Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: nfldbox on October 30, 2011, 03:27:20 PM
-
Far from a "New Topic" but I just wanted to post once more how amazing Joe Derrane is. I'm in the hospital for a minor operation and I was listening to Grove Lane and reading what people like Jackie Daly, Billy McComiskey and others have said about him. I have been listening to Derrane for many years and continue to be overwhelmed by his playing.
-
Far from a "New Topic" but I just wanted to post once more how amazing Joe Derrane is. I'm in the hospital for a minor operation and I was listening to Grove Lane and reading what people like Jackie Daly, Billy McComiskey and others have said about him. I have been listening to Derrane for many years and continue to be overwhelmed by his playing.
His playing is indeed astounding for crispness and the fact that he makes fast tunes sound slow, maybe because he's not pushing what he's capable of. Listening to Joe ought to be made compulsory for all novice melodeon players just so they can hear what crisp playing is all about.
But sometimes it also comes over as a bit lifeless and expressionless, just *too* staccato all the time. And the less said about some of the orchestral mush arrangements by Carl whatsisface the better...
Ian