Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Bocsa on September 01, 2008, 06:13:21 PM
-
My Paolo soprani had screws instead of nail pins when I bought it.They seem to do the job.Im just curious why pins are always used.Is there any advantages other than quick removal?Or are screws bad for the accordion?
-
Bernard Loffet uses screws too I believe. I'm not sure why they tend to use pins. It might be that pins don't require a screwdriver to remove them for quick maintenance in a session say - but most of mine are too tight to get out without recourse to pliers! I suppose it might be a traditional fixing method as, perhaps, in olden times your village peasant wouldn't have had any need for a screwdriver.
However, I seem to recall from the depths of my memory that continually removing and replacing screws can quickly, especially if care is not take, reduce the ability of the wood to grip the screw. So with time the hole and screw would need to be enlarged to get a secure purchase on the wood. With pins you can't overtighten them and if they become looser then a bigger pin will easily suffice.
-
I think quick removal might be the reason. A lot of older boxes (and possible a few bespoke modern boxes?) still use a rotating hook-and-pin set up, which suggests to me that in the past players either needed to, or preferred to, get regular easy access to "the plumbing" inside the bellows.
-
I've seen a number of old boxes for sale which came with a selection of reed blocks, so quick changes were sometimes required. I also recall reading somewhere that a gigging box player would change reeds between dances, to suit the next key!
That approach might have saved me a fortune - but then you'd want a dry set, a swing set ...
What would be good would be a Hohner Pokerwork reed set, perhaps in a Megane, and an fast Italian set to suit. One for the Morris and one for the session after!
-
Bernard Loffet uses screws too I believe.
The screws in my Loffet box are not "standard" wood screws but more like bolts ie no taper. There must be a reason but I never thought to ask what it might be when I bought it.