Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on October 14, 2011, 10:55:59 AM
-
But don't worry if you make the wrong choice as it an easy & relatively inexpensive job to have the low notes changed to accidentals or vice versa. A box without accidentals enables you do develop ;the noble art of faking which is an essential part of the fun of melodeon playhing!
Is that just ignoring accidentals?
-
not quite! faking is a complex art form with an element of 'smoke & mirrors' to it. In essence its down to performing aural conjuring tricks which, if succesful, lead the listener to believe that the non existant accidentals have been played! This can be done by substitution, diversion, plain kidology or whatever!
The late Will Atkinson of the Border Shepherds was a pastmaster at faking on the simple diatonic mouthie - many people thought he was actually playing the numerous.accidentals in tunes like caddam wood & the quaryman. ( There is a CD simply called Will ATkinson Mouthorgan but it is probably 'out of print' now. I saw one secondhand on ebay a few months ago)
george
-
there is acopy of Will Atkinsons CD available on amazon - I recommend it to both box & mouthie players
george
-
not quite! faking is a complex art form with an element of 'smoke & mirrors' to it. In essence its down to performing aural conjuring tricks which, if succesful, lead the listener to believe that the non existant accidentals have been played! This can be done by substitution, diversion, plain kidology or whatever!
Is it like the magic circle and if you gave away the secrets you'd be in trouble? ;)
-
The thing about visual (and presumably musical) fakery is that people see what they're expecting to see. I would imagine that if people know the tune well enough and you cover a missing accidental with a good old oompah on the left side people will imagine that you must have played the note because you didn't play a bum note, so it must have been there. Or perhaps do some little ornamental twiddle instead.
-
thats one way, useful as a 'diversion' if all else fails, but there are more subtle methods in the fakers cu;pboard! :|glug
george
-
One fake that is easy is this:
If you play a "basee-walk" (is that English)? I mean, like in a 3/4 instead of Base-chord-chord, you can play three different basses, usualyy next to eachother, like on a GC : F E D C.
You can do the same with G-A-B-C, but a GC8bass doesnt have a B. Instead of that B i play a normal g chord. If you do that in a tune, and stop right after you played that, and ask people what basses you played, evryone will say (or sing) GABC. while in fact you played GAgC
There are many more tricks like that,
W
-
I think we call that a walking bass, yes. Very much a feature of the standard Cockney "I've got a lovely bunch of coconuts" kind of music. One example that springs to mind is the bit between the chorus and the next verse of Supercalafragilisticexpialdedocious. Or however you spell it.
-
You can do the same with G-A-B-C, but a GC8bass doesnt have a B. Instead of that B i play a normal g chord. If you do that in a tune, and stop right after you played that, and ask people what basses you played, evryone will say (or sing) GABC. while in fact you played GAgC
There are many more tricks like that,
W
But you have actually played a B as part of the G chord!
-
ofcourse you played a b, but as a part of a g chord. And it sounds nowhere near an actual b-base, that people will say you played.
:-)
-
and evwn if remove the thirds, so you DONT play a b, people will still have heard it :-)
w
-
That's exactly what I meant, I think. Because people heard a clear walking bass, and they heard a B (albeit a low treble) they assume they must have heard a B bass because their brain told them it was coming and they heard a note that sounded about right. I would imagine the same would go for unusual chords. You could play a bass that's part of that chord, a couple of trebles that fill the rest of the chord in a bit.
-
One fake that is easy is this:
If you play a "basee-walk" (is that English)? I mean, like in a 3/4 instead of Base-chord-chord, you can play three different basses, usualyy next to eachother, like on a GC : F E D C.
You can do the same with G-A-B-C, but a GC8bass doesnt have a B. Instead of that B i play a normal g chord. If you do that in a tune, and stop right after you played that, and ask people what basses you played, evryone will say (or sing) GABC. while in fact you played GAgC
There are many more tricks like that,
W
That was a very useful tip. It clearly works. Have you got any more tricks to share?
Michael
-
That was a very useful tip. It clearly works. Have you got any more tricks to share?
Michael
None that come to mind right now, but if i actively and conceously use one, i will gladly share it.
Oh wait, i can share one that is a completely different kind of fakery perhaps. If you play a 5time-waltz, i kinda dislike the hoompapahoompa left hand, but it often ISS useful for dancers to let them hear the counts. I usually leave out the count #2. playing Hoom...paHoompa. If you now use your bellow with a very short but reasonably strong accent people will tell you that you played HoompapaHoompa, but in fact you didnt. And if you let them hear HoompapaHoompa they will agree that is not what hey heared...and will usually agree that HoompapaHoompa is a bit too "full".
Perhaps this trick is a bit less "trick" though,
W
-
the only 'test' for good faking must be that nobody can detect it! Which presumably means that re arranging a tune ( as Scottish pipers sometimes have to do) to get round instrumental limitations is not quite the same as faking - or am I splitting hairs?
#
george
-
Creative arrangement. ;)