Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Stiamh on August 29, 2008, 05:05:50 PM
-
Darren,
I'm puzzled by the selection of video links in the "Irish" section. At present, you have links to clips of Bobby Gardiner on a one-row D box, Tim Edey on a D/G, and Alan Morrisroe on another quint box (is it an A/D?).
While these instruments all fit the definition of "melodeon" as used in English trad. circles (a definition that generally excludes halfstep boxes), they are hardly representative of what the majority of Irish players are using.
If you wanted to restrict matters to quint boxes and one-rows, fair enough - I suppose. But the main website has keyboard layouts for all the main permutations of halfstep boxes, and quite a bit of the discussion on the forum deals with them too. So - I don't get it. (I don't care for Alan Morrisroe's playing, btw, and I have a sneaking suspicion you chose it because he could play for a morris side without anybody thinking he sounded Irish :-* )
I also find it curious that the VLP has entries for Switzerland and Slovenia, but not for Scotland (well represented by contributors to the forum, and lots of good YouTube clips of BCC# playing out there) and not even for France ???
Can we help?
Steve
-
Hi Steve,
Thanks for your comments. The VLP is still a work in progress so yes (as I asked everybody for at the time) please let me know any finds you think suitable for adding. It was certainly not my intension to limit the VPL to "melodeons" and will certainly add half step, and other, boxes.
Unfortunately, the past couple of months have been very hectic and stressful for me so I've not had any chance to search for more examples (I seem to have spent it going up and down motorways) or add new ones to the page. Things have now settled back down so the search can restart.
Darren
-
Steve and any other knowledgable people: I've added clips of Damien Mullane, Michael O'Connor, Billy McComiskey and John Whelan to the VLP. Any idea which systems they are using in the clips?
Ta
-
Damien Mullane B/C (he's also a great one-row player btw)
Michael O'Connor B/C
Billy McComiskey B/C (his non-musical accent in evidence at the beginning)
John Whelan B/C
Was pretty certain that they were all B/C players but did a visual check on bellows direction (after checking the key of the tune) to make sure :)
If you want to redress the balance in favour of the press and draw style, here's an absolute cracker:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdXRX9VEqaQ Tony MacMahon playing D/D# (i.e. C#/D style on a "E-flat" box)
Will look out for some others
Thanks
Steve
-
Cheers Steve, some really nice playing in these clips.
-
Some more great playing here -
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ZS1dW6gmWoo
http://comhaltas.ie/music/detail/comhaltaslive_205_6_damien_mullane/
http://comhaltas.ie/music/detail/comhaltaslive_205_2_damien_mullane
Gwarn Damo!!
-
..and heres Brendan Begley on the melodeon (in D)
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=fwRNQSjVbSc
-
Thanks for that clip, tucks. His playing has a remarkable rhythm or cadence to it. The basses are used almost sporadically like regulators on a set of pipes. I enjoyed that. Tougher to play a one-row, they say.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdXRX9VEqaQ Tony MacMahon playing D/D# (i.e. C#/D style on a "E-flat" box)
Steve, got a chance to watch this last night, my favourite of the clips I've found so far.
-
Glad you like it Darren. I see you've linked to it, so here's the missing info: he plays two reels, Ships are Sailing and Toss the Feathers.
It would be nice to find a good clip of C#/D playing - quite a bit of Jackie Daly on YouTube, but never solo :(
There's this one of Conor Keane (also C#/D), not a trad. piece, one of his compositions, don't know if that matters. Nice stuff though: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IstQyuOVE8M&feature=related
-
Cheers Steve, I'll investigate them later.
Tucks - not had a chance to look at those clips yet but thanks for adding them