about both being in equal temperament, Andy? One row instruments sound so much better when tuned to the just scale, no matter how "wet" some of the available register combinations might be.

I didn't say anything about it being related to how wet the tuning was -- they are tuned in equal temperament, period.  Paul mentioned some vintage boxes used for Irish music that were just tuned, but I'm certain that the tuning used by Quebec players on one-row boxes is equal temperament.  Don't forget that these boxes are used to play in a variety of keys, major and minor.  If you flatten the third (F# on a D) box, you end up with a badly tuned fifth when playing in B minor (very common in Quebecois tunes).  It works well for Cajun music because of the keys the boxes are used for, but I wouldn't go so far as to say that it sounds "so much better" in all circumstances.  Especially considering the frequency with which (equal tempered) pianos are used for accompaniment.

There is a variation in the way that a certain Cajun builder tunes accordions that are bound for Quebec, but that is another story...
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal