Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Clive Williams on September 29, 2011, 12:02:51 AM
-
Oooh. Broadcasting on Discovery Science+1 channel now. :o
-
Oooh. Piano keyboard assembly is clever. You need suction apparently.
-
Next... how to assemble a stradella bass. They make it look so easy.
-
The tuner is tuning the reeds entirely by ear. No tuner or tuning software in sight! This is Hohner, by the way. 600 reeds in a piano accordion apparently...
-
All over. Pineapples now.
-
It takes apparently less than 8 minutes to make an accordion, which is why I missed it all. However, I did learn a helluva lot about pineapples and artificial joints.
-
This it?....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcMHiAxB-jQ
-
This it?....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcMHiAxB-jQ
Yep, that's the one!
-
This it?....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcMHiAxB-jQ
Yep, that's the one!
The tuner is tuning the reeds entirely by ear. No tuner or tuning software in sight! This is Hohner, by the way. 600 reeds in a piano accordion apparently...
Look again, from 2.30 onwards there is an electronic tuner at the right of the picture.
-
Look again, from 2.30 onwards there is an electronic tuner at the right of the picture.
Ah yes. Forgot that bit! But look at the chap fine tuning at 3:40 onwards - there's no tuner in the camera shot (it's a different tuning station, because he's not using a foot pump), and he doesn't seem to be looking at anything off camera either when he's listening... ???
-
there's no tuner in the camera shot (it's a different tuning station, because he's not using a foot pump), and he doesn't seem to be looking at anything off camera either when he's listening... ???
...well that conclusively explains Hohner's trademark Almost Tuning then. ;D
-
there's no tuner in the camera shot (it's a different tuning station, because he's not using a foot pump), and he doesn't seem to be looking at anything off camera either when he's listening... ???
...well that conclusively explains Hohner's trademark Almost Tuning then. ;D
I think the accordion in the film is a top of the range Hohner maybe a Morina or Gola. I don't think they would get away with almost tuning on those.
The final tuning in the assembled instrument can be done best by ear by listening to beats when comparing octaves, fifths and other intervals to get the concert pitch reeds tuned to the correct scale (usually ET) and then listening to pairs of tremolo reeds to get an even tremolo across the whole instrument, or zero tremolo in the case of LM and other combinations that should be beat free.
In the first shot at 3.40 chords are being tuned, and you can see the tuner plays two chord before making an adjustment, this probably allows him to adjust the reed in common between two chords, eg D in G and D chords, which in a Stradella bass is the same reed.
-
Most respected English tuner, Ivor Hyde, tunes by ear in fifths and octaves.
-
Piano tuners have been tuning by ear for ages so it's obviously possible.
Nigel
-
Piano tuners have been tuning by ear for ages so it's obviously possible.
Nigel
Pianos are different because the stiffness of the strings -- especially at the top and bottom of the keyboard -- means that harmonics aren't in tune with the fundamentals, leading to "stretched" tuning where the lowest strings are actually a little flat and the highest a little sharp. If you tune to concert pitch everywhere it sounds out of tune.
Reed instruments aren't like this, by definition all the harmonics are exact multiples of the fundamental. They also have a lot more high harmonics than a piano which makes tuning accuracy more critical.