Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: baz parkes on October 11, 2011, 09:10:18 AM
-
I don't recall seeing any other posts about this but I may be wrong...it's pretty amazing. For me, it takes away a certain charm that the 1 row has...but I'm just jealous
Never learned to do blickies, but search Youtube for Scoobywest Improved Keyboard...
Enjoy
Baz
-
Assume you mean this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0)
Seems to work fine as long as you have a pianist to play your bass line. Probably easier to take 12 melodeons to a gig rather than 1 clever melodeon, a piano and a pianist ;D
-
Assume you mean this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0)
I did...cheers Lester
-
Assume you mean this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0)
Seems to work fine as long as you have a pianist to play your bass line. Probably easier to take 12 melodeons to a gig rather than 1 clever melodeon, a piano and a pianist ;D
Ah, but if you play B/C without basses anyway than what's the difference? >:E
Steve
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9E6ZAdyP-q8
This YouTube clip was posted in one of the earlier threads about these accordions, it helps to show which buttons are playing which notes.
-
I don't recall seeing any other posts about this but I may be wrong...it's pretty amazing. For me, it takes away a certain charm that the 1 row has...but I'm just jealous
It is still played, largely, like a one-row, so most of the "charm" is still there, as far as I'm concerned.
I appreciate that this box offers another option for players in Quebec, where the one-row in D has long ruled supreme among accordions, but in trad music in general, for the most part the fiddlers have been the judge and jury as to which tunes become the new standards. This box allows a box player to play most of the fiddle repertoire in a straightforward way, without sacrificing the four-voice sound and without learning an entirely new system, or lugging around multiple boxes (many players carry a D box and a GCF, others have multiple one-row boxes).
So it has its place! I wonder how many Andre Bouchard has made so far.
-
Nice idea - here's a more elegant implementation: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=1873.0
I will find out how many of these have been made when I next see Yves but it's a fair few already.
-
Nice idea - here's a more elegant implementation: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=1873.0
I will find out how many of these have been made when I next see Yves but it's a fair few already.
Yes, those look very nice, with more meticulous detailing.
-
Assume you mean this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOef8pOVLO0)
Seems to work fine as long as you have a pianist to play your bass line. Probably easier to take 12 melodeons to a gig rather than 1 clever melodeon, a piano and a pianist ;D
Ah, but if you play B/C without basses anyway than what's the difference? >:E
Steve
But it's a 1 row, half of what makes a one row a one row is the growl from the bass, no basses not a one row, especially as it has more than 1 row ;)
-
Lester,
If you want the growl of spoon basses to accompany a few more keys with a 1-row melodeon sound, maybe this man could help you out. It looks like he makes a full 2 row open-action box with multiple spoon basses as well as a 1-row 4 stop box with multiple spoon basses . . . So maybe he could make a box with 12 - 15 melody keys in one and a half rows of buttons (but a single row of pallets on the soundboard), 4 stops, and 6 - 8 spoon basses on a growl box! I haven't played one of his accordions but I admire what I see of the designs, for example:
http://www.leeuwaccordeons.nl/productie/index.php?keuze_nr=6
I also admire the new Bouchard and Sag'né designs! It will be interesting to see how they are accepted and how they influence the tradition over the coming years.
BTW I do play a lot these days on a "one row plus" box with 13 melody keys in one and a half rows of buttons (single row of pallets), 8 voices, and 4 basses . . . great box with a great sound, including the basses, even though it lacks the open pallet construction or the growl box. As much as I love the 1-row melodeon as an instrument, and the settings of tunes inspired by the 1-row keyboard, it opens up a new dimension sometimes to be able to play tunes that need a few extra notes on a box that plays and sounds like a 1-row.
PG
-
Nice idea - here's a more elegant implementation: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=1873.0
I will find out how many of these have been made when I next see Yves but it's a fair few already.
Yes, those look very nice, with more meticulous detailing.
And ten extra notes (five extra pallets), as opposed to four on the Bouchard design (which has two extra pallets, and two pairs of linked buttons).
-
I've often thought that if someone could make a true 2 row four voice that sounds like a one row then they'd make a fortune. The basses are more of an issue though I'll grant you.
-
ukebert,
The open pallet 2-row boxes that I've had (some with 4 spoon basses) were 2-voice . . . These have a great sound though only 2 voice, and there is a box like that listed for sale now in the classifieds here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8019.0.html
But the two 2-row boxes shown below, the Saltarelle and the Paolo, are both 4-voice LMMH and each has a sound with some of the qualities of a good 1-row box. Shown with an actual 1-row of course, a Globe that has recently been taken in and restored by another contributor here.
PG
-
A Paolo in LMMH, would love to hear that ;D
-
I play a Bouchard but it is the only one-row I have and so I usually play it in D. The additional notes work nicely but I find I need to keep to the D pattern in order to play with any speed, especially anything new. But perhaps if I were a better player....
-
I've often thought that if someone could make a true 2 row four voice that sounds like a one row then they'd make a fortune. The basses are more of an issue though I'll grant you.
Katie Howson's "green'un" (http://www.veteran.co.uk/katie's_cd.htm) is close. It's actually a three voice Eric Martin, but the the reason why she bought it was that it was close enough to the 1-row sound while having the key versatility of a two row. (as you'll see if you follow the link)