Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: WendyG on October 17, 2011, 09:12:05 PM

Title: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: WendyG on October 17, 2011, 09:12:05 PM
I recently bought a Hohner Club II, 2 row plus 4 helper buttons melodeon in C/F.  The melodeon has had some work done to it by an accordion centre, some valves have been replaced, some reed plates appear to have been re-waxed, and it is relatively in tune.  I purchased for it: 2 basic leather shoulder straps, press-stud bellows straps and bellows gasket.  I have also resurfaced the bass end pallets, replaced the grille and bass end cloths and limited the travel on the treble end.  I am having a mental issue with the gleichton (sp?) button and am thinking about selling it.  Should I do the other jobs on it that need to be done, such as bellows tape replacement, re-surfacing the treble pallets, replacing the bass end strap, and fine tuning before selling or would there be little difference in the price before and after refurbishing.  It is a pinkish celluloid Hohner, the celluloid is in good condition but has shrunk away for the edges.
Title: Re: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: Graham Spencer on October 18, 2011, 05:14:25 AM
If you otherwise like the box, rather than sell it why not replace the gleichton with a conventional bisonoric reed pair?  It's not a huge job, and if you don't feel up to doing it yourself it shouldn't be enormously expensive to get done.  Incidentally, as it's a Club, how are you getting on with the bisonoric bass (knee end on inner row) where you expect a unisonoric one on a "normal" melodeon?

If you do decide to part with it, I personally wouldn't think it worth investing any more time or cash on it for very little, if any, extra return.

Graham
Title: Re: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 18, 2011, 01:00:31 PM
The trouble with refurbishing is that it tends to be all or nothing or you'll be disappointed with the results in one way or another.  If you're otherwise enjoying playing it, then changing the gleichton will make life easier and the "problem" of the extra bass chord will teach you how to play on the pull to get the Bb bass.

Other options if you're keeping it would be to have the bass declubbed or go the whole hog and have it retuned to D/G.  They make a rather nice 2 1/2 row, albeit obviously 8 rather than 12 bass.  Even if you have everything done, it would be cheaper than buying a new box of equivalent quality, the older Hohners are of much better quality than a modern Pokerwork.  Theo rebuilt and retuned a wrecked Preciosa for me for less than the price of a Megane - the first item on the invoice was new bellows at £200!

Rob.
Title: Re: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: Tufty on October 18, 2011, 01:05:44 PM
"Theo rebuilt and retuned a wrecked Preciosa for me for less than the price of a Megane" - I would hope that a small melodeon would come cheaper than a car  ;D
Title: Re: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: Rob2Hook on October 18, 2011, 01:06:53 PM
Yes, but a Preciosa has more Va Va Voom!

Rob.
Title: Re: To reburbish or not, a Hohner Club
Post by: MartinW on October 18, 2011, 09:46:11 PM
A gew years ago I bought a C/F Hohner Club II that was in playable order, but which would really needed a proper service   . After a year or two I decided that , although I could theoretically see  the advantages of the club system, I could not get used to it. Theo de-clubbed it and gave it a good overhaul, and now I have a very nice feeling and sounding C/F box, which cost really very little.

I am glad I waited a while and spent some time with it in its original format, but even more glad I had it converted - thanks Theo.

Martin
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal