Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Ollie on October 14, 2011, 12:57:06 PM

Title: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 14, 2011, 12:57:06 PM
Had a bit of free time today, so I went into our A2 recording studio and did a bit of box recording. This is the Swedish polska Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska learnt from Andy Cutting's solo album.

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=68981

The performance is a bit dodgy in places, but I'm very pleased with the recording results.

Enjoy :)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Clive Williams on October 14, 2011, 01:20:50 PM
Very nicely played, and a lovely sound quality on the recording!

With my 'planning own recording' head on, can I politely ask what you used to record it - what microphones, placed where, effects used, hardware, software, etc?

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Anahata on October 14, 2011, 01:48:01 PM
That's a magnificent effort in the bellows control and rhythm department, which is very tricky stuff in a tune like that.

I'd like to know about the studio too...
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: forrest on October 14, 2011, 04:07:55 PM
That's a magnificent effort in the bellows control and rhythm department, which is very tricky stuff in a tune like that.


Double ditto on that. Very smooth and sensitive performance. Great sounding box too ;)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 14, 2011, 04:24:52 PM
 :|bl Thanks for the comments.  (:)

I recorded it in our live room (not completely dry, but not too much reverb either) using two CAD M179s (large diaphragm condensers), cardioid setting, angled at about 200 from verticle, about 15-17 inches away from each end. In the A2 studio, use an iMac with Logic Pro 8, connected to a Tascam DM 3200 mixing desk.  

I've never really been taught how to mix boxes, but this is roughly what I did. Panned the bass about 36 left, and the treble about 30 right. Two condensers, one with low ratio and low threshold, and the second with a high ratio and a higher threshold (i.e. like vocal compression). With the bass channel, I boosted the bass and the middle, in order to boost the chords a bit. I cut the low end out of the treble channel, but boosted the middle and top end, in order not to make it too shrill or harsh, and to keep the sound warm when the 3rd voice comes in. I used Space Designer in Logic on both channels, but different reverbs - I think I used a vocal plate on the treble, and I can't remember what I used on the bass (might've been a large hall reverb, but I'll check).

I'm really pleased with the results, and it didn't take that long (about 20 minutes/half an hour) to mix. Hope that helps.  (:)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Owen Woods on October 14, 2011, 05:06:07 PM
Lovely playing as usual Ollie and a really nice sound!
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Pete Dunk on October 14, 2011, 07:24:02 PM
Ollie, you been developing into quite a special player for a while now and I hear yet another major step forward in your playing ability here. I'm very impressed to say the least with the expression and subtle nuances you bring to the music. Keep up the good work young man and one of these fine days I may just have to pay a tenner to see you play!  :o
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: tostean on October 14, 2011, 09:32:11 PM
That sure is a very fine version of this swedish classic. So please continue playing polskas - you'll find other fine tunes (mp3) at http://www.durspel.com/ (choose lyssna på låtar = listen to tunes) Well, you might have it bookmarked already.

Do you know this version of Jässpodspolska? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Y1oKFR24tI - two swedes with melodeon and swedish bagpipe. Not bad either ;-)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 14, 2011, 10:24:58 PM
Many thanks for all your kind comments.  (:)

Tallship - I have two gigs lined up in Feb - details nearer the time!

Tostean - many thanks for the link, I will certainly continue to play polskas. I'm currently working on my A2 Music composition, which will take the form of a Minuet & Trio based on different types of polska.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: **DTN** on October 14, 2011, 10:29:06 PM
Just Brilliant! ... like Tallship as you know i've admired your playing for a long time .... You have certainly become an accomplished player in many ways with your own style and great sensitivity to playing the melodeon , please keep developing your skill and i really look forward to hearing you play live ASAP.

cheers derek
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Anahata on October 15, 2011, 12:17:21 PM

I recorded it in our live room (not completely dry, but not too much reverb either) using two CAD M179s (large diaphragm condensers), cardioid setting, angled at about 200 from verticle, about 15-17 inches away from each end.
I'm currenty in favour of putting a stereo pair in XY (as near coincident as possible at 90degrees) or ORTF (strictly 17cm apart with 110 deg. between mics) in preference to miking the two side separately.
Quote
Two condensers, one with low ratio and low threshold, and the second with a high ratio and a higher threshold (i.e. like vocal compression).
I think you meant compressors...  ;)
Result sounds very fine anyway.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 15, 2011, 12:43:29 PM
DTN - that means a lot coming from you. Thank you.   (:)


I recorded it in our live room (not completely dry, but not too much reverb either) using two CAD M179s (large diaphragm condensers), cardioid setting, angled at about 200 from verticle, about 15-17 inches away from each end.
I'm currenty in favour of putting a stereo pair in XY (as near coincident as possible at 90degrees) or ORTF (strictly 17cm apart with 110 deg. between mics) in preference to miking the two side separately.

Interesting... I shall try both at some point and compare results. Not heard of ORTF before.

Two condensers, one with low ratio and low threshold, and the second with a high ratio and a higher threshold (i.e. like vocal compression).
I think you meant compressors...  ;)
Result sounds very fine anyway.


I was wondering who'd be the first to spot that...  ;)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Roland Carson on October 15, 2011, 11:38:31 PM
Ollie that was really nice and it was interesting to me because I have been taken by this tune and made a youtube recording of it last week:-

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MpZU7J_vUE

I didn't know the name of the tune but someone made a comment on my youtube page and told me what it was called and so I was very interested to hear your recording.

Superb ;o)

Roland
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 16, 2011, 07:47:22 AM
Nothing remotely dodgy there!  Steady 3-1  rhythm throughout and felt very danceable (polska ain't my best dance :-\). I'll pass on technical aspects,  miking my own kit is still on a "too hard" list.  But my own ear didn't actually  detect a "join" in there - that's either perfection or not depending what you were after.

Very (very) harmonious approach - I can imagine it on finnish harmonium. I had GHJäs from Milleret who said it was Danish - but Rättvik's defo in Sweden. It plays on  outer row on a G/C and you naturally get sus chords, bit tenser as a result  which works as this G major tune somehow sounds .. minor  ??? wierd or what?

A quite lovely listen. I'm on my third pass and I'm still hearing new nuances. Yup - another one I didn't notice that last time  :P

er .. may I ask what we might "medley it with"  >:E
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 16, 2011, 02:50:09 PM
Nothing remotely dodgy there!  Steady 3-1  rhythm throughout and felt very danceable (polska ain't my best dance :-\). I'll pass on technical aspects,  miking my own kit is still on a "too hard" list.  But my own ear didn't actually  detect a "join" in there - that's either perfection or not depending what you were after.

If by join you mean of different takes, then there isn't one - this was a one (first... sort of) take jobby. Thanks for the comments though.  (:)


Incidentally, what 'grade' do people think this tune is?
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 17, 2011, 08:35:44 AM
It's actually quite a straightforward tune in G. It has that weird 3-1 rhythm (polska was also on Chris's 'too hard' list for some time) unless you play it in fugue mode as in the other video. It has an awkward quadruplet in the middle.  I'd say good GSE primary piece based on what my nephew did in his jazz course.

It would also stand well as an example in an A level musical essay on diversity of rhythm.  Or there's loads to explore in arrangement? You have a good one already.  Milleret suggested.. (it also plays fluently on C/G, outer row)

   G  |  Cmaj7 | Am  | D      |  
   G  |  Cmaj7 | Am  | D,  G |

Same basic chords work in B part except it doesn't like the maj7 extension on the C chord.  This is modal harmony (no D7) and tune goes in and out of suspension against last D rather beautifully (you may need reversed note buttons for this). The old (be judicious) trick of resolving to C rather than G at the end of a measure also works.  

If you want to push the envelope .. I just tried some quartal chords against it on piano just now and there looks to be scope for experiment. You'll defo need double tracking for that!

btw I essayed 'dance traditionelle de France' for French AS ten years ago, but that was prose  :-\
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: EeeJay on October 17, 2011, 05:23:28 PM
Very (very) harmonious approach - I can imagine it on finnish harmonium...

Something like this... (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjZAA5U3HeA) 8)

Ed J

Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 18, 2011, 07:32:59 AM
hmm - a third rhythm  ???  and for a 2 steps per 3 beat bar dance that is lopingly slow. Rydberg is clearly (see other vids) a classically trained and seems to do every dance form going.

As I said - no polska expert - but here's http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuv01VJB-pw&NR=1 a 31 "three one" dance at the fast end of the speed scale - judged from my e experience last winter*  - and "obviously" experienced dancers.  I believe GHJäss is a slow polska.

Step: The couples go round anticlockwise stepping outer foot beat 3 and inner beat 1.  So far .. not too hard. You could call that a slow first step and fast second, but they always seem to start on beat 3.

At the bloke's whim they move into spinning mode - these dancers seem to use a little stamp as a signal.   The step is the same and you have to do a whole turn in 2 steps without the lady going ballistic. It has the same 'intimate' effect as mazurka - your steps seem to move in and out of phase with the tune. And it's about as emancipated as the tango  ;)

There are other polska traditions but this seems to be the 'big' one. *UK Scandanavian aficionados meet in Tideswell in January (limited space) and again at http://scandimoot.wikispaces.com/. "And we have fantastic breakfasts" .. it sez here :P
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2011, 08:51:42 AM
Step: The couples go round anticlockwise stepping outer foot beat 3 and inner beat 1.  So far .. not too hard. You could call that a slow first step and fast second, but they always seem to start on beat 3.


True for the man, but the woman has to put in an extra step during the change so that the man and woman then still do the same step, but the woman starts a beat after the man, and of course they are turning instead of a traveling forwards.  So it's the same only (quite a lot) different. :o
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 18, 2011, 09:07:36 AM
How did you guess that I'd never done the woman's step  ::)  

But thanks for the useful extra info - all the more reason to 'keep rhythm' perhaps?
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Theo on October 18, 2011, 09:31:16 AM
How did you guess that I'd never done the woman's step  ::)  

But thanks for the useful extra info - all the more reason to 'keep rhythm' perhaps?

Absolutely, there is no dance music without rhythm,  though the polska rhythm can be very mysterious to those accustomed to jigs and reels, and there is a very wide variety in polska rhythms too. Notation completely fails to convey the essential subtlety of polska rhythms.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: dahlberg on October 19, 2011, 08:13:07 PM
I think Ollie made a really great version,nice and slow, wich i prefer before sprintversions.
Most non-swedes have really hard learning the polska rythm. I think what confuses people is the loong 1 and cutoff 3. But that goes mostly for 8-beatpolskas,16-beatpolska you can mostly play the basses in 2/4 beat.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Hasse on October 20, 2011, 11:31:30 AM
First of all really great playing Ollie!!!  (:)

Most non-swedes have really hard learning the polska rythm.

I would say everybody who has not danced a polska have a hard time with the polska rhythm, and still you get slight variations on the same polska from person to person. BTW you do also find lots of these tunes in Finland, Norway and to a lesser degree in Denmark.

I think what confuses people is the loong 1 and cutoff 3. But that goes mostly for 8-beatpolskas,16-beatpolska you can mostly play the basses in 2/4 beat.

I agree with you on the 8 and 16 beat polska, but I don't quite get your description of the polska rhythm, a more common description would be if described in a kind of 3/4 time, being down/heavy on 1 and 3, and  lighter or up feeling on 2:

1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  
or
 / ^ / / ^ / / ^ / / ^ /  

... hope you get the idea?, the rhythm varies a lot from tune to tune and musician to musician and if people are dancing or not, and so on .
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Brimley on October 20, 2011, 12:44:59 PM
Yes, just lovely playing, Ollie, but also that recording really is excellent - listening to it it feels like your head is actually inside the instrument!  I wondered whether if you were to use that technical arrangement live in a band, whether you could keep the wonderfully natural sound somehow, but maybe reduce the panning (maybe that's Anahata's suggestion?) - what do you think?  Do you think it's the compression that has mainly given you that sound, or something else?
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on October 21, 2011, 12:10:08 AM
I don't have that much experience of live sound, but it might be possible... the compression, EQ and balance had a lot to do with the final outcome, so probably not. Having said that, when Owen (ukebert) played the open mic at Towersey, his box sounded just stunning... so it might be! Only one way to find out... :P
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: dahlberg on October 22, 2011, 08:06:34 AM
BTW you do also find lots of these tunes in Finland, Norway and to a lesser degree in Denmark.
I have played some finnish polskas (i have very close you know) ans alot pols from norway, but never came across Danish polska, any suggestments?

I agree with you on the 8 and 16 beat polska, but I don't quite get your description of the polska rhythm, a more common description would be if described in a kind of 3/4 time, being down/heavy on 1 and 3, and  lighter or up feeling on 2:

1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  
or
 / ^ / / ^ / / ^ / / ^ /  

... hope you get the idea?, the rhythm varies a lot from tune to tune and musician to musician and if people are dancing or not, and so on .
Well i guess we mean the same,my point was the difference from waltz 1-2-3, the polska is then more like 1-(2)-3. 2 is not marked as in waltz beat. I use to tell people to think about Christmas songs like "Hej tomtegubbar" or "Nu är det jul här i vårt hus" since most people know the beat in these sonx.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Hasse on October 23, 2011, 09:36:21 PM
Soory for taking up more space in your thread Ollie!

BTW you do also find lots of these tunes in Finland, Norway and to a lesser degree in Denmark.
I have played some finnish polskas (i have very close you know) ans alot pols from norway, but never came across Danish polska, any suggestments?

In Denmark the most common polska form is a 2/4 polska or in danish totakts-pols, it's played in 2/4 but the dance is sort of like the common Scandinavian polska dance in "3/4" (not slängpolska). You may also know some of these tunes as a Sønderhoning from Fanö. check this link folkwiki (http://www.folkwiki.se/L%C3%A5ttyper/Totakt-pols).  The 3/4 polskas were more or less forgotten or redone in Denmark, but still there are quite a large number tune still going strong, (often with other styles of dancing!), and lots of great polska tunes in old tunebooks. One of my favourites 3/4 polskas and one of the most popular revived polskas is Storms polska nr 49 or polsch nr 49.

I agree with you on the 8 and 16 beat polska, but I don't quite get your description of the polska rhythm, a more common description would be if described in a kind of 3/4 time, being down/heavy on 1 and 3, and  lighter or up feeling on 2:

1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  1  up  3  
or
 / ^ / / ^ / / ^ / / ^ /  

... hope you get the idea?, the rhythm varies a lot from tune to tune and musician to musician and if people are dancing or not, and so on .
Well i guess we mean the same,my point was the difference from waltz 1-2-3, the polska is then more like 1-(2)-3. 2 is not marked as in waltz beat. I use to tell people to think about Christmas songs like "Hej tomtegubbar" or "Nu är det jul här i vårt hus" since most people know the beat in these sonx.
Oh, yes SORRY Johan!!! Now I of course see what you meant! I'm a bit slow some times  ::)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: michik on October 24, 2011, 08:52:18 AM
The get an idea of the polska rythm: Polska played by Alban Faust ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8NZUpzjF_qo ,  look at his right foot
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Roland Carson on November 02, 2011, 10:03:02 PM
This is beautiful

http://www.youtube.com/user/1952Roland?feature=mhee#p/f/4/ZTg92PB2_TU
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Ollie on November 02, 2011, 10:04:14 PM
This is beautiful

http://www.youtube.com/user/1952Roland?feature=mhee#p/f/4/ZTg92PB2_TU

Ooooh, how have I missed that?! Many thanks Roland.  (:)
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: JohnA on November 02, 2011, 10:12:44 PM
Ahhhhh! Thanks indeed Roland - straight into my favourites folder
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Peter Savage on March 28, 2012, 06:33:02 PM
Here's my crack at it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uVR1eloqzmE&feature=youtu.be
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: Chris Ryall on March 28, 2012, 10:15:50 PM
Interesting - a left handed Castagnari with mirror writing!  ???

Toward the "English" end of polska rhythmatics, but I really enjoyed it's lightness.
Title: Re: Grinds Hans Jässpôdspolska
Post by: hibbs3 on March 31, 2012, 03:00:14 PM
simply well done
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal