Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on October 16, 2011, 11:35:45 AM

Title: Different Tunings
Post by: Daddy Long Les on October 16, 2011, 11:35:45 AM
Hi
Is there an audio resource on here for listening to the range of tunings from dry to wet and everything in between?

Thank you

Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: george garside on October 16, 2011, 12:06:17 PM
\its probably not quite that simple   as there are so many variables  , the degree of sharp or flat tuning of reeds varying with 2 or 3 voice musette  and exactly how shrp or flat differieng  widely between makes & models and that without considering bespoke tuning to the spec of an individual playaer.  Also the same theoretical tuning can sound different  if applied to different boxes and to different quality of reeds etc etc.

A rough idea of the range of wet to dry can be had by listening to utube clips eg modern castagnaris etc fairly dry, (lilly single voice dry)  hohner pokerwork erica  wetter ( sometimes refereed to as 'swing'  paolo soprani one on its own |(wet)  and Shand Morino (wett) spot on - to me anyway!!!

 Also the individual earoles capacity to hear different frequencies will have an effect on percieved  dryness or wetness ( horrible terms that are more appropiate to the tuning of flatulance! >:E)

hope this helps!  :D

george
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Lester on October 16, 2011, 12:13:21 PM
Marc Serafini's site - La Boîte à Frissons has loads of useful info and sound samples as well

http://www.la-baf.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=83&Itemid=99 (http://www.la-baf.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=83&Itemid=99)
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Bobtheboat on October 16, 2011, 01:02:27 PM
Hi, there are some sound samples contrasting the different types of tunings on one of the pages on Mike Rowbothams site too. Bob.
Edit: they are on the 'workshop' page and compare D/G lilliputs tuned dry, classic hohner and wet.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 16, 2011, 01:38:09 PM
Another example on Bernard Loffet's site, where he also descibes the tunings available with an mp3 clip to boot.....
Q
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: waltzman on October 16, 2011, 02:52:14 PM
On Serafini's site when it says 'swing 2' would that be 0 to +2cents at A 440, 'swing 4' would be 0 to +4cents, etc?  Am I interpreting that table correctly?
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Andy in Vermont on October 16, 2011, 03:10:45 PM
That is how I read it.

The tricky thing is that the same "number of cents" will produce more and more "wetness" as the tones get higher and higher.  The beats per second will increase -- unless the tuner grandually reduces the number of cents as the frequencies get higher up the scale.  If you look at Thierry Benetoux's book, he presents several curves.
All this is to say, that it is difficult to provide a simple demo of tuning, because when someone demos a "four cent sharp" tuning, does that mean 4 cents sharp all the way up the scale, or only at A:440 and then the same beats per second for every tone, or some "curve" where the cents sharp are decreased up the scale, reducing but not equalizing the bps?
And because pitch matters, a GC box that is tuned 8 cents sharp all the way up will sound less "wet" than a DG tuned the same way!
I hope that I have not misrepresented this aspect/problem with tuning -- and at the very least, I hope it highlights how difficult it is to get a demo of tuning ... And how detailed one's communication with the tuner needs to be, unless you just trust his or her judgement.

It might be helpful to think if it this way:
A tuning that gives you 1 beat per second at A:440 will give you 2 beats per second at A:880, quite a different effect!
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: george garside on October 16, 2011, 05:01:58 PM
precisely!

george
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: waltzman on October 16, 2011, 06:03:49 PM
My understanding is that the whole reason for using a reference tone like A 440 is precisely because the offset varies up and down the scale to maintain the same tremolo.  Otherwise you could just say '+4cents'.  In addition to that, I think most people prefer the sound of a tuning that has slighlty more tromolo in the treble end than in the bass end.  So the number of cents at A 440 is simply a reference point....but a very useful one.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Bernard Loffet on December 21, 2011, 07:41:53 PM
It might be helpful to think if it this way:
A tuning that gives you 1 beat per second at A:440 will give you 2 beats per second at A:880, quite a different effect!

The difference between the two reeds to obtain 1 beat/sec is 1 Hz.
If you tune your two reeds A 440 / 441 Hz  you will obtain 1 beat/sec.
If you want to obtain 2 beats/sec you have to tune your second reed at 442 Hz.
It's exactly the same way you obtain 1 or 2 beat/sec for the A 1 octave up, A880.
If you tune your two reeds A 880 / 881 Hz  you will obtain 1 beat/sec.
If you want to obtain 2 beats/sec you have to tune your second reed at 882 Hz

Your sentence will be correct if you talk of "cents" between the two notes instead of 'tuning' :
The same difference in cents that gives you 1 beat per second at A:440 (3,93 cents) will give you 2 beats per second at A:880, quite a different effect!

The explanation, mathematical formulae and more about cents, Hz, tuning on my FAQ (sorry it is in French) http://diato.org/faq.htm
There is also explanations and converters cents / frequency on the Peterson Tuner website : http://www.petersontuners.com/media/flash/Cents2Freq.swf

Bernard
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2011, 09:20:31 AM
My understanding is that the whole reason for using a reference tone like A 440 is precisely because the offset varies up and down the scale to maintain the same tremolo.  Otherwise you could just say '+4cents'.  In addition to that, I think most people prefer the sound of a tuning that has slighlty more tromolo in the treble end than in the bass end.  So the number of cents at A 440 is simply a reference point....but a very useful one.

Exactly.   There are so many variables.

1 Some instruments are tuned so that the beat rate doubles every octave.
2 A few are tuned with a constant beat rate across the whole range
3 Most are tuned somewhere in between, with the beat rate increasing with higher pitch, but not as much as doubling every octave.

Actually it is even more complex than that. Because the way the beat rate changes with pitch can be different at the lower end of the range than the upper end, and sometimes the low notes sound better with an even slower beat than any of 1,2 or 3 would predict.

Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 22, 2011, 09:37:57 AM
Exactly.   There are so many variables.

1 Some instruments are tuned so that the beat rate doubles every octave.
2 A few are tuned with a constant beat rate across the whole range
3 Most are tuned somewhere in between, with the beat rate increasing with higher pitch, but not as much as doubling every octave.

Actually it is even more complex than that. Because the way the beat rate changes with pitch can be different at the lower end of the range than the upper end, and sometimes the low notes sound better with an even slower beat than any of 1,2 or 3 would predict.
I totally agree with what Theo has said, and I defer to his expert and practical experience of tuning.

The tremolo rate of two reeds sounding together is not simply a matter of the difference of the fundamental frequencies of the two. Melodeon/accordion reeds do not generate a simple sine wave; there are harmonics involved too. I think one of the reasons for the complexity is that beats are also generated by the harmonics as well as the fundamentals. This is best heard where two reeds are tuned to give ostensibly a slow tremolo; on careful listening you can often discern a weaker but more rapid tremolo overlain on the main tremolo.

I suspect that the intensity of the harmonics tremolo depends on such things as the reed chamber size/shape, the metallurgical properties and shape of the reed tongues and the way they have been filed or scratched, the stiffness and material of the valves, etc. So many variables! It becomes nigh on impossible to predict the effect; you just have to develop a very careful and critical ear when tuning, and ultimately tune to what sounds best to you or your clients.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: george garside on December 22, 2011, 09:39:36 AM
which just goes to prove that  the ear is as important as the meter  for good tuning.  Presumably boxes were tuned largely by ear with the aid of a tuning fork  as a starting point long before sophisticated tuning devices were  available.

years ago I had a aJefferies concertina tuned by a  Jefferies specialist.( now deceased) It sounded absolutely  wonderful. & he said he had done it in ' uneven concert pitch'  - he then explained that he had developed over the years  as  near a match as he could get to the way Mr Jefferies tuned them by ear  & effectively built in the original slight discrepencies .

george
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 22, 2011, 09:47:15 AM
years ago I had a aJefferies concertina tuned by a  Jefferies specialist.( now deceased) It sounded absolutely  wonderful. & he said he had done it in ' uneven concert pitch'  - he then explained that he had developed over the years  as  near a match as he could get to the way Mr Jefferies tuned them by ear  & effectively built in the original slight discrepencies .
That sounds to me like yet another factor in tuning instruments. 'Uneven concert pitch' almost certainly refers to tuning not to Equal Temperament but to an unequal 'well temperament' of some sort (meantone perhaps?). The reason it probably sounded so good is that the non-equal temperament (whichever one it was) enabled simple intervals such as fifths, thirds and fourths to sound really sweet, which doesn't work so well in ET.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: IanD on December 22, 2011, 03:25:22 PM
Exactly.   There are so many variables.

1 Some instruments are tuned so that the beat rate doubles every octave.
2 A few are tuned with a constant beat rate across the whole range
3 Most are tuned somewhere in between, with the beat rate increasing with higher pitch, but not as much as doubling every octave.

Actually it is even more complex than that. Because the way the beat rate changes with pitch can be different at the lower end of the range than the upper end, and sometimes the low notes sound better with an even slower beat than any of 1,2 or 3 would predict.
I totally agree with what Theo has said, and I defer to his expert and practical experience of tuning.

The tremolo rate of two reeds sounding together is not simply a matter of the difference of the fundamental frequencies of the two. Melodeon/accordion reeds do not generate a simple sine wave; there are harmonics involved too. I think one of the reasons for the complexity is that beats are also generated by the harmonics as well as the fundamentals. This is best heard where two reeds are tuned to give ostensibly a slow tremolo; on careful listening you can often discern a weaker but more rapid tremolo overlain on the main tremolo.

I suspect that the intensity of the harmonics tremolo depends on such things as the reed chamber size/shape, the metallurgical properties and shape of the reed tongues and the way they have been filed or scratched, the stiffness and material of the valves, etc. So many variables! It becomes nigh on impossible to predict the effect; you just have to develop a very careful and critical ear when tuning, and ultimately tune to what sounds best to you or your clients.

Sorry to disappoint you, but with free reeds all the harmonics are exact multiples of the fundamental because the waveform produced from a reed is static i.e. it doesn't vary from cycle to cycle. This is a direct consequence of the way the sound is produced.

So the tremolo of two reeds beating *is* exactly determined by the difference in fundamental frequency, you can see this if you look at the waveform. This is different to plucked strings where the higher harmonics are usually sharpened due to string stiffness, which is why you get "stretched" tuning on pianos.

If the reeds are close together and there is coupling between then (like with unbraced reed blocks) then the reeds can "pull" in frequency as the phases move past each other, but the harmonics of each reed are still locked to the fundamental.

There might also be some other effects due to valves fluttering and so on, but these are not due to "out-of-tune" harmonics from the reeds.

Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 23, 2011, 12:30:46 AM
Sorry to disappoint you, but with free reeds all the harmonics are exact multiples of the fundamental because the waveform produced from a reed is static i.e. it doesn't vary from cycle to cycle. This is a direct consequence of the way the sound is produced.

So the tremolo of two reeds beating *is* exactly determined by the difference in fundamental frequency, you can see this if you look at the waveform. This is different to plucked strings where the higher harmonics are usually sharpened due to string stiffness, which is why you get "stretched" tuning on pianos.

If the reeds are close together and there is coupling between then (like with unbraced reed blocks) then the reeds can "pull" in frequency as the phases move past each other, but the harmonics of each reed are still locked to the fundamental.

There might also be some other effects due to valves fluttering and so on, but these are not due to "out-of-tune" harmonics from the reeds.
I don't think I actually wrote anything about 'out-of-tune' harmonics. My point was that tremolo due to interaction of the harmonics does in fact occur and contributes to the complexity of the general tremolo sound. I have the waveforms which demonstrate this. I will try to post examples in the next few days.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: george garside on December 23, 2011, 10:15:29 AM
presumably the Victorian  concertina & melodeon makers knew absolutely nothing about this sort of thing & certinly woiuldn't have  had devices that showed wave forms etc etc.   I read somewhere  that Jimmy Shand  learned the art of tuning from a blind melodeon player in the 1920's & again there would have been no electonic gismos .   Obvioulsy the modern stuff makes life easiser  for the tuner but I wonder if we have just lost  some considerable skills along the way?

george >:E
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: IanD on December 23, 2011, 01:04:59 PM
Sorry to disappoint you, but with free reeds all the harmonics are exact multiples of the fundamental because the waveform produced from a reed is static i.e. it doesn't vary from cycle to cycle. This is a direct consequence of the way the sound is produced.

So the tremolo of two reeds beating *is* exactly determined by the difference in fundamental frequency, you can see this if you look at the waveform. This is different to plucked strings where the higher harmonics are usually sharpened due to string stiffness, which is why you get "stretched" tuning on pianos.

If the reeds are close together and there is coupling between then (like with unbraced reed blocks) then the reeds can "pull" in frequency as the phases move past each other, but the harmonics of each reed are still locked to the fundamental.

There might also be some other effects due to valves fluttering and so on, but these are not due to "out-of-tune" harmonics from the reeds.

I don't think I actually wrote anything about 'out-of-tune' harmonics. My point was that tremolo due to interaction of the harmonics does in fact occur and contributes to the complexity of the general tremolo sound. I have the waveforms which demonstrate this. I will try to post examples in the next few days.

Sorry, I misunderstood what you were saying. As the phases of the two reeds move past each other the harmonics do add and cancel in turn; the fundamental goes through one add/subtract cycle, the second harmonic through two and so on. Since the waveform isn't symmetrical you never get complete cancellation because not all the harmonics are out-of-phase at the same time.

This is why if you listen to a box with almost dry tuning the sound quality changes continuously over one beat period as the different harmonics add and subtract; there will be one "loudest" point where the reeds are in phase and one "quietest" one half a cycle away from this.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 24, 2011, 09:32:53 AM
Thanks, Ian  (:)

This is why if you listen to a box with almost dry tuning the sound quality changes continuously over one beat period as the different harmonics add and subtract; there will be one "loudest" point where the reeds are in phase and one "quietest" one half a cycle away from this.
On one of my Castagnari instruments there is one note (B4 push on the G-row) which is particularly prone to a very strong volume change over the fundamental tremolo cycle. The two reeds M and M+ are tuned 'almost dry'* but the resulting tremolo is so strong in amplitude that it is almost unpleasant. The neigbouring reeds are also tuned to the same tremolo rate, but the tremolo amplitude is much less and/or more complex so that the overall sound is OK.

I suspect the offending reeds, for whatever reason, do not have the higher harmonics tremolo interaction which would otherwise modify the fundamental tremolo, and the latter is therefore slow but almost overwhelming in intensity. Any ideas on how to minimise this behaviour, please? I guess what is needed is to introduce some higher harmonics somehow, in order to modify the fundamental tremolo amplitude variation.


* I know Theo doesn't like this terminology - 'it's either dry or not' - but it's useful because we all know what we mean. Sorry, Theo!  ;)
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Theo on December 24, 2011, 09:42:40 AM
No, I'm content with 'almost dry'.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Theo on December 24, 2011, 09:44:04 AM
Your reed symptoms might be one of the effects that can be mitigated by changing the bracing across the blocks.  Try taking the brace off and sed if that makes a difference
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 24, 2011, 09:47:48 AM
presumably the Victorian  concertina & melodeon makers knew absolutely nothing about this sort of thing & certinly woiuldn't have  had devices that showed wave forms etc etc.   I read somewhere  that Jimmy Shand  learned the art of tuning from a blind melodeon player in the 1920's & again there would have been no electonic gismos .   Obvioulsy the modern stuff makes life easiser  for the tuner but I wonder if we have just lost  some considerable skills along the way?
I understand your sentiments, George, but I think that older instrument makers and tuners in many cases did understand the physics and acoustics involved. I think this is especially true of concertina makers and I have no doubt that as a scientist, Charles Wheatstone knew exactly what was going on. He designed the shape and size of concertina reed chambers to optimise the response of his reeds.

As you say, there were no electronic tuners available in those early days and human tuners had to rely on their ears and by referencing to a 'standard' set of reeds kept in the workshop. These days we do have electronic devices available, and very useful they are too, but we must never forget that the ultimate test of whether an instrument is 'in tune' (whatever we mean by that) is achieved by listening to the fully assembled instrument. The best human tuners know this and pursue their art accordingly.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 24, 2011, 09:50:54 AM
Your reed symptoms might be one of the effects that can be mitigated by changing the bracing across the blocks.  Try taking the brace off and sed if that makes a difference
Thanks, Theo. I wondered about trying that. I will investigate.

Quote
No, I'm content with 'almost dry'.
(:)  :|glug
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Bill the Farmer on December 24, 2011, 10:36:10 AM
presumably the Victorian  concertina & melodeon makers knew absolutely nothing about this sort of thing & certinly woiuldn't have  had devices that showed wave forms etc etc.   I read somewhere  that Jimmy Shand  learned the art of tuning from a blind melodeon player in the 1920's & again there would have been no electonic gismos .   Obvioulsy the modern stuff makes life easiser  for the tuner but I wonder if we have just lost  some considerable skills along the way?
I understand your sentiments, George, but I think that older instrument makers and tuners in many cases did understand the physics and acoustics involved. I think this is especially true of concertina makers and I have no doubt that as a scientist, Charles Wheatstone knew exactly what was going on. He designed the shape and size of concertina reed chambers to optimise the response of his reeds.

As you say, there were no electronic tuners available in those early days and human tuners had to rely on their ears and by referencing to a 'standard' set of reeds kept in the workshop. These days we do have electronic devices available, and very useful they are too, but we must never forget that the ultimate test of whether an instrument is 'in tune' (whatever we mean by that) is achieved by listening to the fully assembled instrument. The best human tuners know this and pursue their art accordingly.

I think this has been mentioned before, but there is a lovely old newsreel of the Wheatstone concertina factory on the British Pathe web site (http://www.britishpathe.com/record.php?id=417), including an old chap tuning by ear about half way through.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: IanD on December 24, 2011, 11:45:18 AM
presumably the Victorian  concertina & melodeon makers knew absolutely nothing about this sort of thing & certinly woiuldn't have  had devices that showed wave forms etc etc.   I read somewhere  that Jimmy Shand  learned the art of tuning from a blind melodeon player in the 1920's & again there would have been no electonic gismos .   Obvioulsy the modern stuff makes life easiser  for the tuner but I wonder if we have just lost  some considerable skills along the way?
I understand your sentiments, George, but I think that older instrument makers and tuners in many cases did understand the physics and acoustics involved. I think this is especially true of concertina makers and I have no doubt that as a scientist, Charles Wheatstone knew exactly what was going on. He designed the shape and size of concertina reed chambers to optimise the response of his reeds.

As you say, there were no electronic tuners available in those early days and human tuners had to rely on their ears and by referencing to a 'standard' set of reeds kept in the workshop. These days we do have electronic devices available, and very useful they are too, but we must never forget that the ultimate test of whether an instrument is 'in tune' (whatever we mean by that) is achieved by listening to the fully assembled instrument. The best human tuners know this and pursue their art accordingly.

You have to take a lot of what is said about this subject with a pinch of salt, if not a bucketful ;-)

About the "tuning the reed chambers" factoid, somebody said that even with the reeds out if you blew across the pallet holes you could "hear" the pitch of the reeds. You only have to look at the differences in sizes of the reed chambers vs. pitch to realise that this is impossible, the range of resonant frequencies is far less than the range of reed frequencies -- I think Tom Tonon analysed this and showed conclusively that it just isn't the case, the resonances both with (Helmholtz resonance with air in pallet hole) and along (cavity resonances) the chambers are far too high in frequency to have much effect, except on the very highest notes.

In most concertinas the reed chambers are pretty much sized to fit the reed frames with as little spare space as possible, this is true both for radial and rectangular reed pan layouts -- which is pretty much what you want to make the reeds speak quickly. There's no evidence of Wheatstone or anyone else "tuning" the chambers, just making them as small as possible. Also the theory needed to analyse the resonant frequencies -- or even why the resonance occurred -- wasn't published by Helmholtz until about 40 years after Wheatstone started making concertinas.

The only possible exception is the lowest bass notes where larger chambers seem to help to stop the reed choking at startup, probably by reducing the rate of rise of air pressure. When Neville Crabb built my wife's G/D in about 1980 he mounted just the low G reed on a separate raised chamber to do this -- he said he'd been wanting to try this for years but nobody had been willing to let him "have a go", and it was so successful that he built all his following G/D concertinas this way (also in a "baritone" sized frame about 1/2" bigger than normal for the same reason).

-- actually it seems that Wheatstone also tried this as well on bass and baritone concertinas, but the same conclusion stands with the higher reeds -- and even for bass reeds the chamber size needed to tune the resonance is far bigger than can be fitted into a concertina, so I'm pretty sure the bigger chambers just helped with startup.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 26, 2011, 05:16:47 PM
I can't remember the source, but someone wrote about music hall players waxing cork into the chambers of their concertinas and carving them to make the smoothest pathway with no uneccesary corners - rather ike flowing the ports of an internal combustion engine.  This was to make the tina play as loud as possible, although perhaps the real effect was to make it speak more quickly and thus sound brighter.

Rob.
Title: Re: Different Tunings
Post by: Mike Averill on January 01, 2012, 07:05:08 PM

The only possible exception is the lowest bass notes where larger chambers seem to help to stop the reed choking at startup, probably by reducing the rate of rise of air pressure. When Neville Crabb built my wife's G/D in about 1980 he mounted just the low G reed on a separate raised chamber to do this -- he said he'd been wanting to try this for years but nobody had been willing to let him "have a go", and it was so successful that he built all his following G/D concertinas this way (also in a "baritone" sized frame about 1/2" bigger than normal for the same reason).


I'd be interested in a few photos if you have the time, ideally with a ruler in the shots.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal