Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: shift on October 12, 2011, 09:00:46 PM
-
Hopefully the images have loaded correctly... So here's the foot next to the air button on my Saltarelle Pastourelle III, which broke when I literally put it down onto the floor. No big impact, but a painful moment none the less.
Has anybody else had similar, and any repaire advice would be gratefully received.
-
Looks like a simple repair. Remove the bass end cover. Glue the foot and snapped off woodwork back in place. Reinforce the repair inside the box. Mind you if I had it in my hands it may appear to be harder ;)
-
This is exactly what happened to my Pastourelle 2 last year. I tried and failed to stick it back together, and eventually a very kind member of this forum made me a new (more solid) bass plate. Don't know whether yours might stick better than mine did, but Good Luck!
-
This is exactly what happened to my Pastourelle 2 last year. I tried and failed to stick it back together, and eventually a very kind member of this forum made me a new (more solid) bass plate. Don't know whether yours might stick better than mine did, but Good Luck!
That is why I recommended reinforcement inside the box. But you may well be right that a whole new board may be the best fix.
-
The original design is rather weak - the foot is bolted to a corner right next to a cut-out! Most boxes have the feet screwed into the main case and/or forming the attachment for the bass plate. To prevent a recurrence, you'll need to follow one of the cures advised, either a new beefier board or (if ther is room behind) glue it back with a substantial reinforcement behind it.
Rob.
-
Hi,
Let me know size,I have a new plate in stock
Pete
-
The main musician in one of the morris sides I'm in has had this happen to her box. It's also happened to her friend's box, which is exactly the same model. Same corner, if I remember correctly.
-
Worth letting Saltarelle know? Perhaps they can improve the design for future boxes. Often these things that are trivial enough for people to fix at home never come to the attention of the manufacturers so they don't know the design needs tweaking.
-
The main musician in one of the morris sides I'm in has had this happen to her box. It's also happened to her friend's box, which is exactly the same model. Same corner, if I remember correctly.
As Rob2Hook has pointed out its a weakness in the design. To remedy the design weakness probably needs some or all of:
- move air button further from the corner
- Fit the feet differently so that the load on the feet is transmitted directly to the instrument case
- use a stronger material for the board
and be very careful every time you put the box down, even when in a hard case of gig bag.
-
Are these relatively recent Saltarelles? Mine (a Pastourelle II - I can't remember exactly when I bought it, but it has to be more than 25 years ago) is as tough as old boots. Earlier this year I dropped it bass-end first on to a solid tiled floor; I picked it up, played the set I was about to do then another spot in the second half (it was in a folk club), then took it home, where I discovered that one of the corner joints had opened. A smear of Titebond II and cramping up (that's clamping in the USA!) for an hour or so and it's as good as ever. It's fairly battlescarred and weary-looking, having had a hard life in bands and morris, but its structural integrity is uncompromised.
Graham
-
The problem is with material used,thin chipboard.The ones I make are 3 layers aircraft grade ply.
-
The problem is with material used,thin chipboard.The ones I make are 3 layers aircraft grade ply.
Then they are recent models - mine has a ply end-plate.
-
Sorry,just checked the one from Ellies box again,ply but very light weight type with no substance,another one I re made was chipboard
-
It's interesting what manufacturers do to reduce costs - the endplate on mine is a solid job from a stable veneered 6mm ply.