Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Sandy on October 26, 2011, 03:39:09 PM
-
Had a go on Baffetti binci box today. Beautiful sound and so responsive. The D bass chord on the push sounded much higher over all like it was an inversion of the one on my other boxes. Is this normal for these boxes or a customised setting ?
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
I haven't noticed particularly on that chord, and mine's a prototype of the new Dino special which may be differently tuned anyway, but in general I think the maker will chose which octave range to put all the chord reeds in for best balance with the treble end, so you can expect that kind of difference.
Similarly: on the bass notes, there is inevitably a place where two notes nominally a tone or semitone apart are actually a seventh apart. That break happens in different places on my Oakwood (B to C) and My DB special (G to A)
-
It was my box Sandy played yesterday, which is in fact a DB with prototype reeds. Following our discussion I went to see a friend who taught music. With reservations, because of notes not a single reed she says :-
D chord on RH is root chord (3rd, 4th and 5th keys)
D chord push on LH is 1st inversion
D chord pull on LH is 2nd inversion.
Whatever that means
-
D chord push on LH is 1st inversion
D chord pull on LH is 2nd inversion.
It strikes me as odd that the two D chords should be different.
-
That was my reason for seeing Sandy
-
D chord push on LH is 1st inversion
D chord pull on LH is 2nd inversion.
It strikes me as odd that the two D chords should be different.
They're different on my Pokerwork.
-
I have a Pokerwork too. I see a little research project coming up...
-
D chord push on LH is 1st inversion
D chord pull on LH is 2nd inversion.
It strikes me as odd that the two D chords should be different.
They're different on my Pokerwork.
and my pressed wood but there was a greater difference on the baffeti like it was almost an octave up on the push...I'm just not skilled enough to work it out :|bl
-
On a Pokerwork you get
D Push D4 - F#4 - A3
D Pull D4 - F#3 - A3
On my Connamara 3 they are both D4 - F#4 - A3
-
On a Pokerwork you get
D Push D4 - F#4 - A3
D Pull D4 - F#3 - A3
On my Connamara 3 they are both D4 - F#4 - A3
lighter haired moment but what is the numbering ???
(:)
have a feeling this will be a big DOH ! moment. ::)
-
D chord push on LH is 1st inversion
D chord pull on LH is 2nd inversion.
It strikes me as odd that the two D chords should be different.
They're different on my Pokerwork.
The D chord (and equivalent in other tunings) are always different in Hohner pokerwork/erica/2915 because of the way the chords are built from reed that have the closest pitces on push and pull on the same reed plate. It is unusual in Italian boxes to have different voicings because they are usually built with tonic for push and pull on one plate, thirds on one plate and fifths on one plate, and the chord reeds are usually all within one octave range.
-
On a Pokerwork you get
D Push D4 - F#4 - A3
D Pull D4 - F#3 - A3
On my Connamara 3 they are both D4 - F#4 - A3
lighter haired moment but what is the numbering ???
(:)
have a feeling this will be a big DOH ! moment. ::)
They tell you which octave the note is in so the D Pull chord has a F# 1 octave lower than the push chord.
-
On a Pokerwork you get
D Push D4 - F#4 - A3
D Pull D4 - F#3 - A3
On my Connamara 3 they are both D4 - F#4 - A3
They tell you which octave the note is in so the D Pull chord has a F# 1 octave lower than the push chord.
then I guess the Baffetti was ..
D Push D4 - F#4 - A4
D Pull D4 - F#3 - A3
therefore hearing an octave difference on the higher note too which would be much more obvious than the middle note on it's own ??? and I repeat it is a guess :P
-
lighter haired moment but what is the numbering ???
(:)
have a feeling this will be a big DOH ! moment. ::)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequencies_of_notes
Third column in the big table lists them in number form
-
So I've tried this on my Baffetti Binci and it also has different D chords.
Listing chord notes from lowest note to highest,
Pull chord on the G/D pair is A-D-F# (2nd inversion if you like that sort of terminology)
Push chord on the D/A pair is D-F#-A (root chord)
The difference is even more striking if I pull out the thirds - it's very obvious then that one is a D with the A a fifth above it, the other is the same D with the A a fourth below it.
No numbers required ;)
-
Mine appear to be the same on push and pull.
-
lighter haired moment but what is the numbering ???
(:)
have a feeling this will be a big DOH ! moment. ::)
Don't beat yourself up about it, I know lots of people who know way more theory than you do. I know who'd I'd rather listen to playing. ;) ;D