Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Rog on September 27, 2011, 11:29:56 PM

Title: B minor v B major
Post by: Rog on September 27, 2011, 11:29:56 PM
I have a 5 yr old Delicia Popular Deluxe with a B minor bass chord on the left hand. Was in Hobgoblin in London today 'trying out' various boxes - all the DG ones seem to have a B major chord on the left side (Hohner, Excelsior).
What's the story on this? Have fashions changed in the last few years? Or is the Delicia just a bit weird? As it happens I like the Bm chord.
Watched a Youtube vid of someone playing a Salterelle and I think it had B minor left hand chord.
BTW I was rather taken by the Excelsior mini...
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Anahata on September 27, 2011, 11:37:48 PM
I've had a B minor box for many years, but I've just purchased one with B major (my choice)
I still can't make my mind up.

The B major box does have the G row accidentals reversed so I can play a D# with the B major chord, which makes a lot of sense.

The argument for B major is that if you want a B minor you can usually use a D chord (Bmin7) or G chord instead; if you want a B major you can't fake it with other chords.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 28, 2011, 12:16:20 AM
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Ollie on September 28, 2011, 12:21:43 AM
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.

But B maj is the fifth of E minor, and you can create a B min chord by playing a B bass and a D maj chord.

B maj is more useful.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2011, 08:01:33 AM
Yes, depends on what you play, but it isn't the 'key's - it is the 'modes'.  

The D/G's most natural minor is E and there are common aolian (with C from the G row) and dorian (C# from the D row) 'folky' modes.  Both lie easily under the fingers and would want a B minor chord as their '"V" (dominant) chord

If you play Scandanavian, Russian, Balkan, quite a few French and Spanish tunes, or anything 'jazzy' such as Grapelli "minor swing", or blues for that matter  then you are on (or relating to) the "harmonic minor" scale ...

   E F# G A B C D# E  - - in which '"V chord" B D# F# A = B7

   The melodeon doesn't offer 4-note LH chords - but "hence the B major"  :|glug
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: dave t on September 28, 2011, 09:05:26 AM
B maj is more useful.

To say B major is more useful is overstating it somewhat. As Chris says, it depends on the music you play. True, B major is the 5th chord of E minor in classical terms but as much of traditional music is modal and I have consistently found that I want B minor and not B major I've just had my box converted. It's also true to say that you can get B minor 7 with a B bass combined with a D major chord but often I don't want the minor 7th, I just want the straight minor chord, for me there's a big difference.

Dave
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: george garside on September 28, 2011, 10:32:55 AM
which just goes to show that  it is impossible to make a 'standard' push/pull 8 bass layout  that isn't a compromise and therefore won't meet everybodys ideals.   
 
It also seems to methat there are effectively two 'schools' of melodionists,  the theorists and the pragmatists.  The former enjoy worryhing about what they have not got and the latter enjoy making the best of what they have got.  Could this have anything to do with classical    training - v -  the if it sounds ok it is ok self taaught (by ear) approach.

george ;) >:E
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Rog on September 28, 2011, 12:21:41 PM
Thanks for the comments. Without spending time on a box with Bmaj I cannot judge really. It shouldn't be too difficult to convert, esp as I tend make up the LH as I go along and by ear.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: David J on September 28, 2011, 01:35:56 PM
Quote
you can create a B min chord by playing a B bass and a D maj chord.

I have one D/G box with a Bm, but I've got so used to using the above combination for a Bm, I find it annoying not to have the B maj and will probably get it changed back at some point. There are at least 6 English tunes I know where the B maj is important, and of course, once you venture into European stuff, it's very often the norm to have the maj dominant V chord.

Alternatively, take the thirds out and don't worry about it. . .
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Owen Woods on September 28, 2011, 01:54:32 PM
B maj is more useful.

To say B major is more useful is overstating it somewhat. As Chris says, it depends on the music you play. True, B major is the 5th chord of E minor in classical terms but as much of traditional music is modal and I have consistently found that I want B minor and not B major I've just had my box converted. It's also true to say that you can get B minor 7 with a B bass combined with a D major chord but often I don't want the minor 7th, I just want the straight minor chord, for me there's a big difference.

Dave

I disagree. Given that you can make Bm7 easily enough, and given that you can use B major a lot in Em tunes if you want to mix it up a bit, and that there are plenty of English tunes that require a B major I'd say that having the B major is significantly more useful.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Dazbo on September 28, 2011, 10:04:09 PM
Well, I can't think of any tune I play (except one, an Italian tarantella) that uses a B major chord.  Many people I know with bass stops nearly always play with the thirds out and quite a few who've taped up the thirds if they don't have a stop.  So as far as I'm concerned, the B major chord is more of a pain in the arse than anything else.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 29, 2011, 08:25:41 AM
I always imagined that the reason Hohner used the B maj chord for the UK market was that the history of the box in the early twentieth century involved its use for playing popular music, such as music hall numbers, where 'double dominants', and major chords in general, seem to occur quite often.  (For example, in tunes such as 'There's a long long trail a-winding').  And then that the reason they never changed to Bm when folk music became its main use was simply that opinions were divided, just as this thread has shown.

However I've no idea if this is true.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: LJC on September 29, 2011, 09:02:11 AM
I'm definitely in the Bm camp, it just works so much better for the slightly more subtle, esoteric sounding diatonic tunes I enjoy playing. It also makes sense on a DG as it  allows playing in the key of Bm (the relative minor of D major) which the box is obviously well equipped to do - even more so on a 12 bass where you have the option for F#m, completing a minor i iv v chord set. I would rather have two complete keys (Em/Bm) than just a very specific Em chord set.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Cooper on September 29, 2011, 10:24:49 AM
How about taping down the a from your D chord? that way you can make your Bm chord without the 7?


TBH i am so used to hearing that 7 when i play my Em (on a GC) that i dont hear it anymore, and i actually miss it if it nst there,
W
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Alison Scott on September 29, 2011, 02:25:06 PM
I'm a B Major sort of girl. I'm happy enough playing B note + D chord to fake a Bmin, and for the times I use that B Major chord I just love the strength of it. I'd miss it if it weren't there.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 29, 2011, 02:47:20 PM
As we're onto 'feel' rather than theory - - I've no thirds on one box and a stop on the other.

On standard kit, or 'stop unengaged' I'd say the same as Alison.  That B major is very useful whan you need it in a tonal melody (eg Flatworld, Poules Houppées). It's also the right dominant* chord in E blues

I tend to cross chord onto D when the tune is modal, but there are other ways. Sometimes a simple B bass is sufficient, or often you can weave the notes of the Bm chord into tune on the other end (B D and F# push, if you use the A you might as well use method 1)! Depends on the tune opportunities, but as ever the ear can hear what isn't there ...

*Unless you've a a BAlt or F7 handy!
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: dave t on September 30, 2011, 09:20:51 AM
So, again, it seems to be down to the types of tunes that you are playing. I'm still fairly new to all of this and my repertoire is admittedly limited but of all of the English tunes that I play I've yet to come across one where the B major chord works or is appropriate. Any chance of someone listing some English tunes where you use B major?

Up to this point I've assumed, much like Chris B, that the B major chord was simply a hangover from the melodeon's origins in Europe.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Steve_freereeder on September 30, 2011, 09:44:54 AM
So, again, it seems to be down to the types of tunes that you are playing. I'm still fairly new to all of this and my repertoire is admittedly limited but of all of the English tunes that I play I've yet to come across one where the B major chord works or is appropriate. Any chance of someone listing some English tunes where you use B major?

Up to this point I've assumed, much like Chris B, that the B major chord was simply a hangover from the melodeon's origins in Europe.
Whatever your repertoire at the moment, I can almost guarantee that sooner or later you will want to have a go at some Renaissance/Playford/French tunes in modal E minor, and the B major chord is very useful for many of those.
That's why I personally think it is ill-advised to have the B chord tuned as B minor. You can fudge a B major chord into minor by playing Bm7, but you can't fudge a B major chord from Bm.

You have more options open with B major. Why limit them?
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 30, 2011, 10:34:42 AM
Quote
Up to this point I've assumed, much like Chris B, that the B major chord was simply a hangover from the melodeon's origins in Europe.

Actually, I'm not going that far - I'm more in the 'horses for courses' or 'sitting on the fence' camp, and I was just talking about the possible historical origins rather than venturing an opinion on whether it's desirable or not.  Actually I tend to avoid the issue by usually taking out the bass thirds anyway.  In the tune Schottische à Bethanie (I've played it on http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=17116), there's a bit in the B music where I tend to add the D# (push) on the RHS the second time through the B music to change the chord to B major.

Also, I don't really accept that the box is just for folk music anyway.  But that's a whole new thread!......
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 30, 2011, 11:39:38 AM
Just to be clear

  'Modal' scales map to the diatonic scale - tunes playable on white notes of piano or single row melodeon

   Em as   1. dorian of Dmaj, staring second note,   
              2. natural minor of Gmaj, starting sixth note

       the 'correct' V chord for both these 'folky' scales is Bm or Bm7 depending on what side of bed you got out.

  "Tonal" scales are everything else .. in this case
 
  - Emharmonic = E 1 F# ½ G 1 A 1 B ½ C 1½ D# ½ E

  I've put in the 'intervals' in tones. Tha 1½ tone gap C to D# cannot map to 'white notes'  => 'tonal' scale
  The 1½ note interval is 'characteristic' of harmonic minor and its modes eg 'Romanian' 'Flamenco'

  Harmonic's dominant V chord starts on note 5 .. B => B D# F# A and the oversize 1½  gap makes it major
  that's the one in use for Baroque/Playford/Russian/Klesmer/Balkan/Baltic and 'some' French (esp Gurdy stuff) 
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 30, 2011, 11:58:28 AM
It's probably just chance that every D/G I've owned has come with a Bmaj chord, so I've no real experience of playing anything else. My C/F has an Amin chord, and as I've mentioned elsewhere, I'm so accustomed to expecting a major chord that it throws me a little and I find it very hard to get used to. Incidentally, my 1930s Bb/Eb has a Gmaj chord and as far as I am aware always has had - but then maybe Clubs always do.

Graham
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: birchy on September 30, 2011, 12:55:18 PM
As a bit of an aside, I've been a bit puzzled about the naming of modal scales.  In Chris's example above, do you call the scale in example 1 E Dorian, because it starts on E, or D Dorian, because D is the "mother" scale?

David
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 30, 2011, 02:40:48 PM
Using only the D major notes but starting 1st, 2nd, 3rd  ..

 D 'major'
 E 'dorian'       (these are 'classical Greek' names from Church music')
 F# 'phrygian'
 G 'lydian'
 A 'mixolydian'
 B 'aolian or "natural" or "Neopolitan" minor'
 C# 'locrian'

2 ways of looking at it -  E dorian is named for its E tonic note, and is a mode of the D diatonic scale

'D dorian' is actually a mode of the C diatonic scale Hear them on http://chrisryall.net/modes

Anything not deriving from a diatonic scale - harmonic, melodic minors, blues, diminished, whole tone, whatever is classed as 'tonal'
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: birchy on September 30, 2011, 05:05:04 PM
Thanks!  That's very clear.  I'd never even heard of modal scales before I joined this web site!

D
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 03, 2011, 08:52:51 AM
I started out (long) ago acapela singing in Darlington song workshop, and Gosforth trad music club - harmonies there were (still are) pretty "in yer face" and maybe that's what made me so conscious of them.  Anyway, I just stumbled on this track from Sheffield Holbrook/Matlock/Rotherham's Coope, Boyes & Simpson. It's sung in a convenient E minor and is in dorian mode - listen out for it's characteristic C#  in phrases like "garden so fair (pure)".

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzVcdi1xrYw

The chorus is also interesting - the third voice harmonises the last 3 words variably "in the cool of the day". Sometimes it's a D (ie true to the underlying scale), in others he sings D# transferring briefly to 'harmonic' harmony for what is in effect the song's 'turnaround' cadence and so anticipating the harmony of the next verse.   It would be deeply non melodeonic to allude any note 'halfway between' D and D# -  a Mod here has previously told me off for posting such distractions! I'll therefore not make any  mention of the occasions I might think this is done in the song and leave it to your own ear  >:E

Minor harmonies are actually pretty flexible - try for instance playing (or humming) an Fnat against the harmony line - mostly it's OK?   Now try a Cnat - very non dorian note -  but again it 'survives'.  We've already demonstrated that D/D# can be used 'flexibly' at a cost of 'different tune context'  - that's perhaps the essence of this thread?

The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab).  Attempt this one after a sustaining meal .. it'll save cleaning your teeth!
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: howard mitchell on October 03, 2011, 09:37:32 AM
... Sheffield's Coope, Boyes & Simpson....?

I'd never really placed them in Sheffield.  Barry lives in Holbrook, Derbyshire, Lester in Matlock and Jim in Rotherham.

H
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Anahata on October 03, 2011, 10:01:30 AM
The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab).  Attempt this one after a sustaining meal .. it'll save cleaning your teeth!

Never say never...
A Tierce de Picardie (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picardy_third) switches to the major third (the G# in your example) on a cadence at the end of the phrase. Agreed, it's a device that should be used sparingly, but if it was good enough for Bach...

If you mean combining the minor third with the major third in the SAME chord, I'm surprised you've never encountered that in your jazz and blues explorations. A 7th chord with a minor third on top can be delightfully scrunchy. I even wrote (and use) a Molly tune that exploits C natural against an A major bass/chord.

A major third over a minor chord - now (given I'm not where I can try it out on anything right now) I guess that would be less useful, to put it politely.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: jb on October 03, 2011, 11:27:57 AM
The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab).  Attempt this one after a sustaining meal .. it'll save cleaning your teeth!
Some entertaining exchanges on this and other matters here:
http://www.thegearpage.net/board/archive/index.php/t-715647.html (http://www.thegearpage.net/board/archive/index.php/t-715647.html)
If you want to check out the Coltrane reference (gennation, 05-06-2010, 08:42 PM), you can have fun trying here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xf0SGxi8HZw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xf0SGxi8HZw)
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 03, 2011, 11:36:26 AM
A major third over a minor chord - now (given I'm not where I can try it out on anything right now) I guess that would be less useful, to put it politely.

 Thought that's wot I sed  ???

The only 'never' note against a minor E is G#(Ab). 

OK - perhaps 'minor E chord' would have been clearer. There are numerous minor chord types, and against E as a 'note' anything is 'some form of harmony'.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 05, 2011, 01:02:41 PM
Chris, I found your example of Coope, Boyes and Simpson's 'Cool of the Day' to be fascinating.

A question I've got about modes - I know that many folk musicologists have ascribed traditional songs to 'modes', as if the singers who wrote them somehow knew musical theory.  I would have thought it's more likely that they had some sort of instinct for the sequence of notes in a certain mode.  But then more complex pieces of music often modulate to different keys or modes, which might imply that folk music doesn't.  To me, this seems something of a straightjacket on folkies - to what extent do you think that traditonal folk musicians actually imposed it on themselves? 

It seems to me that the reason that dance musicians often use a 'set' of tunes is surely because variety in keys or modes generates interest, and the changes in a 'set' of tunes are an important element of the overall performance, which is often under-appreciated.  I think perhaps Playford understood this in his tune selections.

So, could you say that CB&S have (extremely effectively) stepped outside the modal structure of the original song?
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: pikey on October 05, 2011, 01:22:30 PM
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.

But you need a B major chord to play Delilah correctly!!  (da dit dit da dit dit da dit dit da dee dee tum TA  (Bmaj) )  ;D
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: pikey on October 05, 2011, 01:25:44 PM
Using only the D major notes but starting 1st, 2nd, 3rd  ..

  A 'mixolydian'

 

I prefer the Myxamatosis mode myself...... That's the one where everyone in the sesssion roll their eyes and fall about on the floor......
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Strigulino on October 05, 2011, 02:06:01 PM
I keep meaning to learn more about modes but conversations like this one just make my eyes glaze over after a while.  I'm very much of the "if it sounds right, it's right" school, but then again I'm lucky enough to have a good ear for harmony (in fact, I've often found myself singing harmonies of songs on the radio other than the melodies) so I tend to just go for it and see what sounds right. 

The drawback of having a good ear is that I can't watch things like X Factor because people singing flat is torture to me...
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 05, 2011, 02:30:03 PM
CB&S?  They are sort of occilating between a truly modal approach and someone's irrisistable  urge to sing a 'tonal' leading tone ;)  Yes, if it sounds right it usually is, but isn't this thread about the reason for B 'whatever'  The two minors are really quite different to me and when they combine C# and D# in their melody/harmony the boys are actually into a third variant 'melodic'. Enough said

But you need a B major chord to play Delilah correctly!!  (da dit dit da dit dit da dit dit da dee dee tum TA  (Bmaj) )  ;D

   Harmonic  minor again - but AFAIR Samson had enough trouble with B's  - even before he married Delilah  ;D



This looks a good website: http://www.howmusicworks.org/608/ChordScale-Relations/C-Harmonic-Minor-Chords
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 06, 2011, 10:35:48 AM
Well certainly, getting back to the thread:

It's a long time since I played a 2-row Hohner, but I notice from the layouts that you don't get a D# push on the RHS, with the accidental first buttons, so on this box you can't fill in the major B chord if you had a thirdless LH.  Therefore, if you want the opportunity to play either Bm or Bmaj, which seems to be what's emerged as being important here, there's something to be said for keeping the Hohner Bmaj LH chord, and filling in on the RHS for the Bm.

Incidentally, some people seem not to mind the 'hybrid' Bm7 chord.  I have to say that I'm not sure about that - many of the Bm tunes that are nice to play if you have a thirdless LH tend to be slow airs, and that minor 7th often really destroys their feel!

However, on the more general question, I still have a hunch that musicology is essentially descriptive rather than prescriptive.  'Stepping out of line' to me often generates added interest in a piece of music.
Title: Re: B minor v B major
Post by: IanD on October 06, 2011, 11:49:20 AM
It depends on the keys in which you play. If you only play in G, D and Em (as many players of D/G instruments do), then Bm is of more use because the third is a D natural, whereas in a B major chord the third is a D#. However, if you play in other keys, the B major becomes more useful.

But you need a B major chord to play Delilah correctly!!  (da dit dit da dit dit da dit dit da dee dee tum TA  (Bmaj) )  ;D

And if you play Swedish/French/Italian waltzes in Em (which I do, a lot) they almost always need a B major, a minor sounds horrible.

Ian
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal