It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.
B maj is more useful.
you can create a B min chord by playing a B bass and a D maj chord.
B maj is more useful.
To say B major is more useful is overstating it somewhat. As Chris says, it depends on the music you play. True, B major is the 5th chord of E minor in classical terms but as much of traditional music is modal and I have consistently found that I want B minor and not B major I've just had my box converted. It's also true to say that you can get B minor 7 with a B bass combined with a D major chord but often I don't want the minor 7th, I just want the straight minor chord, for me there's a big difference.
Dave
So, again, it seems to be down to the types of tunes that you are playing. I'm still fairly new to all of this and my repertoire is admittedly limited but of all of the English tunes that I play I've yet to come across one where the B major chord works or is appropriate. Any chance of someone listing some English tunes where you use B major?Whatever your repertoire at the moment, I can almost guarantee that sooner or later you will want to have a go at some Renaissance/Playford/French tunes in modal E minor, and the B major chord is very useful for many of those.
Up to this point I've assumed, much like Chris B, that the B major chord was simply a hangover from the melodeon's origins in Europe.
Up to this point I've assumed, much like Chris B, that the B major chord was simply a hangover from the melodeon's origins in Europe.
... Sheffield's Coope, Boyes & Simpson....?
The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab). Attempt this one after a sustaining meal .. it'll save cleaning your teeth!
The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab). Attempt this one after a sustaining meal .. it'll save cleaning your teeth!Some entertaining exchanges on this and other matters here:
A major third over a minor chord - now (given I'm not where I can try it out on anything right now) I guess that would be less useful, to put it politely.
The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab).
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.
Using only the D major notes but starting 1st, 2nd, 3rd ..
A 'mixolydian'
But you need a B major chord to play Delilah correctly!! (da dit dit da dit dit da dit dit da dee dee tum TA (Bmaj) ) ;D
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.
But you need a B major chord to play Delilah correctly!! (da dit dit da dit dit da dit dit da dee dee tum TA (Bmaj) ) ;D