Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on September 27, 2011, 11:09:22 AM
-
I'm a little bemused at the moment I can't figure out how to play faster (faster not FAST) without it sounding rushed.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
-
Learn to play slow, speed will come when it's ready.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
The real skill is to play at the required speed without giving the impression of speed
-
I think it just comes with practise.
I also find I can play faster (or at least think I can), after I am "in the zone" in a session or a gig.
I guess there might be some "techniques" that you might have picked up which might be holding you back, or ones you have yet to learn which will help with the speed.
-
Learn to play slow, speed will come when it's ready.
[ The real skill is to play at the required speed without giving the impression of speed
This is indeed the essential ingredient of playing 'fast ' tunes at their correct speed . The best example to me was the way Jimmy Shand played at considerable speed when the tune required it but without the slightest signs of charging about or in fact of doing very much atall whilst maintaining superb phrasing , dynamics and clarity i.e. as Theo has pointed out without giving t any impression of speed.
The key to effortless fast playing is to sort out the required phrasing, dynamics etc whilst playing a tune at at slow or moderate speed and then to gradually increase the speed (up to the tunes natural speed) whilst making sure said phrasing & dynamics remain fully intact. Thiss will mean for most of us that at several intermediate spoeeds we lose the phrasing etc. That is the time to drop the speed back a little untill all is well and then try increasing it again a little bit etc etc etc.
Just playing a tune very quikly without attention to maintaining phrasing, dynamics etc tends to result in an unending & unmusical jumble of notes.
george
-
how to play faster (faster not FAST) without it sounding rushed.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
To me 'sounding rushed' means that the rhythm starts to be uneven which is what happens when you try to play faster than you really can. I know many on this forum will disagree, but I think the very best way to cultivate a nice even 'groove' is to practice with a metronome and use it to gradually increase your speed without losing the groove. The reason really good players sound 'laid back' is because their technique focuses your ear on the groove which isn't going that fast and you're not really "hearing" all the notes they are packing into that groove.
-
how to play faster (faster not FAST) without it sounding rushed.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
... I know many on this forum will disagree, but I think the very best way to cultivate a nice even 'groove' is to practice with a metronome and use it to gradually increase your speed without losing the groove. ....
I never did, and i dont think i ever will, but this is the method used in classical music often. Key is not to increase your speed to quick. Play it a couple of days at metronome-speed x, then play it a couple of days at speed x+1, etc. Don't try speeding up too much in too little time as you will then lose your punctuality/swing/groove/phrasing.
W
-
I agree that phrasing is all important. It is the difference between playing a tune and playing a bunch of notes in the correct sequence! Once you have learnt a tune (mechanically) the next step is to interpret it as phrases to breathe life into it and then that becomes the way that you think of it. The next step takes more time or a lifetime - becoming adept at varying that phrasing to good effect (listen to Simon Care playing a "simple" tune).
It seems to me that achieving the second step of thinking of the tune in terms of phrases is what makes it possible to increase speed as required. Don't ask me why, but it is easier to play each phrase faster than to speed up a tune which hasn't embedded itself to this level. Of course, there is an upside to this as so many phrases are similar between many tunes, that as you increase your repertoire it becomes easier to pick up a new tune in a session even at the speed it is being played. The downside is that you will also need to practice using different phrasing of known tunes to avoid getting set in your ways - a trap I've become all too familiar with, particularly when it comes to one's Morris repertoire! Never practice those, so I get stuck in a rut.
My criteria for when to drop out of a session "race" is when it is no longer possible to play the tune as phrases! I would liken playing a tune to one's fingers dancing on the keyboard.
Rob.
-
Lots of good advice here and I like what George has to say. I'd add that good phrasing in dance music is largely a matter of getting the internal rhythm of the tune right - paying attention to the relative lengths and weight of notes to get the right swing and feel. If you haven't got that, then even careful practice with a metronome won't give you a good result. At speed the faults in the rhythm will be magnified and nobody will enjoy the result.
The other point is that to play any instrument fast, you need economy and efficiency of movement. You need to be able to make the minimum amount of movement to play the tune. For example the use of the bellows. If you're wasting effort, it's not going to sound good when you speed up. When we see a virtuoso playing we often think, "he/she makes it look so easy." That's because, for them, it is easy. There is no unnecessary effort.
-
The other point is that to play any instrument fast, you need economy and efficiency of movement. You need to be able to make the minimum amount of movement to play the tune.
This is where the melodeon soundly trumps the PA and CBA..... >:E
-
how to play faster (faster not FAST) without it sounding rushed.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
To me 'sounding rushed' means that the rhythm starts to be uneven which is what happens when you try to play faster than you really can. I know many on this forum will disagree, but I think the very best way to cultivate a nice even 'groove' is to practice with a metronome and use it to gradually increase your speed without losing the groove. The reason really good players sound 'laid back' is because their technique focuses your ear on the groove which isn't going that fast and you're not really "hearing" all the notes they are packing into that groove.
But metronome is souless...won't that make my playing souless.
Don't wont to sound more boring and monotonous than I am already. :(
-
But metronome is souless...
I agree. The other problem with them is that absolutely all of them slow down. ;)
-
how to play faster (faster not FAST) without it sounding rushed.
Any suggestions on how to give impression of more speed without actually having to go fast?
But metronome is souless...won't that make my playing souless.
Don't wont to sound more boring and monotonous than I am already. :(
That is the standard argument against using a metronome and it is total rubbish. It is a very helpful and inexpensive tool.
-
But metronome is souless...won't that make my playing souless.
Don't wont to sound more boring and monotonous than I am already. :(
That is the standard argument against using a metronome and it is total rubbish. It is a very helpful and inexpensive tool.
I think a generous sprinkling of "in my opinion" might help here chaps ;)
-
But metronome is souless...
I agree. The other problem with them is that absolutely all of them slow down. ;)
you dont have to use one while on stage...it is a practicing tool,...
-
LDT - you illustrate on Oh Joe this month and on lots of other things that you've got a very steady rhythm and that's surely the most important thing. Don't you also play concertina and fiddle? If so, is it possible you're maybe taking on a bit too much? I wouldn't really worry about it - like many other people, I tend to practice at too fast a speed before I've really mastered a tune whereas one really should practice more slowly to get everything right before getting up to speed. Also, compared to some of us you're obviously nobbut a youth so you have decades ahead of you to work up a bit more pace. (:)
-
But metronome is souless...won't that make my playing souless.
Don't wont to sound more boring and monotonous than I am already. :(
That is the standard argument against using a metronome and it is total rubbish. It is a very helpful and inexpensive tool.
I think a generous sprinkling of "in my opinion" might help here chaps ;)
Yes, I stated that more strongly than I do most things. I think strongly held opinions are, in general, an impediment so I make a deliberate effort to hold my opinions lightly. Having said that, this is one opinion I hold fairly strongly. In my experience, most people who claim that using a metronome is detrimental are experienced musicians who have never worked with one. That is why I take the opportunity to state my opinion which is based on personal experience. It doesn't seem quite right for accomplished musicians to warn beginners away from something they have never used. It's just a basic tool for rhythm training that I would be willing to bet is used in every music school in the world. Perhaps it is uniquely detrimental to melodeon playing but I remain doubtful.
-
There's a big difference between using a metronome for practice and paying metronomically, as with a drum machine. I agree that totally regular playing can be soulless, but using a metronome sometimes (not all the time) can show you where you're playing unevenly, which isn't always apparent when you're practising on your own. If a tune sounds rushed it may be because you're not giving full measure to every longer note or rest, and a metronome will show up any lumpy bits like that. It will also help you to correct any tendency to speed up during a tune (easily done if you start cautiously and then get more confident).
Using it to mark an absolute speed can also show you what speed works best for a particular tune (for you) - obviously you can't use this when playing "out" but eventually you'll be able to find the right speed without a fixed reference.
-
What I'm not clear about is WHY anyone would want to play tunes fast as an end in itself (that's not intended as a criticism, but a genuine request for clarification). When playing with other people I often have the devil's own job to slow them down enough to let the tune "breathe" (unless of course it's "their" tune and they have established the pace they want). In the repertoire I generally play (English, with the odd Kerry polka or slide) there's generally a "groove" where the tune naturally sits, and when you happen to hit it there's nothing to beat the feeling. And don't get me started on 100mph morris! You're often reminded when driving - "Speed Kills". :D
Graham
-
My 'fast' is usually everyone elses 'mid' speed. ;)
-
My 'fast' is usually everyone elses 'mid' speed. ;)
Your playing of "Oh Joe" sounded absolutely fine to me. Playing too fast is a big fault of mine, it sounds fine while I am playing but often when I record myself it sounds way too fast, so I have to make a conscious effort to play at what seems too slow a pace.
-
My 'fast' is usually everyone elses 'mid' speed. ;)
My fast is often everyone else's snail's pace - after 30-odd years of playing I don't let it bother me!
-
Well done LdT for a thoughtful post.
Well, I'm thinking about it now.... ;D
There seems a lot of sound stuff here, and it has made me think about what I'm doing. Always a useful thing to do.
I think 'finding the groove' at whatever speed that may be for the tune seems to come after the umpteenth time through.
I seem to be getting to this point with a few tunes. Perhaps it's not that I'm speeding it up much, but maybe through repetition, playing it in a more confident manner - less hiccups, trying to get some emphasis here and there. Sort of 'playing the tune' as opposed to just pressing the right buttons.
Then I get overconfident......Yep - it then all goes out the window :(
But it's good before it goes pop :D
Hmmmm got me thinking.... must be time for a :|||:
Q
-
Another contributor to the groove, is including all the micro beats in between the main ones.
Listen to a player with a strong rhythmic groove and you will be able to count a strong beat 1 that marks the start of the bar, there will also be a strong beat at the start the main divisions of the bar, and other beats between those main beats. Those smaller pulses should still be felt in the music even where the notes are longer. For example its common in many waltzes to have several bars with just a single note, but to get a good waltz rhythm the pulse has to come across in those long notes, in some waltzes it is also possible to put a micro-pulse into each of those three main beats. Once you start doing that it becomes much harder to speed up because you are playing the same number of pulses per bar, irrespective of the length of the notes, and this has the effect of making it easier to play the long notes long enough, and to avoid speeding up in passages with lots of short notes. I'm talking about melody playing here, not something you add with the left hand. This is a bit of a simplification because rhythm will vary from bar to bar, though the pulse should always be there, even if on occasion it may only be in your own head.
here is a good example http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COQA-uc6yS8&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COQA-uc6yS8&feature=related)
-
Pulsing - yes I'm sort of playing with that now, trying to fathom it all out.
There's been another thread about this recently and I've hit on that and it got me thinking about how to put it in.
I also realised my rhythm from my English concertina comes just from the melody ( no basses on it! ) as someone pointed out which when I thought about it made perfect sense. A light went on
Just need to get it into the tunes.......
so much to do :Ph !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Q
-
Hm "The Groove". Listen to Charlie Watts and Bill Wyman, yes they've got the beat but also that something extra, often CW is just ahead of the beat and swings into it. OK it's rock and roll but so is the bass end of a melodeon (:)
Steve
-
I hate playing to a metronome, I always have since my childhood. Why? probably because I'm a poor musician and I lack discipline. Once you are an accomplished player you can write your own rules, until then you learn by the numbers and if you're not prepared to put the work in it simply won't happen unless you have a gift for music, some people do and that's all the more frustrating.
One of the part time music teachers at the school where I work spent many years on the treadmill of playing in the great London orchestras and is an extraordinarily gifted and expressive player. He challenged me to play a tune faultlessly at 1/4 of the normal playing speed. I failed dismally, which proved his point that poorly practised musicians rely on tempo and bravado to bluff their way through pieces they cannot play well.
If you know the piece and you have the skill you can play any tune at any tempo without falling on your face, with or without a metronome, but if you can't play with one you'll never play well without one.
-
One of the part time music teachers at the school where I work spent many years on the treadmill of playing in the great London orchestras and is an extraordinarily gifted and expressive player. He challenged me to play a tune faultlessly at 1/4 of the normal playing speed.
That is an EVIL trick and very hard to do!
It's also a good exercise - once you can do it at 1/4 and 1/2 speeds, your playing at normal speed should improve dramatically.
Nobody enjoys playing to a metronome, but it's a useful skill to learn if you ever get asked to use a click track in a recording studio, and it's also instructive to do it occasionally when your natural tendency is to speed up (or, much more rarely, slow down)
-
But metronome is souless...won't that make my playing souless.
Don't wont to sound more boring and monotonous than I am already. :(
[/quote]
Hello,
I have viewed most of your TOTM video's and I would say that your playing is neither boring or monotonous. Perhaps you have something else in your mind, after hearing your tunes? Yes, it's possibly not at the ease of some more seasoned players? I'm sure that's when experience is beyond, what is being played? [Not sure If that's dumb?] I would say that your playing is fine and I look forward to your interpretations each month. As the other players who contribute, too. ...... I would say that, TOTM is a gas! It's wonderful and I hope that it goes on. So good luck ladydestemps, please do not be discouraged just continue with your own style. I like it .......... cheers Jamie.
-
. He challenged me to play a tune faultlessly at 1/4 of the normal playing speed. I failed dismally, which proved his point that poorly practised musicians rely on tempo and bravado to bluff their way through pieces they cannot play well.
If you know the piece and you have the skill you can play any tune at any tempo without falling on your face, with or without a metronome, but if you can't play with one you'll never play well without one.
YES & YES!!
george ;D
-
What I'm not clear about is WHY anyone would want to play tunes fast as an end in itself (that's not intended as a criticism, but a genuine request for clarification). When playing with other people I often have the devil's own job to slow them down enough to let the tune "breathe" (unless of course it's "their" tune and they have established the pace they want). In the repertoire I generally play (English, with the odd Kerry polka or slide) there's generally a "groove" where the tune naturally sits, and when you happen to hit it there's nothing to beat the feeling. And don't get me started on 100mph morris! You're often reminded when driving - "Speed Kills". :D
Graham
Rapper.
... though you're generally correct I think.
-
One of the part time music teachers at the school where I work spent many years on the treadmill of playing in the great London orchestras and is an extraordinarily gifted and expressive player. He challenged me to play a tune faultlessly at 1/4 of the normal playing speed.
That is an EVIL trick and very hard to do!
It's also a good exercise - once you can do it at 1/4 and 1/2 speeds, your playing at normal speed should improve dramatically.
Nobody enjoys playing to a metronome, but it's a useful skill to learn if you ever get asked to use a click track in a recording studio, and it's also instructive to do it occasionally when your natural tendency is to speed up (or, much more rarely, slow down)
Arg! Click tracks. They drive me mad.
There are only two ways that I can cope with them. Either set the speed in mind and then start playing whilst ignoring the click track (usual method), or find a guitarist or keyboard player (chords) who can play to a click track and then play to that recording and the click track.
-
[ Graham
[/quote]
Rapper.
... .
[/quote]
indeed! I used to play Athol Highlanders regularly at 'rapper speed' 'cos it makes agood rapper tune! Otherwise I prefer it as originally intended i.e. as a pipe march at a marching speed of around 90.
george
-
Arg! Click tracks. They drive me mad.
There are only two ways that I can cope with them. Either set the speed in mind and then start playing whilst ignoring the click track (usual method), or find a guitarist or keyboard player (chords) who can play to a click track and then play to that recording and the click track.
Yes, I hate click tracks too; the sound is so staccato and dry, I actually find them difficult to hear as I'm playing. If I am recording for my own interest/pleasure using Apple's Garage Band, I will sometimes lay down a digital drum/percussion track first. There are all sorts of options available in Garage Band sound loops. I find that playing along to a percussion track, especially if it has subdivided beats, is much easier than playing to a dry click noise. Once the recording is finished, I delete or deactivate the percussion track.
-
A tip I picked up at a JK workshop. Practice playing familiar tunes very slowly and very stacatto. Definately works for me.
-
try playing tunes using just one finger as they will have to be 'staccato' or crisp or whatever. Start with a run through tune with 1st finger then do it with each other finger including little finger. Then try a run though using only one finger but randomly changing which finger is in use during the tune. AS well as playing staccato this little exercise helps to get away from the idea that a particular finger ha to play a particular note with the result that any finger can be used for the 'tune'note leaving 3 spares to do something else by way of right hand rhythm, harmony or a combination of both. It also strengthens the little finger so it can play its full part in the proceedings.
The one finger playing ( which may be a useful skill if you lost 3 in a nasty accident!) should be able to cope up to a decent march speed.
george
-
Great post, and some excellent advice.
Agree that metronomes don't mean you can't play a groove. Just that you don't speed it up. A lot of great bass players and drummers use clicks to practice with and just get comfortable with pushing or pulling the beat a little. I speak as a drummer (though not a great one unfortunately).
Also as a drummer, where practice is all about taking techniques slowly and precisely then building them up gradually and repetitively, I find for me that's the same on melodeon...slow, staccatto practice where you are aware of each note. I use a specific tune (at the moment Gilderoy as it has accidentals and I am trying to learn where they are) and just play it right hand, over and over, speeding up very gradually. Really like George's "one finger" approach too.
It feels a very mechanical kind of practice but it's like medecine, in time it makes a difference to accuracy and speed and that gives you more time to think about sounding nice.
Mind you I've practice drums technique since I was 12 and I still can't do this....
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppX4wJL37j4
-
The other point is that to play any instrument fast, you need economy and efficiency of movement.
Speaking as a very fast touch typist, this is all important. A melodeon keyboard is probably similar to a computer keyboard. On the old word piano you won't get far beyond 60 wpm if you're arching your fingers right up, and it's not a comfortable way to type either. A really fast typist will have their fingers only slightly rising from the keys, skimming the keyboard to the letter they want. It's taking the most direct route from A to B.
But it's something to think about once you know where all the home keys are. It's something to try to attain from the start, but you can't think of too many things at once so first steps are more about remembering what key is where and trying to type without looking. You learn to type first, then when you can type and are wanting to improve speed and accuracy, you *slow down* to actually think about your movements, to make them more precise. I stress slow down, because you find yourself typing and thinking "no, no, don't raise your fingers so much. Brush the keyboard. Stop wasting time and effort.". After a while your fingers get into the good habit and you find yourself getting faster without your fingers actually going faster as such - it's just that you've increased the speed by reducing the distance your fingertips travel.
I presume as this works for the typist's keyboard it will be the same for any musical keyboard. Efficiency of movement.
-
Don't be influenced by those melodeon players who think playing tunes fast is clever.
It isn't. Plus it usually ruins the tune. It may impress some people, but not me . It is actually harder to play tunes more slowly!
QV Spiers and Boden 'The Sloe'. Very fast, very flash, but I'd rather here the Ladydetemps version anytime.
(BTW - I know John can play it at the proper speed when appropriate!)
Pikey
-
It's a bit of an odd train of thought to go from folk to dance, but you're quite right - the current fashion for dubstep just goes to show that something played at half speed can sound more strong and disctinctive than some E-fuelled four to the floor techno track.
Me and You by Nero springs to mind.
-
Dubstep folk dance, now there's a thought. ;)
-
Ah, but the thing about folk, is that it was about peasants having a few beers, and dancing to some of their favourite tunes after a hard week's work. As any Essex Girl will tell you, just go down Basvegas on a Friday night and you will see a lot of us peasants still going out to have a few beers and dancing to some of our favourite tunes after a hard week's work.
Folk is just dance from a while ago. Therefore, dance is modern folk. Perhaps in 200 years time there'll be morris teams doing "Saturday Night" or "Agadoo" for tourists... recreations of 80's raves and rock concerts, with people wearing painstakingly hand-painted Metallica t-shirts.
-
It's a bit of an odd train of thought to go from folk to dance, but you're quite right - the current fashion for dubstep just goes to show that something played at half speed can sound more strong and disctinctive than some E-fuelled four to the floor techno track.
Me and You by Nero springs to mind.
Had to go look up dubstep
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dubstep
So its this kinda stuff? ;)
http://youtu.be/3N9APY0A7HY
-
Nice to see the young folks enjoying themselves ...
Time to celebrate St. Vitus' day as well as 1st May?
-
[ Graham
Rapper.
... .
[/quote]
indeed! I used to play Athol Highlanders regularly at 'rapper speed' 'cos it makes agood rapper tune! Otherwise I prefer it as originally intended i.e. as a pipe march at a marching speed of around 90.
george
[/quote]
Agreed, played as a pipe march with oomph (especially in A, which is easy on a D/G box and the fiddlers love it!) -- which unfortunately isn't how it often gets played in sessions, and it loses all the impact played too fast and diddly-diddly...
-
The first and last bits weren't too bad, with their forays into capers...
-
Needs more bass...
I do admit to certain Essex Girl stereotypical qualities. The car being a great place to sing at full volume, for example, although I draw the line at putting a speaker system in the boot.
-
Not going to pimp your melodeon then. With go faster stripes, neons and fluffy dice. ;)
-
I have to admit I'm very tempted by the blingy manfrini melodeons (if only I had the money). I have a pair of shoes which would match it.
-
I have to admit I'm very tempted by the blingy manfrini melodeons (if only I had the money). I have a pair of shoes which would match it.
The bling is really superficial, the box behind it has no pretensions. It's loud, it's proud and it will blow your shoes into the next universe. 8)
-
i got told to never play faster than you can whistle ! FWIW i play to a speed that makes me want to tap my feet - but im told thats too fast ! and it makes you tie your fingers up! i think speed comes with a tune once you have played it alot
-
I can play some Kerry polkas , & other tunes,extremely fast ,probably because I have played them for many years. However , played at that sort of speed they are certainly not danceable as the maker intended nor are they 'musical ' as at maximum speed all vestige of phrasing & dynamics is sacrificed to the alter of shit off a shovel velocity!
I try to work on the basis that the prime function of a dance tune is to make the dancers job as easy as possible i.e. by providing maximum rhythm & lift (I play to the feet of the best dancer in the hall). However if playing 'dance tunes 'for a 'performance' I will sometimes play at a wee bit faster than 'dance speed' as this seems to suite a seated audience of hand clappers & foot tappers.
george