Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: oggiesnr on November 07, 2011, 06:41:55 PM
-
So I've broken my left wrist and can look forward to six weeks or so in a cast. The cast won't allow me turn my arm enough to cover the holes on a whistle so it looks like I'm playing a moothie for a while.
So the question is what to play/learn? As I see it I can't play a chromatic as I can't hold and operate the slide correctly so it's going to be the moothie equivelent of a one row (with that annoying lack of the low E on a G one). So do I learn to play tunes I already know or should I go forth and learn some one-row stuff which is new?
Comments, suggestions and cracking one row sessions tunes greatfully received (:)
Steve
PS as I also have a Highlander I'll probably learn a few pipe tunes but they don't really appeal as a solid diet so to speak.
-
Tabor pipe or try a flabiol.
-
Tabor pipe or try a flabiol.
Tabor pipe I have but what is a flabiol?
Steve
-
The highlander has a good D side so that lends itself well toslow airs eg da slockit light;, waters of tyne, as well as jigs such as muckin of geordies byre, bugle horn etc etc etc. and many many more
george
-
Tabor pipe I have but what is a flabiol?
Another one-handed whistle. Here's the wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flabiol) entry.
Of course there's also plenty of piano music for one hand, though usually for the left (due to a war accident happening to philosopher's brother).
-
Flabiol in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBuqLrT47qs
I want one, it goes without saying.
-
Flabiol in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBuqLrT47qs
I want one, it goes without saying.
Thanks, so do I!
At the moment I've dug out my Hohner Marine Bands in C and G and Im going through the Thomas Sands Collection which has some good tunes. I'm also playing some French tunes but it's a hell of a lot harder breathing in and out at speed than operating bellows and cross rowing (especially as I've managed to bruise some ribs at the same time)
All the best
Steve
-
Flabiol in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBuqLrT47qs
I want one, it goes without saying.
Hmm, interesting. To the recorder what a tabor pipe is to a whistle?
-
Along the idea of breaking out the Marine Bands, but more fun, get yourself a Lee Oskar Harmonic Minor harp, instant Klezmer, etc.
A must have.
-
Flabiol in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBuqLrT47qs
I want one, it goes without saying.
Hmm, interesting. To the recorder what a tabor pipe is to a whistle?
Essentially (although at 0122 it took me a while to work out that sentence). Our friend Andy is the one to ask, he has one and has been to conventions on them. Amazing things.
-
Along the idea of breaking out the Marine Bands, but more fun, get yourself a Lee Oskar Harmonic Minor harp, instant Klezmer, etc.
A must have.
Which key would you suggest?
Steve
-
Sympathies to Oggie
That flabiol is quite amazing. Thank you. I'd come across 3 hole pipes down there but find a fully chromatic one handed instrument incredible. Who'd have thought it?
Nearer to home - Darlington market used to run on Wednesdays (I bet no one expected me to say that)! More importantly so did its famous folk song workshop in the Golden Cock. As a result an occasional visitor was the amazing Dave Brad(le)y (http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/2006/jun/27/guardianobituaries.artsobituaries) - raucous voice of Swan Arcade.
Another "ex biker" ::) Brady never let loss of most of his right arm hold him back. I met Dave when I was 17 - he ran a carpet business in t'market. Later in he pub he'd bring along a concertina and play it with one end between his knees. More to accompany song than for tunes.
Then once he borrowed a guitar! He played that holding down 3 finger chords ... strumming with his little finger. Great man in every sense. Guess I should post this in the present pinkie callisthenics thread too? :|glug
-
Dave also played a mean bass guitar, all done with hammer-ons and pull-offs. The concertina was a duet and he'd play the treble side.
Can't find anywhere that sells flabiols :( You can however buy adapted recorders with keys so you can play them single-handed, only problem is that they're the thick end of £500 so maybe not this time.
Steve
-
Can't find anywhere that sells flabiols :( You can however buy adapted recorders with keys so you can play them single-handed, only problem is that they're the thick end of £500 so maybe not this time.
Although if you cut off your right arm they are considerably cheaper. I think that the reason why those recorders are so expensive for able bodied people is that the increased cost subsidises the people who really need them, which is fair enough.
-
Hmm, interesting. To the recorder what a tabor pipe is to a whistle?
Actually there are one-handed recorders for one-handed recorder players, so I guess those are to the recorder what the tabor pipe is to a whistle. ;) Traditionally the flabiols are more played like a tabor pipe than like a recorder, so with some kind of tabor drum. See for example the flabiol festival (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4a_Sie3U8k) (although there's also a guy playing hurdy gurdy with flabiol). Sans Luthiers in Spain makes flabiols. I've just ordered a couple last month for our shop. Wonder if you can play two flabiols simultaneously ;D
-
Oggie--
I like the Am harmonic minor in straight harp. (that is, first position, first hole blow)
Not too high, not too low.
But I think you would enjoy any harmonic minor.
(see also: http://www.harmonica.com/forums/harmonica-gear/just-got-my-lee-oskar-am-harmonic-minor-harp/)
(and) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RLCNesboqKw for an Am
Lot's of YouTubes if you want to get a sense of the pitch for other keys.
Plus, this is maybe the only "no hands" instrument I can think of (though I don't think you will find an harmonica holder that comfortable)
-
Thanks for that, should be with me early next week.
I'm actually finding that playing harmonica is making me listen more. On a box I know which note I'm playing because I know which button I'm pressing. On a harmonica it's a lot easier to get disorrientated so I have to listen more to what I'm actually playing, not what I think I'm playing (:)
Steve
-
The cast finally came off today BUT the wrist is the far side of useless, in fact it hurt less and I could do more with the cast on. However I am told this will pass and use will return but I've a bit more harp practice to come (:)
Steve
-
Thanks for that, should be with me early next week.
I'm actually finding that playing harmonica is making me listen more. On a box I know which note I'm playing because I know which button I'm pressing. On a harmonica it's a lot easier to get disorrientated so I have to listen more to what I'm actually playing, not what I think I'm playing (:)
Steve
the relationship between brain & gob when playing a mouthie seems much more akin to the relationship between brain & gob when singing. than the brain/button relationship used by many when playing the box. This I why I strongly advocate the any finger for any button approach which goes some way towards eliminating the brain/button syndrome.
Whatever the reason I find picking out a tune first time on a mouthie quite often has the same 'feel' as humming it!.
As to mouthies the hohner highlander is great and one seller still has them at half price c£35
george
-
Hurdy gurdy ... Kevin Dalot (no hand on the left): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pi-Yzqq-jus
-
Simon-regrets, I see you had already suggested the chiff an fipple.
-
Can't find anywhere that sells flabiols :( You can however buy adapted recorders with keys so you can play them single-handed, only problem is that they're the thick end of £500 so maybe not this time.
Although if you cut off your right arm they are considerably cheaper. I think that the reason why those recorders are so expensive for able bodied people is that the increased cost subsidises the people who really need them, which is fair enough.
here is a shop here that sells them for Eu 70, in a couple of colours, if that is important.
http://www.pick-et-boch.com/anglais/produit.php?prodid=2926&bd=Flabiol+%28Catalan+one-handed+flute%2FTabor+Pipe%29+-+Boxwood+model
This is the one, in boxwood:
(http://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k88/dougdarter/flabiol_-_modele_en_buis_ref.jpg?t=1324427975)