Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Strigulino on October 03, 2011, 10:33:26 AM
-
Hello all - Essex girl looking for help beginning melodeon. Have been toying with the idea since seeing someone play one a year or so ago at the British Esperanto Congress of all things, but recent honeymoon in Ireland has clinched the idea, so I'm hopefully getting a beginner b/c 2 row this month when I can get to Hobgoblin to try some out.
As you can tell I love the craic but I'll play anything fun. Musical background is I played flute at school and can read music a bit and pick out notes and chords on a piano but my sight reading is not fast. I always used to use the music as a guide and learn the part by ear which probably makes me an ideal folkie.
Incidentally, husband is keen to at least have a go and was a percussionist at school so is thinking of attempting bodhran if you know of any suitable hand-holders for that too.
I'm based in Basildon, Jewel of the East but can travel evenings as long as its not a huge distance as I dont finish work until 7. Can't do Fridays.
Thanks all.
Strig
-
Hello Strig and welcome to the melnet madness! I hope you will find lots of help and support on here.
Just one little niggle of concern....
Unless you are totally in to Irish traditional music and you are sure that's the style you want to pursue (and have a support network of players/sessions around you), I would be a bit wary about buying a B/C tuned melodeon. They are not so suitable for the majority of English/general folkie tunes which would mostly be encountered in your general location. Most people in your area will play a melodeon tuned in D/G, and at the beginner stage, you really need as much peer support as you can get.
The B/C (the two rows are tuned a semitone apart) and the D/G (two rows tuned a 4th apart) are very different in the way in which they are played. It may be that you are totally sure that the B/C is what you want, in which case I apologise and you may totally ignore this post (I shan't be miffed ;) ) but if you are at all uncertain, think very carefully and take some more advice before committing yourself to the B/C system.
-
Thanks for the reply - I'm always prepared to be swayed (the main point of a forum is to garner information after all). I have given it a bit of thought and there were three main reasons for B/C:
1) Irish music - I like Irish music and the B/C is recommended for that in a few places (although not all, I admit).
2) Non-folk playing - I wanted a chromatic as I like to arrange and the possibility of rock anthems arranged for folk instrument appealed to me, so I was wary of limiting myself to a diatonic instrument. I'd hate to have to limit muso friends to certain keys on my behalf. I like singing too, so I wanted to be sure I could play in keys I can sing in.
3) Futureproofing - if I started on a diatonic box and then moved to a chromatic, I'd have to learn a whole new set of fingerings presumably. As you say, they're played differently and I don't want to put effort and money into learning one and then having to do it all over again with a new box.
I have set up this little coconut shy of reasons for you to chuck things at and knock my prejudices down as you see fit.
From my brief foray into the world of melodeons, I have come to a few conclusions:
1) A melodeon sound, make and key is a very personal choice.
2) They're a bit more complicated than they look.
3) Melodeon players like to gain converts by helping new people.
That's why I'm here. I'm hopeful that in the future I'll find the melodeon for me, but at the moment I'm faced with a buffet of possibilities with various people saying "try the fish", "no, have that vol-au-vent, it's amazing", "no, don't have that, it's cheap", "no, have the cheap one, you don't want to have an expensive one and not like it". My main idea at the moment is to go into a shop with an open mind and have a go of a few. I'll probably just fall in love with the sound of one and that'll be the one for me.
-
Welcome to melnet O fellow Essex person! Good luck with your quest. I've been playing about 4 months and all I can say is - it's great fun! Been a guitarist all my life so this has been a real shock to me but I'm loving every minute of it. Sorry, I'm not much use to you as I'm a D/G player. Have a chat with Martyn White who lives down the road from us in Howe Green, nr. Chelmsford. He sells and restores melodeons and will, I'm sure, get you fixed up with something. Beware of eBay unless you really know what you're doing. I bought both of my boxes from Martyn and I'm glad I did as they're both fettled and tuned to perfection.
Sounds as though you know exactly what you're after - when I started I didn't have the first clue and was lucky enough to get good advice before I wasted a load of time and money.
My very best wishes to you.
Les ;) :||:
-
Hi Strig and welcome.
One of the ironies in the use of the chromatic boxes in Irish music is that they are on the whole played in a limited range of keys! A large proportion of Irish tunes are played in G D A and related modes. The value of the semitone system is more for the way it can be used for ornamentation as it is for playing in all keys. Much of the available tuition materials are geared to these keys so in exploiting a wider range of keys you will to a large extent be making your own way. Nothing wrong with that of course, but its useful to know what is up ahead.
As an accompaniment to singing there tends to be more need to playing chords than melody, and two row diatonic boxes will give you a richer palette of chords on the right hand than you would have with a BC. Then the choice comes down to finding the pitch of diatonic that suits the keys you like to sing in.
-
Thanks all - I must admit I've not made my mind up either way. If I was really sold on playing every note possible on the right hand I'd get a piano accordion. I'm more into something that you can bang a tune out on quite quickly, and I admit one of the draws of a diatonic is that it's a bit hard to hit a really bum note as they're not actually available.
I have fond memories of my mum and dad's old brown plastic 70s chord organ, which is sort of what I'm trying to recreate. Tune by ear on the right hand, appropriate chords on the left, bob's your maiden aunt. I suppose if I'm mainly playing on my own at home I can play stuff in whatever key I please.
Something that someone else said to me recently is that most pop songs are folk songs with amplification, which is true really. If you can't play that note, miss it out and pretend it was ornamentation. :D
/edit As an afterthought, the D/G chord and bass keys seem to have much more useful chords for songs in Dmaj and Gmaj, which I believe most Irish trad is.
-
one of the draws of a diatonic is that it's a bit hard to hit a really bum note as they're not actually available.
Oh I don't know - I seem to manage pretty well!!!! :|bl :|bl :|bl
-
I've got a friend who can play just about every folk instrument I've heard of and quite a few I haven't. I'll have to ask him his opinion also.
Am I right in thinking, then, that the two rows of the right hand are basically a D major scale and a G major scale with a few accidentals in there as spares?
-
I've got a friend who can play just about every folk instrument I've heard of and quite a few I haven't. I'll have to ask him his opinion also.
Am I right in thinking, then, that the two rows of the right hand are basically a D major scale and a G major scale with a few accidentals in there as spares?
Yep -spot on (with a bit of pushing and pulling)!!
-
Am I right in thinking, then, that the two rows of the right hand are basically a D major scale and a G major scale with a few accidentals in there as spares?
Yes. The layout of a D/G box makes playing in G major and D major very easy, and E minor and A minor nearly as easy. With the help of the accidentals, C major, and A major are fairly straightforward; B minor is a little trickier but still quite possible.
'Standard' D/G layout is here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21acc.gif
The beauty of the '4th apart' tunings (D/G, C/F, G/C, etc) is that the basses and chords tend to 'automatically' work with the RH melody.
-
So basically if you're accompanying yourself, or it's in D or G, push and pull and press buttons and it'll probably be OK. Sounds like my kind of instrument. :D
I've never been a huge fan of theory - I tend to get Magic Roundabout playing in my head as soon as someone mentions modes or the circle of fifths - so just pick it up and make your own style sounds good to me.
I'm a 70 wpm touch typist so if I can manage the word piano a squeezebox shouldn't cause me great issues as long as I get some practice in.
Can't wait to get my hands on one now! A pushmi-pullyu. :|||:
-
We're off to Alton Towers for the weekend and have Friday off to travel - cunningly the Newport Pagnell Hobgoblin is very close to the M1 so we're thinking of dropping in on Friday and having a play. I phoned and they said they'd have a selection of likely boxes for me to try. Apparently Simon Care will be there so it'll be an excellent day to drop in and do some brain picking. Even if I don't buy anything I will probably end up with a better idea of what I do want.
-
Had a go of the wooden style of D/G Scarlatti - sounded nice. Strap was a bit loose. They didn't have a Nero so I've had one put by in London Hobgoblin as I'm going to London next week anyway.
Went to a local session on Monday night - that was fun! Got to noodle on a couple of boxes. Am getting my head round the fact that there are two notes on each button, and that they don't always go in tone order either when you're crossing the rows.
I think I've finally worked out why I don't like sight reading too. My brain's always been geared towards words rather than numbers - total numerophobe - show me a page of text and I'll find the typo almost instantly, but show me a page of numbers and I go to pieces. My husband's luckily the other way, so he does the sums and I do the spelling.
The upshot of this from a music point of view is if you show me sheet music I can very quickly work out what note I'm supposed to be playing, but if I don't know the tune I have to think too hard about how long each note should be. So I learn the tune by ear and then just read the dots to get what note I should be playing. It only just occurred to me that my lack of affinity for numbers might explain why I *can* sight read, but not fast enough. I'm liking ABC, as I can type stuff into a machine and it plays the tune for me so I don't have to faff around with all them dotted crotchets and rests and things. :D
-
Well, I suppose somewhere there's a melodeon out there with my name written on it, and I think my name might be Morgane. I think I've just fallen in love with the Hohner Morgane based on a video from YouTube. Damn that thing has BASS! :D I'll definitely have to try one now. And it's so pretty... (girly moment).
Rybchuk's Waltz. Very dark video, but oh, the BASS!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhFW7kPOf84&feature=youtube_gdata_player
-
I don't think that you can go far wrong with a Morgane (:) Lovely boxes. When I was buying my box it was a toss up between a Morgane and a second hand Bouebe. The Bouebe won, but for the money the Morgane is really very good.
-
I don't think that you can go far wrong with a Morgane (:) Lovely boxes. When I was buying my box it was a toss up between a Morgane and a second hand Bouebe. The Bouebe won, but for the money the Morgane is really very good.
Yep - what he said....
-
I do have the "gut feeling" about it. Just convincing myself I don't need accidentals!
I've actually found there's a little virtual Hohner melodeon for iPhone which has the low notes layout. Been noodling away and I haven't felt the need for a Bb yet so should be fine.
So I suppose that'll make the Morgane my second box, if you count the phone. :D
-
I personally prefer low notes to accidentals on a 2 roiw DG box if the choice is only between having low notes OR accidentals. However given the chance I would always go for both i.e 4th button do instead of 3rd button do.
But don't worry if you make the wrong choice as it an easy & relatively inexpensive job to have the low notes changed to accidentals or vice versa. A box without accidentals enables you do develop ;the noble art of faking which is an essential part of the fun of melodeon playhing!
george
-
I should be fine for what I intend to do - play along in sessions, noodle a few pop and rock tunes for my own amusement. The great advantage of only being able to play tunes in D or G is that if you're going to work out a tune you know where to start, and what chords you're going to have to use. Faking, as you say.
Half the fun of a puzzle is the rules that limit you. Completing the puzzle gives the sense of achievement. Any nub can put random numbers in a sudoku - putting the right numbers in the right places is the charm. I'm just thinking of it as a big puzzle - I want a certain tune, I have a box that only plays certain notes - how can I make that tune work?
I was saying to someone else recently that you really have to go with the gut reaction on these things. If you have that honeymoon feeling with a box, you're more likely to pick it up and play it, get the practice in. If you have that nagging feeling you should have got another one, you won't.
Only a week to go.... trust me to pick an instrument that you can't just pop down into town and get. All dressed up and nowhere to go. I have a copy of George's book now, which I'm leafing through. Just what I needed - dots, but not too many, detailed instructions on how to hold and what to push, a few tunes I actually know already, down-to-earth language.
-
Hah it's just occurred to me that I'm going to have to change my chart to show low notes instead of accidentals... ho hum.
-
I now have a shiny Morgane. :) Happy squeezer.
Currently travelling London with a gig bag looking like a proper muso.
-
I now have a shiny Morgane. :) Happy squeezer.
Currently travelling London with a gig bag looking like a proper muso.
Congratulations.
I found having melodeon in backpack quite good for blocking people getting past you on the underground. lol
-
Well done Strig! I hope you'll be very happy together! Bob.
-
So.... did you go for a DG or BC in the end?
-
D/G. And trying to do oompah basses with a melody is like trying to pat your head and rub your belly. Possible, but my brain is having difficulty with the concept that a change of note may involve moving a button of the right hand, moving a buttin on the left hand, changing bellows direction, or any combination of the three. The Sloe is now the Incredilbly Sloe. I'm having to learn it by rote. Hopefully once my hands get the idea they can oompah by themselves in future.
-
I now have a shiny Morgane. :)
Excellent! Congratulations! (:)
-
Not sure of my grip yet. I'm holding the bass end like I'm trying to stop it getting away. Need to relax.
-
It's a fairly steep learning curve Strig, lots of unnatural movements and challenging coordination issues. Back to basics, play at a snail's pace, one hand at a time if needs be. When you put it all together it will probably collapse the first time around which only highlights the need to slow things down to a point where you can't get it wrong then work from there. You'll get it. I, like many others, was greatly impressed with your iPhone playing. This is just a beast with very different rules. :D
Pete.
-
I am a transcriptionist by trade and was about 65-70 wpm last time I was tested; now when I think back to the days of my youth trying to touch type home key phrases like "dad had a fag" without looking, when I knew I could type it faster with two fingers, I think learning melodeon is going to be like that. You eventually get to a point where you're fast enough to actually use it for day-to-day work, and then there's no stopping you. Now I type faster than I handwrite, so if I can possibly type something instead of scribbling it, I will.
Hopefully melodeon is the same, in that once you can play well enough to join in at a session, you sudddenly get lots of practice.
-
I am a transcriptionist by trade and was about 65-70 wpm last time I was tested;
I remember Huw Williams on learning the melodeon "I wasn't musical at all, but luckily I knew how to type. You just type like this (plays a scale on the D row). And if you hit shift, it sounds like this (plays a scale on the G row)."
-
I have often wondered why there has never been an accordion made with a simplified qwerty keyboard. In theory any one who could type would be able to play it. Music could then just be written out as groups of letters. ???
Martyn
-
On each side? >:E
-
On each side? >:E
Could use the numbers for the left hand I suppose.
Martyn
-
learning to touch type on an old underwood manual machine is exellent for developing finger strength , particularly the little finger. It also sorts fingers out for staccato playing. I'm not sure whether touch tyuping on a modern computor keyboard would have the same benefits but it would no doubt help to a lesser degree.
george
-
I've been just practicing a few tunes before I go to work and a few when I get home. It's getting better. My left hand is getting the idea that it's supposed to pull and push, and press two buttons alternately. I'm beginning to notice that they're getting a better idea of when making a note lower or higher requires a change of bellows direction. Working out how to hold it so I don't get cramp too.
I have found myself occasionally playing the bass again so I'm sort of going oom, oom, oom pah but it sounds okay so something to work on later.
My Very Sloe sounds a bit "fairy footsteps" at the moment though. "La.........laaaa, la la, la...........(very long pause).................LAAAAA, la la".
I should imagine typing helps with staccato definitely. For example, for a capital letter at the start of the sentence you want to hold down Shift only for the first letter you type. And if you're typing 70 or 80 wpm by definition you're averaging more than one letter a second so you therefore are holding down Shift for a fraction of a second. Melodeons, however, do not have Auto Correct so I'm going to have to be a bit sharper - perhaps melodeon will improve my typing accuracy too. ;D
-
I touch type too and don't think that it really helps much with playing the melodeon.
With typing everything is accessed from the home keys (so you're not shifting hand position) and generally each letter is operated by a particular finger. Also, you tend to press only one key at a time (I'm discounting holding shift down because this is normally done with the hand not typing the letter).
Moreover, the whole support and orientation of your hand is different.
-
I don't claim to touch type, but I learnt to operate a code desk - a simplified qwerty keyboard for encoding enveloppes. I still find that I wake up in a sweat having typed out my nightmares! Melodeon playing is far more relaxing.
Rob.
P.S. Tyed one-handed as my cat is sleeping on the left one!
-
I had come to similar conclusions, actually - that was half the problem I was having at first, in that my fingers were convinced they had to move to a different key to get a different "letter". However, I think it does help that your fingers will be somewhat trained to make accurate movements quickly.
Re support/orientation - agreed - I have been trying to think with my "elbows at 45 degrees, wrists straight" head on, but it doesn't exactly follow. I think you probably have to just hold it however works for you. I'd tried resting my thumb on the keyboard edge on the right but that made me arch my fingers far too much so I've got my thumb round the back. I did have a bit of fun on the right in as much as I tried to get my little finger on the bottom bass key and if I held my hand in that position for any length of time I got pins and needles in my last two fingers. Now found a comfortable hold with wrist in the strap and using my first two fingers for all the bass buttons (I have seen other people on TOTM videos with similar playing style; I think it might have been McGrooger). Bit more of a reach but much more comfortable for me.
I think I might be subconsciously trying to get my hands into a typewriter position but sideways. So I'm striking the keys in a similar way. But I'm using the same adage for melodeon as I am for typewriter - "if it hurts, change position".
So yeah, a bit like the old word piano but with two letters on each key. I think the shift key analogy does work - yes, if you're typing capital P you use the right hand to type the P and the left to do the shift, but to carry the analogy to melodeon, you're using your right hand to press a button and your left hand to "shift" between the two possible notes on that button by either pushing or pulling.
And I find for melodeon there are still home keys as such, in that you pick the four keys for your fingers that are most likely to be used, and move around the keyboard from there. In one tune you may start on the third, in another you may start on the fourth, in a third tune you might be on the G row, but once you are on those "home" keys you work from there.
I do know people who have "relearned" touch typing to use a Dvorak keyboard, or court stenographer's keyboard, for example. It can be done. Presumably similar to learning a D/G and then a B/C.
The upshot of it all is that some degree of manual dexterity is required - those who have proven manual dexterity will find it a boon that they know they have the ability, and may be able to carry over some theory and good posture from their other skill, but they may have things they have to "unlearn" for playing music.
So we're both right. :D
-
I hate to break it to you guys, but a melodeon is not a typewriter. ;)
About the only thing you can carry from one to the other, possibly, is a general aptitude for co-ordinated movement of fingers, and the knowledge from experience that learning these things needs patience and takes time. Also perhaps the experience of avoiding physical postures that become painful.
Analogies such as those between bellows direction and shift keys are fine if they help, but really can't be stretched too far!
Strigulino (I finally found out what your name means, by the way, and learned something about Esperanto) - delighted to hear you've finally got a real box to play, and of course we are all looking forward to hearing it, especially after your promising iPhone start!
-
I've just realised it's 90 degrees, not 45. Silly me.
I just spent the weekend at the Language Show in Olympia at the Esperanto Association's stall doing a bit of PR. It's good fun, actually. People have some really odd misconceptions about Esperanto so it's good to actually explain it to people.
My online Esperanto name, Noktema Strigulino, is basically a really detailed way of saying Night Owl. Nokt is the root for night, and strig is the root for owl. O is a noun, a is an adjective. So Nokta Strigo would be "night owl", but your actual owl in the night. Em is a suffix meaning a tendency or inclination to something, ul is a suffix for a person with that quality, and in is the suffix meaning female. So Noktema Strigulino actually means a night-loving female owl person thing. It's like Lego. You take the basic "brick" for what you want and add bits until you get exactly what you mean.
I could talk about Esperanto all day (I talked about it all Saturday and Sunday) but this is a melodeon forum of course; if anyone's really keen either ask me by PM or have a look at lernu.net. I am now the third Esperantist melodeon player I know of. ;D
-
I hate to break it to you guys, but a melodeon is not a typewriter. ;)
When I told a Canadian musician friend that I had taken up the button box he commented, "Ah, the Newfie typewriter." ;)
(Brothers and sisters in Terre-Neuve will please forgive this use of the "N word": I realize that many of you object to it - except when using it yourselves of course.)
Seriously, though, I think the analogy with "home keys" might prove less than helpful in the long run. When dissecting possible fingerings for tunes I do often conceive of a particular finger on a particular button as an anchor point or a jumping-off point, but only for short lengths of time. Thinking in terms of leaving four fingers in one place until you are obliged to move them would I think tend to induce a kind of inertia that wouldn't work for the music I play anyway.
George Garside has commented once or twice on the desirability of establishing a "brain-button" connection rather than a "finger-button" connection and I think this is a very useful thing to bear in mind.
-
Must admit I have found the "home key" idea useful for folk tunes in that they tend not to stray too far from one octave in one key. However, on noodling a few other tunes I did find I had to occasionally stray into the G row to get the combination of chord and note that I wanted. So don't worry, I am not afraid to think out of the box if necessary. :)
-
(Brothers and sisters in Terre-Neuve will please forgive this use of the "N word": I realize that many of you object to it - except when using it yourselves of course.)
Really? I had no idea that Newfoundlanders objected to being called 'Newfies'. What a shame, I've always looked upon the term with great affection synonymous with a hardy, resilient folk not easily offended by anyone or anything.
-
It always seems to me that you never know which terms will offend or enrich people. These things change with the times and the seasons anyway. Suffragette, for example, started out as a journalists' derogatory term and is now the preferred description for such historical ladies. Something of the perverseness of human defiance; we often re-use the weapons of others.
I myself am an Essex Girl (not by birth, however) and rather proud of it, although I do not own any white stilettoes. I do confess to listening to music rather loud in my car as I hurtle down the A13 swearing at people who think the speed limit is 60 mph, though. Some stereotypes I can live with. :)
-
Actually, doing the Language Show this weekend and answering questions on Esperanto, some of the preconceptions stung a little. "Oh, that died out, didn't it?". No, or we wouldn't be here, would we. "But that's such a Eurocentric language". "Yes, but it was created in the 1880s by a European so it would be, wouldn't it. That doesn't mean it's not worth using". "Do you know any Klingon?" "Yes, a couple of words, in fact. The interesting ones".
After a while you learn to swallow the sarcastic answer and give the sensible one. And for every person who asks a question based on hearsay, another one asks a proper question that is a pleasure to answer. Although I wish I had a pound for everyone who asked how many people speak it. That's a question that should go on QI as the "nobody knows"...
I'm used to that kind of thing now. My hobbies include various handicrafts, Esperanto, rollercoasters, card games (Munchkin and Catan, not bridge and snap) and now playing the melodeon. Having nailed most kinds of knitting, blackwork and last year Hardanger whitework, my next trick for crafts is going to be bobbin lace (always wanted to try it). I always seem to want to do things that even nerds think is a bit niche.
-
... my next trick for crafts is going to be bobbin lace (always wanted to try it). I always seem to want to do things that even nerds think is a bit niche.
Believe me, bobbin lace only leads onto even more nerdy things! On the other hand I have got some really nice Russian and Finnish pattern lanyards from people who went down this route, can't remember what they called them, though.
Rob
-
Most of it is because I hate what I call "dead time". Sitting on trains, sitting in pubs, waiting for things to happen. I read very fast so always used to run out of books quite fast on holiday, and I like to actually be producing things with my dead time. I've always got socks on the go. You can't go wrong with knitting a sock. Four double-pointed needles looks impressive to the uninitiated, they're small enough to knit on trains without inconveniencing your neighbours, you don't need much yarn, and when you've finished, you've got a pair of socks.
-
Most of it is because I hate what I call "dead time". Sitting on trains, sitting in pubs, waiting for things to happen.
I've never thought of sitting in pubs as "dead time" ;D :|glug
-
Most of it is because I hate what I call "dead time". Sitting on trains, sitting in pubs, waiting for things to happen. I read very fast so always used to run out of books quite fast on holiday, and I like to actually be producing things with my dead time. I've always got socks on the go. You can't go wrong with knitting a sock. Four double-pointed needles looks impressive to the uninitiated, they're small enough to knit on trains without inconveniencing your neighbours, you don't need much yarn, and when you've finished, you've got a pair of socks.
Knitting an melodeons...keep an eye in the background ;)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FoxvuqPIOZE
-
I've never thought of sitting in pubs as "dead time" ;D :|glug
Well, admitted there is drinking and chat to be had, but my fingers get fidgety. ;D
-
Hi Strigulino, congrats on your new box. If your looking? you will find a nice bunch at the White Swan, Horndon on the hill, 1st Thursday of the month,(Olive Branch folk club) look out for Nel, DG box player, nice and friendly and very helpful, folk club there every (Sunday Sail Loft folk club) as well and another on 1st Monday of the month upstairs (Jingling Gate folk club). I have waited to see what layout box you went for as I teach Irish C#D and a bit of Irish concertina amongst other things, thought you might be heading down that route from your first post, but as you have gone for DG I thought I'd offer to point you in a helpfull direction, there are plenty of players around through the Morris if you'd like to get some help or get involved locally we have a Ladies side Hands Around, Cockleshell clog, Malden Green Jackets, Rumford Morris, all details on the Web, also in Leigh on sea we have the Thames gate folk Orchestra and lots of other stuff. I hope you have a long and fruitful relationship with........ (fill in name at your leasure) feel free to contact me personally (see profile) all the best mory (MoryArty)
-
Nice to meet you; I went to the Yardarm a couple of weeks ago and I know someone who goes to the Sail Loft so doubtless we'll meet at some point. If not already. Ships in the night and all that.
-
[I've never thought of sitting in pubs as "dead time" ;D :|glug
Only for the brain cells! ;D
-
Went to another session type thing last night. Ye Gods my sight reading is coming along well. Getting to grips with the fact that most tune sections end with a D or a G so at the very least I can blast out the last note right, and sound like I know what I'm doing.
Seriously though, I'm getting to the point where I can see a G, or an A, or a D coming and know what I have to do to get that note to come out.
Got a few tune books to work through. What were these people drinking when they named these things? "Shave the Donkey"? "Planxty Fanny Power"? And my personal favourite, "The Cat Rambles to the Child's Saucepan". Friends of mine think it's something to do with a cat trying to nick the last dregs of a child's milk, which makes sense I suppose, but it sounds to me like the kind of thing spies would use as a code phrase.
I have found myself having to pad my left hand though - strap won't go any smaller and I keep slipping upwards and losing my air button. Might make some kind of strap padding.
-
What were these people drinking when they named these things? "Shave the Donkey"? "Planxty Fanny Power"? And my personal favourite, "The Cat Rambles to the Child's Saucepan".
'Shave the Donkey' is a quote from the words of the song which goes with the tune:
Sharp' the razor,
Shave the donkey,
Don't cut his tail off,
Pretty little thing.
A Planxty is (or was) a tune written in honour of a person, usually a benefactor or patron of some kind. Many planxties were written by the blind harper Turlough o' Carolan in the 17th/18th century.
The Cat Rambles.... is indeed a piece of espionage wireless message code (usually thought to mean 'I can't make it to the session tonight, but I'll see you in the bar afterwards.')
I have found myself having to pad my left hand though - strap won't go any smaller and I keep slipping upwards and losing my air button. Might make some kind of strap padding.
One answer to this is to angle the axis of your melodeon slightly downwards (see my avatar picture). Gravity then acts partly against the palm of your hand and it is less likely to slip upwards. Or you could use a bath sponge like Sharon Shannon does.
-
I have found myself having to pad my left hand though - strap won't go any smaller and I keep slipping upwards and losing my air button. Might make some kind of strap padding.
There's my anti slip strap ;) I make them from my quilting scraps.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1880.20.html
-
Must admit, I'd come up with three solutions, none of which look like that. So I now have four options:
1) The Lady de Temps Wrist Strap
2) Making some kind of padded cylinder to go above the wrist to stop it sliding up.
3) Some kind of fingerless glove with a padded back.
4) Padding the inside of the strap.
-
Must admit, I'd come up with three solutions, none of which look like that. So I now have four options:
2) Making some kind of padded cylinder to go above the wrist to stop it sliding up.
Foam pipe insulation would be worth a try.
-
Not something I have to hand (pun intended) but I do have tons of knitting/crochet/sewing stuff so was thinking of just making a tiny bolster that I can tie on. But something that size and shape, certainly.
-
Those little thingies that you put round car crash belts to stop the belt cutting can also be used on a bass strap.
-
There are some good box players in South Essex whom could give you practical advise face to face. You might want to pop along to some of the sessions locally and speak to them. I will say this though....it is easier to grow as a box player around other box players.
Sorry that this is not a technical message but may prove a practical message.
Wickford.
-
I have been going to a few sessions; all good fun!
-
yeah I can see that now....didnt look at all the postings. This was my first posting and I was trying to be helpful...I'm such a fool sometimes.
-
All advice is good. If you get the same piece of advice twice, it must be important. ;)
-
Had a lovely moment at a jam session last night. I was trying to remember how Princess Royal goes. Snuck my "Baby Tunes for Noobs" book out of my bag and started playing it in a quiet moment... and everyone joined in. And sped it up quite a lot, obviously, but they recognised it. :D
-
Well what a musical journey this is becoming. I didn't realise quite how many tunes I already knew. Heard Brighton Camp on Monday and found my memory came up with "Its pure and fresh and English too, Dum Dum Dum Dum Dum dee dee, oh you can't put a better bit of butter on your knife and your cake's all turning creamy".
And I just read A Hundred Pipers from the dots and realise I know it better as Hoots Mon by Lord Rockingham's XI.
-
And I thought you much younger than that!
-
38, but I wear it well. ;)
-
38, but I wear it well. ;)
I would have guessed 10 years younger than that. :o
-
People generally do. I have to actually get my driving licence out to prove it sometimes.
-
I know how you feel. I've had people think I was 16 before.
-
I know how you feel. I've had people think I was 16 before.
That has happened to me too, but not since the 1960s! ;D ;D
-
Just a little update. Sewed some padding round the left hand strap which seems to be helping.
Still enjoying practice time! I get home from work, see if there's any freelance work online, and if not, squeezy time.
This month it's been Bear Dance, the TOTM. My first foray into a relative minor key. Husband likes this one; says it reminds him of Monkey Island and Pirates of the Caribbean. (Note to self - learn theme to Monkey Island!) Requires a little dancing about the bass end to get the chords I want but I'm getting the hang of that, and am finding it a surprisingly easy and rewarding tune to play.
Other than that, still doing The Sloe, Princess Royal (I just love playing it!) and have been working on The Trumpet Hornpipe so I can impress friends with being able to play Pugwash. Glad I got the Hohner for that, it's the one tune where I've actually found myself all the way up at the chin end so the low notes have been useful.
I've also started my first steps on MADness as I have ordered one of those little blue plastic jobbies (as suggested elsewhere on the forum, one of Ray Langton's that has been checked over) as I might be spending a bit of time away from base this year doing various things and a hand-luggage-sized box I don't mind getting stolen or broken is worth £25 IMHO. Even if it's in a different key, leaky bellows and sounds utter pants. Need to keep practicing!
-
The leaky bellows teaches us (a) patience (b ) air control. Mine is great fun, I just don't take it to sessions because it's in "C" and, as I have said before, very red. Keep squeezing! ;D
-
I do love the way you have it down on your forum notes as a "Hohner C one-row". Makes it sound so much more impressive.... :)
-
I've also started my first steps on MADness as I have ordered one of those little blue plastic jobbies (as suggested elsewhere on the forum, one of Ray Langton's that has been checked over) as I might be spending a bit of time away from base this year doing various things and a hand-luggage-sized box I don't mind getting stolen or broken is worth £25 IMHO. Even if it's in a different key, leaky bellows and sounds utter pants. Need to keep practicing!
£25! You were robbed I got mine for £22 from hawkins baazar...
-
I've also started my first steps on MADness as I have ordered one of those little blue plastic jobbies (as suggested elsewhere on the forum, one of Ray Langton's that has been checked over) as I might be spending a bit of time away from base this year doing various things and a hand-luggage-sized box I don't mind getting stolen or broken is worth £25 IMHO. Even if it's in a different key, leaky bellows and sounds utter pants. Need to keep practicing!
£25! You were robbed I got mine for £22 from hawkins baazar...
You waz boff robbed. I got mine for £20. ::)
-
I've also started my first steps on MADness as I have ordered one of those little blue plastic jobbies (as suggested elsewhere on the forum, one of Ray Langton's that has been checked over) as I might be spending a bit of time away from base this year doing various things and a hand-luggage-sized box I don't mind getting stolen or broken is worth £25 IMHO. Even if it's in a different key, leaky bellows and sounds utter pants. Need to keep practicing!
£25! You were robbed I got mine for £22 from hawkins baazar...
You waz boff robbed. I got mine for £20. ::)
You woz all robbed I only paid £14 ;D ;D
-
Ah, but mine got checked by a melodeon player before it got posted to me. I doubt Hawkin's Bazaar know what a melodeon should sound like.... ;)
-
Ah, but mine got checked by a melodeon player before it got posted to me. I doubt Hawkin's Bazaar know what a melodeon should sound like.... ;)
Mine was checked by me in Hawkins Bazaar much to their amusement :)
-
;D there's a lot of us with one of these little boxes :|||: ( bright red @ £14 some years ago, was late OH's)
now if only I could play this William Tell (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=brWw4m_RFVo) on it (or on the big G/C for that matter ) :|||:
must practice more ;D
-
I tried mine outside the shop and got asked where I got it from. lol
-
Mine came from PJ Music at IVFDF last year. So much fun (till the thumb strap broke off, along with the bit of plastic...).
-
You were all robbed, I don't have one at all ;D
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47uQFcsmbfc
Princess Royal. My current party piece, with only a few bum notes. I've nearly got the fast bits sussed anyway.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47uQFcsmbfc
Princess Royal. My current party piece, with only a few bum notes. I've nearly got the fast bits sussed anyway.
For 4 months that is outstanding ;D
My only observation is I would play more with the tips of your fingers, mind you as a girl you may have fingernail problems ::)
-
Heh, on the one hand an outrageously sexist comment, but to be honest, totally accurate. ;) One of my little Essex girl foibles is french polish gel overlays, which was a way of a) stopping me biting my nails and b) keeping them nice despite all the typing I do. It does indeed make my fingertips a bit slippery, but I've been thinking I'll just end up with whatever playing style I end up with.
Gratified you think it "outstanding" - that might have something to do with the fact that despite a foray into carols in December, I tend to just play four tunes over and over again. The Sloe, Princess Royal, Bear Dance and now attempting Trumpet Hornpipe as it's a song of my youth and also a good way of practicing arpeggios and scales. I think my poor husband now knows those tunes better than he should. But I like playing them, and I'll add other tunes as and when a TOTM comes up that I like, or I hear one at a session I'm really desperate to learn.
I've been coming home from work and playing those four, or concentrating on one or two of them, for half an hour or an hour perhaps. One day I just played the complicated bits of Princess Royal over and over again. Must have driven the cats insane.
It's good to be a patient person. Most of my hobbies and jobs include repetitive practice - knitting, photocopying, typing, lace work, embroidery, grinding mobs on computer games. I set goals and keep going until I reach them. Probably true to say that I am more hard on myself than I am with anyone else. If I want something bad enough, I'll keep going until I get there. I try a lot of things but there's only a few that stick, but by any God you care to name once I'm into something I have to master it!
-
congratulations! - I totally agree with Lester. You are way ahead of an average 4 monther!. Perhaps now is the time to start experimenting a little with dynamics by varying the volume (by changing bellows pressure) to highlight bits of the tune here & there.
george
-
I tend to be playing quite quietly as I'm usually practicing in the evening, but I do give it some welly of a weekend sometimes and damn the neigbours' baby! :D
-
damn the neigbours' baby! :D
sounds like a good name for a tune. lol!
-
damn the neigbours' baby! :D
sounds like a good name for a tune. lol!
I have just found a "Dancing the Baby" which will have to do. :)
-
Just noticed I'm now a Hero Member. Zero to Hero in a year. >:E
Just thought I'd take that opportunity to report back.
In that year, I've bought not one but two melodeons (four if you count the iPhone one and the toy one). Loving playing, and play most days. I now have a small repertoire I can do reasonable justice to, complete with bum notes and mumbled swearing. Have made good friends, and performed with my melodeon at the Edinburgh Fringe with someone who has been on telly.
Definitely a keeper as hobbies go.
-
Just read your thread from the very beginning, Strig - I SO identify with it! From first sight at one of the last Edinburgh Folk Festivals (courtesy of the Music Room), I was fascinated by these instruments and wondered how on earth anyone got a such varied tunes out of them when appearing to only hit about three buttons! It took me two years to take the plunge - mainly because in my neck of the woods melodeons/button accordeons were like hen's teeth; there was no shop anywhere near to drop into and try and there was no-one at all to give guidance but it wouldn't let go of me because .... yes, you've guessed - I was a 70wpm typist too!
I was lucky enough to cross paths with an Irish player who gave me a few lessons (mainly to help me avoid bad technique) but mostly I've learned the music from being around the music. Very easy to do that here in Edinburgh where there are plenty of sessions and where we have a wonderful organisation called the Scots Music Group which offers weekly classes for over 16s and where around 400 folk turn up each week for tuition on fiddle, mandolin, pipes, whistle, guitar, piano accordion and also learn to play in a mixed instrument setting which was an excellent environment for me and infinitely preferable to the piano accordion class (I could join in - and I could hear myself too!) At first, other folk couldn't make head nor tail of the box till I explained it's like a moothie and it helps if you can operate a qwerty keyboard in the dark! I play by ear, it's how I learned and what I prefer - but now I have attained the dizzy heights of being able to read 'retrospectively'. If I know the tune I can follow the dots ... but don't ask me to do it the other way round :o
So, I play in sessions :|glug and also in a band :||: and I love it all :-* My first box was a Saltarelle Irish Bouebe. I added to that a Castagnari Dinn II (both B/C because Scots traditional music is what I love) but I later fell in love with a Lilly in D/G which system has gone a fair way to scrambling my brain - not least because it means using both sets of fingers! I promised myself to learn each new tune on both tunings if possible .... I failed a fair bit, but am improving - if extremely slowly.
..... then a couple of years ago along came a fiddle and tapped me on the shoulder. Back to SMG classes :D
-
I have now Played for Morris. I feel like a proper melodeonista now.
That said, it was in a practice session and I was to be fair doing the "doing the odd run when I worked out a bit and then doing a huge chord at the end to pretend I was playing the whole time", but people were very nice and I now have a list of new earworms I need to learn properly - Paddy McGinty's Goat, Mhairi's Wedding, I'll Tell me Ma and Stern Polka for starters.
-
Paddy McGinty's Goat, Mhairi's Wedding, I'll Tell me Ma and Stern Polka for starters.
Not proper morris then >:E :M
-
Well, seeing as it's a ladies' side I doubt you'd call that "proper" either LOL.
My take on the matter, in all seriousness, is that the dances hundreds of years ago would be to songs popular at the time. So if the tune fits the dance, and it's a popular tune, so be it. There's tradition and then there's hidebound. ;P
They did play a lot of other tunes that I'm sure would have met with your approval. :D
-
Well, seeing as it's a ladies' side I doubt you'd call that "proper" either LOL.
My take on the matter, in all seriousness, is that the dances hundreds of years ago would be to songs popular at the time. So if the tune fits the dance, and it's a popular tune, so be it. There's tradition and then there's hidebound. ;P
They did play a lot of other tunes that I'm sure would have met with your approval. :D
Who is it?
And I was only joshing ;)
-
I know. I was only pulling your leg back. It has bells on. :)
Erm... that I remember names being mentioned: Country Gardens, The Rose Tree, Portsmouth/Sailor's Hornpipe, Curly Headed Ploughboy, Laudanum Bunches.
The side are Hands Around. They don't have much of an online presence (I had the devil of a job tracking down when and where they rehearse. Might suggest a website of some sort when I'm a known face there). There are some videos on YouTube.
-
I notice no-one has mentioned the bodhran for your husband. He could make his own with Mog at Renegade Rhythms www.renegaderhythms.co.uk
But just make sure he stays away from Morris teams and English sessions! (Though my present Grump is the Turkish style drums with plastic skins which occasionally appear in sessions >:()
But played well with the right music the bodhran is a joy!
BTW it' s taken me about 4 years to learn to play the tunes you mention! :||:
-
Erm... that I remember names being mentioned: Country Gardens, The Rose Tree, Portsmouth/Sailor's Hornpipe, Curly Headed Ploughboy, Laudanum Bunches.
We don't use Portsmouth (except as an apres morris session tune) but play the other four for dancing. I find that the slows in Laudanum Bunches tend to throw me, I'm not quite sure why but some tunes seem almost evasive and that's one of them. Our side do a crowd pleasing and dangerous looking stick dance to The Curly Headed Ploughboy which they call 'Old Twanger', I've yet to see another side dance it but then again I live a sheltered life. The 'B' music sets off at breakneck speed for the dangerous sticking bit then rapidly slows back down in the last two bars to return to the rather sedate 'A' music. I'd be interested to know what Hands Around dance to the tune.
Pete.
-
Erm... that I remember names being mentioned: Country Gardens, The Rose Tree, Portsmouth/Sailor's Hornpipe, Curly Headed Ploughboy, Laudanum Bunches.
We don't use Portsmouth (except as an apres morris session tune) but play the other four for dancing. I find that the slows in Laudanum Bunches tend to throw me, I'm not quite sure why but some tunes seem almost evasive and that's one of them. Our side do a crowd pleasing and dangerous looking stick dance to The Curly Headed Ploughboy which they call 'Old Twanger', I've yet to see another side dance it but then again I live a sheltered life. The 'B' music sets off at breakneck speed for the dangerous sticking bit then rapidly slows back down in the last two bars to return to the rather sedate 'A' music. I'd be interested to know what Hands Around dance to the tune.
Pete.
I tried really hard to not comment but it has got the better of me - it's LAUDNAM Bunches not LAUDANUM Bunches.
There I feel better now ;)
-
I tried really hard to not comment but it has got the better of me - it's LAUDNAM Bunches not LAUDANUM Bunches.
There I feel better now ;)
A bit like Dingle'S Regatta then?
(feeling good too ;) )
-
Such fun! Lol
-
That's Dingle's Regatta Blues?
-
Just an update to say what I've been up to lately - don't really feel that I'm a beginner any more, so have changed the thread title to reflect that.
Am now finding that I can play a few tunes pretty well. The odd little hiccup. I am now planning more playing in public - specifically a yearly club talent show that I've been meaning to do for years.
Can play a waltz now, which is of great personal satisfaction to me. I had trouble before.
I'm going to Melodeons and More - the two tunes for my morning session refuse to stick in my head, so I'm going to have to put some effort in this weekend. For the afternoon session I am borrowing LDT's concertina to see if I want to ask the family for a concertina for my 40th later this year. I went away "tropical" for a couple of weeks and left my precious boxes at home, and missed having something to play.
I went to London to the recording of a radio show for my friend that I was playing the melodeon for at the Edinburgh Fringe last year (for the BBC he has a proper band, and quite right too!). Was surprised and pleased to see that in the bar of the Up the Creek comedy club where it was recorded, there were various musical instruments for decor on the walls, including a couple of PA's and an ancient and very dusty melodeon. There was talk of us "getting the band together" for one last go of the show we did up in Edinburgh, but it's a pipe dream at the moment.
So yes, I progress. I still play most days. I am noticeably better, and nearly "good enough" for my liking for playing in public (in fact, I already have a few times, but just chords and easy Christmas Carols thus far). I'm toying with branching out into the anglo if it's not too different when I try it. I have trouble with a few tunes, but have a nice little repertoire now. If I ever lose my job, I will at least have busking to fall back on!
-
If you do decide to take up the anglo I would be more than happy to give you a little help to get you started.
Martyn
-
Are you at Melodeons and More? I shall see you there, if so.
Maybe I can convince my parents that they need to relieve you of that "probably a Stagi" on your website. Do you do hire purchase? ;)
-
I'll send you a PM.
Martyn
-
*sigh* I'm slipping into MAD, aren't I. Or perhaps it is more properly Squeezebox Acquisition Disease. SAD. Two melodeons and a concertina is ENOUGH.... (quotes) "But it must be the last. Absolutely the last. Final. Full stop. Never again. Cross my heart and hope to be spanked until my bottom goes purple."
-
Cross my heart and hope to be spanked until my bottom goes purple."
:o :|bl
-
It's a Blackadder quote, in my defence. :D
-
*sigh* I'm slipping into MAD, aren't I. Or perhaps it is more properly Squeezebox Acquisition Disease. SAD.
MAD isn't side-ist. Six sides or four, it's all the same. The slope is just as steep. But beware. The little six-sided box is insidious. Just leave it where you can see it. It will call to you, your hands will slip into the straps. You don't even need to put it on. It is so easy - and the evening is gone. The chores are not done. It is nearly over. But there is time for just one more tune...
-
The siren of squeezeboxes, eh. ;)
-
The siren of squeezeboxes, eh. ;)
Puts me in mind of Les Barkers monologue about Arnold the Armadillo (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MN7p40S1DvI) falling in love with a concertina.
"Bright silver buttons, on rows from head to toe in black leather..."
-
...But beware. The little six-sided box is insidious. Just leave it where you can see it. It will call to you, your hands will slip into the straps. You don't even need to put it on. It is so easy - and the evening is gone. The chores are not done. It is nearly over. But there is time for just one more tune...
Oh yes! This is me and my concertina, perfectly described... :o :|bl
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxUoHGHEeZY
Oyster Girl, recorded on the veranda of what we call our "Summer Residence" with unintentional comedy ending. Mr Spouse has just pointed out that the comedy ending was in the Bee part. ;)
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nxUoHGHEeZY
Oyster Girl, recorded on the veranda of what we call our "Summer Residence" with unintentional comedy ending. Mr Spouse has just pointed out that the comedy ending was in the Bee part. ;)
Well played! Interesting that you play the basses very differently from me in this tune, both sound fine but not at all the same. Perhaps that's to do with the fact that my Liliput doesn't have thirds in the chords so I can be a little more liberal with what I play and can get away with. I'll try very hard to make a recording sometime but I find that very hard these days. :(
-
Mine's declubbed too, so plays Bb in both directions.
-
Finally Melnet is no longer blocked at my work - so I can have a sneaky look from time to time.
I have a Giordy now. I call it my derringer. I take it on holiday. I played it on a Norfolk Broads cruiser and felt like a pirate.
This week I have been mostly learning Grandfather's Tune and Lincolnshire Poacher.