Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ursa Minor on November 14, 2011, 04:09:30 PM

Title: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 14, 2011, 04:09:30 PM
Hello melodeon.net members!

New one here on the forums. I'm having an old Hohner Corona III changed from G-C-F to C#-D-D# and I would really like an opinion on the bass layout I'm contemplating. See the diagram below. Chords will be without thirds.


              Chin     

           push/pull

 Outside row      Inside row

      A/E                F#/B

      D/A               A#/C#

      G/G               F/C

               Knee


I think that with this layout and the 3-row I should be able to play in the keys from F-major up to A-major and their relative minors + the fiddle key of gm and perhaps E-major(?), and have a useful bass for these keys. Am I overlooking something? I know there are members on the board that have a lot of experience with different tunings and also a lot more experience than I have with the british chromatic system and I would really appreciate your input!

Any opinions are welcome, of course.

Thanks in advance!
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 14, 2011, 04:20:14 PM
3 row semitone boxes are chromatic & to benefit fully  from this need stradella bass.  Have you thought about grafting  the bass end of a 48 bass piano accordion on ( info on  making an adapter palte domewhere on this forum!.  The trichord  which is the same size normally had 12 stradella bass note & major chords FCGDAE  ( in b oth directions!) 

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 14, 2011, 04:38:11 PM
Well, the accordion tuner/repairer that will remake my Corona have already tried to convert me to the CBA-system (that's what every accordionist play around these parts...) but I want small, handy and lightweight instruments.

I have been thinking about unisonoric basses before, as I usually play a finnish "ristibasso"-type (it was actually made by the father of boardmember Aaro). I have more and more drifted back to bisonoric basses, though, it's more fun I think, and gives the music a different kind of "punch". Also, in this kind of instrument, with its lack of bassbuttons, I think you lose more than you gain.
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: pgroff on November 14, 2011, 04:59:52 PM
Ursa Minor,

George's suggestion makes a lot of sense if you *want* to play this like a stradella bass box.  Not that there's anything wrong with that.

But the stradella bass layout requires a different approach to playing the entire accordion, compared to a standard diatonic box -- in particular, the completely chromatic versions with 24, 32, 48, or more basses, can add a lot of weight to the left hand side.  IMO, this is worth some thought, since some of the best players I've heard on Hohner Coronas actually remove even the diatonic-style bass/chord reedblocks entirely to lighten up that left side!  

For the music I play, not that I'm a great player, I personally vote for a 12 bass diatonic type layout of the general kind you suggested.  Provided 1) that you want to maintain or develop skills that will transfer as much as possible to the most commonly encountered types of  "Irish style" C#/D box (or D/D# box, played outside-in) that you might sometimes pick up,  and 2) that you are playing in the keys you suggested, in concert pitch.

Possible minor alterations to your layout:  Consider whether you might sometimes like to play in "C#/D" fingering on the inside 2 melody rows, to play along with instruments tuned up 1/2 step from concert pitch (such as Eb flutes or pipes, or fiddles tuned up).

In that case you might want to switch the A#/C# bass and chords to D#/A# (= Eb/ Bb).  I realize you indicated that you want to play in concert pitch F, so that might be why your layout suggests that Bb bass and chord on the push.  But you might find it's more useful to have the Eb/Bb basses and chords in the press/draw direction so they fit with playing in Eb and its modes.

Alternatively, if you ever play with musicians who tune down 1/2 step from concert pitch, then for playing based on the C# row and its modes it might be handy to have the C#/G# basses and chords in the press/draw directions, more so than the C#/A# you suggested.

Or maybe best of all since this is a Hohner Corona III for which extra reedblocks should be easy to find -- set up your box as you suggest, but get one or more extra sets of bass/chord blocks tuned up (and/or down) a 1/2 step.

Finally, if you do decide to swap the left side of your box to a stradella bass, I'm in the market for the left side of a diatonic 12-bass Corona -- and I could actually trade you the left side of a stradella 12-bass Trichord for it.

PG
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 14, 2011, 06:22:24 PM
@pgroff

This is the way I see it too, I guess. There is a lot of excellent musicians with 3-5 row chromatic instruments (with stradella bass) and I can really enjoy the music they make but I don't want to play in that style or lug that big ”knee-organ” around myself. The pushing-and-pulling style is one of the reasons why I think it is more fun to play the small boxes, and I have noticed that I lose some of that ”quality” with my ristibasso (finnish 16-bass unisonoric).

I had not really considered the halfstep changes you talk about as I've never been in that situation (playing with Eb instruments) but maybe that's something to think about. It's not something that is common where I live (the utmost northern part of Sweden) though, and I think I may have more use of the Bb (A#), as you wrote. It's true that it is the A#/C# basses that I'm curious about the most, both the actual usefulness of these basses and the bellows direction.

Thanks for the offer but I think I'll keep the bass-side, you will hopefully find something a bit closer to where you live too...  ;)
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Theo on November 14, 2011, 07:10:29 PM
Another possibility is to do away with the chords and have basses only,  then you can be chromatic without extra weight.
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 15, 2011, 11:36:36 PM
Yes, but I think I would miss the normal bass accompaniment. The bass could be used more as a drone and in basslines but wouldn't it be impossible to play "normal" bass? Have you tried this system, Theo?
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Theo on November 16, 2011, 12:16:31 AM
No I haven't tried.
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 16, 2011, 12:33:17 AM
Ok. Well I guess I have to think about this a little bit more but I will probably try the layout in my first post. It is always possible to change it later if I don't like it.

Thanks to all of you for your input!
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Stiamh on November 16, 2011, 02:19:34 AM
Your original layout is very close to the most common 12-bass configuration for a C#/D box, and your questions about the "spare pair" coincides with my belief that there's no very obvious choice for the 6th pair. Jackie Daly has C#/E, which he uses to great effect. I've tried F#/C# (with B/B at the top, a push Bm being useful against the note of D), and my latest box has B/F# - but with a C# bass on the F# so that I have a complete octave of bass notes.

However all this does not take the possibilities of the D# row into account. Or the C# one for that matter. Also, it occurs to me that with a pull D on the D# row, you might not need a G push bass (and nor would you need the Bm push, which you haven't considered anyway). I guess the choice is, do you want to make the most of playing in the usual keys for trad, or do you want to have a couple spare for playing in strange keys on the outer or inner rows...

If it were me, I think I'd go for the former, since having just two for playing in, say C# or D#, wouldn't excite me very much.
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 16, 2011, 10:07:45 AM
Another possibility is to do away with the chords and have basses only,  then you can be chromatic without extra weight.
  another possibility on these lines is to have 12 thirdless major chords (same both ways)same as the major chord row on 12x4 stradella  but obviously set out in 2 rows.  This would provide a bit of accompanyment in keys of Ab,Eb,Bb,F,C,G,D,A,E,B.

This could work quite well  and can be roughly tested by playing only major chords on a stradella box.
I am experimenting with an 8 bass version of this Bb to B for a standard 8 bass BC box.  UP to now the most promising reed combination ( for me anyway) is to use  a low treble piano accordion reed together with  the 5th reed an octave higher.  This in effect provides a light unobtrusive  bass note(compared with standard bass reeds) with a 'hint'  of a chord.  Experiments continue!!

For  the semitone boxes (2 or 3 row) this would provide far more 'accompanyment' than the standard set up and would  leave treble fingering free  & reversals free from having to choose direction to suite the bass end rahter than for good bellows control ;& ease of fingering.


 Like all other 8 or 12 bass layouts it is a compromis but may be worth looking at.

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 17, 2011, 12:44:45 AM
Yes it's definitely a compromise. Maybe I should give more info about my thinking and background. I've been playing the G/C for about 12-13 years and started from the beginning with the finnish system. That was purely by coincidence, I knew nothing about the different systems and bought my first 2-row (a Hohner Corso) from a Sweden Finn and he had changed it to the finnish system. The main difference is that the fifth button on the inside row is reversed, I now know that it is also called a "dutch reversal", so I guess the dutch probably makes the same change? The typical bass layout on a G/C is like this:


                Chin

              push/pull

outside row      inside row

  G/D                em/am

  C/G                  B/B

                Knee



With this layout the main keys is G major and e minor. I play a couple of tunes in a minor and maybe some in C major but that's about it. For a couple of years I have been interested in exploring the british chromatic system, not mainly for playing irish trad (although I really enjoy listening to it and will definitely try to learn some tunes in the future), but mostly to be able to play the finnish-swedish-norwegian trad repertoir not possible to play on the standard finnish 2-row accordion/melodeon. I play the fiddle too and usually revert to that if I play with a bunch of fiddlers. Many times though I would really like to be able to play my fiddlerepertoir on the box but I'm not interested in the big cba-system or pianoaccordion. Tried that and didn't like it.

Irish 2-rows are very scarce where I live, but I was lucky to find a cheap, low quality B/C box(marked Williams) in Norway when I was visiting friends last spring. I have tried playing it as a B/C and as a C#/D and for me C#/D feels more "natural", more intuitive. I've since realised that practically all of my favourite irish boxplayers play the C#/D or D/D# so I think I've made the right choice of tuning. I don't want to give up my standard 2-rowrepertoir (finnish 2-row tunes, mostly) and the ultimate goal is to change over altogether to the british chromatic system but still be able to play the finnish polkas, waltzes and schottises that I love to play.

I think that I would want to keep the G/G bass as is but after trying a couple of finnish polkas tonight I've been thinking that maybe it would be useful to have a D-bass on the pull too? I didn't think I needed D on the pull before but there are apparently some tunes that would benefit from it. Maybe I should try for somekind of hybrid layout "semi-unisonorous"?

How about this?:


                Chin

             push/pull

Outside row       Inside row

    A/A                   F#/B

    D/D                   Bb/E

    G/G                   F/C

             Knee


Then again, my main instrument nowadays is a finnish ristibasso with 16 unisonorous basses and I have come to realise that I do enjoy bisonoric basses more so... :-\

It's definitely a compromise as stated earlier...
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 17, 2011, 10:03:00 AM
the 3 row british chromatic  (BCC#) usually comes with stradella bass  , without which the benefit of fairly easy playing in 12 keys is lost ( unless you are happy with several bassless keys.  )  Will Starr recorded  many 'continental' tunes  and much of his stuff is available on CD. Electric Scotland  stock them and you can listen to some nice samples on their website.

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: pgroff on November 17, 2011, 12:37:59 PM
george,

I remember a photo of Mr. Shand playing on a 2 row double ray, when he was getting on in years so may have valued a lightweight instrument.  Do you know if this was an 8 bass or a 12 bass, and how he had his basses set up on that box?

PG

Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 17, 2011, 01:31:05 PM
 

I don't know how the double ray you mention was set up , but he made a number of recordings using an erica tuned CC# fitted with italian reeds & morino pallets.

He can be seen playing this box on the DVD 'dancing with the Shands'.  He played the Shand Morino well into his 80's     and of course was originally a two row man.
george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: pgroff on November 17, 2011, 02:47:13 PM
Hi george,

Possibly it was an Erica in the photo I saw of Jimmy Shand.  Then there is this fella:

http://kilcairn.com/Crawford1.html

Point being, after much experience working with the 3 row, stradella-bass B/C/C# box, how did these men set up their (8 - 12?) basses when they ultimately chose a much smaller, lighter box?

PG
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 17, 2011, 03:04:05 PM
I think it is quite likely that Shand retained the standard 2 row 8 bass bass layout as on some recordings he puts in a bit of bass and on others he only playe the treble end.  An interesting variation on the 2 row is the double ray delux ( 3 voice)  with 48  stradella grafted on played by Bruce Lindsey on the  currently availble DVD 'the button box in scotland'

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: dahlberg on November 21, 2011, 11:37:41 AM
Aha!
Henry and i spoked about B/C system and he told me you had something going on. Gonna be intresting to see how it will work out, im really curious about this subject.
Who will make the re-build btw.?
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 21, 2011, 11:45:11 AM
Aha!
Henry and i spoked about B/C system and he told me you had something going on. Gonna be intresting to see how it will work out, im really curious about this subject.
Who will make the re-build btw.?

See my posting on this thread on 14th nov. 

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: dahlberg on November 21, 2011, 11:52:34 AM

See my posting on this thread on 14th nov. 

george
Are you gonna do the rebuild or?
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: george garside on November 21, 2011, 12:04:54 PM

See my posting on this thread on 14th nov. 

george
Are you gonna do the rebuild or?

Yes!  but this is new territory for me  so not sure how  it will turn out.   It is not in any way a rebuild as it only requires the making of 2 new bass reedblocks ( the originals being retained so they can be put back if it doesn't work as planned) The replacemtent blocks ( for  8 bass) will have spaces for 2 reeds per button  arranged so that existing holes in bass booard are unaltered.  . The reeds will be 1st & 5th but whcih 1st & 5th I have yet to make final decision on.  A useful refinement ( but which I am not going to attempt) would be to have a stop to remove the 5ths  so you would have a choice of 8 bass notes or  thirdless chords, but not at the same time!.

As I have a lot on at the  moment it is going to take some time!

george
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 21, 2011, 03:24:58 PM
I believe there is a little bit of miscommunication going on now...   ;)(:)

Johan: it's Per Stenelund of course!  :||: And I'm still thinking about the bass layout - but now I am almost through thinking.  :Ph

I've concluded that I definitely need the B bass in both directions, at least if I want to be able to play those finnish e-minor tunes I usually play. I've also realised that I have small use of the Bb (A#) chord. The plan was to be able to play in F-major but when I tried some F maj tunes it became clear that I would probably need the F chord on the pull and I can't really afford to sacrifice more buttons for such a few tunes. The Bb bass then becomes somewhat  unnecessary. So... What I probably will choose is this:


                  Chin

               push/pull

outside row          inside row

    A/E                     B/B

    D/A                   F#/C#

    G/G                    F/C

                 Knee


I will just need a little bit more checking if it's better to reverse the F#/C#-bass buttons. On second thought it's actually easy to change later... (:). I will talk to Stenelund tomorrow, I think. He is in the process of ordering reeds from Italy, I believe he will place the order any day now so I have to come to a decision.
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Stiamh on November 21, 2011, 04:02:48 PM
I've concluded that I definitely need the B bass in both directions, at least if I want to be able to play those finnish e-minor tunes I usually play. I've also realised that I have small use of the Bb (A#) chord. The plan was to be able to play in F-major but when I tried some F maj tunes it became clear that I would probably need the F chord on the pull and I can't really afford to sacrifice more buttons for such a few tunes. The Bb bass then becomes somewhat  unnecessary. So... What I probably will choose is this:


                  Chin

               push/pull

outside row          inside row

    A/E                     B/B

    D/A                   F#/C#

    G/G                    F/C

                 Knee


I will just need a little bit more checking if it's better to reverse the F#/C#-bass buttons. On second thought it's actually easy to change later... (:). I will talk to Stenelund tomorrow, I think. He is in the process of ordering reeds from Italy, I believe he will place the order any day now so I have to come to a decision.

What you have there is the same layout as I have on my Serenellini 273 C#/D, although with the buttons placed differently. B on the push is a great asset, but experience has taught me that it is more convenient (for my repertoire anyway) to have F#/B on one set of buttons and the B push elsewhere. This is because I use the B push less frequently and curiously enough I find it comes in handier in tunes in D than tunes in Bm !

F# on the pull is mainly useful for F#maj which I do find the very occasional need for. That's why on my latest box, as I said earlier, I had Mike R set up the sixth pair as B/F# but with a C# bass so that I have a complete octave of bass notes.

But if I had to choose between F# pull or push, it would be push definitely.

My current layout:

                  Chin
              push/pull
outside row          inside row

    A/E                   F#/B
    D/A                   G/G
    B/F#*                F/C

               Knee

* with C#bass
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Ursa Minor on November 23, 2011, 06:57:08 AM
@Steve Jones

Yes it seems to me that in Bm I could manage without the push B, but I definitely need it in most of the Em tunes I play. Seems strange to me that you need the B more in D major tunes!? How about Em tunes? As I said before I don't really play irish music (yet!) but I thought it wasn't uncommon to play in Em..? Maybe it's in the difference between irish and - for example - finnish music (melodically and harmonically)?

I'm curious about the C# bass, I think for myself that I would become a bit confused with a different bass & chord but maybe it's just something you get used to?

The button placement I chose was made with the 3-chord theory in mind. All the important chords in the main keys should be adjacent to one another, was my thinking.

I've talked to the tuner/repairer and sent the layout to him by traditional mail (he is a bit old fashioned...  (:) ) so now the ball is set rolling.  :||:
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: Stiamh on November 23, 2011, 11:01:59 AM
UM, it's only the push B that seems to be more useful in D - which is not to say that it isn't useful in Bm tunes also. And yes, Bm is very handy in Em tunes but so far (btw I'm by no means an expert player of the basses) the pull B is all that I've needed in Em.

I agree the C# bass on the F# pull is odd, but having had a conventional C# setup on my first 12-bass box, I found I never needed the C# chord, but occasionally the F# pull. But that C# bass is handy for "walking" bass notes.

Let us know how you get on with your new box and layout. I have mused about C#DD# but decided that I prefer compact machines, and that two rows is enough for all the box player I'll ever be.  ;)
Title: Re: C#-D-D# bass layout?
Post by: pgroff on November 23, 2011, 12:19:19 PM
Hi Ursa Minor, Steve, and all,

Possibly for the same reasons as Ursa Minor, I like the sound of a push B bass (and both major and minor triads) for tunes in the key of E minor (and related modes with tonic E and flattened third note).  D/G box players may often have a pair of bass buttons that provide B bass and B major on the press, and E bass and E minor on the pull.  With this layout, you can also play the B bass note along with a D major triad (also often available on the press on a box with a D row) to provide a B m7 chord, a decent substitute for a B minor on the press.

Here's a layout I am using on a 12-bass C#/D box that gives some nice options when harmonizing tunes in E minor.  Most of the basses and chords are available in the same directions as for Steve's layout:


A major / E major          F# major / B minor
D major / A major          B major / E minor
G major / G major          D minor (F bass note) / C major


Except for the Dm with F bass, all these triads are paired with the root note as a bass button so only the triads are listed.  The Dm over F  (which can be heard as an F6) can substitute for F major in a pinch, or the Dm triad can easily pair with the D bass note.

For A minor tunes, the A bass notes with the C major triad can provide an Am7 chord.

This isn't the only layout I like, but reflects my personal preference for full triads that include the thirds, and provides a good number of options for the tunes I like the most.  IMO, given my choice to include the thirds in the triads, it's at least as versatile as the stock Hohner Corona layout for a 12 bass diatonic box with no couplers on the bass side.

PG


SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal