Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: wilfredsdad on October 25, 2011, 12:04:19 AM

Title: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: wilfredsdad on October 25, 2011, 12:04:19 AM
Hello - I roughly know what a roll is (three notes played in the time of one) but could anyone possibly explain to me how to physically execute a roll on a button melodeon. Specifically: are the three notes which are rapidly played the same three notes - so you are just rapidly tapping the same button three times with the same finger? Or are they different notes, that is say - the first note then an appropriate note above/below tapped with another finger, and then the first note again?
Does anyone know of a YouTube video or any other resource on the net which shows how to do a roll on a button melodeon (preferably in slow time)?
I know I have expressed this question rather clumsily but I hope you get the gist of it, and yes I am aware that it offers up lots of scope for gags about bacon rolls, cheese rolls, swiss rolls, chocolate rolls etc - well if that's the price I have to pay for a bit of info so be it - but if anyone could help with a bit of practical advice aswell it would really help, kind regards Pete
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: LDbosca on October 25, 2011, 01:21:18 AM
Hello - I roughly know what a roll is (three notes played in the time of one) but could anyone possibly explain to me how to physically execute a roll on a button melodeon. Specifically: are the three notes which are rapidly played the same three notes - so you are just rapidly tapping the same button three times with the same finger? Or are they different notes, that is say - the first note then an appropriate note above/below tapped with another finger, and then the first note again?
Does anyone know of a YouTube video or any other resource on the net which shows how to do a roll on a button melodeon (preferably in slow time)?
I know I have expressed this question rather clumsily but I hope you get the gist of it, and yes I am aware that it offers up lots of scope for gags about bacon rolls, cheese rolls, swiss rolls, chocolate rolls etc - well if that's the price I have to pay for a bit of info so be it - but if anyone could help with a bit of practical advice aswell it would really help, kind regards Pete

The traditional Irish roll is sometimes called the 5-note roll, it's actually three main notes and 2 grace notes; one higher and one lower. These separate the three melody notes. E.g.

G BGF#G

The timing of the Gs in the roll should be three even quavers - it shouldn't be an uncontrolled explosion of notes. The lower grace note is always a semitone below the melody note. The upper grace note is can be 2nd, 3rd or 4th above but should a note in the key you are playing in.

Assuming you are playing B/C box, on notes such as G or D you need to made a triangle with your fingers - middle on the G, ring on the higher grace note on the outer row and index on the lower grace note. To perform the roll you first play the G, then flick momentarily to the B (like a crushed note), back to the G, flick momentarily to the F#, then back to the G. The G will be lifted each time you change and the grace notes barely sound.

On notes where the upper grace note is on the inside row (e.g. A, B, C, F) then you do the same thing but with your ring finger on the inside row.

The other, less traditional, type of "roll" (although I'd say it's really the equivalent of bowed ornamentation on a fiddle) is the repeated single note, a la Sharon Shannon. Usually one longer note played with the index finger, then a fast triplet played by alternating the ring, middle and index fingers on the same button in rapid succession. Achieved by practicing it really slowly and cleanly and then speeding up.

IMHO, although perhaps more appealing at first, these rolls lose their appeal compared to 5-note rolls since they don't introduce the colour that 5-note rolls do. They're also significantly easier than 5-note rolls.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 25, 2011, 02:31:13 AM
What Luke said. BTW I think it's very confusing to call what Sharon Shannon does, and other similar devices, a roll.

I'm not aware of any demonstrations of classic 5-note rolls on the internet, but you will find them demonstrated in various DVD tutors - by John Williams, Peter Browne, and Damien Connolly for example.

It really is all in the timing. Rolls can sound very ugly (to my ear) if the timing isn't right and for many people (including me) they are a bit of an acquired taste because, although Luke pointed out that the upper grace should be in the key you're playing in, in many cases the lower grace will inevitably be out of key, and this is what jars. So for me the trick is in the timing, not making the lower grace too prominent.

These "5-note" rolls started life as an attempt to reproduce on the accordion what fiddlers, fluters and pipers do on their instruments. I'm not sure the attempt has been entirely successful, but whatever, the result has become pretty well established, and I'm even starting to like them myself.  (:)

If you don't care for the 5-note roll, or if your execution of it isn't up to par, there are other ways to deal with passages where rolls might seem to be called for, including but by no means limited to the Sharon Shannon rasp and more leisurely varieties of one-note triplet. 
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: nfldbox on October 25, 2011, 02:56:43 AM
Somewhere in the archive there is a video of DTN doing a nice version of the triplet. I have no idea how to find it however.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 25, 2011, 10:16:03 AM
These clips selected at random aren't demonstrations but should give you a fair idea of what "5-note" rolls can sound like.

Annette Owens:  http://youtu.be/1xBdo2uYTaI

Joe Burke: http://youtu.be/qcThzEOBv30

Martin Mulhaire: http://youtu.be/FgVYHvTwLWo 
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Simon on October 25, 2011, 12:00:42 PM
On melodeon there's also the 'half roll' where you play the higher button only between the first two of the three notes. For example start with index finger on D, do a short twiddle with your ring finger on F# and play the second D with middle finger, and finally the third D with your index finger. The Irish rolls are usually not exactly triplets but the first of the three notes is slightly longer.

Edit: found this link (http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/category/Playing-rolls-for-ornamentation-on-a-DG-box-1-903018.html) on the Spiers&Boden message board explaining rolls (including the half roll).
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 25, 2011, 03:08:41 PM
On melodeon there's also the 'half roll' where you play the higher button only between the first two of the three notes. For example start with index finger on D, do a short twiddle with your ring finger on F# and play the second D with middle finger, and finally the third D with your index finger. The Irish rolls are usually not exactly triplets but the first of the three notes is slightly longer.

Edit: found this link (http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/category/Playing-rolls-for-ornamentation-on-a-DG-box-1-903018.html) on the Spiers&Boden message board explaining rolls (including the half roll).

I wrote all that stuff about half-rolls on the old board. The fingering sequence you describe is something I worked out for myself and I'd be curious to know whether other players do the same. I have to say I haven't come across any. The more usual way to do it is with two fingers - say the index for the D in your example and the ring finger for the F#.

Whether those thingies are "swung" or not (first note lengthened) depends rather on whether the tune being played is swung, and the placement of notes in the bar. Spread over three quavers/a dotted crotchet on a strong beat, they sound good swung in a jig or a hornpipe.

In a reel it would depend rather on how much of a swing the tune as a whole was getting. Luke described the 5-note roll as having three evenly spaced main notes, and the same works well for a half-roll too. And if the roll is in an off-beat position in a reel (e.g. BE ~E2) you wouldn't want to swing it, even if you had time to do so.

Steve
formerly Polkaholic

 
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Simon on October 26, 2011, 10:06:34 AM
I edited the fingering according to the message board post, so that explains it. Before editing it was 2-{3}-2-1 instead of 1-{3}-2-1 but it kind of depends on where you need your fingers before and after the roll. However I usually use different fingers for the last two notes. And of course you're right about the straight triplet rolls in e.g. reels. Didn't think of that since I hardly play any reels on melodeon ;)
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 26, 2011, 11:38:45 AM
Any one else use this? Semitone box. inside row index finger, button above middle finger,  index finger again, slide to outside row(semitone down) with index finger and finish on origanal button with middle finger  ie C#D box DF#DC#D IMIIM so a two finger roll.
Incidentally I always thought Sharon's one note triplets and extended triplets although emulating the bowed triplet of the fiddle also related to her playing with her Banjo(where the same note triplet seems to dominate) playing sister and her early interactions with the likes of Karen Tweed and Phil Cunningham PA players where the three finger triplet and extended triplet  is used to great affect. Another useful roll related to the two finger single note triplet ie MIM on same button, is the note Middle, note above Ring, the note Middle, same note Index, same note Middle ie DF#DDD- MRMIM.  I sometimes use a four finger roll same note Pinkie Ring Middle Index and either Middle Index or Ring pending where I'm going next ie PRMII or PRMIM or PRMIR. Anyone else?  mory
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 26, 2011, 01:51:00 PM
Any one else use this? Semitone box. inside row index finger, button above middle finger,  index finger again, slide to outside row(semitone down) with index finger and finish on origanal button with middle finger  ie C#D box DF#DC#D IMIIM so a two finger roll.

No, but I do almost the same thing - starting on index and ending on middle - but using three fingers: the difference being that the upper grace is played with the ring finger, the second instance of the main note played with the middle. i.e. C#D box DF#DC#D IRMIM. Jackie Daly showed me that trick, very useful for rolls after a downward stretch e.g. BE ~E2. In fact Jackie said that at one time that is how many  players usually did rolls.

Quote
Another useful roll related to the two finger single note triplet ie MIM on same button, is the note Middle, note above Ring, the note Middle, same note Index, same note Middle ie DF#DDD- MRMIM.  I sometimes use a four finger roll same note Pinkie Ring Middle Index and either Middle Index or Ring pending where I'm going next ie PRMII or PRMIM or PRMIR. Anyone else? 

Yes, me! Well, very similar things. I stumbled on your DF#DDD MRMIM, but dropped it because it sounded too busy. (Jackie D told me that Tony McMahon executes his "crans" very much like that, say DADDD IRIMI.)

Now I use a slightly simpler thing constantly, e.g. DF#DD MRIM. I don't use the little finger but I do change the final finger depending on where I'm going next, e.g.  DF#DD MRIR. And if I need a "treble" followed by the same note e.g. eA (3AAA A I'd do the final two notes either II or IM as you say, depending what comes next.

Thanks Mory, it's fun discovering someone else who has tried endless fingering permutations to get the best effect away from the "classic" 5-note job. And Simon, I made a mistake in my earlier post about using two fingers: it should have read middle instead of ring for the F#. Otherwise, as you can see from the above, I agree with you about changing fingers depending on where you need them after. Cheers!  :|glug

Quote
Incidentally I always thought Sharon's one note triplets and extended triplets although emulating the bowed triplet of the fiddle also related to her playing with her Banjo(where the same note triplet seems to dominate) playing sister and her early interactions with the likes of Karen Tweed and Phil Cunningham PA players where the three finger triplet and extended triplet  is used to great affect.
I assumed it was the result of her obsession with Tommy Peoples' fiddle playing and his famous scrunchy treble. I read somewhere that when she was young she walked around the house all the time with headphones on, listening to Tommy.

So, Wilfrid's dad: have we answered your question yet?   (:)
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 26, 2011, 05:39:29 PM
Thanks Mory, it's fun discovering someone else who has tried endless fingering permutations to get the best effect away from the "classic" 5-note job.
     Likewise Steve

Your IRMIM is interesting, a new one on me anyhow. My IMIIM was a gift from Jackie, I'd just played this overdone bunch of embellishments at least that's what he said," to busy" as I remember it, he definatly wasn't wrong, he then proceeded to give me this to add to the mix.
The bit you attribute to Tony McMahon's crane tech, I've had a go like that as well, usually on the Eminor side of things. I find DF#DDD MRMIM has a bit more feel to it than some, at least an element of control in the individual duration of the notes within. I have to admit single note PRMIR etc is quite dramatic but interesting none the less. I like your MIRM I'll be having a fiddle with that, or should that be "a box with that" the triplet same note RMI can be four note and land on any of the three pending where its going to ie, RMIM RIMI etc. I do a little triplet that at pace has a sound more like a cut,( possibly due to a broken little finger years ago) on the Ring finger with the Pinkie usually EF#E GBG etc I'm always trying to get more seperation in there oh well. All the Best mory ps I also like using the turn of the box ie DF#DED IMIII or DF#DC#D MRMMMetc orDF#DC#D MRMIM with the turn on the C# I suppose from Melodeon  or DC# box where its more comfortable than steping out in that direction.

So Wilfred's dad hows it going? what box are you playing? it might help to know and it will probably encourage players of a similar layout to come in and share their techniques AtB mory

dont know why its all in the quote box Theo Clive? help please (now sorted )
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Anahata on October 26, 2011, 05:51:19 PM
Incidentally I always thought Sharon's one note triplets and extended triplets although emulating the bowed triplet of the fiddle also related to her playing with her Banjo(where the same note triplet seems to dominate) playing sister and her early interactions with the likes of Karen Tweed and Phil Cunningham PA players

I heard somewhere that this technique was invented (as a PA thing) by Phil Cunningham and Sharon Shannon learnt it from him, which sort of agrees with the above. It's funny how it's now widely associated with Sharon...
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 26, 2011, 05:53:42 PM
Ah yes but watch a bit of Phil with his brother on the tube to really see it in action mory
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 26, 2011, 06:35:35 PM
I could be wrong, as I often am, but I think Freeland Barbour might have been doing "it" before Phil Cunningham. Can anybody confirm this?
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Anahata on October 26, 2011, 06:40:46 PM
dont know why its all in the quote box Theo Clive? help please

The quoted text starts after [ quote ] and ends at [ /quote ]
You should put your reply in AFTER the [ /quote ] bit

(spaces added so the square brackets actually show instead of doing their grey box thing)
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 26, 2011, 07:24:27 PM
Thanks Anahata
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: wilfredsdad on October 26, 2011, 09:56:08 PM
Well, thanks everybody for so much useful information - it's really helped. In the first instance I will have to own up and say that the 'roll' I was looking for was the sharon Shannon ('crann'?) roll. I like that sound - it does emulate the banjo sound - and to my ear it sounds good, and very 'Irish'. Being a novice I have been labouring away trying to achieve this with one finger - wrong! Now that I understand that it is achieved by 'rolling' three fingers in rapid succession across the same button I have already begun to make better progress with it. I have also twigged that the direction in which you roll your fingers is determined by what note is going to immediately follow - whether it's an 'up' note or a 'down' note.
I don't care for over elaborate ornamentation - I realise now that some of the ornaments which I have heard Irish players using and which to my ear have sounded slightly out of tune are probably the five note rolls which incorporate an out of key grace note.
I am learning on a B+C box and I think I am correct in saying that some of the rolls mentioned above - like DF#DD - you could not do on a B+C because it would require a bellows reversal - I can't imagine that being possible in the middle of a roll.
I like the word 'Crann' - it describes that stuttering effect very well, and I like the sound of a crann - particularly at the beginning of a musical phrase - so that's what I am concentrating on for starters - and if I can make it sound even half as good as Ms Shannon (or Damien Mullane) then I will be more than happy.
Thanks again to you all, kind regards Pete
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Anahata on October 26, 2011, 10:07:01 PM
I am learning on a B+C box and I think I am correct in saying that some of the rolls mentioned above - like DF#DD - you could not do on a B+C because it would require a bellows reversal

Yes, on a B/C you go to either F (natural) or E on the B row, or possibly even up to the A two buttons away, which emulates a pipes ornamentation.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: **DTN** on October 26, 2011, 11:25:55 PM
Somewhere in the archive there is a video of DTN doing a nice version of the triplet. I have no idea how to find it however.

ah ..sorry removed them ... needed webspace! :-[
Derek
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: LDbosca on October 27, 2011, 12:57:47 AM
Well, thanks everybody for so much useful information - it's really helped. In the first instance I will have to own up and say that the 'roll' I was looking for was the sharon Shannon ('crann'?) roll. I like that sound - it does emulate the banjo sound - and to my ear it sounds good, and very 'Irish'. Being a novice I have been labouring away trying to achieve this with one finger - wrong! Now that I understand that it is achieved by 'rolling' three fingers in rapid succession across the same button I have already begun to make better progress with it. I have also twigged that the direction in which you roll your fingers is determined by what note is going to immediately follow - whether it's an 'up' note or a 'down' note.
I don't care for over elaborate ornamentation - I realise now that some of the ornaments which I have heard Irish players using and which to my ear have sounded slightly out of tune are probably the five note rolls which incorporate an out of key grace note.
I am learning on a B+C box and I think I am correct in saying that some of the rolls mentioned above - like DF#DD - you could not do on a B+C because it would require a bellows reversal - I can't imagine that being possible in the middle of a roll.
I like the word 'Crann' - it describes that stuttering effect very well, and I like the sound of a crann - particularly at the beginning of a musical phrase - so that's what I am concentrating on for starters - and if I can make it sound even half as good as Ms Shannon (or Damien Mullane) then I will be more than happy.
Thanks again to you all, kind regards Pete

I'm not saying you should or shouldn't but people mostly go downwards on one-button triplets, i.e. 1 3 2 1. (1 being index finger). If you're going to go both ways then you should definitely give priority to downwards.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Gromit on October 27, 2011, 11:27:43 AM
Thanks Steve and Mory that was interesting - perhaps you can enlighten me on cuts.

When I play a cut on the flute it's usually between two repeated notes ie two G's and I'd cut with the A (GaG)- if you are whistle players it's the same, this is the way I'm playing on the B/C box and would keep the G button pressed down while flicking the A sharp on the outside row.
But from what I read in Damien Connolly's tutor a cut or grace note is played BEFORE the main note ie. gracing A you quickly play B before playing the A. What I'm doing is playing similar to the way I would on a flute/whistle which kind of sounds better to me but may not be correct for the box - any thoughts?

Thanks

John
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 27, 2011, 12:09:22 PM
Hi Gromit thanks and that's not to leave LDBosca out after all he's the one in Ireland  (:)

here's a bit from Uillian piping terms   Cut (i) An old term for a single gracenote; (ii) to reduce the length of a note in a way not easily described by conventional music notation - for example, the cut note in a strathspey, normally rendered as a semiquaver, is described as cut and the resulting note is much shorter.

I think both types, as you describe, cutting with a lower note I know as the tip or tipping, is that not the scots snap? and cutting with a higher note, for me usually same direction note above, but lots of choices, a really quick flash of the higher note indistinguishable for tone before the note being cut, I tend to use this more on the concertina with my box its usually more of a short roll but pretty much the same effect although I make an effort to try and play them as a cut in airs as they have a clean soulfulness to them. the effect is a sort of dla. Ive noticed some concertina players seem to use something like a combo of a roll/triplet and a cut by keeping the note being cut on and cutting over it ie, play C and hit the E quickly while still sounding the C its like a triplet with the C constant and the E cutting into the middle of it.
Be nice if Steve and Luke come in and share their thoughts and of course any body else All the Best mory
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: LDbosca on October 27, 2011, 01:36:08 PM
Hi John,
Both types of cut that you mention are used frequently and considered correct, that is having a single grace note before the note or using a grace note in between two notes (such as two Gs) to separate. If you are doing the second type then you should always lift the melody note for the split second when you play the cut.

If you're cutting a G then presumably you're cutting it with the B on the outside row? The A# would be on the pull so I don't think that'd be practical.

Mory, I've heard that lower grace note ornament called a tip too. I always thought the scots-snap referred to anytime you have a semiquaver-quaver pair in a tune, but I'm sure a Scottish person would be better qualified to answer that.

Just for the record, this is the standard set of Irish ornaments for box playing (no notes should be held while the grace notes are sounded):

Cut on single note: BG

Cut between two notes: GBG

Tip: GF#G

Roll (5-note): GBGF#G

Short roll: BGF#G

Triplet: DF# ED, A C# BA etc.

One button triplet (not everyone does or approves of this one but that's another day's work): D DDD


There are various permutations but that's more or less the standard set.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Gromit on October 27, 2011, 01:42:52 PM
Thanks Mory (and also to Luke)

The concertina - combo of a roll/triplet and a cut but holding down the "main" note (C in your example) is pretty much how I'm trying to develop my long rolls - sounds a bit better to me than what I'm getting when I lift my finger from the main note, but as I'm a relative (self taught) beginner on the box I don't want to go picking up bad habits that are hard to get out of - I learnt that from my early days of flute playing.

John

PM sent re Camden

Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 27, 2011, 01:58:24 PM
I tend to use fiddle & whistle terminology, too, since I took up the box after decades of playing those instruments.

I'm glad to learn there is a standard set of terms for the box, Luke, but I think there's plenty of evidence to suggest that not every player or teacher uses it!

In Peter Browne's video he uses the term cut to describe a semitone "slide" into a note from outer row to inner, e.g. F#G

I would never call what Sharon Shannon does a "cran" since it sounds nothing like a piper's cran. It is akin to a fiddler's "treble" and that is a handy term to use, IMO, since "triplet" can mean several things.


One button triplet (not everyone does or approves of this one but that's another day's work): D DDD

This seems to need clarification. I think what Luke is describing is not what I referred to as a treble above. Examples of that would be:

FA (3AAA BAFA|dfed BcdA|  (more properly written FA A/A/A in ABC)
eA  A/A/A ABcd|eaae gedg|

etc.

What Luke is talking about seems to be a substitute for a long roll where you start the note and then "treble" it. Very similar to all those DF#DD things mory and I were talking about, except with everything on the same button.

In fact, even if not everyone approves, you can hear some nice examples of this device on Luke's myspace page, Queen of the Fair set, second tune, first part. Or am I mistaken, Luke?  (:)

Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Gromit on October 27, 2011, 02:02:23 PM
Thanks Luke

- yes got my draws in a twist there it should have been cutting the G with a B not an A sharp.

"no notes should be held while the grace notes are sounded"

Thanks for the advice because that's what I was doing

John
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: mory on October 27, 2011, 02:06:44 PM
Hi Gromit it wasn't really a suggestion more an observation/point of interest. If I may make a suggestion it would be to follow Lukes post, its all there to be had. The seperation of fingering/notes that really charecterises the 4/5 note roll is paramount, practice slow concise movements they will pick up speed all on their own, finger off at the same time as finger on I think explains it, but slow, real slow, when you have it and it picks up speed go back and slow slow slow it down. if you can play a familiar tune with the required embellishments real slow with every thing sounding right, you know with a bit of a lilt to it, then it will all be in place for the next race, (I mean session)  the beauty of the BC is you can pretty much play all the fiddle rolls with the same notes as the fiddle , we will have to get Luke to put up some teaching posts. AtB mory

 ps. No PM in my in box?

sorry for any cross over with posts

Collins English Dictionary definition of "Scotch Snap" - "a rhythmic pattern consisting of a short note followed by a long one
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Gromit on October 27, 2011, 02:30:07 PM
Thanks Mory
This is all great stuff and confirmation that I'm doing it wrong! excellent - yes I understand slow, real slow been through all that previously with the flute.

Oh yes I'll be back in a few years asking about basses (:)

John
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: LDbosca on October 27, 2011, 06:06:06 PM
I'm glad to learn there is a standard set of terms for the box, Luke, but I think there's plenty of evidence to suggest that not every player or teacher uses it!

In Peter Browne's video he uses the term cut to describe a semitone "slide" into a note from outer row to inner, e.g. F#G


One button triplet (not everyone does or approves of this one but that's another day's work): D DDD

In fact, even if not everyone approves, you can hear some nice examples of this device on Luke's myspace page, Queen of the Fair set, second tune, first part. Or am I mistaken, Luke?  (:)


Ha, hence my desire to get those recordings down, they're pretty rough and I don't do my 5-note rolls well in them either. All sorts of things wrong with them. Maybe I should alter my signature...

Those terms are nearly universal, I'd say Peter uses the term to describe the slide in due to the fact that that particular move, (F#G), is a relatively new development and so doesn't have a term. Some people would say not to use it at all, I'd say maybe very occasionally.

Mory, I hadn't thought about doing teaching videos, maybe in the future...unfortunately I think the tutor market's been covered so I can probably rule out making any money off it! Thanks for the words of approval/support.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Keithypete. on October 29, 2011, 11:06:57 AM
 This is a fascinating thread. I may be missing something fundamental though. If a crotchet has the 'roll' symbol above it, in a reel for example, the five notes fit into the space where the single note was - if I've understood things correctly.

 An observation regarding rolls, and the Irish style generally, often the rolls and other ornamentation seem to give the impression of speed when the tempo is moderate. This is probably what people refer to as 'busy'. My playing often sounds soooooooooooo English, like morris even, as I'm just playing plain melody with very few ornamentations, save for a little twiddle here and there, so the advice given here is very helpful. Thanks all.
 I love the playing of Joe Burke - the other players are mighty fine too.
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: Stiamh on October 29, 2011, 12:35:04 PM
A "long roll" covers the space of three quavers. On flute, fiddle etc. you can compress the five components of the long roll into the space of a crotchet: That is, I suppose, a scrunched-up long roll.

I don't know but I wouldn't think many box players attempt that.... maybe someone else can confirm that.

Now, there are also "short rolls" in the fiddling and fluting world - covering a crotchet. The usual way of executing a roll in the space of a crotchet on flute or fiddle is to omit the first note: instead of G{A}G{F#}G, you play {A}G{F#}G, starting the note with the grace. I think that box players would tend to play G{F#}G or G{B}G instead.

Now, very often when you see a roll symbol above a crotchet it's in a context like BE ~E2, and the way that most fiddlers - and box players I would say - execute that is BE {F#}E{D}E. Most flute and fiddle players do not articulate after the BE part (that is, change bow direction or tongue/glottal stop), so they have the same amount of time to get all five notes in (three quavers), but the emphasis is shifted onto the off-beat.

Clear as mud, no doubt, but maybe it will be of some help.  ;)
Title: Re: How to do an Irish 'roll'
Post by: wilfredsdad on October 30, 2011, 06:26:25 PM
Again - thank you all - very useful and helpful advice.
Thank you Luke for the clear descriptions of each type of 'roll' (also I enjoyed your playing on MySpace enormously - if you ever come down Bristol way to play please drop me mail - I'd love to come and hear you)
Also KeithyPete (sorry I don't know your name) - your comment about how ornaments can make playing at moderate speed sound much more interesting and lively I think is right on the nail - because I am a beginner I am focusing very hard on just trying to play the tunes accurately and sweetly with nice phrasing and I am not even thinking about speed (I am hoping speed will come naturally as I get better) - however I have found that (when I can pull it off) a simple grace note ('cut') or triplet just seems to help the tune so much.
Thanks to you all - I am sure that you all know that being a beginner on any musical instrument is a hard and lonely road (sob sob) so a little advice from people who have been there helps a great deal.
Thanks again, Pete
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal