Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on September 22, 2011, 09:28:44 PM
-
having just chopped off a bit of my middle finger at work, ( right hand ),
i think maybe i should start getting my left hand jumping around a bit ! i guess now is a great time to practace! .
can anyone tell me any good exercises to build up strength in my left hand??? id like to try and use 4 fingers on the bass if possible :o
-
Ouch! I hope the injury isn't too bad. I once chopped a bit off my thumb but years later all I have is a slightly flat bit that's barely noticeable. I know a concertina player who protects an injured fingertip by wearing the kind of rubber thimble a bank clerk used to wear when counting money. One of those might help once the worst of the soreness is over.
I use four fingers on the basses but I can't really recommend any proper exercises cos I'm not that good! Hope it mends soon and there are no long term problems mate. (:)
-
I have used one of these to improve my finger strength:
http://www.amazon.com/Gripmaster-Exerciser-Medium-Tension-7-Pounds/dp/B0006GC5D8 (http://www.amazon.com/Gripmaster-Exerciser-Medium-Tension-7-Pounds/dp/B0006GC5D8)
A 100 mile each way commute on motorways at the time gave me plenty of time to exercise. ;)
-
I use four fingers on the Bass end but I find that when I'm using the little and ring fingers the other two seem to stick up and out a lot, I also find that when stretching the little finger over the G bass to reach the C bass that I sometimes puss the G bass at the same time because the finger is so flat, I've been thinking that I'm either doing something wrong or that it might be better for me to try to use just three fingers.
Videos of the bass end from four finger players would be very helpful (she says hopefully ::))
Louise
-
Commiserations. I did the same about 15 years ago breaking the bone tip of index finger and a black, black nail. My advice to someone probably at/near the same playing stage as me then ..
Use this as a forced opportunity to develop your right hand technique. After all you already know the tunes, but bring that lazy little finger into use. My black finger took about a month to heal, I've been using my "pinky" ever since. :|glug
-
I also find that when stretching the little finger over the G bass to reach the C bass that I sometimes puss the G bass at the same time because the finger is so flat, I've been thinking that I'm either doing something wrong or
You may find it helpful to put your left hand further through the strap, then you can allow your fingers to adopt the natural curve of the relaxed hand, and can more easily bridge the inside row of buttons. This is not quite as simple as it sounds because you may then have to make other adjustments to how you hold the box - for example tilting the top slightly further away from your body.
-
I agree with Theo on this. Ideally the fingrs should hit the bass buttons with the ir ends rather than sides. To achieve this it its necessary ( with slight variation according to tyhpw of box , size of hand etc,) to have arm through wrist strap so wrist strap is roughly where you would wear a waatch. This then enables han & fingers to be in a sort of 'U' shape with finger ends pointing down on the buttons and makes the inside (bellows side) buttons much easier to reach without catching the outside ones and also makes it much easier to 'get about' on the bass end. For what its worth I tend to play 8 bass boxes mainly with just 1st & 2nd fingers and have no difficulty hitting whatever buttons are required.
The sma 'U' shaped technique is essential when playing stradella bass as otherwise nasty accidents can/will occur hitting unwanted buttons- and if 3 and perhaps occasionally 4 fingers are enough for 120 bass then 2 must be perfectly adeqate most of the time for 8.
george
-
and if 3 and perhaps occasionally 4 fingers are enough for 120 bass then 2 must be perfectly adeqate most of the time for 8.
George i think that is based on a false assumption that the only difference between a melodeon bass and a stradella bass is the number of buttons. One other significant difference is that melodeon bass buttons are almost always spaced much more widely, which might suggest more fingers would help. Also with most melodeons the air button is in use all the time which constrains the amount of hand movement possible.
-
and if 3 and perhaps occasionally 4 fingers are enough for 120 bass then 2 must be perfectly adeqate most of the time for 8.
George i think that is based on a false assumption that the only difference between a melodeon bass and a stradella bass is the number of buttons. One other significant difference is that melodeon bass buttons are almost always spaced much more widely,
on the other hand it is quite normal to sometimes travel longer distances (and back) between the required buttons on stradella
Also with most melodeons the air button is in use all the time which constrains the amount of hand movement possible.
indeed, b ut this also applies to the type of stradella box I mainly play.
george
-
I'm trying to use four fingers on my 8-bass D/G box left hand.
I can reach the keys comfortably enough with the hand position I'm using, though I don't have my hand pushed though the strap quite as far as George suggests.
My problem is that my hand tends to slide gradually up towards the top of the instrument (or the weight of the instrument causes it to move down relative to my left hand). Then when I try to reach C with my little finger I find it is out of reach without an awkward hand position readjustment.
Does anyone know a cure for this?
-
possibly down to the bass stap being too loose which is often the case if round the arm
end of the hand rather than round the arm itself (roughly watch strap position.) In this position it can be tighter without discomfort so as to retain the arm midships on the keyboards , wrist movement being quite sufficient on an 8 bass box to reach all buttons with however many fingers are prefered
george
-
I don't think my little finger is unusually short, but it's significantly shorter than my ring finger and I find it much easier to reach the lowest bass buttons with that, rather than stretching with my pinky. I've always, and instinctively, played with three fingers for this reason.
If it's too much of a struggle to reach with the little finger maybe you should reconsider your technique and switch to 3 fingers.
-
im such a wuss... i just wacked on a plaster and now i can play fine! i still need to get my left hand strong though, thanks for all the tips!
-
If you have seriously chopped off a bit of your middle finger then just putting on a plaster may well not be enough! Is your tetanus up to date? Is the wound properly clean?
In all seriousness I know someone who basically did what you've done and ended up minus a hand!
It's easier to sort it out properly now rather than wait for it to go wrong because of infection problems.
Steve
-
One of the problem with both hans is the independence of the third and fourth finger. One very simple way to get you hand and brain to separate the two fingers is by simply letting your hand on your lap and trying to raise your third finger ALONE! Not with the 2nd or 3rd! Try it only ten times once you can do it and I can garantee you will feel it up your arm!
-
Thanks for the suggestions.
I'll try George's answer - push left hand a bit further through and make sure strap is tight enough.
I'm quite comfortable playing with four fingers so long as my hand stays put where it's supposed to be.
-
I'm in favour of using all four fingers of the right hand, but I'm not convinced about the benefits of doing this with the left. For many people the little finger is quite a bit shorter than the third, and trying to reach across to the lower C button is too much of a stretch. I find it much easier to use just 3 fingers.
-
I'm in favour of using all four fingers of the right hand, but I'm not convinced about the benefits of doing this with the left. For many people the little finger is quite a bit shorter than the third, and trying to reach across to the lower C button is too much of a stretch. I find it much easier to use just 3 fingers.
Or two ;)
-
I'm in favour of using all four fingers of the right hand, but I'm not convinced about the benefits of doing this with the left. For many people the little finger is quite a bit shorter than the third, and trying to reach across to the lower C button is too much of a stretch. I find it much easier to use just 3 fingers.
That's just a matter of how you position your hand/arm. I have never seen any one of my students (hundreds) who couldnt reach that button with their little finger.
Once you start playing combinations of basses and chords on your left hand you are going to have to. Did you try combining your C-bass with your Bm chord for a CM7 without using your little finger.
And ofcourse, moving your hand costs time also, even without those kinda chords. so you wil always be slower then when you practice your little finger,
w
-
ive been jumping round elvis"s 12 basses with 2 fingers lately, its not too hard, so im wondering if i should just play bass with 2 fingers....and im using me thumb to reach accidentals...should i stop all this before bad habits set in ???
-
I don't think you need to use all 4 fingers for normal oop-pah-ing on an 8 bass melodeon - indeed many people are quite proficient using just 2.
I'd even suggest that trying to use your little finger as a goal in itself would be a false aim (especially with regard to playing the C buttons) and that you should do as much as you can with 3, then use the 4th if you find you can't do what you want.
Moreover, it takes quite a while to develop the necessary strength in the little finger. I developed mine on the stradella bass, but melodeon bass buttons are a lot bigger and are often stiffer, so be careful not to strain anything.
-
ive been jumping round elvis"s 12 basses with 2 fingers lately, its not too hard, so im wondering if i should just play bass with 2 fingers....and im using me thumb to reach accidentals...should i stop all this before bad habits set in ???
I only use 2 fingers on the basses and seem to get by. As to using your thumb, not wrong with that either but not much good for m a a single strap guy.
If something works for you go with it.
-
I'm in favour of using all four fingers of the right hand, but I'm not convinced about the benefits of doing this with the left. For many people the little finger is quite a bit shorter than the third, and trying to reach across to the lower C button is too much of a stretch. I find it much easier to use just 3 fingers.
That's just a matter of how you position your hand/arm. I have never seen any one of my students (hundreds) who couldnt reach that button with their little finger.
Once you start playing combinations of basses and chords on your left hand you are going to have to. Did you try combining your C-bass with your Bm chord for a CM7 without using your little finger.
And ofcourse, moving your hand costs time also, even without those kinda chords. so you wil always be slower then when you practice your little finger,
w
If you push your hand forwards so the (shorter) little finger can reach all the buttons, your other three fingers have to curl backwards more to shorten themselves, and this isn't good ergonomically.
Just using the little finger on the lower outer row buttons doesn't cause this problem -- but then this isn't really much of a reason to use it. I've found I can do all the cross-chords I need with 3 fingers, but others may find differently...
-
I'm normally a 3 finger bass player. I'm currently learning a tune requiring a D7 bass, so have been using a C bass and a D chord.
For me on my Tommy that's a full stretch - first finger on D chord and ring finger on C bass. I can just about do this without requiring occasional treatment on a medieval torturer's Rack.
Someone here has posted a copy of the left hand chords available on a 2 row, and on that chart, for a D7, it's giving a D bass + D chord and C bass. Interestingly, I can't bring my second finger into play for the D bass and keep the others on the D chord and C bass as above. It feels like one of those kiddie's games where if you hold your hand in such a way, you loose power on a finger, presumably because of the way the tendons are wired to the fingers.
To maintain a D7 chord as above it's looking like I need my little finger or drop the D bass and go back to what I originally thought a D7 chord was.
It appears that if cross rowing on basses you do occasionally need 3 or more fingers, or cheat somewhere ..... or alternatively simply not play odd chords.
Q in learning mode
-
I'm normally a 3 finger bass player. I'm currently learning a tune requiring a D7 bass, so have been using a C bass and a D chord.
For me on my Tommy that's a full stretch - first finger on D chord and ring finger on C bass. I can just about do this without requiring occasional treatment on a medieval torturer's Rack.
Sounds as if you are playing this on the push. Make your life considerably easier for yourself, and play it on the pull!
-
I'm in favour of using all four fingers of the right hand, but I'm not convinced about the benefits of doing this with the left. For many people the little finger is quite a bit shorter than the third, and trying to reach across to the lower C button is too much of a stretch. I find it much easier to use just 3 fingers.
That's just a matter of how you position your hand/arm. I have never seen any one of my students (hundreds) who couldnt reach that button with their little finger.
Reaching it is one thing, but using it comfortably is another, and as Ian says it then makes the other fingers more awkward.
I don't think I've ever felt the need to play Cm7 but having tried I find that I can do it fine with three fingers - although for that combination I probably would use the little finger. Also like Ian, I don't have any problems with the cross-chording patterns I use. And I'm not ruling out it's use when its expedient to do so, simply questioning whether trying to use it in normal playing is really worthwhile.
I really don't believe speed is an issue either - I'm never so rushed that using one finger rather than another would make a difference.
-
Ollie: yes absolutely right. It's on the pull in the second bar which is a lot easier, but on the first bar have to push against a D push on melody.
If only i had a pulled D on a half row ;)
I probably have the coordination to use my left pinkie, but it comes up to about the first joint on my first finger, so it is enuinely a little finger!
That's evolution for you, some things don't need improving ;D
Q