Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Kennymac on September 28, 2011, 08:12:33 AM

Title: It it were a car....
Post by: Kennymac on September 28, 2011, 08:12:33 AM
Hi
I am a newbee and would appreciate some guidance if possible on the massive range of boxes out there. I am staggered by the range and prices for some of the melodeons I see. I realise spending a lot of money on an instrument is not necessarily going to make me improve my playing. However, it would help me in choosing an instrument if I could draw some parallels and here is an obvious start.... hopefully in simple terms.
If a melodeon was a car, where would it sit i.e. what is the real workhorse (the Volvo of the box world), what is the melodeon that only comes out for show and rarely played (Lamborghini). Is it possible to fit brands such as Serafini, Eric Martin, Saltarelle, Hohner, Delicia, Oakwood, Baffetti, Castagnari into one of the four categories below. Would a beginner buy an Eric Martin or Oakwood?

Entry Level / Starter :    Mini, Peugeot 107, The Banger....
Mass Market Family Car :    Opel Astra, Ford Mondeo, Volkswagen Passat
Luxury Car :       Audi, Mercedes, Lexus, Jaguar
Super Car:       Porsche, Ferrari, Aston Martin, Lamborghini, Morgan
 
In other words what is the

Entry Level Box :
Mass Market Box:
Luxury High End Box:
Super Box:

This might be an over simplification but, at the very least I will know when to look impressed when someone tells me the make and model of the melodeon.

Thanks - Kenny
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2011, 08:54:52 AM
This previous thread developed a similar analogy ...

    http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,2052.0.html

You might also note that the 'entry level' could be changing

   http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7727.0.html
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Christopher K. on September 28, 2011, 09:36:53 AM
Although fun, I'm afraid automobiles is not the most helpful analogy. There are too many variables. And prices can be misleading, too. There's a huge difference in quality and performance, imo, between a Mazda 3 and a Kia Forte SX. But looking at the prices you'd think they were more similar than they really are. The only reason I currently own a Kia is that it's the only dealer consistently willing to roll my negative in a trade.   ;D

I would not expect better playability just because a melodeon costs more -- cost may have increased because the melodeon has more features, or even better materials, but that doesn't mean the finished product plays and responds better than something which is less expensive. It is a learning process that takes time. Good advice, I think, is to identify your price range and play as many as you can until find the combination of features and feel that you need for your style. When in doubt, start with an overhauled Erica or Pokerwork which are certainly workhorses, and are very nice instruments that hold the value you'll pay to own one.

Sometimes, and I think we've all been there at least once, eating the cost of an accordion is to some extent a part of the learning process. You buy something because you thought it was going to solve all your problems, were assured of its quality by its reputation and glowing reviews, and it turns out to be completely different than you expected.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Kennymac on September 28, 2011, 11:28:20 AM
Although fun, I'm afraid automobiles is not the most helpful analogy.


Hi – It wasn’t intended as a bit of fun. Everything generally is part of some hierarchy or pecking order..... hand tools, guitars, bagpipes (which I play and could rate a handful of instruments accordingly) and even musicians. I would’t buy a new instrument anymore than I would buy a new car (loses so much when you drive it off the courtyard just as a box would lose its value once your credit card has been swiped).
If I can get a sense of the pecking order of an instrument, I can work out what brands, models to look out for. I guess a quick and dirty rule of thumb with regards the pecking order would be useful. In the piping world for example, you would now have to wait over a year for a set of handmade Kinnear Smallpipes (fortunately, I have mine... and this is a quality instrument if you are into that particulr traditional sound).
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Theo on September 28, 2011, 11:46:14 AM
I've been trying to think of a car analogy to the cheapest, often dubiously branded, Chinese boxes, but I don't think there is one, a car of this sort of quality would not meet EU construction and safety regulations!   :o

GDR era Galotta/Weltmeister might be equivalent of a Trabant

Post-GDR era Galotta/Weltmeister could be likened to the newer Skoda

Hohner Erica/Pokerwork  - Morris Minor  (sorry showing my age)

Saltarelle range - Ford

Castagnari  - Volvo

Oakwood - Lotus

Paolo Soprani - Bently

Briggs - Bristol

Of course there are even more arguments over cars than boxes, so please lets keep cool everybody  ;)

Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Cooper on September 28, 2011, 12:05:39 PM
I dont own or drive cars so i cannot help you there...but just for fun. It's ofcourse a big generalization and depending on taste and purpose(style) as well. plus a first start, please adjust when appropriate


Entry Level Box : Pokerwork/Erica, Hohner/Harmona. (There are worse boxes on the market (chinese) but you dont want to buy those)
Mass Market Box: the above mentioned could be here as well. Going up to Sandpiper/Mengascini/Saltarelle going up to Serenellini/Loffet
Luxury High End Box: Castagnari/vdAA/Maugein/Verde going up to Serafini
Super Box: Gaillard/Cairdin/Libouton/Martin

Some of them i've only played or seen once or twice, so that doesnt say much,...

i am interested to see the boards adjustments :-)
W
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on September 28, 2011, 12:10:20 PM

I don't think that people are being deliberately awkward or missing the point, it *really* isn't that simple.

I did write some stuff showing how I think the analogy doesn't work, but I got bogged down in analogies about analogies that didn't work, that didn't work ... then I gave up.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 28, 2011, 02:25:59 PM
I am not going down the car analogy route because I don't think it is helpful. Different people have very different perceptions of the different makes available. For instance, I regard Volvos as towards the better end of the mass market whereas my brother-in-law considers them to be luxury cars. When buying my current car, I eventually chose a Kia Sorento in preference to a Jaguar because it felt more like a luxury car, drove better and had more whistles and bells. However, I know that not many people would agree with me in regarding a Kia as a luxury car!

Your division into entry level, mass market, luxury and super is more useful. Theo and Cooper have both given a good indication of where different boxes fit in that spectrum, so I won't repeat what they have written. However, I would suggest from my own experience and from those of friends that the advice we were given to start with a mass market box such as a Hohner Pokerwork or Erica or perhaps a Weltmeister was not helpful. We bought these instruments only to discover that, while some of them (especially the Hohners) make a delightful sound, they are not as easy to play as some of the more expensive instruments (e.g. Castagnaris).

A starter would be well advised to avoid fancy boxes with multiple voices and slides or stops and begin with a two-row eight-bass instrument, but I would advise buying the best instrument you can afford because the action is likely to be easier than it is on many of the cheaper instruments. Furthermore, good quality secondhand instruments retain and often increase their value, so that if you find you want to sell it and buy something different a few years down the line, you may find that you can sell it for more than you paid for it.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Theo on September 28, 2011, 03:10:19 PM

Luxury High End Box: Castagnari/vdAA/Maugein/Verde going up to Serafini
i am interested to see the boards adjustments :-)
W

I've only actually played and worked on a couple of Verde boxes and while nicely made certainly not in the luxury class.  Based on what I've seen I think they belong firmly in the mass market category.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Cooper on September 28, 2011, 03:47:36 PM

Luxury High End Box: Castagnari/vdAA/Maugein/Verde going up to Serafini
i am interested to see the boards adjustments :-)
W

I've only actually played and worked on a couple of Verde boxes and while nicely made certainly not in the luxury class.  Based on what I've seen I think they belong firmly in the mass market category.

yeah, you're right,
W
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on September 28, 2011, 04:13:58 PM
gabbanelli - icecream van.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Clive Williams on September 28, 2011, 04:25:53 PM
Super Box: Gaillard/Cairdin/Libouton/Martin

I've not heard of Libouton before; a Belgian maker that passed away in 2005 I gather, though I don't know if anyone kept them making them in his name. Anyone know anything more about them?

Clive

PS: Streb = Prius
Brrrum brrrum!


Title: Re: If it were a car....
Post by: Kennymac on September 28, 2011, 05:49:43 PM
Thank you for the feedback. This really is useful and actually helps makes sense of some of the comments and contribution in the forum.
For example someone in one forum made the comment “I would still go for a Hohner Erica unless I was going to splash out on a posh Italian box”.... now I appreciate their relevant standing.
It is also useful having some of the comparative views e.g. it is interesting the comments Theo makes as I understand he “works under bonnet” and maintains and refurbishes melodeons if I picked up his web links correctly.
Many thanks.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Matthew B on September 28, 2011, 05:57:44 PM
Just to keep it complex, I think the hierarchy of boxes should be probably include both the models and the traditions in question.

For example, Hohners range in quality and cost from the mighty Morinos (of all flavors) to the humble early-Chinese pokerworks.  As I understand it, for some Scottish players only a Shand Morino will do the trick: A Rolls, or nothing.  

For many English players the Hohner Pokerwork seems to be like a Raleigh three-speed: Affordable, reliable (mostly), drifting in and out of fashion, everyone's had one, got one, or will soon get one.  And you'll have to tinker with it in the shed sooner or later, to get it to behave.  

In the American South-West only tricked-out Hohner Coronas and Gabinellis are considered worthwhile: Cadillacs, with fuzzy dice, low-rider air suspension, and tail-fins.  

In the Fanco-American North-East and South, only exquisite locally made bespoke reproductions of cheap German mass-produced one-rows will do it: Philipino Jeepneys perhaps?

And so on . . .

Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: TomB on September 28, 2011, 06:08:49 PM
Kennymac, I see that you play a Delicia popular. I know a few people with these boxes (albeit GD tuning) and they seem to like them. The ones I've played sound pleasent and are easy to play. I'm even looking for one myself for trying out GD tuning (I play BC normally). I wonder what the concensus is concerning the 'build quality' and reed quality? Obviously not in the higher class but still very playable.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Cooper on September 28, 2011, 07:29:25 PM
Super Box: Gaillard/Cairdin/Libouton/Martin

I've not heard of Libouton before; a Belgian maker that passed away in 2005 I gather, though I don't know if anyone kept them making them in his name. Anyone know anything more about them?

Clive

PS: Streb = Prius
Brrrum brrrum!

I dont thnk they are still made. I've only seen and played on 3 i think. They are entirely different thing from the rest, and quite heavy (kilo's). Yet they jump out for some reason.
W
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: ACE on September 29, 2011, 10:37:32 AM
Just remember when you are poodling along in your Nissan Micra,  when a few more join in they usually hareing along in their Jags. Don't be tempted to join them. I took a chequered flag to a session that was notorious for speeding up every tune, I waved it at the end of one set, they got the message.
Title: Re: If it were a car....
Post by: Kennymac on September 29, 2011, 01:39:04 PM
Hi Tom,

The Delicia Popular is a nice instrument. I bought it in a big high street music shop in Cambridge. Choice was pretty much limited to that and Hohner. I bought a BC model and the tutor book called "The Box" and have dipped into it every so often. I played Scottish Highland Pipes when I was younger which are just sometimes way way too noisy. Great for going into battle and a new year bash. Three years back I was in a bar in Portree in Skye and came across a session group and someone playing Scottish Smallpipes (had never seen them before and have since found out they were brought back to life in 1983). I now play them and the big pipes again on a regular basis (big pipes with a band every week). In the next two / three weeks I am going along to my first session which I have never done before. I am looking at the box as a 2nd instrument. The smallpipes are a nice instrument and not a noisy as the big pipes but I think the box is a nice complement in between playing the smallpipes. Been playing a lot more recently and the interest is sparked again. Starting to focus on a repertoire and applying the same discipline I need for the pipe band tunes to the box. 

If it goes well with session playing and box playing, my sense is to upgrade the box but I know I will only be doing it once. Hence the reason for my question. I have had the same big pipes for over 30 years and they are now sounding about right.

Kenny
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Graham Spencer on September 29, 2011, 02:42:36 PM
Just to keep it complex, I think the hierarchy of boxes should be probably include both the models and the traditions in question.


Not to mention the age of the box - my very old Serenellini-built Saltarelle may have its faults, but it's a far better box than some of the later ones from other factories.  I imagine the Bafetti-built ones are OK, but I've never knowingly played one!
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: folkman on September 29, 2011, 02:52:40 PM
I bought my Hohner Pokerwork box from Theo because he said it was a great 'Morris' box. I thought he meant for playing morris but it seems he was talking about the car. Blast! ::)
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Alison Scott on September 29, 2011, 03:22:08 PM

Oakwood - Lotus


Pretty sure an Oakwood is a whole lot more like a Morgan than a Lotus, you know.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Theo on September 29, 2011, 03:23:03 PM
I bought my Hohner Pokerwork box from Theo because he said it was a great 'Morris' box. I thought he meant for playing morris but it seems he was talking about the car. Blast! ::)

Oh  no!  I've been rumbled  >:(
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Theo on September 29, 2011, 03:23:25 PM

Oakwood - Lotus


Pretty sure an Oakwood is a whole lot more like a Morgan than a Lotus, you know.

OK I'll go with that.
Title: Re: It it were a car....
Post by: Peter Savage on September 29, 2011, 05:27:43 PM
Let me start by saying that I am not expert since I have only be playing 4 years or so (and just switched to D/G from B/C).  However, in my opinion in comes down to 2 factors:

1) How much money have, or are you willing to part with?

2) What style of playing do you like?

I think #1 is obvious...you get what you pay for generally, as with most musically instruments.

#2 is a little more interesting...

If you are into morris, or spend every evening listening to John Kirkpatrick, then it's quite possible that you might like the sound of one of the cheaper boxes that have been mentioned so far (e.g. Hohner Erica or Pokerwork). 

However, if you like, for example, Andy's Cuttings sound then you're probably not going to like what you hear coming out of the average Erica/Pokerwork.

This is exactly what happened to me.  I started on an Erica and was getting better fast but my ears were really not liking the sound that I was producing.  So I bought a Castagnari Illary (I was playing B/C at the time) and suddenly the smile was on my face.  Yes, the action was better and that certainly helped.  But the main thing is that I liked what I was hearing and wanted to play more.

So my advice would be to look at the music you like and then try to find a box, within your budget, that gives you that sound. 
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal