Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on November 13, 2011, 08:37:25 PM
-
as an intermediate player I'm looking forward to 2012 and starting to think of tunes etc to learn next year, i also want to improve on my technique - i currently practice about 45 min - an 1hr 30Min's a night.
can anyone tell me there top 5 tips to improve their playing??
many thanks
Tommy
-
In my case its : practice, practice, practice, practice and practice
-
listen analyticaly & critically to what you are playing with particular attention to phrasing & dynamics & be prepared to make many small adjustments to get a tune sounding good. Recording what yhou are playing & then listening can be a useful option.
I am sure that others will add at least another 3 tips so yhou will probably finish up with more than 5!
george
-
The gaps in music are as important as the notes (possibly more important)
More later ;)
-
What Lester said.
Practice playing things with a little space between every note....like they were peas instead of spaghetti. ;D
-
Maybe agreeing with Lester, but unless you are a very productive practicer, best progress is made from 20-30 minute sessions, 1x or 2x a day at most. No real benefit from the 90 minute slog.
Take a day off from time to time. It's not a job. Make it fun.
Listen to tunes some days and play less. Go to sessions and don't play at all.
Best lesson of all is to watch others play. 2nd best lesson is to learn basics (Mally is good, George G also) so you don't spend a lot of time learning and practicing bad habits.
If you can arrange it, have your box tuned and "fettled" a bit (practicing my "foreign languages vocab" here)
-
If you can arrange it, have your box tuned and "fettled" a bit (practicing my "foreign languages vocab" here)
;D
-
More thoughts fom a slightly drunk person who has just completed two hectic days of melodeon workshops:
Play with others, don't practice on your own all the time.
When you play with others ask what they think of your playing, accept criticism (the analysis or evaluation of a work of art, literature, etc) gracefully, process it and act upon it if you agree with it, store it away if you disagree, if you hear it again reconsider your disagreement!
-
Yes play with others, excellent advice and make it playing with players of other instruments. Too many melodeon players seem to shy away from all the other wonderful instruments.
Vive la difference!
-
I can only suggest one - analyse your playing position. It has to be naturally comfortable, easy to beat time with a foot, and the RH end needs to be as firm as a rock, while your hand is free to play all the notes with ease. If it's not all these things, you'll be restricting your ability to do all the other things you'll need to be able to do.
-
Recording yourself and listening to it back makes a big difference in how you perceive your playing.
-
I'm still trying to get my head around peas and spaghetti ;D
Recording yourself and playing it back can be soul destroying but at least the recording machine doesn't lie, that's really what you sound like to the person sitting next to you.
Chris is the only one to mention playing position. To me this is one of the most important areas that can hold improvers back. Look at any good player of just about any instrument and see how relaxed they look. That's no accident, it takes time and thought to become totaly at ease with your chosen instrument. If you are uncomfortable or tense in any way, that will show through in your performance.
-
I forgot to add to my playing position comment that the chair must be the right height if you're sitting down. Most are too low for me, and I have to compensate by hunching forward, but it's only a partial fix. Extra cushions help, but they wobble and aren't perfect. I use an adjustable drum stool for gigs, or stand on one leg with the right foot on a couple of cases. Office chairs without arms are good, except that if you have them at their highest position, they sometimes seem to lose pressure. Having a back is nice to relax on between playing. I just wish they didn't take up so much space in the car!
-
I've found that I improve when I work hard on the part of the tune that I constantly get wrong. In other words instead of ploughing through the tune from start to finish each time, zoom in on that problematic bit, perfect it and then put it all together.
-
a good example of this might be the fast 'run down' in Harvest Home - take it out of the tune & work on it separately until its right. Then put it back in the tune & it probably won't be right! so then work on integrating it back into the tune!
george
-
The gaps in music are as important as the notes (possibly more important)
Agreed! once the basics of the box are mastered learning to 'play the gaps' will transform the way a tune sounds.
In 2009 ( I think) there was a programme on BBC radio in Scotland to commemorate the 100th anniversery of Jimmy Shand which a certain member of this parish kindly put on a CD for me. It consists of, a;mongst other things, interviews with peopole who knew Shand well ..
One of those interviewed was Jack Emblow, a piano accordionist of some renown & reputation & a top class sight reader.( he accompanied all the sing something simple series on BBC radio fo.r several years amongst many other programmes & ran his own band. For some reason he plaayed 2nd box for Shand on a couple of recordings one being Lilly of Laguna. The commentator asked Jack if he had learned anything from Jimmy Shand? - Jack Emblow replied that Shand tought him the difference between long & short notes. presumably meaning not chrotchets or quavers but creating gaps by playing 92% of a crotchet or 67 % of a quaver oor whatever . In other words playing the gaps.
george
-
Learn and practice slowly, and don't practice at a speed where you make mistakes because you will learn the mistakes.
-
Bit of a beginner on the melodeon myself, but I've played other instruments. One thing I'd add is to have a sense of perspective and to see the future. What I mean by that is, don't think that you'll be able to play anything properly straight off, and don't assume that because you can't play it now, you won't be able to play it in the future. If playing a musical instrument was easy, everyone would be doing it, but if you put the work in, you'll be able to do it too.
So yes, don't be disillusioned by how you play now - focus on how you intend to play in the future and strive for that.
Learning to play is a bit like how life was described to me once ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERbvKrH-GC4 ) - people too often define life by their goals, and once they get to their goal (swanky job, money, marriage, whatever) they sit there and think "now what?". Life is more like music. The defining moment of a tune is not the final chord, it's the whole song. It's not the goal that is important, it's the journey. Quite a Taoist way of looking at it I suppose, and a good way, I think. Live your life (and learn your instrument) like appreciating a piece of music - enjoy each part of it for what it is; an important part of the whole. Each thing you learn is another tune in the Great Morris Set of Life. :D
So enjoy practicing because you know it's taking you where you want to go. Don't get grumpy about the bum notes because they don't fit in with your "goal" of a perfectly played tune, they're inevitable, but as has been said before, accept them as something that's going to have to be worked on, and work on them. Bum notes are part of the tune of your musical journey. :)
So there's my advice, Grasshopper - don't expect too much of yourself too soon, look forward to a time when you can play the tune you want to play, but don't get so focused on goals you forget to focus on what you're achieving right now.
-
I can only suggest one - analyse your playing position. It has to be naturally comfortable, easy to beat time with a foot, and the RH end needs to be as firm as a rock, while your hand is free to play all the notes with ease. If it's not all these things, you'll be restricting your ability to do all the other things you'll need to be able to do.
hear hear
W
-
In no particular order...these are top on my list.
1) Play tunes/phrases through very slowly and treat every note with equal importance.
2) Listen lots to the great players and try to analyse how they can make a simple tune sound so good.
3) Play tunes through staccato as if the buttons were red hot !!
4) Learn the notes of the buttons...( I haven't done this yet and it's bugging me because I know it will just make life so much easier)
5) Play a familiar tune over and over again almost to a 'trance' state where you find, without thinking, you start adding variations and twiddles that you didn't know existed.
cheers,
Sandy
(:)
-
I was getting a bit "in the zone" with the Sloe recently. You often find that if you stop concentrating on playing the right notes, you just start playing them anyway. In some cases, you find you play it better when you stop thinking about it too much.
-
I agree with you, Strigulino - it's a bit contradictory, but to play well I think you have to learn to play the right notes (in the right order), then the best thing to do is to forget all that, and then learn how to play the tune properly.
-
A bit off at a tangent, but there are a series of Terry Pratchett books called The Science of Discworld which use his fantasy books to explain real life science. Anyway, my point is that in those books they go into what they call "lies to children". The simplified reasons we give for why things are the way they are, like why the sky is blue, or where babies come from, or why things fall when you drop them. Then they get to university and are told that what they've been told isn't strictly true. It is sort of true, but more complicated than the simple answer. So they have to unlearn the pat answer they were given at school to pass an exam, and learn the real answer.
Same with tunes. Yes, you can mechanically follow the dots, pressing all the right buttons in the right order. Then when you can play it like a computer would play it, shut your eyes, ignore the dots and listen to what it actually sounds like, and learn how to be musical with it.
Yes, definitely make a conscious effort to get away from the dots. It's not like a two-phrase tune is a great long symphony where you need a bit of paper to remember where you are. Dots are like trainer wheels on the side of your bike. They make life easier when you're starting a new tune, but they will eventually start to hold you back. If you're concentrating on reading you're not concentrating on listening. So yes, once you know a tune, shut the book and try to play it.
I went to a great "no book" workshop on Saturday last. Just everyone going round in a circle suggesting a tune or just playing whatever was in their heads. I think a lot of people surprised themselves at just how many tunes they could bang out without music in front of them. Perhaps a little practice session at home. Write yourself a little list of your favourites, that you'd really like to be able to play at a session, and have a go at them without the book. From my own experience, remembering how they start is the hardest part. Once you're off, the rest flows.
-
Recording yourself and listening to it back makes a big difference in how you perceive your playing.
Ain't that the truth......... :D
-
As a melodeon beginner I would have to say that learning this instrument is the most enjoyable of the instruments I have tackled. Unlike many other instruments, it's relatively easy to make an nice sound, or sequence of sounds (my family may disagree on this point!). The chromatic limitations of the instrument also make it easier to approach.
However, what I have found (& this is certainly true of other instruments also) is that there is a world of difference between playing a tune for your own enjoyment & playing it for other people. Even though I can play quite a few tunes fluently, I generally still make stupid mistakes along the way. This isn't a big deal when you're playing for yourself, but it's less than impressive when you're playing for others. I find it takes a LOT longer to master a tune so that you can play it 100% error-free, 100% of the time for an audience AND have the extra control to be able to focus on the phrasing & expression rather than just "not making mistakes".
I guess recording yourself is a good way to bridge that gap between playing for yourself & playing for others, although the thing with a recording is ... you can always re-record it!
-
However, what I have found (& this is certainly true of other instruments also) is that there is a world of difference between playing a tune for your own enjoyment & playing it for other people. Even though I can play quite a few tunes fluently, I generally still make stupid mistakes along the way. This isn't a big deal when you're playing for yourself, but it's less than impressive when you're playing for others. I find it takes a LOT longer to master a tune so that you can play it 100% error-free, 100% of the time for an audience AND have the extra control to be able to focus on the phrasing & expression rather than just "not making mistakes".
Hit the nail on the head there - I couldn't agree more!! :D
-
This is one of those threads that has so many good points, it almost needs adding to the Home page.
Some I've digested previously but comments in this thread reminds me again. I need reminding!
As someone who has been playing melodeon for 15 months, I'm starting to find on a few favourite tunes that now the buttons are programmed into the fingers ( mostly (:) ) I can start to concentrate on 'playing' the tune as opposed to just pressing the right buttons in rougjly the right order. Bit like learning to drive, you only start to learn poperly once you've passed your test and have the freedom to go and drive the car.
Theo told me right at the beginning - it takes time. I'm starting to believe him!
Ahhh time for :M must dash
cheers
Q
-
some great comments here thanks!
i currently play with a guitarist and fiddler and we record most weeks, so i guess im on the right track,
i try to soak up advise so please keep your comments flowing!
-
Just reading back over people's comments here, one that hasn't been mentioned yet, particularly for anyone who is learning to play completely by ear (and desperately trying to avoid any grandmother/egg issues!), is the importance of the simple '3 chord trick' (the so called tonic, sub-dominant and dominant chords), and an understanding of the notes that they comprise (in G or D on a melodeon in those keys), and where to find them on the RHS. Just in case anyone isn't aware what this trick is, it's a little bit of music theory that you can immediately 'hear', and it's worth looking up because it very often helps you find the LH chord that fits best. Then learn the relative minor chord, and the double dominant, and you're well away!
-
What is double dominant?
-
do we need to know! >:E
george
-
(In G major, it would be A7 - in D major, E7. It's the sort of dominant chord for the key of the dominant chord, if you see what I mean. Gives a bright fresh sound, a bit 'music hall' sometimes.)
eg: "(Tonic) me the way to go home, I'm (sub-dom) and I wanna go to (Tonic). I had a little drink about an hour ago, and it's (double dom) right to my (dom)".
-
1. Gaps - try to articulate both the start and the end of each note. Each note will then count, and you will learn to control the gaps between them. Especially, avoid playing consecutive notes that are on the same button - but in different bellows direction - without taking your finger off the button in between.
2. Keep your initial repertiore small. Practice each tune until it becomes automatic. As you build up your repertoire (and confidence) you will find that many phrases you already know will crop up again and again - making it easier and quicker to learn new tunes.
3. Practice the most difficult phrases separately. Then, add the phrase either side. Finally, practice the whole tune. This way:
- The parts of the tune that need the most practice get the most practice.
- You learn to pitch the speed of the tune correctly. Often, the first few phrases are simpler - so we start off too quickly - then fluff the difficult bit.
4. Spend at least as much time listening as playing.
5. Don't join the "I can play faster than you" brigade. If you are in a session that gets too fast just put your instrument down and go the the bar / the bog or something. Then listen to what is actually being played. It will usually sound absolutely cr@p. Many a beautiful melody is spoiled in this way.
Chris Kirk
-
(In G major, it would be A7 - in D major, E7. It's the sort of dominant chord for the key of the dominant chord, if you see what I mean. Gives a bright fresh sound, a bit 'music hall' sometimes.)
Ah! in stradella terms its up two and accross two
george
-
Spend at least as much time listening as playing.
Yep!
-
George - if you carry on doing that don't you get what they call a 'circle of fifths'?
-
thats how stradella work . starting with Ci.e. G<. each diagonal row is up or down a fifth . i.e. going up owards chin its CGDAEetc & going down its CFBbEbAb etc. the vertical rows are it from bnellows end cou;nterbass ( bass major, minor, 7th chords.
george
-
(In G major, it would be A7 - in D major, E7. It's the sort of dominant chord for the key of the dominant chord, if you see what I mean. Gives a bright fresh sound, a bit 'music hall' sometimes.)
eg: "(Tonic) me the way to go home, I'm (sub-dom) and I wanna go to (Tonic). I had a little drink about an hour ago, and it's (double dom) right to my (dom)".
Thanks. I've never heard that term before. I'm used to thinking of an A7 in the key of G as a 'temporary key shift' to the key of D.
-
I've never heard it called that before; the more standard name is the 'supertonic', or chord II(7). Actually, what Chris described is a sharpened supertonic (#II7), as the third is sharpened in a major key, and the third and fifth are sharpened in a minor key.
Good lord, A level Bach Chorale harmony is coming in useful!
-
I got the term from a guitar tuition book many years ago, Ollie, and I found it useful because for me it described a sound in a way that's easy to hear.
and the third and fifth are sharpened in a minor key
Did you mean that?
(NB But remember the context of this thread - no-one up till now has mentioned scales.)
-
There are lots of names for everything. I like double dominant. One of my top tips is to make use of what I call the "drop dominant", which is ending a phrase on the sub-dominant as opposed to the dominant or tonic.
-
all this just goes to show what a wonderfully 'broad church' we are on melnet. ONe half wallow in such technical/theoretical deliberations and the other half havn't a clue what they are going on about
george ;)
-
That plagal (finish on iV chord) trick is a tip - but perhaps not 'top'. It's also called the "Amen" sequence (listen to it)!
My tip is "how to change key" and is the reason for that 'double dominant'. Very common - especially in those fast 2 row polkas. I'd say A7 gets used more than E7 though (unless you like playing in A). Basically your G row has a C, D has C#. In terms of' notes available' that's the only difference.
So 'when in G' you play IIminor you are 'in scale' A,C,E. Make the chord or note sequence Amajor A,C#,E and you've moved the tonal focus into D 8) A true 'double dominant' is a 4 note - here A7 = A,C#,E,G - available 'right end'. But actually playing anything with a C# in is all you need.
Tigger's guide ;)
How to use this trick? Well chord progressions are a lot more about 'where you are going' than 'where you are now'. So play your polka or whatever with chords running
G ..diddle .. Em .. diddle diddle .. D ... diddle .. G
Second time through simply change that last chord to get progression.
G ..diddle .. Em .. diddle diddle .. D ... diddle .. A
Voila! Now play the next part of the music on the D row. You have "moved up a fifth".
Physically - true A7 chord lies on the the D/G as a right hand chord. It is A from [G row pull], the other three notes [D row pull]. But it's easy just to pull your A left end triad. Note (importantly) that the A pull comes as the last chord of your G music. It 'anticipates' a D row B part.
As they say in the driving lessons - that's how to change up. I'll let you work out how to change down ...
-
There's a middle way, George! Working out what those funny 8 buttons are for, strictly no wallowing!
-
indeed!
george ;)
-
1) I learn new tunes by putting together quickly a very simplified version of the tune and playing that, adding the bits I find hard one by one until I can play it "properly". This works on any instrument.
2) (In large friendly letters) http://DON'T PANIC!
Chris (the other one)
-
All this theory talk is all very well, but it tends to make me switch off. However, have found a golden nugget of a tip amongst it - that "Show Me the Way to Go Home", showing what chords go where. A tune that everybody knows, and you can think of how the chords sound so you can match a chord to the fancy name.
-
Coz I'm quite odd. I have to set myself deadlines to learn tunes for (and record them) else I get a bit lazy about it. I also plan my practice in advance. What I'm gonna practice on which instrument when and how long. But then I do have 3 instruments and clog dancing to fit into the time available for practice. Oh and I try to do at least one practice without looking at the music.
All this theory talk is all very well, but it tends to make me switch off.
Me too. I can understand programming language but music theory turns my brain to mush. ;)
-
so you can match a chord to the fancy name
Strigulino, one word: Yesssss!!!!! (:)
"(Relative minor) I mean....., (Doub dom) show me the way...(dom)...., to go... (tonic, adding the flattened seventh note and ninth in the scale, if you can).....ho-o-o-o-o-me!"
-
Rather along the lines of the recommendation of a simple three chord trick, i would recommend that you consider how each tune is to be used. There is a world of difference between the possibilities for a "concert" performance and the requirements for playing for dance. This may lead you to develop two approaches for many tunes!
Each year our band members come back from Witney and want to play those mushy continental crossed chord sequences they have just learnt. I have to be quite emphatic that that is not suitable for a Morris band! Strict tempo and simple accompaniment for clarity, please. Likewise, I know some otherwise excellent players who insist on playing the clever way for a ceilidh. That's alright if you're not playing lead, but it can lose the drive needed to enthuse the dancers - exceptions like Rosza?
Rob.
-
very much horses for courses!
george
-
I got the term from a guitar tuition book many years ago, Ollie, and I found it useful because for me it described a sound in a way that's easy to hear.
and the third and fifth are sharpened in a minor key
Did you mean that?
(NB But remember the context of this thread - no-one up till now has mentioned scales.)
Interesting. I quite like it.
Yes, I did mean that. If you take G minor as an example; chord II of G minor is A-C-Eb. Therefore, you have to sharpen the 5th to make it sound nice and to avoid the Devil's Interval (augmented 4th/diminshed 5th)! It also happens to sound nice in baroque harmony if you sharpen the 3rd as well.
That plagal (finish on iV chord) trick is a tip - but perhaps not 'top'. It's also called the "Amen" sequence (listen to it)!
Plagal cadence is IV - I, not something-IV. As far as I know, there's no proper name for finishing on the sub dominant, though I like ukebert's suggestion!
-
Each year our band members come back from Witney and want to play those mushy continental crossed chord sequences they have just learnt. I have to be quite emphatic that that is not suitable for a Morris band!
Amen to that!
Plagal cadence is IV - I, not something-IV. As far as I know, there's no proper name for finishing on the sub dominant, though I like ukebert's suggestion!
Again .. not for Morris ;)
-
Plagal cadence is IV - I, not something-IV. As far as I know, there's no proper name for finishing on the sub dominant, though I like ukebert's suggestion!
Again .. not for Morris ;)
I beg to differ! :P
-
there's no proper name for finishing on the sub dominant, though I like ukebert's suggestion!
Maybe 'unfinished' would be good name for it.
-
Heres two that I found improved the way I play
Learn to play quietly / softly
Learn standing up
Andy
-
I find it takes a LOT longer to master a tune so that you can play it 100% error-free, 100% of the time for an audience
Certainly does - I've been playing for over 30 years and I still can't do that! 98% error-free, 98% of the time on some tunes maybe, but perfection in front of an audience still eludes me...........
-
I find it takes a LOT longer to master a tune so that you can play it 100% error-free, 100% of the time for an audience
Certainly does - I've been playing for over 30 years and I still can't do that! 98% error-free, 98% of the time on some tunes maybe, but perfection in front of an audience still eludes me...........
Us amateurs practice til we can get the tune right, professionals practice til they don't get it wrong ;)
-
Lester: A classic comment - how true!
Q
-
Q wish it was of my making but it was someone else but can't remember who
-
Never mind, it was well remembered and certainly worth saying again.
Q
-
Actually, professionals quite often get it wrong, but they're very good at covering it up so you don't notice - or at laughing it off if it really does go pear-shaped.
When you're playing to an audience it often doesn't matter if you go slightly wrong, as long as you don't let it put you off. The melodeon is particularly forgiving - it's usually difficult to play a spectacularly wrong note - and the moment is usually past and gone before anyone can notice. The only time you need to get it 100% is when recording, but now everything's digital and with software such as Pro Tools or Cubase even that can be put right.
If you make a mistake, keep the rhythm going and glare at the other members of the band as if it was them who'd gone wrong :)
"Once is a mistake, twice is a variation, three times it's an arrangement.
Four times, it's jazz."
-
I think the ability to keep going, as Howard says, is a massive step forward. If you're on top of it all and drop a note, a musical version of a 'typo', but don't crumble and keep it going, then as you say it's been and gone and porbably not noticed.
I'm mostly at the stage when if i go wrong i do crumble >:(, but am noticing i'm getting better at holding it together and getting it right next time through.
.... but then something else crumbles :P
but that's life (:)
Another good thought.
Q
-
In a really good band the band the members will make the leaders mistakes with him/her & nobody will notice anything untoward. It must be very nice to have a nand dthat follows the leader that close
george
-
Absolutely - improvising and you hit a bum note - general advice is to just ... play it again.
The only truly forbidden note is a major third over a minor chord.
-
The only truly forbidden note is a major third over a minor chord.
We've been here before (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7944.msg99280.html#msg99280). In my opinion, at the right moment it can be a fine thing.
-
The only truly forbidden note is a major third over a minor chord.
We've been here before (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7944.msg99280.html#msg99280). In my opinion, at the right moment it can be a fine thing.
Bu@@er.....you beat me to it :-))
-
...........Learn standing up
Andy
This is a good one. To do it properly, you need two straps. >:E (ducking the thrown tomatoes). Sure, lots of players play standing with one strap, and best wishes to them. As for myself, I find that standing with two straps solves many problems: freedom of arms and shoulders for bellows control, no worries about bellows dragging across your legs (seated); less worry about supporting the left end, thereby freeing the left hand to operate the basses unencumbered; less problems with the treble end waggling; ability to use entire body for playing, which can help with expression. Sure, I usually sit, but I have found that the strength, power, and dexterity of my playing improves when I stand. Especially when playing something bigger than a Pokerwork.
-
The melodeon is particularly forgiving - it's usually difficult to play a spectacularly wrong note -
If you played a semitone box, Howard, you might change your mind about that ;)
-
This is a good one. To do it properly, you need two straps. >:E (ducking the thrown tomatoes). Sure, lots of players play standing with one strap, and best wishes to them. As for myself, I find that standing with two straps solves many problems: freedom of arms and shoulders for bellows control, no worries about bellows dragging across your legs (seated); less worry about supporting the left end, thereby freeing the left hand to operate the basses unencumbered; less problems with the treble end waggling; ability to use entire body for playing, which can help with expression. Sure, I usually sit, but I have found that the strength, power, and dexterity of my playing improves when I stand. Especially when playing something bigger than a Pokerwork.
On the other hand many (inc. me) may/will disagree with all/most of the above (:)
-
Two straps for me too!! Otherwise the darn thing feels like its trying to escape!! Bob. :||:
-
...........Learn standing up
Andy
This is a good one. To do it properly, you need two straps. >:E (ducking the thrown tomatoes). Sure, lots of players play standing with one strap, and best wishes to them. As for myself, I find that standing with two straps solves many problems: freedom of arms and shoulders for bellows control, no worries about bellows dragging across your legs (seated); less worry about supporting the left end, thereby freeing the left hand to operate the basses unencumbered; less problems with the treble end waggling; ability to use entire body for playing, which can help with expression. Sure, I usually sit, but I have found that the strength, power, and dexterity of my playing improves when I stand. Especially when playing something bigger than a Pokerwork.
As a aconfimed 'twossrpist' I can but concur!
george ;D
-
The melodeon is particularly forgiving - it's usually difficult to play a spectacularly wrong note -
If you played a semitone box, Howard, you might change your mind about that ;)
Steve is quite right - the treble end of semitone boxes are far less forgiving than that of a DG etc & this is compunded by the lack of thumpy rhythmic bass being constantly available to to divert the punters attention from treble cock ups large & small!
george
-
Two straps for me as well. I used to use one only, but some years ago I went to a workshop by Pete Grasby and I recall him saying that the first essential is to make sure the box is secure against the body and always in the same relative position. I tried it and found it much easier to move up and down the buttons on both ends and also found it easier to find the button I wanted the first time!
Another tip given to me which I try my best to adhere to when in a session, is to remember that there are other musicians playing - so play quieter so as not to drown them out. Of course, once the red mist comes down when playing a particularly enjoyable tune it's easier said than done >:E
On a similar note (sorry!) the best box players, Andy Cutting etc use varying the volume to superb effect.
-
On a similar note (sorry!) the best box players, Andy Cutting etc use varying the volume to superb effect.
And he and many other "best box players" use only one strap >:E
-
On a similar note (sorry!) the best box players, Andy Cutting etc use varying the volume to superb effect.
[/quote]
Something all box players should be able to do - the facility so to do comes totally free of charge on every box. All that is required to avail oneself of it is to play the bulk of a tune at half volume (ish) so you then have the facility to go louder of softer ( even on individual notes if required) . Many players play at full throttle all the time and in so doing forfeit much of this built in facility
george :(
-
Actually, professionals quite often get it wrong, but they're very good at covering it up so you don't notice - or at laughing it off if it really does go pear-shaped.
When you're playing to an audience it often doesn't matter if you go slightly wrong, as long as you don't let it put you off. The melodeon is particularly forgiving - it's usually difficult to play a spectacularly wrong note - and the moment is usually past and gone before anyone can notice. The only time you need to get it 100% is when recording, but now everything's digital and with software such as Pro Tools or Cubase even that can be put right.
If you make a mistake, keep the rhythm going and glare at the other members of the band as if it was them who'd gone wrong :)
"Once is a mistake, twice is a variation, three times it's an arrangement.
Four times, it's jazz."
A man after my own heart..... :||:
-
On the other hand many (inc. me) may/will disagree with all/most of the above (:)
And he and many other "best box players" use only one strap >:E
Tomatoes duly noted, Lester. ;D However, I would not presume to advise Mr. Cutting, or yourself, for that matter, on the subject of straps. My offering was given as advice to an intermediate player, Gypsylad, who merely asked for suggestions. As an intermediate player, I found that using two straps standing was significant for me, and was of some benefit.
-
Surely the strap issue boils down to two things - is the RH end rigid, and is it comfortable to play? If the answer to either is no, something really needs to be changed, if you want your playing to have accuracy, speed, control and attack. That change can involve your stance, and/or maybe straps. Some people seem to be able to avoid wobble by controlling the position of their left arm movements carefully - I can't. Others grip the fingerboard, and put up with the restrictions in RH movement that that inevitably entails. But an awful lot of people unfortunately just seem to put up with wobble, to judge from many Youtube vids. (Hence it was my top tip that it's got to be sorted out.)
-
i dont think i could play elvis with one strap...
-
I can't play any box with only one strap
george
-
Not with him doing all that stuff with his hips!
-
As a melodeon newcomer I struggled with a variety of strap/position options before discovering that two straps offered more stability than any other method. Is the single strap thing similar to the way rockstars hang their guitars down around their knees? ;)
-
Re: The One Strap/Two Strap Debate.
Follow the Gourd! The Holy Gourd of Jerusalem!
The Gourd!
Hold up the sandal, as He has commanded us!
It is a shoe! It is a shoe!
It's a sandal!
No, it isn't!
Cast it away!
Put it on!
;) >:E
-
@ Strig' -'dirty splitters!' ;D
-
What lets many novices down is playing turgid bass which drags all the life out of the music.
- there's more to the left hand than oom-pah. Mix it up with held chords, drones or even silence
- notwithstanding the previous point, there are times when oom-pah is all that's needed. Don't overcomplicate things where it doesn't add to the music
- if you're going to play oom-pah then keep it light and crisp. The left hand should drive the tune forward and give it lift, not hold it back
- find alternative chords to the same phrase and use them at different points in the tune to add variety (for example, Em can make an interesting alternative to G) - but don't overdo it
- whatever happens, keep a steady rhythm going. This is even more important than playing all the notes in the melody.
-
The straps debate: I recon it is a fashion thing of the 70's and 80's!
Airtime's on the mark here. I remember listening to John James, the best ragtime guitar I've enver heard, talk about his guitar and the fact that he plays it on his knee ' and those 'lectric ones are worn over the shoulder at around waist level.... with lots of this going on ( he used to swing the neck a lot ) .... cos they're changing to their *other* chord....' and so on. It was a hillarious bit of patter, but seeing him play was astonishing.
Can I see parallels with single strappers >:E
Q
-
The Holy Gourd
"So what have the Italians ever done for us, eh?"
"Well, APART from the reeds?"....
-
More on-topic:
I think I'd advise not pursuing a tune too hard. i.e. if it's not coming after a good go at it, put it to one side, and have another go in a while. Don't keep banging away and getting nowhere.
I'm realising a second look at a tune I struggled a while back with because of awkward fingering or stretching now is starting to come, possibly because in my other playing my fingers have loosened up, and maybe part of that odd button sequence has been learnt in another tune.....so when I come back to the originl tune it somehow seems more playable than before.
I suppose in a nutshell - don't force a tune, come back to it.
Q
-
More on-topic:
I think I'd advise not pursuing a tune too hard. i.e. if it's not coming after a good go at it, put it to one side, and have another go in a while. Don't keep banging away and getting nowhere.
I'm realising a second look at a tune I struggled a while back with because of awkward fingering or stretching now is starting to come, possibly because in my other playing my fingers have loosened up, and maybe part of that odd button sequence has been learnt in another tune.....so when I come back to the originl tune it somehow seems more playable than before.
I suppose in a nutshell - don't force a tune, come back to it.
Q
I couldn't agree more. Quite often I work at a tune for an hour or two for a couple of days, then leave it for maybe a week; when I come back to it it's amazing how much subliminal learning I've done.
Graham
-
"So what have the Italians ever done for us, eh?" "Well, APART from the reeds?"....
I for one have spent the past two weeks buying Euros at the Co-op 8) (can be 2% cheaper than my bank robber). I will have to hand over quite a few to a man in Eindhoven next summer, and have come to bless S. Berlusconi whatever his personal foibles. Its Ciccarelli reeds (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7797.0.html) are another gift from the Adriatic. :|glug
Tip time (picking up from above). For left hand in waltz, mazurka or bourrée time. Play anything except "um, pah, pah"
-
I couldn't agree more. Quite often I work at a tune for an hour or two for a couple of days, then leave it for maybe a week; when I come back to it it's amazing how much subliminal learning I've done.
Graham
Works for me, too. Although leaving to toooo long has the opposite effect. (:)
-
Not playing a tune doesn't necessarily amount to 'leaving it'. You can carry it around in your head and practise it there too, even subconsciously. This most obviously applies to phrasing and dynamics. In fact I think the best way of developing phrasing and dynamics is through singing the tune, if only in your head. But I sometimes think that just visualising or imagining what it feels like to play it on the box can be helpful practice too, in terms of fingering and muscle memory etc, without being anywhere near the blasted thing.
Very true. Most of my practice these days is done on the way to the shops. It's got to the stage that whenever I have a tune in my head (which is most of the time) I will be fingering it in my head as well.
-
DO NOT ATTEMPT THIS WHILST DRIVING!!! :'(
-
With regard to the strap debate, I used to play with one strap whether standing up or sitting down. We have two chiropractors in our Morris side who suggested that I would spend less time on their treatment table if I played with two straps when standing up. They were proved right!
-
In defense of "oom pah", it is good to learn, as a beginner, to play the left hand independently of the right.
For us beginners, it is hard enough to play the bass plus chord independently + switch to other basses and chords.
Once you can do that, then it's time to sometimes stop doing it.
-
The um pa & particularly the um pa pa is important for dances such as the St Berhard Waltz to give the dancers something to work with. I tend to start with a fairly heavy um pa pa for the first 2 or 3 bars returning to this at the start of a new tune. In between quick bursts of umpahing anything goes - very light um paing - pas without ums,ums without pas, absolutely no bass ( the easy free of charge ornementation!), and a veriety of long or short left hand chords played accross a few treble notes.
My general aim is to avoid monotony creeping in by never to doing the same thing with the bass for very long when playing for dancing. For accompanying singers a different approach is required with more attention to unobtrusive right and left hand chords & less emphasis on rhythm.
george
-
One of my tips would be: pick the right tunes!
I've got to say that the melodeon has to be the easiest instrument I've tried for achieving something that sounds good in a short amount of time. It really isn't a "virtuoso" instrument, which is a big part of its appeal. Some of the simplest tunes are the most beautiful & are relatively easy to learn to play. Other tunes, even those which appear simple, have a sequence of push/pulls/fingering that seem to be much harder to master for a beginner.
-
I'm with you on the um pahs, George. It is certainly the case that even for dancing LH accompaniment needs not to be overbearing, and it is good to introduce variations. And if playing to an audience, repetitive, too loud, or ham-fisted um pahs can distract from the tune. But on the other hand, for social dance, a good rhythm is crucial (though I wouldn't go as far as those who say that the tune isn't important), and if a steady um pah helps the dancers (and the musician), then I wouldn't knock it. Nothing ruins the enjoyment of the dancers more than the rhythm falling apart.
-
The rhythym is of course essential when playing for dancing, and oom-pah is at the core of melodeon playing. However there are more ways of keeping the rhythm than oom-pah.
What I was referring to earlier is those players who play a metronomic oompahoompahoompahoompah, giving equal value to both parts, with no light and shade. It may be bang on the beat but it just drags the tune down. That's what I meant by "turgid". Good players mostly keep it light and crisp, so it lifts the music, and add a bit of variety to keep it interesting. Then it's good to dance to and to listen to. Of course there are times when you want to come down heavy on the basses, but it should be by choice, not default.
-
but it should be by choice, not default.
There is another good tip! There is more than one way of doing most aspects of playing, aim to get alternative rhythms, fingering patterns, chords, dynamics, (or anything else) so fluent that you can play your chosen alternative at will. This is a long term aim, so don't worry that to start with you only have one way to play, just don't get stuck in a rut! :o
-
many years ago John Kirkpatrick did a workshopon ;melodeon/accordion bass ( both because participants only needed the means of playing C bassnote & C major chord so it worked equally well for 'melodeon' and 'stradella' bass players
The whole theme of the workshop was around developing a short um and a long pa to provide dancers with 'lift' (i.e. emphasising the off beat)rather than them being equal or long um & short pa which tends to come out turdgid.. Mst participants agreed on the eficasy of the short um and long pa but of course there were the usual 2 disenters!
george
-
In a similar workshop at Witney a few years ago, JK also got us switching to pa ums, and a few other variations to give lift to the tune.
Particular emphasis was giving to using the Hohner percussion section as well!!! (:)
Andy
-
many years ago John Kirkpatrick did a workshopon ;melodeon/accordion bass ( both because participants only needed the means of playing C bassnote & C major chord so it worked equally well for 'melodeon' and 'stradella' bass players
The whole theme of the workshop was around developing a short um and a long pa to provide dancers with 'lift' (i.e. emphasising the off beat)rather than them being equal or long um & short pa which tends to come out turdgid.. Mst participants agreed on the eficasy of the short um and long pa but of course there were the usual 2 disenters!
george
George,
I think that workshop may have been my fault. About 16 years ago, JK did a 25th wedding anniversary bop for a mate of mine. His fee was on the understanding that somebody would put them up for the night. As my mate's house was full of relatives I got the job. On the way home, we were discussing workshops and I mentioned that every one I had attended had concentrated on the squeaky side of the instrument and none had really explored the other end. The next year at Whitby, he did this workshop.
For waltzes, I still believe that some long OOOOOOOM Pah Paaaaahs work well, as long as they are punctuated by a few strategically placed staccato Om Pa Pas.
Chris
-
i must admit that i like playing umm pahs to give bounce - but i do swap chords other than sticking to to the same stuff, sometimes il hold a chord, or bass note , but it is my preference for bouncy bass that fits the tune. i guess thats what makes styles
-
Why is everyone talking about "um pah"? This was about "um pah pah" to stultify a waltz or crucify a mazurka
I've no probs at all "um pah" - indeed it's the essence of melodeonism and 4 time is somehow more forgiving. Nor um __ pah, um paaaaaaah , ummmmmmmm ____, ummmmmm pah or any of the other variants being discussed.
Don't ever forget that that taking your finger off the button is also a rhythm event - allowing um paa↑__ as a bass line.
The more variety the better - and once you get this going the odd "um pah pah" is bound to creep in in 3 timers. The tip is to consciously get your left hand playing "anything else".
-
Many French waltzes have an A music that is played quite legato with an underlying rhythm of three crotchets to the bar and then they go into a more staccato B music based on a rhythm of six quavers per bar. There is probably a better technical way of describing this, but I hope my meaning is clear. Tunes like La Bout du Monde and Callipyge illustrate this clearly.
A technique I find useful with these French waltzes is to accompany the legato A music with a bass rhythm of um, pause, pah and the B music with um, pah, pah (with variations to add interest, as others have said).
-
a simple little variation on the um pah pah theme that can be effective if used sparingly and at the most only once in about 4 bars is to play a long fairly quiet um over 3 beats immediately followed by PA pa pa ( with the emphasis on the first PA.) This seems to fit quite naturally into a particular place in some tunes.
george.
-
As a beginner myself, I would suggest the following tips:
Listen to as many different melodeon players as you can; it teaches you tunes and suggests different playing styles.
Watch youtube avidly - again for the tune learning and style appreciating but also if you watch the melnet TOTM you will learn heaps about different music styles, and can often learn a tune straight off by watching the left and right hands on the buttons.
Practice for short bursts, and always finish up with something you feel you make a good job of ie end on a positive note. :D
Take time to isolate the tricky bits and give them a bit of repetition - but don't sweat it, a bit of work and the ability to do those runs eventually just happens - see the comments on subliminal learning earlier.
Start using 'both ends together' as soon as you can. I was pulled up sharp by well meaning friends (you know who you are!) as I was happily whizzing away on the melodies thinking I was doing brilliantly - only to find I had to undo most of what I'd been doing when I tried to put the left hand in! In fact, if I'm trying to learn from a cd I often just do the chords and basses as I'm listening - it's usually too fast for me to manage the right hand anyway, but it does mean you get the left hand sorted right away.
Re the spaces. Simon Care was talking about the spaces between the notes being just as important as the notes, at MAW the other weekend. Even as a beginner you can hear the difference when the spaces are being acknowledged. Funnily enough I remember my old Art teacher, exhorting us to give as much attention to the spaces on the canvas/paper as the paint. And another school example, was the hockey and netball mistress emphasising that we had to keep being aware of the spaces and use them. Probably not relevant, but it made me think. And of course, there's always SPACE! THE FINAL FRONTIER! ::)
-
Quite good tips on this on today's bass variations (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,8338.0.html) thread. Yes, space is very important in a bass line (listen to any bass player). The little "-" characters in my own post are intended as 'silence'.
May I nominate this one as tip 'zero' ;D
-
I always approach a new tune as I would a roast dinner.If I tried to eat it in one go ,I would choke on it.I pick out the easier bits of the tune first [regardles of playing order ] then when I have them all under my belt I then stick it all together,this works for me,also I only play tunes that I like.
-
Pat - A roast dinner, that's a good way of looking at a tune, I like that!
I also find learning a tune I don't like is hard. It's happened to me on a very few occasions on my EC, where for some event I've had to learn a tune that normally I wouldn't have touched cos I didn't like it. It's hard. I suppose this ability separates the men from the boys, in as much as professional musicians just learn it regardless.
Q
-
Pat - A roast dinner, that's a good way of looking at a tune, I like that!
I also find learning a tune I don't like is hard. It's happened to me on a very few occasions on my EC, where for some event I've had to learn a tune that normally I wouldn't have touched cos I didn't like it. It's hard. I suppose this ability separates the men from the boys, in as much as professional musicians just learn it regardless.
Q
Yes, it's not easy learning tunes you don't like; I've had to do it many, many times in what passes for my musical career - but hey, you get paid at the end of it! At the moment I'm about to have the final rehearsal with a scratch band for a St Andrew's Night bash: up until 3 weeks ago I think I knew maybe 4 Scottish tunes. By this time next week, when it's all over, I will almost certainly know maybe 4 Scottish tunes.......
Graham
-
Be aware Graham, Scottish tunes can become highly addictive as I have found out.
-
My accordion dealer sent me this link, after I complained about stiff (?) bellows, breaking in reeds, etc: Helpful Hints to Playing the Cajun Accordion (http://www.savoymusiccenter.com/helpfulhints.html), by Marc Savoy. He throws in the keep-the-bottom-strap-fastened tip George Garside already advised me to try. That seemed to help but the strap wouldn't stay fastened so I didn't persist with it, but after reading Marc's hints last week I thought to wrap a bit of pipe cleaner around the strap's post, so now it can't go anywhere, and voila. That helps immensely, albeit I think the main problem is this box is too much for me to drive the way I want to, sans this assistance. Or maybe it won't be an issue in a while, after I've built up some stamina, or figured out the correct way to squeeze things, or whatever. Mostly at the moment I want to play different boxes, find out what else is to be had. Mine is a nice instrument, mind you, just don't think it's quite my style.
Now, I've had a terrible time with fingering. All this advice about 4 fingers, 3 fingers, I tried both but mostly just stumbled a lot. The whole move-the-whole hand down the keyboard business threw me off. Curse of the pianist/touch typist, perhaps.
Well, today it occurred to me to try just 2 fingers, and for some reason that boosted my confidence an order of magnitude. Don't know how that works! But having to use just the 2 means you can't fake it like you can with 3, perhaps. And you aren't completely at sea like you'd be with just the 1 finger. Try 2 if you're having trouble jumping about, I couldn't believe what I was hearing/feeling. It was like the day a friend sold me a cake of dark, sticky rosin, instead of the lightish junk I'd been using, and suddenly my fiddle actually worked.
So those are my accordion epiphanies for the holidays.
-
My First post...
As a beginner box player but an experienced booker of box players, my best advice would be; if you are playing dance music, be sure to dance from time to time.
You don't have to be a good dancer, but it's the best way to get an understanding of that element in the music that makes it danceable, call it 'lift' or 'swing' or whatever you like.
Cheers.
-
Agreed! In my experience musicians who have no personal experience of ceilidh or morris or whatever dancing struggle to 'get it right' Also , at risk of being hung drawn and quartered by some, I would add that those with no dance experience and a dependence on the dots struggle to an even greater extent!
Give me dancing byearists in a band any time!
george ;)
-
Agreed! In my experience musicians who have no personal experience of ceilidh or morris or whatever dancing struggle to 'get it right' Also , at risk of being hung drawn and quartered by some, I would add that those with no dance experience and a dependence on the dots struggle to an even greater extent!
Give me dancing byearists in a band any time!
george ;)
Yes! I've actually seen some Morris musicians playing from dots in public. The danciblity of the music left a lot to be desired...
-
...
I would add that those with no dance experience and a dependence on the dots struggle to an even greater extent!
...
Turn everything off and listen carefully to hear the haunting sound of a human exhaust :P
Yes! I've actually seen some Morris musicians playing from dots in public. The danciblity of the music left a lot to be desired...
No problem for good dancers :M
All we need now is for someone to make the erroneous claim that musicians should watch the dancers' feet ;D ;D ;D
'a road of cobras' (Benny Hill)
-
Dependence on the dots for learning the tune is one thing... I have seen a few dance musicians play well from the dots (not Morris), also run out of dots before the end of the dance and just stop...
-
...
I would add that those with no dance experience and a dependence on the dots struggle to an even greater extent!
...
:M
All we need now is for someone to make the erroneous claim that musicians should watch the dancers' feet ;D ;D ;D
'
guilty as charged!
george ;D
-
;)
-
I'd agree with that. I love playing for ceilidhs but don't much like dancing to them. But I do from time to time, because you can't play to something that you don't know how to dance.
-
I'm surprised. Ceilidhs are one of the few places where one is encouraged to grab hold of every woman in the room!
Rob.
-
I'm surprised. Ceilidhs are one of the few places where one is encouraged to grab hold of every woman in the room!
Rob.
Heh. I'm not complaining about that bit! Ceilidhs round here tend to be danced a little fast for me, as I'm tall with big feet and find it difficult to move that fast. I always feel constrained in terms of space and don't like dancing so close to the ground, I like to get up in the air. Morris suits me a lot better, as you have your own space, the music is slow enough for you to move properly and you get up rather than across.
It does mean that I tend to play for ceilidhs a little slower than most, which I think makes them better. There is a groove of speed where you can see the rhythm of the dancers coalesce. If you play it too fast there will be some who can't keep up and it will look messy. If you play it too slow some will lose the time and it will look plodding. But get it right and it... looks right!
-
I'm surprised. Ceilidhs are one of the few places where one is encouraged to grab hold of every woman in the room! Rob.
I'm reliably informed that the correct Irish pronunciation is "Cuddles", >:E
but I am too well brought up to suggest anyone might "stick 'dat in yer craik"
-
Probably most of you have seen Jeff's "monograph" on the subject.
My opinion, he is 99% spot on.
-
Probably most of you have seen Jeff's "monograph" on the subject.
My opinion, he is 99% spot on.
Well I hadn't (:) Thank you for posting.
Steve
PS Likewise I agree with almost all of it :||:
-
Indeed, I'd not seen that either. What an excellent article. I could think of a few people who could do well from reading that a few times. ::)
-
Er, are we up to 5 yet?
-
only melodeonists could manage 7 pages worth of 5 best tips. - just goes to show what an interestingly diverse lot we are!
george 8)
-
More thoughts fom a slightly drunk person who has just completed two hectic days of melodeon workshops:
Play with others, don't practice on your own all the time.
When you play with others ask what they think of your playing, accept criticism (the analysis or evaluation of a work of art, literature, etc) gracefully, process it and act upon it if you agree with it, store it away if you disagree, if you hear it again reconsider your disagreement!
I agree: It is essential, I think, to compare his own style of play. However, as unfortunately it is not possible to always play with others, for my part I learn a lot in me shooting the camcorder or playing in front of a mirror. This allows me to realize my faults e to try to correct them...
-
More thoughts fom a slightly drunk person who has just completed two hectic days of melodeon workshops:
Play with others, don't practice on your own all the time.
When you play with others ask what they think of your playing, accept criticism (the analysis or evaluation of a work of art, literature, etc) gracefully, process it and act upon it if you agree with it, store it away if you disagree, if you hear it again reconsider your disagreement!
Try telling that to Tony Hall. ;)
-
I'm surprised. Ceilidhs are one of the few places where one is encouraged to grab hold of every woman in the room!
Rob.
As a lady I would object to being 'grabbed'. ;)
-
I'm surprised. Ceilidhs are one of the few places where one is encouraged to grab hold of every woman in the room!
Rob.
As a lady I would object to being 'grabbed'. ;)
Depends who's doing the grabbing :D >:E
-
Firmly but gently is the key! When you put your arm confidently and courteously around her, many a severe looking lady will soften and begin to enjoy herself. OK, that's only four and very little to do with melodeons.
Rob.
-
Firmly but gently is the key! When you put your arm confidently and courteously around her, many a severe looking lady will soften and begin to enjoy herself. OK, that's only four and very little to do with melodeons.
Rob.
Now that sounds better.
I googled dancing etiquette and came across this http://www.burrows.com/other/manners.html
GIVING A REASON FOR NOT DANCING.
When a young lady declines dancing with a gentleman, it is her duty to give him a reason why, although some thoughtless ones do not. No matter how frivolous it may be, it is simply an act of courtesy to offer him an excuse; while, on the other hand, no gentleman ought so far to compromise his self-respect as to take the slightest offense at seeing a lady by whom he has just been refused, dance immediately after with some one else.
HOW TO ASK A LADY TO DANCE.
In inviting a lady to dance with you, the words, "Will you honor me with your hand for a quadrille?" or, "Shall I have the honor of dancing this set with you?" are more used now than "Shall I have the pleasure?" or, "Will you give me the pleasure of dancing with you."
WALL FLOWERS.
The master of the house should see that all the ladies dance; he should take notice, particularly of those who seem to serve as drapery to the walls of the ball-room, (or wall-flowers, as the familiar expression is,) and should see that they are invited to dance. But he must do this wholly unperceived, in order not to wound the self-esteem of the unfortunate ladies.
This made me chuckle:
Any presentation to a lady in a public ball-room, for the mere purpose of dancing, does not entitle you to claim her acquaintance afterwards; therefore, should you meet her, at most you may lift your hat; but even that is better avoided - unless, indeed, she first bow - as neither she nor her friends can know who or what you are.
-
Damned hetro-centric folk dance scene... ::)
-
I'm one of the wallflower variety myself...but mum drags me onto the dancefloor eventually.
-
Damned hetro-centric folk dance scene... ::)
I mostly dance with 5 other blokes :M
-
Damned hetro-centric folk dance scene... ::)
The publication quoted was from 1893, when the alternative was illegal...
I was intrigued with "giving a reason for not dancing" - presumably gross personal put-downs would be unladylike so one had to have a repertoire of tactful excuses.
-
The publication quoted was from 1893, when the alternative was illegal...
I mostly dance with 5 other blokes :M
I didn't mean that, of course...
-
The publication quoted was from 1893, when the alternative was illegal...
I mostly dance with 5 other blokes :M
I didn't mean that, of course...
;D
-
The publication quoted was from 1893, when the alternative was illegal...
I mostly dance with 5 other blokes :M
I didn't mean that, of course...
;D
Illegal morris dancing. :o :M
-
As a woman, I generally try (or maybe this should be past tense, I scarcely dance now) to accept any male partner who asked me to dance unless he was visibly drunk. An occasional problem at some ceilidhs has been offers of a dance with another female. In some dances it's just about OK, and I've often danced with our daughters when they were growing up, but dancing in a ballroom hold with another woman whom I don't know ("bust-to-bust", as Joyce Grenfell described it) just feels all wong. Women are too soft and squishy, and they don't move the same way as men.... and then in progressive dances it just causes chaos. But how do I say, "Oh, go and ask a man! I'm waiting for a better offer" without causing offence?
-
Damned hetro-centric folk dance scene... ::)
The publication quoted was from 1893, when the alternative was illegal...
It wasn't an entirely serious comment... that said, it does annoy me that it's still a bit taboo for two blokes to dance together at a normal ceilidh, yet seeing two women together is really not uncommon (I know there's a number of reasons for that...).
-
And being short finding a dance partner at a reachable hight is also a problem.
-
Actually I see more and more men dancing together at ceilidhs, there were several at a 21st party I played for last weekend.
-
Actually I see more and more men dancing together at ceilidhs, there were several at a 21st party I played for last weekend.
I agree, in my experience, it is far more common that a few years ago.
-
Actually I see more and more men dancing together at ceilidhs, there were several at a 21st party I played for last weekend.
I agree, in my experience, it is far more common that a few years ago.
Admittedly my only real ceilidh experience is festival ceilidhs, where it still does seem very rare indeed.
-
Commonplace in the east side of France - Morvan, Alsasse
..are nearly here yet?
-
I think, really, that most ceilidh dances are hetero in nature - they often require different things of the man and the woman, and the partner-swapping that goes on in a dance relies on couples being mixed-gender if the moves are to make any sense.
I did see a male couple together at a ceilidh once (well, it was near Brighton, so it was hardly surprising) and all I can say is that it caused endless confusion, as generally no one in the set (including the men themselves) knew which was the "woman", so many dances kept falling apart. For the dance to work properly for the majority of dancers, it's really best if every couple, regardless of sexual orientation, dances as a mixed-sex couple. Women who are used to dancing in couples (usually because there aren't enough men) are generally quite business-like about sorting out which one is the "man", but even so, it can be tricky for the other dancers to work it out if they need to.
Having said that, I think we had a thread some time ago about suitable dances for a gay wedding, at which a number of the guests would be gay. There are quite a number of dances in which the roles of the partners are more or less interchangeable, or the gender is irrelevant, and these are good ones for such occasions, as they work perfectly well for hetero dancers too.
-
Indeed, I'd not seen that either. What an excellent article. I could think of a few people who could do well from reading that a few times. ::)
I can think of people who could do with it tattooing onto their eyeballs so they *can't* ignore it ;-)
-
I think, really, that most ceilidh dances are hetero in nature - they often require different things of the man and the woman, and the partner-swapping that goes on in a dance relies on couples being mixed-gender if the moves are to make any sense.
I did see a male couple together at a ceilidh once (well, it was near Brighton, so it was hardly surprising) and all I can say is that it caused endless confusion, as generally no one in the set (including the men themselves) knew which was the "woman", so many dances kept falling apart. For the dance to work properly for the majority of dancers, it's really best if every couple, regardless of sexual orientation, dances as a mixed-sex couple. Women who are used to dancing in couples (usually because there aren't enough men) are generally quite business-like about sorting out which one is the "man", but even so, it can be tricky for the other dancers to work it out if they need to.
I think a lot of it is down to the experience of the dancers too. Unless it's some insanely complex dance, it's fairly easy to remember where you're supposed to be. It's certainly be fine on the rare occasions I've danced with another bloke.
-
Women are too soft and squishy, and they don't move the same way as men....
That was the sum total of the relationship advice I received at school...
-
Women are too soft and squishy, and they don't move the same way as men....
That was the sum total of the relationship advice I received at school...
Blimey, you must have gone to a progressive school, then! Our advice boiled down to "There is a fence between us and the girls' school next door for a very good reason." Fortunately there were a few weak spots in the chain-link.............
Graham
-
I've danced with other men at ceilidhs before. It is generally quite tiring, as once you build up momentum in a swing with 2 blokes of 13 stone or more it takes quite a bit of energy to stop...
-
Women are too soft and squishy, and they don't move the same way as men....
Not necessarily a bad thing. Making love to a skinny woman is like riding a bicycle without any tyres. I imagine a similar metaphor can be applied to dancing.
-
This thread seems to have become slightly strange!
Referring to some earlier comments, I would like to take a new look at this - isn't the idea that gents ask ladies to dance, but not the other way round, absurdly outdated? Many men are shy of making any approach, but it seems that the main reason that the old convention exists is because it's a convenient excuse for ladies not to have to do so themselves. Come on, girls, just go for it, you may be pleasantly surprised, and nobody is going to criticise you! After all, the worst thing you'll suffer is rejection, which of course men have to risk all the time. ;)
-
Referring to some earlier comments, I would like to take a new look at this - isn't the idea that gents ask ladies to dance, but not the other way round, absurdly outdated?
Not only outdated, but no longer the normal think where I've been recently. I often get asked to dance, and I almost always say yes. (:)
As to partners size and shape I believe it is irrelevant, it is how good a dancer you are that makes the biggest difference. Its not about youth, energy or enthusiasm either, it's more to do with good balance and going with the music.
One simple example is the swing. Once you understand where to place your feet, and how to give weight to your partner, you can swing really really fast (if both of you want to) with very little effort. In a progressive dance its great when you meet someone else who also understands this.
-
Making love to a skinny woman is like riding a bicycle without any tyres. I imagine a similar metaphor can be applied to dancing.
No tyres? How do you steer?
I find the ideal partner is sized so that you can comfortably put your arm around her waist. Having rather short arms, that restricts me to smaller/skinnier women or those wearing jeans - you can grab a belt loop. Otherwise you risk insulting them by trying to explain the interlinked grip for the swing, first when they take it as an insult to their womanly shape and second when it all goes wrong and they clamp your hand before you've got it round to their back. The worst experience was when I got caught up in the lady's bib and brace outfit, unclipping the braces as I extricated my offending hand.
Rob.