Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: PaulFreeman on October 05, 2011, 10:21:48 AM
-
Hi all,
I'm considering an upgrade, and would like some advice on models !
So far I've been through these:
- started with a regular 2 row G/D Pokerwork. Not played it for a couple of years so I ought to get rid of it but it's got sentimental value as my first box.
- next got a 1 row Pokerwork in G, which I can't get rid of because it suits some tunes perfectly.
- then I got a Sandpiper from the Music Room and have been very happy with it. It's dryer and faster than the above two and suits my style more.
But now I feel like moving on to something over £1000. I'll make a final decision only after playing a few boxes, but I could do with some pointers to the right makes and models that might suit my playing style. Some videos of my playing are at http://www.thefreemans.co.uk/Music.htm or Youtube pfgoklcg, if you want to get a feel for this.
My preferred pro's are Jon Spiers, Simon Care, Saul Rose, but the tracks by Ed Rennie and Nick Cooke on the Banquet of Boxes CD are current favourites.
Any tips would be gratefully received.
thanks
Paul Freeman
-
Hi Paul,
I will shortly have two brand-new Manfrini 2-row 3-voice instruments available. They are currently with Theo having the reeds fitted and being fine-tuned. They are excellent instruments indeed; light-weight, fast, responsive and with a powerful sound, thanks to the hand-made (a mano) Voci Armoniche reeds. D/G, fourth button start, with accidentals.
You can hear a clip of my own instrument here:
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=54749
The two instruments I have are very much like the black one in the photo but with a very dark turquoise (almost black) finish, and all-black bellows and buttons. Stunning looking instruments! The manufacturer's new list price is £2195, but I will be able to offer a very substantial discount (to be finalised but in the order of approx. £300 off).
Contact me by PM if you are interested in knowing more.
-
Paul, one significant decision is whether to stick with a two voice box, or to go for a three voice. The way you decide and to go on that one will narrow down your choice significantly. Other things being equal a two voice box is lighter and will play a bit faster than a three voice.
Makers worth considering would be Loffet, Castagnari, Beltuna, Excelsior, Saltarelle all of which are easily available. No UK stockist for Loffet but he will be in the UK later this month (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7592.0.html)
-
Try and get your hands on a Dino Baffetti Binci either two voice or three - very fast and responsive and with plenty of oomph
-
Hi all,
I'm considering an upgrade, and would like some advice on models !
So far I've been through these:
- started with a regular 2 row G/D Pokerwork. Not played it for a couple of years so I ought to get rid of it but it's got sentimental value as my first box.
- next got a 1 row Pokerwork in G, which I can't get rid of because it suits some tunes perfectly.
- then I got a Sandpiper from the Music Room and have been very happy with it. It's dryer and faster than the above two and suits my style more.
But now I feel like moving on to something over £1000. I'll make a final decision only after playing a few boxes, but I could do with some pointers to the right makes and models that might suit my playing style. Some videos of my playing are at http://www.thefreemans.co.uk/Music.htm or Youtube pfgoklcg, if you want to get a feel for this.
My preferred pro's are Jon Spiers, Simon Care, Saul Rose, but the tracks by Ed Rennie and Nick Cooke on the Banquet of Boxes CD are current favourites.
Any tips would be gratefully received.
thanks
Paul Freeman
If you want a fast box with a loud bright sound then there's nothing else even close to the Baffetti Binci at the moment, unless you can get a good second-hand Oakwood -- which are about as common as rocking-horse s**t, and a lot more expensive ;-)
If you're looking for something quieter and sweeter-sounding there are lots of alternatives, but this isn't my area of expertise...
Ian
-
Not advice but an observation; "a fast one with plenty of oomph" - melodeons, cars, women... men always want the same qualities. ;)
-
I always thought men wanted women with va-va-voom...?
-
Theo: Two of those melodeons - Loffet and Beltuna - are starting to become more common, Beltuna especially, after being brought to the market by the Music Room and Rees of this parish, and Loffet throguh word of mouth.
I remember reading that you've seeing both recently through the servicing side of things.
Was wondering what your opinion of both are?
( i.e build, responsinveness, overall feel etc )
With the summer festival season over now, it might be a year before I get any chance to bump into either for a personal opinion.
Q
-
Theo: Two of those melodeons - Loffet and Beltuna - are starting to become more common, Beltuna especially, after being brought to the market by the Music Room and Rees of this parish, and Loffet throguh word of mouth.
I remember reading that you've seeing both recently through the servicing side of things.
Was wondering what your opinion of both are?
( i.e build, responsinveness, overall feel etc )
With the summer festival season over now, it might be a year before I get any chance to bump into either for a personal opinion.
Q
It was originally Hobgoblin who brought in Beltunas something like 3 or possibly 4 years ago, then they dropped them (in favour of Excelsior) about 18 months ago, and MR took up the Beltuna.
Both are well built instruments but quite different in sound and feel. It is so difficult to put these things into words, but Beltunas I've seen have a very bright clean sound, Loffet warmer and fuller, subjective I know but its they way thay come across to me.
-
Thanks Theo, interesting observations. A subjective opinion is helpful too, as it is an opinion from someone who sees and plays a lot of different things!
I had a quick play with a second hand Loffet Petit G/C and a new Beltuna Alex 2 at Shrewsbury.
Both very different melodeons, in size, sound and even tuning!
I admit I quite liked the Beltuna, but abolutely loved the Loffet. Considering I have no use or plans for a G/c ( thst I know of as yet! ) I gave it a quick squeeze just to say I'd played one.
It was gorgeous, but I also realise I have never played any other G/C so perhaps some of the enchantment was because it was in a different and very resonant pitch. It was also of a similar size to my current melodeon so perhaps that made it feel at home with me. I can understand the 'warmth of sound' comment
Being a wood lover I kept fondling it :|bl
The Beltuna was nice too but obviously a very different beast and much larger than my normal box. It felt good, nice wood too :D
Prehaps I was a woodworm beetle in a previous exisitance ???
Q
-
I have never played any other G/C so perhaps some of the enchantment was because it was in a different and very resonant pitch.
G/C is very different if you are accustomed to plying a D/G. Even a G/C Hohner is a bit of a revelation after a D/G.
-
Almost like a "treble" melodeon vs. a "tenor".
-
Is it possible to upgrade from a Pokerwork? >:E
-
Theo and Steve: Yep ok, I can understand that, and 'treble v's tenor' is a nice way of thinking about it.
.....but still, lovely wood ;D
Lester: Yes ;D
but that's only my opinion of course ;)
Q
-
Hi all,
I'm considering an upgrade, and would like some advice on models !
I think you are at the crossroads i got to some time ago!
12 Bass / 2.5 row ... develop new skills and chords !
Derek
-
I agree with Derek: the accidentals on a 2.5 row and the four extra bass buttons on a 12 bass open up a whole new world of exciting possibilities. I have just put down my box after playing through some new tunes I am learning, one in A minor Dorian, one in G minor Dorian and the third in D minor Aeolian. I still have a smile on my face from the beautiful sound of those tunes.
By the way, thanks to Chris Ryall for explaining in simple terms (for once >:E) the difference between these modes.
-
Lester, you tell 'em.
I think if more people had a chance to play an in-tune, slightly dried out Pokerwork, with the button travel limited and a little "declackification", they would understand.
And:
"Nothing raises hell like a Pokerwork" >:E
-
Depending on budget I'd look at the Dino Baffetti Balck Pearl. I have a II which is now around £1300 whilst the III is a couple of hundred more. The Baffetti Oakwoods/Bincis are a lot more (I bought a second hand Loffett 2.6 for less).
Steve
-
Is it possible to upgrade from a Pokerwork? >:E
Depends what your Pokerwork is like. :P
-
Lester, you tell 'em.
I think if more people had a chance to play an in-tune, slightly dried out Pokerwork, with the button travel limited and a little "declackification", they would understand.
And:
"Nothing raises hell like a Pokerwork" >:E
Yep, amen to that.
Step 1) - don't get rid of your pokerwork
Step 2) - chat to Theo/Mike/Martyn/etc about having it fettled and retuned - not sure how Chinese ones sound once they've been done up, but the German ones sure sound good.
Step 3) - do it (I love mine, and it's tuned *dry*)
Step 4) - enjoy
Step 5) - ... then consider if you want to get a 2.5 / 12 bass *as well* ;D
-
and it's tuned *dry*
Noooooooooooooooooooooooo!
-
You can certainly improve on a Chinese Pokerwork! Missed my chance on an improved Erica, but that's another story. Older Hohners had less tremolo than the Pokerwork, I prefer the larger, old club models. One of these retuned to D/G and de-clubbed would make a potential candidate.
I sneaked a go on DTN's C/F Loffet once and it was lovely - warm, powerful sound and fast, quiet action. By comparison with most boxes, there is no raw edge to the tone at all.
The BP II is quite loud and punchy, but like nearly all small boxes, it is possible to over-pressure the bellows and choke the reeds (the bass stops first). I don't know whether the Binci version chokes, I haven't dared hammer one that hard in a shop! I must admit that I prefer a three voice box for a D/G as it takes the shrill edge off the sound.
Rob.
-
I agree with Derek: the accidentals on a 2.5 row and the four extra bass buttons on a 12 bass open up a whole new world of exciting possibilities.
Even more so if you have a 4th-button start and extra low notes.
-
You can certainly improve on a Chinese Pokerwork! Missed my chance on an improved Erica, but that's another story. Older Hohners had less tremolo than the Pokerwork, I prefer the larger, old club models. One of these retuned to D/G and de-clubbed would make a potential candidate.
I sneaked a go on DTN's C/F Loffet once and it was lovely - warm, powerful sound and fast, quiet action. By comparison with most boxes, there is no raw edge to the tone at all.
The BP II is quite loud and punchy, but like nearly all small boxes, it is possible to over-pressure the bellows and choke the reeds (the bass stops first). I don't know whether the Binci version chokes, I haven't dared hammer one that hard in a shop! I must admit that I prefer a three voice box for a D/G as it takes the shrill edge off the sound.
Rob.
The Binci doesn't (same as my Oakwood), and I've got a very big hammer ;-)
Ian
-
Not advice but an observation; "a fast one with plenty of oomph" - melodeons, cars, women... men always want the same qualities. ;)
I just want to say that I'm completely not a bloke and I still like fast ones with plenty of oomph.
-
I just want to say that I'm completely not a bloke and I still like fast ones with plenty of oomph.
What are you talking about, Alison - melodeons or men? >:E
-
Wasn't clear to me either, even after reading several times :o
-
The Binci doesn't (same as my Oakwood), and I've got a very big hammer ;-)
Ian
One of my customers managed to choke some of the lower Binci reeds in his GC box. I swapped them with Ciccarelli's (special measure, made to my suggestions). Problem solved.
-
Thanks for all the chatter on this subject, I thought it might provoke this sort of thing (including the humour) !
It's been useful so far, and the 2.5 row direction is something I'd already realised might be inevitable. Just put off by the extra cost, I guess.
I've been attracted to the Black Pearl a few times, but when I've tried it I've been scared off by its loudness, and find it's pretty similar in sound to the thing I'm moving up from. Not a bad move, perhaps, but it might be more interesting to go that bit further...
keep them coming,
- Paul
-
scared off by its loudness,
We all thought you wanted loud! What did you actually mean by "plenty of oomph" then? ;D If you don't want loud then you may not want an Oakwood or a Binci Baffetti either. :'(
-
The Binci doesn't (same as my Oakwood), and I've got a very big hammer ;-)
Ian
One of my customers managed to choke some of the lower Binci reeds in his GC box. I swapped them with Ciccarelli's (special measure, made to my suggestions). Problem solved.
Both my instruments are DG, which is what I thought the OP was asking about and (I assume) the BP II referred to was.
Lower pitched reeds are more prone to choking because they're usually shorter than they really ought to be to keep the reed plate size down. If the Ciccarellis were longer scale this would help a lot.
-
scared off by its loudness,
We all thought you wanted loud! What did you actually mean by "plenty of oomph" then? ;D If you don't want loud then you may not want an Oakwood or a Binci Baffetti either. :'(
Hi Theo... I was scared off by the loudness when I tried it about 2 years ago. I can play better now, so I'm less scared of loudness! It might be that my default next step is to a Black Pearl II or III (probably a II).
By the way, what's the difference between Oakwood and Binci ? At the Music Room I see a "Dino Baffetti / Oakwood Binci" for £1999
-
scared off by its loudness,
We all thought you wanted loud! What did you actually mean by "plenty of oomph" then? ;D If you don't want loud then you may not want an Oakwood or a Binci Baffetti either. :'(
Hi Theo... I was scared off by the loudness when I tried it about 2 years ago. I can play better now, so I'm less scared of loudness! It might be that my default next step is to a Black Pearl II or III (probably a II).
By the way, what's the difference between Oakwood and Binci ? At the Music Room I see a "Dino Baffetti / Oakwood Binci" for £1999
Oakwood stopped making their own boxes several years ago, so they're only available secondhand and have been going for frankly silly prices recently.
The Music Room box is a Dino Baffetti (Carnival II?) specially made with Binci reeds for The Music Room and then finished/tuned by Oakwood. They're the closest thing to an original Oakwood you can get nowadays, and a lot louder than a Black Pearl II.