Anyone else had this problem with your left hand thumb?
Thanks for the replies - I carried on playing for a bit, avoiding anything that involved excessive air button usage, and it didn't seem quite so bad. The air button is quite stiff as well as sticking out a fair bit - so I might have to look into your suggestion Theo of having the air button fettled in some way.I've seen and played Liz's box and can confirm the the air button is not as comfortable as I would personally like - the 'high' end of the wedge-shaped button is quite sharp and stands well proud of the base plate. It should be a fairly simple task to modify the button, rounding it off a bit and reducing the height a little. Maybe the compression force on the spring could be adjusted too.
Liz :|||:
| This little clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bXdg8T8myo) shows four of the five basic movements of the thumb - that little mound of muscle at its base is a complex beastie. The 5th movement 'opposing a finger' has it's own little muscle opponens, a human evolutionary first! Flexion /extension - which on a melodeon sweep towards the floor or up - are strong movements and are assisted by forearm tendons. Abduction /adduction - which would push a melodeon air button in - are weak. So any box that has this type has IMHO a design fault. The thumb flexor tendon also passes through that little 'carpal tunnel', right next to the nerve that supplies the short muscles. so there's scope for triggering cramp from there. Liz's doctor could advise if she has the syndrome (a bit of skin will be numb too). But I suspect not, if she has a push-in air hole. sounds like simple fatigue |