Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: oread_uk on October 19, 2011, 08:00:39 PM

Title: Painful thumb...
Post by: oread_uk on October 19, 2011, 08:00:39 PM
I have a massive dilemma - I bought one of the Bafetti/Binci 3 voice boxes at the end of August.  I love it BUT I've been having a problem with cramp type pain in the base of my thumb (the pad bit, that I often end up using to push the air button).  I picked up my Sandpiper today and played for a bit with no pain - then picked up the Bafetti again and within a few minutes - ouch.  Trouble is, as much as I love the box, I'm not playing as much as I was because the cramp is obviously taking the fun out of it.

Now I don't know whether I should have gone for something smaller... I've tried changing my hand position, the tightness of the strap etc, but to no avail.  I don't know whether to keep going or think about changing to a different box...  The air button sits quite high, which I don't think helps.

Anyone else had this problem with your left hand thumb?

Liz X
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Theo on October 19, 2011, 08:07:30 PM
Anyone else had this problem with your left hand thumb?


Yes, I get a sore thumb from playing boxes with the Italian type push in air button,  The Hohner type works best for me.  You could try modifying your air button to the Hohner type.
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Sandy Flett on October 19, 2011, 08:35:28 PM
Is the tension on the air button spring noticeably stronger on the new box?

In the past I have suffered a similar ache from (a) a Liliput whose air button spring was fierce (now sorted by Mike Rowbotham) and (b) playing in G on a 12-bass ADG Oakwood because of the extra, bad angle, stretch down to the G and C basses.

The other thing to watch for is that you may be unconsciously tensing up a bit when playing the new box, especially if you are trying new stuff on it. Try to play really familiar stuff as relaxed as you can for a while - and don't forget to take short breaks to let the blood back into your muscles - and see what that does for the problem. If no different, then you will need to look at the type of air button (as Theo observed), its positioning, and the spring tension. If it is not as bad, however, then you just need to slowly phase in new stuff and try to stay relaxed and take plenty of breaks in a practice session.

Final thought, try to observe and analyse what is different between your playing of the two boxes.
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: oread_uk on October 19, 2011, 08:52:46 PM
Thanks for the replies - I carried on playing for a bit, avoiding anything that involved excessive air button usage, and it didn't seem quite so bad.  The air button is quite stiff as well as sticking out a fair bit - so I might have to look into your suggestion Theo of having the air button fettled in some way.

Liz  :|||:
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Owen Woods on October 20, 2011, 12:31:33 AM
Yes, I've had that specific pain in both hands doing a variety of activities, bellringing is the worst for some reason. I find that the more you play the box, the more you subconsciously adapt to a position that doesn't hurt, but that may not be the safest way to proceed! Keep an eye on it and don't push it.
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Steve_freereeder on October 20, 2011, 08:19:12 AM
Thanks for the replies - I carried on playing for a bit, avoiding anything that involved excessive air button usage, and it didn't seem quite so bad.  The air button is quite stiff as well as sticking out a fair bit - so I might have to look into your suggestion Theo of having the air button fettled in some way.

Liz  :|||:
I've seen and played Liz's box and can confirm the the air button is not as comfortable as I would personally like - the 'high' end of the wedge-shaped button is quite sharp and stands well proud of the base plate. It should be a fairly simple task to modify the button, rounding it off a bit and reducing the height a little. Maybe the compression force on the spring could be adjusted too.

Liz - if your Sandpiper air button is comfortable, try comparing the two for dimensions, shape and compression force.
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Chris Ryall on October 20, 2011, 08:39:10 AM
[anatomist mode=on]
  This little clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bXdg8T8myo) shows four of the five basic movements of the thumb - that little mound of muscle at its base is a complex beastie. The 5th movement 'opposing a finger' has it's own little muscle opponens, a human evolutionary first!

Flexion /extension - which on a melodeon sweep towards the floor or up - are strong movements and are assisted by forearm tendons.
Abduction /adduction - which would push a melodeon air button in - are weak.  So any box that has this type has IMHO a design fault.

The thumb flexor tendon also passes through that little 'carpal tunnel', right next to the nerve that supplies the short muscles. so there's scope for triggering cramp from there. Liz's doctor could advise if she has the syndrome (a bit of skin will be numb too).  But I suspect not, if she has a push-in air hole. sounds like simple fatigue
[anatomist mode=off]

Agree - solution is to fettle or convert it, and I believe Theo might be your man  ;)

I had long discussion with Frans van de Aa this summer on air holes  ::)  Showed him Gaillard's clever air  'gulper' which has a plate outside with three rubber studs - it doesn't matter where your thumb is to operate that one!  Sadly he couldn't fit that in, but as a player himself always puts in the sensible slider type anyway. Chris

cc 20th century box thread
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Sandy on October 20, 2011, 09:00:07 AM
I really struggled with my Saltarelle at first. My thumb/hand ached a lot with the change of air button and I thought that the purchase might have been a mistake. Did persevere though and it proved to be fatigue. It took a couple of months to  build up the strength and now I'm not aware of any problems at all. I do have a strong hands though  >:E

cheers
Sandy
p.s. Hope it is just that. Good Luck.
Title: Re: Painful thumb...
Post by: Anahata on October 20, 2011, 10:31:30 AM
I get the thumb problem sometimes on my Oakwood, which has an Italian-style air button.
It also has (had) a terrible mechanism to transmit the button movement to the pallette, which involved sliding surfaces with a lot of friction. I redesigned it so it's much more of a pure spring response and this requires less pressure, but it does have to be adjusted occasionally or the thumb starts hurting again.

Hohner air buttons hurt my thumb in a different way because they all seem to have rather sharp edges.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal