Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: docEdock on October 06, 2011, 05:04:32 PM
-
I read somewhere that storing a melodeon any orientation other than with its four feet down leads to repairs, perhaps due to the leathers (aka valves?) curling or maybe something else. What say you repairers?
I ask because my Hohner Pokerwork lives much of it's life aboard in a canvas bag. I had been storing it right side up but I fumbled taking it out and it hit the deck. Since then I've found that keyboard down is more secure, allowing me to lift it out of its sack by the bass strap, rather than by the keyboard. Storing it in a proper case -- the little black suitcase it came with -- isn't really an option.
-
Dont belive the valve thing myself but others may disagree. But I would worry about storing a pokerwork in a soft bag keyboard down mainly because if you drop the bag the plastic keybard would be the first thing to hit the deck and it is probably the most fragile part of the box
-
Maybe the answer is to get a proper Pokerwork with a wooden keyboard... ducks for cover (but melons for ecstasy!) >:E
Graham
-
Maybe the answer is to get a proper Pokerwork with a wooden keyboard... ducks for cover (but melons for ecstasy!) >:E
Graham
Wouldn't much fancy dropping one on a wooden fingerboard much either.
-
True - but they're easier to repair!
-
I read somewhere that storing a melodeon any orientation other than with its four feet down leads to repairs, perhaps due to the leathers (aka valves?) curling or maybe something else. What say you repairers?
I ask because my Hohner Pokerwork lives much of it's life aboard in a canvas bag. I had been storing it right side up but I fumbled taking it out and it hit the deck. Since then I've found that keyboard down is more secure, allowing me to lift it out of its sack by the bass strap, rather than by the keyboard. Storing it in a proper case -- the little black suitcase it came with -- isn't really an option.
Since some melodeons don't have all the reeds in the same X/Y direction anyway (flat-mounted + right-angled) this seems unlikely to be true because of valves, otherwise there's be no safe way to store a Preciosa or one-row or Steirische or...
But if you are going to drop one it's probably better if -- like a cat -- it lands on its feet :-)
-
But if you are going to drop one it's probably better if -- like a cat -- it lands on its feet :-)
Actually it landed on my foot, which is a blessing, since it was tumbling as it fell and might have spent all nine lives in one moment. Now I'm more careful and find holding onto the strap safer than clutching the keyboard, which is plastic and slippery. Now if it were wooden . . .
The point about dropping the bag is well taken. I think I'll add a thick layer of foam to the bottom of the bag, and hope it's cat like.
-
But if you are going to drop one it's probably better if -- like a cat -- it lands on its feet :-)
Actually it landed on my foot, which is a blessing, since it was tumbling as it fell and might have spent all nine lives in one moment. Now I'm more careful and find holding onto the strap safer than clutching the keyboard, which is plastic and slippery. Now if it were wooden . . .
The point about dropping the bag is well taken. I think I'll add a thick layer of foam to the bottom of the bag, and hope it's cat like.
If it spends a lot of it's life aboard maybe one of those yellow thingies that inflate on contact with water is a good idea too. Maybe with a similarly activated flashing light so you can still find it if it falls overboard in the dark. But at least you won't need a whistle, I've heard melodeons screaming for help before now :-)
-
I've known two people smack the keyboard off their boxes - and that doesn't includes Del's using a Saltarelle as a motorbike airbag! I was just wondering whether the gig bag will fit inside a drybag? I'd be inclined to worry most about keeping the salt atmosphere off it - just look at what happens to brass inside the cabin off an offshore yacht.
I was distracted the other night in a pitch dark carpark (must have been my lucky day) and as I reversed there was a stange dragging sound. The strap of my gig bag was caught on the rear wheel! The bag was a bit scuffed, but the box was fine. Of course, i tripped over the 4 -stop as I got out to investigate. ;D
Sometimes an innocuous bump can destroy them, but often they survive horrendous falls without incident.
Rob.
-
But at least you won't need a whistle, I've heard melodeons screaming for help before now :-)
I believe the sound of the captain's melodeon going overboard is likely to be the crew's spirited round of applause, which would drown out any screams.
I was just wondering whether the gig bag will fit inside a drybag? I'd be inclined to worry most about keeping the salt atmosphere off it - just look at what happens to brass inside the cabin off an offshore yacht.
I've considered a dry bag, but since I play quite often I thought I might be trapping the salt in as much as keeping it out. It's been aboard for the last six months (Georgia to Rhode Island, through hurricane and flood) and so far seems OK. The grill is still shiny though I've not peered at its insides. I assume that the main concern would be rust on the reeds?
-
Hi Doc...
I've had my old one-row Hohner aboard for about 12 years now (I live aboard) - I made a wooden box for it with a rubber seal round the lid, and it doesn't seem to be any the worse for wear.
Besides which, it's got an anchor in its logo, so it must be ok on a boat!
Brian.
-
I won't mention an old mate of mine who became famous as the man who reversed a transit van over his bandoneon......as I watched in horror...
Oops! I mentioned it.....
Luckily it was in it's case, which kept all of the jigsaw pieces together - so a few weeks later my skilful friend solved a complex jigsaw puzzle without a picture, and several pints of home made cascamite glue later, he had a working bandoneon again.
His missus needed a new pressure cooker though, as the horse glue tainted the food.......
;-)
-
I won't mention an old mate of mine who became famous as the man who reversed a transit van over his bandoneon......as I watched in horror...
Oops! I mentioned it.....
Luckily it was in it's case, which kept all of the jigsaw pieces together - so a few weeks later my skilful friend solved a complex jigsaw puzzle without a picture, and several pints of home made cascamite glue later, he had a working bandoneon again.
His missus needed a new pressure cooker though, as the horse glue tainted the food.......
;-)
Well I won't mention the well-known musician who left his Jeffries anglo on the roof of his car and drove off -- and was last seen in a ditch at the side of the road saying "I've found another bit!"
-
Or a friend of a friend who backed over their £13k cello... which after it was put back together was valued at £15k.
-
Dont belive the valve thing myself but others may disagree. But I would worry about storing a pokerwork in a soft bag keyboard down mainly because if you drop the bag the plastic keybard would be the first thing to hit the deck and it is probably the most fragile part of the box
I can certainly attest to that. Plastic 1140C keyboards shatter nicely. They also break like concrete-hulled boats grounding on a rock; there's a small hole on the outside and inside a whacking great crater. Mine now has a tastefully feathered-in black plastic plate on the underside (the melodeon, that is).
-
Or a friend of a friend who backed over their £13k cello... which after it was put back together was valued at £15k.
Wow - must try backing over my banjo.....
-
Most box players have tried to back over a banjo... ;D
Rob.
-
In reply to the original post:
On Bernard Loffet's site he advises storing the melodeon on it's feet when not is use.
I remember last year sometime a long thread about this, after referring to the reference above, some believed it, others didn't.......
I store mine in it's box, but now stand it up so the melodeon is 'feet down' as it takes up less space in the room!
Q
as I write, Mr. Hook has replied.
I find myself in total agreement >:E
-
Sometimes an innocuous bump can destroy them, but often they survive horrendous falls without incident.
Bit like toddlers then. They run about in the garden and fall flat on their face when they think you're not looking, get straight up and carry on running about. Slightly stub their toe when they know you ARE looking - histrionics and drama worthy of high opera.
-
- histrionics and drama worthy of high opera.
And just about as convincing as the "acting" in opera!
My niece, as a toddler, did have one trick that would fool anyone. She could shiver so hard that even her jaw vibrated. Eventually I twigged that she enjoyed the close hugs she got to "warm her up".
Rob.
-
Since some melodeons don't have all the reeds in the same X/Y direction anyway (flat-mounted + right-angled) this seems unlikely to be true because of valves, otherwise there's be no safe way to store a Preciosa or one-row or Steirische or...
Ian is right -- and to add to that, the "feet" on a one-row are located at the side that is the "bottom" when the accordion is in playing position.
To get back to the original poster's question -- I'm under the impression that the leathers are more likely to curl if the melodeon is stored for a long time without being played. (So playing it frequently is probably more important than any particular orientation in its case, where it should remain for, at most, 22 hours?)
That said, you are probably in very humid conditions. I don't know what that means for the leathers. My impression is that a melodeon, after spending a long time on a boat, should probably expect a visit to the doc for a checkup and perhaps more.
-Andy
-
(So playing it frequently is probably more important than any particular orientation in its case, where it should remain for, at most, 22 hours?)
Interesting... it appears I'm going to have to leave a note for the lady that feeds my cats when I'm on holiday. "Feed and water cats, change litter, turn melodeon".
-
(So playing it frequently is probably more important than any particular orientation in its case, where it should remain for, at most, 22 hours?)
Interesting... it appears I'm going to have to leave a note for the lady that feeds my cats when I'm on holiday. "Feed and water cats, change litter, turn melodeon".
I'm sure you'll be OK -- just don't leave it unplayed for months on end...
-
(So playing it frequently is probably more important than any particular orientation in its case, where it should remain for, at most, 22 hours?)
Interesting... it appears I'm going to have to leave a note for the lady that feeds my cats when I'm on holiday. "Feed and water cats, change litter, turn melodeon".
I'm sure you'll be OK -- just don't leave it unplayed for months on end...
LOL!
-
I've had my old one-row Hohner aboard for about 12 years now (I live aboard) - I made a wooden box for it with a rubber seal round the lid, and it doesn't seem to be any the worse for wear.
Brian, this is encouraging. I'll have to reconsider the dry bag idea. Are you on salt water or fresh?
That said, you are probably in very humid conditions. I don't know what that means for the leathers. My impression is that a melodeon, after spending a long time on a boat, should probably expect a visit to the doc for a checkup and perhaps more.
-Andy
My first thought was also that humidity would be the major influence. Oddly, relatively humidity aboard is about like that on land, given that on land is in Atlanta, which is itself a bit muggy at times. I do notice that the bellows pick up a bit of an odor if I don't play for several days. The first couple of exhales can be noticeably musty but then it settles down and just smells like melodeon breath. Daily playing seems to avoid this, perhaps by ventilating the box's sinuses?
Is there a treatment for the reeds (wax or the like?) that might help protect against rusting, without affecting the pitch or other characteristics? If so has anyone ever tried it?
-
Hi Doc,
Sorry for the delay in replying!
I'm on the sea, and have been for the last 15 years. The box has been with me down as far south as Africa and the Cape Verdes, and as far north as Maryport (exotic, huh?). Played regularly and doesn't seem to have suffered. I always put it back in its box when I'm at sea, but its usually out when I'm in harbour or at anchor...
What do you sail?
Regards,
Brian.
-
Brian,
My, you do have a long and adventuresome wake. It's good to know that your box is well traveled and none the worse for wear. I would consider Maryport to be exotic, for the likes of me, at least.
I'm on a 35' cutter, a solid little cruiser built by Island Packet. She won't win any races but takes me here and there without too much fuss. I've come to think of her as a portable hard case for my melodeon. And you? What do you sail?
Boat pix at:
https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/sredir?uname=docedoc123&target=ALBUM&id=5559009976686249441&authkey=Gv1sRgCJWeg5uChqzEbw&invite=CODp1tgL&feat=email
(https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/sredir?uname=docedoc123&target=ALBUM&id=5559009976686249441&authkey=Gv1sRgCJWeg5uChqzEbw&invite=CODp1tgL&feat=email)
-
Pretty boat!
-
Ukebert,
I'm squinting at your icon -- or whatever the little picture is called -- and thinking it is a traditional sailing vessel. True? Any big pix? What waters?
-
Avatar (:) Yeah, it's a baltic ketch. Lovely boat, but not mine, I just like the picture! I sail a Trapper TS240 out of the Blackwater, not as glamorous but good fun. With the university yacht club I also occasionally sail their Sigma 38 out of Ipswich, which goes all over the place.
-
Many moons ago I had a Miracle. Had to let her go because I lost access to a car. :(
-
Hi Doc,
Let's drift his thread a bit further... :-)
I sail and live aboard my Flot 18, an 8m French-built aluminium sloop... Had a couple of wooden boats, but aluminium's much better!! :-))
Brian.
-
Don't drop any loose change into the bilges, though. Copper and aluminium just fizz in company! Mine's an 8.4m sloop (GRP).
Rob.
-
What is it about melodeons and boats? Is it the deep-seated need to sing sea shanties occasionally? ;)
-
Maybe I should get a boat. This time of year you could sail down just about any road in Wensleydale! ::)
-
I believe that it is also correlated with the disproportionately high number of beards. Present company excepted of course!
:D
-
Well, I don't have a beard but my husband, father and father in law all do. So I suppose that makes me relatively beardy. My Dad was in the Navy, which is about as beardy and boaty as you get. I travelled to my wedding venue (a ship) on a boat, and went on another ship to my honeymoon where we sailed a boat.
I must admit that when I recently told friends I was taking up the melodeon and they asked "what's that?" I had trouble finding an explanatory video that didn't just confirm their "beardy-weirdy" idea of the thing. They probably think I'm mere months away from morris.
That said, a friend of mine did also say that he plays the bhodran and I'm welcome to practice with him. So it goes both ways.
-
Maybe I should get a boat. This time of year you could sail down just about any road in Wensleydale! ::)
Reminds me of some folk I knew who bought a house on the Somerset levels with the front door on the first floor and a mooring ring beside it! Their new conservatory made a lovely fishtank!
Rob.
-
What is it about melodeons and boats? Is it the deep-seated need to sing sea shanties occasionally? ;)
Interesting question. I migrated to melodeon because it was easier to store aboard and keep in tune (compared to a guitar or a grand piano). Before melodeon it was concertinas and whistles, but I found it difficult to be a one-man band on concertina, much less whistle. I'd guess that a melodeon is popular on boats because it is relatively small in size and weight, includes chords, and is somewhat robust compared to crew -- who sometimes throw up when they should be harmonizing. Sea shanties could be a plus, perhaps I should learn some to go with my beard.
-
What is it about melodeons and boats? Is it the deep-seated need to sing sea shanties occasionally? ;)
Interesting question. I migrated to melodeon because it was easier to store aboard and keep in tune (compared to a guitar or a grand piano). Before melodeon it was concertinas and whistles, but I found it difficult to be a one-man band on concertina, much less whistle. I'd guess that a melodeon is popular on boats because it is relatively small in size and weight, includes chords, and is somewhat robust compared to crew -- who sometimes throw up when they should be harmonizing. Sea shanties could be a plus, perhaps I should learn some to go with my beard.
Never throw up always try and throw down it makes less mess :D